The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (1835 claims)

Adoption
7395 claims
Productivity
6507 claims
Governance
5877 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
5157 claims
Innovation
3492 claims
Org Design
3470 claims
Labor Markets
3224 claims
Skills & Training
2608 claims
Inequality
1835 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 609 159 77 736 1615
Governance & Regulation 664 329 160 99 1273
Organizational Efficiency 624 143 105 70 949
Technology Adoption Rate 502 176 98 78 861
Research Productivity 348 109 48 322 836
Output Quality 391 120 44 40 595
Firm Productivity 385 46 85 17 539
Decision Quality 275 143 62 34 521
AI Safety & Ethics 183 241 59 30 517
Market Structure 152 154 109 20 440
Task Allocation 158 50 56 26 295
Innovation Output 178 23 38 17 257
Skill Acquisition 137 52 50 13 252
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 120 64 38 23 252
Employment Level 93 46 96 12 249
Firm Revenue 130 43 26 3 202
Consumer Welfare 99 51 40 11 201
Inequality Measures 36 105 40 6 187
Task Completion Time 134 18 6 5 163
Worker Satisfaction 79 54 16 11 160
Error Rate 64 78 8 1 151
Regulatory Compliance 69 64 14 3 150
Training Effectiveness 81 15 13 18 129
Wages & Compensation 70 25 22 6 123
Team Performance 74 16 21 9 121
Automation Exposure 41 48 19 9 120
Job Displacement 11 71 16 1 99
Developer Productivity 71 14 9 3 98
Hiring & Recruitment 49 7 8 3 67
Social Protection 26 14 8 2 50
Creative Output 26 14 6 2 49
Skill Obsolescence 5 37 5 1 48
Labor Share of Income 12 13 12 37
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Inequality Remove filter
This lack of focus creates uncertainty about whether regulatory technology helps legitimate economic recovery or instead strengthens exclusion and informality.
Interpretive observation from gaps identified in the reviewed literature; no empirical resolution provided.
high mixed RegTech-enabled governance of sanctions-safe enterprise ecos... impact of RegTech on legitimacy of economic recovery vs. exclusion/informality
Digital transformation reconfigures development patterns across regions and countries, altering established trajectories of regional development.
Theoretical integration of a technology–labor–space framework together with comparative regional field evidence illustrating changing development patterns (no quantified effect sizes or sample sizes reported).
high mixed Automation, Migration, and Development: Geography of Job Pre... regional development patterns (spatial-economic reconfiguration)
Accounting for heterogeneity in AI literacy (agents' ability to identify and adapt to inaccurate AI outputs) can produce skill polarization in the long-run steady state.
Analytical/theoretical steady-state distribution analysis of agent skill dynamics with heterogeneous AI literacy parameters; paper reports conditions under which polarization emerges (theoretical, no empirical sample).
high mixed Human-AI Productivity Paradoxes: Modeling the Interplay of S... distribution of agent skill levels (skill polarization across population)
The intervention serves as a middle ground in the trade-off between higher costs (from more granular demographic targeting) and skew (from ignoring demographics entirely).
Authors' comparative claim about cost–skew trade-offs observed in their intervention versus alternatives; no quantitative cost or skew figures provided in the excerpt.
high mixed Into the Unknown: Accounting for Missing Demographic Data wh... trade-off between advertising cost and magnitude of ad delivery skew
Aggregate effects are geographically uneven (geographic unevenness in AI-driven labor market impacts).
Synthesis across studies observing variation by geography and noting non-Anglophone markets and developing economies as under-studied and differentially affected.
high mixed Creation, validation, obsolescence: observed evidence of AI-... geographic heterogeneity in labor market impacts
Wage polarization characterizes the aggregate pattern of labor market change associated with recent AI advances.
Aggregate characterization from synthesized studies reporting divergent wage outcomes (higher wages for AI-augmented workers, pressures on junior/routine roles) consistent with polarization.
high mixed Creation, validation, obsolescence: observed evidence of AI-... wage distribution changes (polarization)
Sectoral effects are heterogeneous: infrastructure, security, and quality-assurance roles have expanded while developer roles have contracted.
Qualitative and quantitative results aggregated across the included studies noting role-level expansions and contractions; no single pooled effect size provided.
high mixed Creation, validation, obsolescence: observed evidence of AI-... changes in employment/posting volumes by occupational role (infrastructure, secu...
Depending on the used fairness metric, the Pareto frontier may include upper-bound threshold rules, thus preferring individuals with lower success probabilities.
