The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Digests 🎲

Evidence (2340 claims)

Adoption
5267 claims
Productivity
4560 claims
Governance
4137 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
3103 claims
Labor Markets
2506 claims
Innovation
2354 claims
Org Design
2340 claims
Skills & Training
1945 claims
Inequality
1322 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 378 106 59 455 1007
Governance & Regulation 379 176 116 58 739
Research Productivity 240 96 34 294 668
Organizational Efficiency 370 82 63 35 553
Technology Adoption Rate 296 118 66 29 513
Firm Productivity 277 34 68 10 394
AI Safety & Ethics 117 177 44 24 364
Output Quality 244 61 23 26 354
Market Structure 107 123 85 14 334
Decision Quality 168 74 37 19 301
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 75 52 32 21 187
Employment Level 70 32 74 8 186
Skill Acquisition 89 32 39 9 169
Firm Revenue 96 34 22 152
Innovation Output 106 12 21 11 151
Consumer Welfare 70 30 37 7 144
Regulatory Compliance 52 61 13 3 129
Inequality Measures 24 68 31 4 127
Task Allocation 75 11 29 6 121
Training Effectiveness 55 12 12 16 96
Error Rate 42 48 6 96
Worker Satisfaction 45 32 11 6 94
Task Completion Time 78 5 4 2 89
Wages & Compensation 46 13 19 5 83
Team Performance 44 9 15 7 76
Hiring & Recruitment 39 4 6 3 52
Automation Exposure 18 17 9 5 50
Job Displacement 5 31 12 48
Social Protection 21 10 6 2 39
Developer Productivity 29 3 3 1 36
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Skill Obsolescence 3 19 2 24
Creative Output 15 5 3 1 24
Labor Share of Income 10 4 9 23
Clear
Org Design Remove filter
The paper presents Governed Memory, a shared memory and governance layer addressing the memory governance gap.
System architecture and design description in the paper (proposal of a shared memory and governance layer).
medium positive Governed Memory: A Production Architecture for Multi-Agent W... existence of an architecture called Governed Memory
A hybrid strategic–computational framework, supported by governance mechanisms (human-in-the-loop checkpoints, escalation paths, accountability structures), is motivated to manage tensions and ensure responsible decision-making in AI-rich managerial contexts.
Synthesis-driven prescriptive framework produced by cross-framework analysis; conceptual recommendation rather than implementation evidence.
medium positive Comparative analysis of strategic vs. computational thinking... presence and effectiveness of hybrid governance mechanisms in managing human–alg...
Roles oriented to information processing, optimisation, and operational precision (monitor, disseminator, resource allocator) are substantially enhanced by computational thinking (automation, optimisation, algorithmic decision-support).
Theoretical mapping of computational capabilities onto Mintzberg’s information-processing roles; conceptual reasoning without empirical validation.
medium positive Comparative analysis of strategic vs. computational thinking... enhancement in information-processing tasks (accuracy, speed, automation potenti...
Investment choices in collaboration AI and digital infrastructure become central strategic decisions affecting firms' comparative advantage.
Management literature synthesis and illustrative multinational cases; argument is conceptual without firm‑level comparative empirical data presented in the paper.
medium positive The Sociology of Remote Work and Organisational Culture: How... firm comparative advantage; strategic investment in AI/digital infrastructure
AI collaboration tools (virtual assistants, meeting summarizers, asynchronous platforms) complement hybrid work by reducing coordination costs and supporting dispersed teamwork.
Conceptual integration of technology and organizational literature; supported by illustrative case examples of multinational organizations but not by new quantitative causal evidence.
medium positive The Sociology of Remote Work and Organisational Culture: How... coordination costs; dispersed teamwork effectiveness
Hybrid and remote work increase employee autonomy and work–life integration.