Analytical derivations showing that for certain fairness metrics the set of Pareto-optimal rules includes rules that impose upper-bound thresholds; theoretical examples and arguments in the paper.
high mixed Fairness vs Performance: Characterizing the Pareto Frontier ... presence of upper-bound threshold rules on Pareto frontier (preference toward lo...
Responses [about AI's effects] vary by cohort and depending on survey framing.
Paper asserts heterogeneity in survey responses across demographic cohorts and due to framing effects (no subgroup sample sizes or framing experiment details in excerpt).
high mixed AI’s Economy and Its Political and Institutional Consequence... variation in survey responses by cohort and framing
This [model divergence] may explain why public opinion is not settled about the effects of AI.
Paper's interpretive claim linking model divergence to unsettled public opinion (presented as a plausible explanation; no causal test or survey linkage provided in excerpt).
high mixed AI’s Economy and Its Political and Institutional Consequence... public opinion about AI's effects
Current models about the vulnerability level of occupations and economic sectors differ widely in their forecasts.
Paper's comparative statement about existing models and their forecasts (no specific models, quantitative comparisons, or sample sizes provided in the excerpt).
high mixed AI’s Economy and Its Political and Institutional Consequence... disagreement across model forecasts of occupational/sector vulnerability
Introducing taxes on AI returns (τ_ai) and financial gains (τ_f) yields three distinct long-run regimes: low-tax (extreme inequality), moderate-tax (stable mixed economy), and high-tax (post-scarcity with universal basic income).
Model extension with tax parameters τ_ai and τ_f and analysis of steady states/long-run regimes; bifurcation analysis identifying regime types associated with ranges of (τ_ai, τ_f).
high mixed The Economic Singularity: Core Mathematical Model long-run regime (inequality vs. stability vs. post-scarcity/UBI)
The finding that recurrence and neighborhood statistics are stronger predictors than complaint volume has direct implications for complaint routing given the demographic correlates of those features.
Interpretive implication drawn by the authors from the SHAP results; presented as a logical consequence rather than a separately tested empirical result in the excerpt.
high mixed Scaling the Queue: Reinforcement Learning for Equitable Call... implications for complaint routing policy/practice
We empirically validate these theoretical observations using both synthetic and real datasets.
Experimental evaluation reported in the paper applying proposed policies and measures to synthetic data and at least one real dataset (details not given in abstract).
high mixed Price of Fairness in Short-Term and Long-Term Algorithmic Se... empirical consistency of theoretical findings (PoF behavior and long-term dispar...
Modeling fiscal policy as a government problem (instead of an abstract planner) implies a tax changes the firm's automation first-order condition, raises revenue only on the remaining automation base, and requires specifying rebates and administrative losses.
Explicit governmental optimization and budget-accounting setup in the model: taxes enter firms' automation first-order conditions; revenue is computed on post-tax automation activity and rebates/administration are modeled.
high mixed The Demand Externality of Automation effect of taxation on firm automation choice, tax revenue base, and fiscal accou...
The central analytic object is the derivative of household consumption demand and the collective wage bill with respect to automation.
Paper's stated modeling focus: comparative-static derivatives linking automation to household consumption demand and aggregate wages; used to characterize incidence and welfare effects.
high mixed The Demand Externality of Automation sensitivity (derivative) of household consumption demand and aggregate wage bill...
Automation reallocates income and ownership claims.
Theoretical model with heterogeneous households who hold capital/equity claims; equilibrium determines wages and returns and shows changes in income and ownership shares when automation increases.
high mixed The Demand Externality of Automation distribution of income and ownership (capital vs. labor income shares)
While Agentic AI enhances economic performance, its benefits are mediated by structural conditions and are unevenly distributed across countries (i.e., reinforcing core–periphery inequalities).
Combined findings from fixed-effects regressions, mediation analysis, and observed heterogeneity between developed and emerging economies in the 2015–2024 panel.
high mixed The Economic Value of Agentic AI: A Comparative Analysis of ... distribution of economic benefits from AI across countries (inequality of gains)
Generative AI-powered tools like ChatGPT are reshaping market skill demands while also offering new forms of on-demand learning support to meet those demands.
Framed in paper as background/motivation; asserted from prior literature and the paper's motivating claims rather than reported as a quantified result in this study.
high mixed Upskilling with Generative AI: Practices and Challenges for ... impact of generative AI on market skill demands and availability of on-demand le...
The rise of digital agents will transform the foundations of production, labour markets, institutional arrangements and the international distribution of economic power.
Synthesis and theoretical projection across sections of the paper; presented as a broad conclusion without reported empirical quantification in the provided text.
high mixed DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... transformation of production systems, labour markets, institutions, and internat...