Conceptual synthesis of sociological and management literatures; supported by secondary data and illustrative case studies from multinational organizations. No primary quantitative analysis or sample size reported—based on comparative case illustrations and theoretical integration.
medium positive The Sociology of Remote Work and Organisational Culture: How... employee autonomy; work–life integration
Generative AI functions as a socio‑technical intermediary that facilitates interpretation, coordination, and decision support rather than merely automating discrete tasks.
Thematic analysis and co‑word linkage between terms related to interpretative work, coordination, and decision‑support and technical GenAI terms within the corpus.
medium positive Generative AI and the algorithmic workplace: a bibliometric ... portrayal of GenAI role in organisational processes (socio‑technical intermediar...
The literature indicates a managerial shift away from hierarchical command‑and‑control toward guide‑and‑collaborate paradigms, where managers curate, guide, and coordinate AI‑augmented teams rather than micro‑manage tasks.
Synthesis of themes from the 212‑paper corpus (co‑word and thematic analyses) showing recurrent managerial/behavioural concepts such as autonomy, coordination, and decision‑support tied to GenAI discussions.
medium positive Generative AI and the algorithmic workplace: a bibliometric ... reported dominant managerial paradigm in the literature (guide‑and‑collaborate v...
Trust is a principal demand driver for AI-enabled marketing among Generation Z — higher trust substantially raises adoption intention and thereby accelerates diffusion.
Interpretation/implication drawn from the large standardized path coefficients (Trust → Adoption Intention β = 0.718) and mediation results in the SEM on n = 450 Gen Z respondents.
medium positive Trust in AI-Driven Marketing and its Impact on Brand Loyalty... Adoption Intention / diffusion implications
Adoption intention partially mediates the relationship between trust and brand loyalty (indirect effect Trust → Adoption → Loyalty: standardized β ≈ 0.390, p = 0.001).
Cross-sectional survey (n = 450); mediation tested within SEM framework; reported indirect standardized effect ≈ 0.390 with p = 0.001.
medium positive Trust in AI-Driven Marketing and its Impact on Brand Loyalty... Brand Loyalty (indirect effect via Adoption Intention)
Economic models of firm behavior and market microstructure should incorporate endogenous, adaptive segmentation processes and faster feedback loops enabled by human–AI systems; ABS and large‑scale interaction data can be used to calibrate such models.
Methodological recommendation grounded in the study's mixed‑methods findings (ABS experiments and 150M interaction dataset) and observed differences between autopoietic and traditional STP regimes.
medium positive The Algorithmic Canvas: On the Autopoietic Redefinition of S... modeling approaches and measurement strategies for firm behavior (recommendation...
Canvas Design Principles mitigate algorithmic myopia (overfitting to historical patterns) and improve adaptability and resource efficiency.
Set of design principles proposed in the paper and evaluated through agent‑based simulation scenarios and analyses of the large behavioral dataset. Specific experimental details and quantitative effect sizes for these principles are not detailed in the summary.
medium positive The Algorithmic Canvas: On the Autopoietic Redefinition of S... algorithmic myopia (reduction) and adaptability/resource efficiency
Reconceptualizing STP as an autopoietic (self‑organizing) system enables continuous human–AI co‑creation and yields better outcomes in unstable markets than traditional, process‑based STP.
Conceptual argument grounded in 6‑month lab ethnography (n = 23), design and deployment of the Algorithmic Canvas in that lab context, and validation via large behavioral dataset analyses and agent‑based simulations.
medium positive The Algorithmic Canvas: On the Autopoietic Redefinition of S... overall STP effectiveness/adaptability/resilience in unstable markets
Algorithmic co‑creation methods detect substantial market fluctuations about 5.8× better than traditional approaches.
Computational analysis of large behavioral dataset (150 million customer interactions) and comparative performance evaluation in empirically grounded agent‑based simulations. The detection metric and statistical significance details are not provided in the summary.
medium positive The Algorithmic Canvas: On the Autopoietic Redefinition of S... signal detection performance for market fluctuations (relative improvement facto...
The autopoietic model shortens strategic planning cycle length by approximately 90%.
Observed/recorded time‑to‑update or strategy revision metrics gathered via Algorithmic Canvas usage and lab ethnography (6‑month lab ethnography inside a Fortune 500 company, n = 23). Exact measurement protocol and whether reduction measured in live firms, simulations, or system logs is not fully detailed in the summary.
medium positive The Algorithmic Canvas: On the Autopoietic Redefinition of S... strategic planning cycle length (time to update/strategy revision)
Design and policy interventions that encourage active human contributions (e.g., draft-first workflows, co-creation interfaces, training) can help preserve worker agency and mitigate psychological costs.
Recommendation based on experimental evidence that Active-collaboration preserved psychological outcomes relative to passive use; presented as policy/design prescription rather than directly tested intervention at scale.
medium positive Relying on AI at work reduces self-efficacy, ownership, and ... inferred mitigation of psychological harms (not directly measured at firm scale)
A complementary real-world survey (N = 270) across diverse tasks reproduced the experimental pattern, suggesting external validity beyond the lab writing tasks.
Cross-sectional survey of N = 270 respondents reporting on their AI use across multiple task types; reported patterns consistent with the experiment (passive use associated with lower efficacy/ownership/meaningfulness; active collaborative use did not).
medium positive Relying on AI at work reduces self-efficacy, ownership, and ... self-reported relationships between AI-use mode and psychological outcomes (self...
Effective teams tend to evolve from ad-hoc interpretive methods toward systematic evaluation by (a) formalizing prompts/tests, (b) instrumenting outputs, (c) mapping failure modes to remediation paths, and (d) creating organizational decision rules.
Pattern observed in the qualitative coding of interviews where participants described trajectories or steps their teams took to formalize evaluation.
medium positive Results-Actionability Gap: Understanding How Practitioners E... process maturity in evaluation practices (ad-hoc to systematic)
Successful teams close the results-actionability gap by systematizing interpretive practices and creating clearer pathways from evaluation signals to product changes.
Interview accounts and cross-case analysis showing some teams adopting formalization steps (e.g., standardized prompts/tests, instrumentation, remediation mappings) that participants described as enabling action.
medium positive Results-Actionability Gap: Understanding How Practitioners E... degree to which evaluation leads to implemented product changes
Immediate research priorities for AI economists include: field experiments testing NLP‑driven acquisition/personalization (measuring CAC, LTV, retention, consumer welfare); structural/empirical models of adoption that include data access costs and complementarities; and analyses of privacy regulation impacts on external text data availability and value.
Authors' set of recommended research directions derived from identified gaps in the systematic review and implications for AI economics.
medium positive Natural language processing in bank marketing: a systematic ... types of empirical/structural studies to be undertaken and the economic outcomes...
Unit costs for bookkeeping and compliance tasks are likely to fall, potentially affecting professional services pricing and leading to consolidation.
Analytic inference from case advantages and industry literature; no empirical market-wide cost study included.
medium positive Explore the Impact of Generative AI on Finance and Taxation unit cost per bookkeeping/compliance task, pricing pressure, market consolidatio...
Generative AI can raise labor productivity in finance and tax, shifting work from routine processing to oversight, exceptions handling, and higher-value analysis.
Analytical framing supported by case observations and literature; presented as an expected economic effect rather than measured across a population.
medium positive Explore the Impact of Generative AI on Finance and Taxation labor productivity and task composition (share of routine vs. oversight/high-val...
Successful deployment requires new human capital: finance professionals with AI literacy, data governance, model validation, and control expertise.
Paper's labor and skills implications derived from case examples and analytic framing; recommendation-based observation rather than measured workforce data.
medium positive Explore the Impact of Generative AI on Finance and Taxation demand for hybrid roles, skill composition of finance workforce
Generative AI provided better decision support via scenario analysis and anomaly prioritization.
Descriptive case examples and literature indicating use of LLMs and RAG systems for drafting scenarios and prioritizing anomalies; evidence is qualitative and illustrative.
medium positive Explore the Impact of Generative AI on Finance and Taxation quality of decision support (scenario outputs) and prioritization effectiveness ...
Generative AI adoption produced cost savings through labor reallocation and task automation.
Qualitative evidence from Xiaomi and Deloitte case analysis and analytic framing suggesting lower labor requirements for routine tasks; no standardized cost-accounting or sample-wide cost metrics provided.
medium positive Explore the Impact of Generative AI on Finance and Taxation labor costs and unit cost per transaction for bookkeeping/compliance tasks
Using generative AI led to higher consistency and reduced human error in repetitive finance/tax tasks.
Case-driven qualitative observations from the two organizational examples and literature synthesis indicating reduced variability in repetitive processes when AI-assisted.
medium positive Explore the Impact of Generative AI on Finance and Taxation consistency of task outputs and incidence/rate of human errors in repetitive tas...
Generative AI deployment increased processing speed and throughput for routine finance and tax tasks.
Observed improvements reported in case studies (Xiaomi and Deloitte) and corroborating industry/literature sources described in the paper; qualitative descriptions rather than standardized time-motion metrics.
medium positive Explore the Impact of Generative AI on Finance and Taxation processing speed and task throughput for routine finance/tax operations
Applying generative AI within corporate financial sharing centers (illustrated by Xiaomi’s Financial Sharing Center) and professional services firms (Deloitte) materially improves the efficiency and accuracy of finance and tax operations.
Qualitative case analysis of two organizations (Xiaomi Financial Sharing Center and Deloitte) supplemented by literature review and analytical mapping; no large-scale quantitative measurement reported.
medium positive Explore the Impact of Generative AI on Finance and Taxation operational efficiency and accuracy of finance/tax tasks (accounting, fund manag...
Phased deployment and regulatory sandboxes can lower barriers for startups to pilot lower-risk applications, thereby shaping innovation trajectories.
Comparative policy analysis of sandboxing and phased deployment approaches in other jurisdictions; prescriptive inference without empirical testing in Vietnam.
medium positive ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE: A CRI... barriers to entry for startups and startup participation in public-sector AI pil...
Properly governed AI can yield large efficiency gains (reduced processing time and lower per-case costs), but those gains depend on redesigning legal processes to accommodate algorithmic workflows.
Analytic synthesis of administrative-process characteristics and AI capabilities; no primary quantitative evidence or measured effect sizes provided.
medium positive ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE: A CRI... administrative efficiency (processing time per case, per-case administrative cos...
Establishing a graduated implementation model and clear regulatory pathways reduces regulatory uncertainty and makes public-sector AI procurement and private-market participation more predictable and attractive.
Normative recommendation informed by comparative institutional analysis and economic reasoning; not empirically tested in the paper.
medium positive ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE: A CRI... predictability of procurement and attractiveness to private participants (procur...
A graduated implementation model—phased deployment, differentiated safeguards by risk, and mandatory human oversight for high-stakes decisions—can balance innovation with rule-of-law protections.
Normative framework development combining doctrinal findings and comparative lessons; prescriptive recommendation rather than empirical validation.
medium positive ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE: A CRI... balance between innovation (AI adoption) and protection of legal rights (procedu...
Comparative analysis of international frameworks reveals a range of institutional responses and regulatory instruments that Vietnam could adapt.
Comparative institutional analysis synthesizing governance approaches from liberal and civil-law jurisdictions (review of secondary sources and policy frameworks).
medium positive ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE: A CRI... availability of adaptable regulatory instruments and institutional models
AI can substantially modernize administrative decision-making in civil-law systems (speed, consistency, scalability).
Qualitative doctrinal and comparative institutional analysis using Vietnam as a focused case study; no primary quantitative field data or sample size.
medium positive ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE: A CRI... administrative modernization (processing speed, consistency of decisions, scalab...
SERF (Structured Error Recovery Framework) defines structured, machine-readable failure semantics to enable deterministic agent self-correction and automated recovery strategies.
Design and formal specification of SERF in the paper; formalized as a testable hypothesis with reproducible experimental methodology.
medium positive Bridging Protocol and Production: Design Patterns for Deploy... rate of deterministic recovery or successful automated recovery actions when usi...
ATBA (Adaptive Timeout Budget Allocation) frames sequential tool invocation as a budget-allocation problem over heterogeneous latency distributions to improve end-to-end latency and reliability.
Algorithmic formulation and formalization provided in the paper; ATBA is presented as a testable hypothesis with reproducible benchmarks and latency/error models.
medium positive Bridging Protocol and Production: Design Patterns for Deploy... end-to-end latency and reliability (e.g., success rate within deadline) under AT...
The MCP (Model Context Protocol) is widely adopted: >10,000 active MCP servers and 97 million monthly SDK downloads as of early 2026.
Reported protocol-adoption metrics in the paper (protocol adoption context); presumably aggregated server and SDK-download statistics (time-stamped to early 2026).
medium positive Bridging Protocol and Production: Design Patterns for Deploy... adoption (number of active MCP servers; monthly SDK downloads)
Historical institutional publication records encode an extractable evaluative signal ("taste") that can be learned by models and used for scalable triage, screening, and curation of submissions.
Empirical results showing improved predictive accuracy after fine-tuning on accept/reject records, plus demonstration of transfer tasks and a cross-field (economics) result; implications for applications (triage, screening) are drawn from these empirical findings rather than directly deployed field experiments.
medium positive Machines acquire scientific taste from institutional traces Extractability of evaluative signal as operationalized by improved predictive ac...
Models show well-calibrated confidence: their highest-confidence predictions are 100% accurate.
Calibration analysis of fine-tuned models comparing predicted-confidence levels to actual accuracy; reported that examples the model assigned its highest confidence to were 100% accurate. (Number of highest-confidence examples and calibration buckets not reported in the provided text.)
medium positive Machines acquire scientific taste from institutional traces Calibration accuracy (accuracy among highest-confidence predictions)
The learned evaluative signal transfers to untrained tasks such as pairwise comparisons and one-sentence summaries.
Fine-tuned models were evaluated on related, untrained evaluative tasks (pairwise comparisons of pitches and one-sentence summary evaluations) and showed positive transfer performance relative to baselines. (Specific metrics, effect sizes, and sample sizes for these transfer tasks are not provided in the supplied text.)
medium positive Machines acquire scientific taste from institutional traces Performance (transfer) on pairwise-comparison and one-sentence-summary evaluativ...
The core findings (harm from ToM order mismatches and benefits from A-ToM) are robust to partners beyond LLM-driven agents.
Paper reports robustness checks testing generalization to non-LLM agent classes (details summarized in robustness section); comparisons use the same coordination metrics.
medium positive Adaptive Theory of Mind for LLM-based Multi-Agent Coordinati... coordination performance (joint payoff, success rate) when paired with non-LLM a...
A-ToM recovers coordination performance by aligning its effective ToM depth with partners across a range of multiagent tasks.
Experimental results showing A-ToM achieves coordination levels closer to matched fixed-order pairings across the repeated matrix game, grid navigation tasks, and Overcooked when facing partners with different fixed ToM depths.
medium positive Adaptive Theory of Mind for LLM-based Multi-Agent Coordinati... coordination performance (joint payoff, success rate)
An adaptive ToM (A-ToM) agent that infers its partner's ToM order from prior interactions and conditions its predictions and actions on that estimate restores alignment and improves coordination.
Implemented A-ToM (estimation from interaction history + conditioning of partner-action predictions) and evaluated it against fixed-order agents in the four environments; reported improvements in coordination metrics when A-ToM paired with partners of varying ToM orders.
medium positive Adaptive Theory of Mind for LLM-based Multi-Agent Coordinati... coordination performance (joint payoff, success rate, task completion time)
Human–AI chat logs contain more explicit strategy commitments (stated rules) than human–human chats.
Content analysis / coding of natural-language chat logs from the human–AI experiment (human–AI n = 126) and the human–human benchmark (n = 108); coding counts show higher frequency of explicit commitments/statements of rules in human–AI messages.
medium positive Playing Against the Machine: Cooperation, Communication, and... frequency/count of explicit strategy-commitment messages in chat logs
Human–human subjects converge to Tit‑for‑Tat under one condition and to unconditional cooperation under the repeated-communication condition.
Strategy-estimation and behavioral trajectory analysis from the human–human benchmark (Dvorak & Fehrler 2024; n = 108) reported in the paper, showing condition-dependent convergence to Tit‑for‑Tat and to unconditional cooperation under repeated communication.
medium positive Playing Against the Machine: Cooperation, Communication, and... prevalent strategy type over time in human–human pairs (Tit‑for‑Tat vs unconditi...
Strategy estimation indicates human–AI subjects tend to favor Grim Trigger when allowed pre-play communication.
Strategy-estimation/classification applied to subjects' choices in the human–AI condition with pre-play chat (subset of the human–AI n = 126); inferred strategy prevalence shows elevated assignment to Grim Trigger-type rules.
medium positive Playing Against the Machine: Cooperation, Communication, and... prevalence/frequency of Grim Trigger strategy classification among subjects
Extensive simulation experiments across different network topologies and attacker/defense scenarios validate both the FJ modeling of LLM-MAS and the effectiveness of the trust-adaptive defense.
Multiple simulation studies reported in the paper that vary network density, trust matrices, attacker stubbornness/persuasiveness, and defense strategies; validation claims stem from consistent patterns observed across these simulated settings. (The summary does not list the number of experimental runs or statistical reporting.)
medium positive Don't Trust Stubborn Neighbors: A Security Framework for Age... agreement between model predictions and simulation outcomes; effectiveness metri...
A trust-adaptive defense that dynamically reduces trust in agents suspected of adversarial behavior can limit adversarial influence while preserving cooperative performance better than static trust-lowering strategies.
Implemented a trust-adaptive mechanism and evaluated it in simulation experiments across multiple network topologies and attack/defense scenarios, reporting reductions in adversarial sway with preserved task performance compared to naïve trust reduction. (Exact experimental counts and numeric effect sizes not provided in the summary.)
medium positive Don't Trust Stubborn Neighbors: A Security Framework for Age... reduction in adversarial influence and retention of cooperative task performance...
Increasing the number of benign agents dilutes an adversary's relative influence and thereby reduces the probability and magnitude of persuasion cascades.
Simulation experiments varying the count of benign agents in networks while measuring adversarial sway and collective opinion outcomes across different topologies. (Summary does not report exact counts or statistical summaries.)
medium positive Don't Trust Stubborn Neighbors: A Security Framework for Age... adversarial sway (magnitude of shift in collective opinion) and final consensus ...
The Friedkin–Johnsen opinion-dynamics model (innate opinions + interpersonal influence weights + stubbornness) closely captures LLM-MAS behavior across settings, both theoretically and empirically.
Modeling: derivation of FJ dynamics for LLM-MAS; Empirical: simulation experiments comparing FJ model predictions to observed LLM-MAS opinion trajectories and final consensus under varied topologies and trust matrices. (Exact goodness-of-fit metrics and sample counts not provided in the summary.)
medium positive Don't Trust Stubborn Neighbors: A Security Framework for Age... fit between model-predicted opinion trajectories/fixed points and simulated LLM-...