There is a fundamental asymmetry between economic and social reproduction: digital agents can compensate for productive functions of the population but are unable to substitute the population's functions of social reproduction.
Theoretical argument and conceptual distinction in the paper; no empirical study measuring substitution in social reproduction provided.
high mixed DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... capacity of digital agents to substitute productive vs social reproduction funct...
The rapid growth of AI and automation offers Sub-Saharan Africa economic opportunities as well as labor market challenges.
Systematic review of the literature reported in the paper; scope and number of studies not specified in the abstract/summary provided.
high mixed The Impact of AI-Driven Automation on Semi and Unskilled Wor... economic opportunities and labor market challenges in Sub‑Saharan Africa
AI adoption leads both to job displacement and job creation, including the emergence of new occupational categories.
Abstract states the review examines empirical evidence on both job displacement and creation and the emergence of new occupations; no numeric counts or sample sizes provided in abstract.
high mixed AI and the Transformation of Human Employment: Challenges, O... job destruction and creation; emergence of new occupations
The study identifies short-term transitional risks and long-term productivity gains associated with AI integration in the workforce.
Abstract states the paper evaluates both short-term risks and long-term productivity gains from AI integration based on the reviewed literature; no empirical quantification given in abstract.
high mixed AI and the Transformation of Human Employment: Challenges, O... transitional risks and productivity gains
AI-driven automation and augmentation are reshaping employment landscapes, with emphasis on sector-level disruption, skill transformation, and socioeconomic consequences.
Abstract states this as a conclusion of the review drawing on interdisciplinary empirical literature; no specific studies or sample sizes cited in abstract.
high mixed AI and the Transformation of Human Employment: Challenges, O... employment landscape changes (sector disruption, skill transformation, socioecon...
The accelerating deployment of artificial intelligence across industries has fundamentally altered the structure of global labour markets.
Statement in abstract summarizing a systematic review of interdisciplinary literature (economics, computer science, organizational behaviour, public policy); no specific sample size reported in abstract.
high mixed AI and the Transformation of Human Employment: Challenges, O... structure of global labour markets
Survey evidence suggests public attitudes towards AI combine optimism with apprehension, and most respondents oppose granting AI systems final authority over hiring and dismissal decisions.
Review cites multiple public opinion and survey studies reporting mixed (optimistic and apprehensive) attitudes and opposition to AI final authority in employment decisions (survey evidence summarized).
high mixed From Technological Substitution to Institutional Response: A... public attitudes toward AI and policy preferences (authority in hiring/dismissal...
There are important regional differences—especially in developing contexts—that necessitate context-specific approaches to improving women’s participation in AI-enabled work.
Observation reported in the review drawing on geographically diverse studies and policy analyses; the abstract does not quantify differences or report sample sizes for cross-region comparisons.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence and GenderedEmployment: Reviewing Op... regional variation in barriers and opportunities affecting women's participation...
Social, cultural, and ethical considerations influence women’s engagement in AI-centric workplaces.
Claim made in the review, based on interdisciplinary literature that includes sociocultural analyses and ethical discussions; the abstract does not provide empirical effect estimates or sample sizes.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence and GenderedEmployment: Reviewing Op... women's engagement in AI-centric workplaces
AI applications—ranging from recruitment algorithms to workplace automation—can either reinforce gender disparities or promote equitable employment outcomes.
Stated in the review based on collated findings from multiple studies and analyses that document both harms (e.g., biased recruitment algorithms) and potential benefits (e.g., tools designed to reduce bias); no single empirical study or pooled effect size provided in the abstract.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence and GenderedEmployment: Reviewing Op... impact of AI applications on gender disparities in hiring and employment outcome...
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming workplaces across the globe, offering both novel opportunities and unique challenges for women in technology-driven industries.
Stated in the paper's introduction/abstract as a summary conclusion based on a narrative literature review of peer-reviewed studies, policy analyses, and preprint research; no specific sample size or primary empirical method reported in the abstract.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence and GenderedEmployment: Reviewing Op... women's participation and experiences in AI-enabled workplaces
These efficiency gains are offset by a growing 'Efficiency-Legitimacy Paradox' (i.e., improvements in efficiency come with worsening legitimacy concerns).
Conceptual synthesis from the systematic review (2018-2026) identifying a recurring trade-off across reviewed studies; specific empirical quantification not provided in abstract.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence, Public Policy and Governance - impl... trade-off between administrative efficiency and democratic legitimacy/procedural...
There is a structural shift from 'street level' bureaucracies to 'system-level' architectures that can be defined as the institutional division of 'Artificial Discretion' to algorithmic infrastructures.
Synthesis from the PRISMA-guided systematic review of literature (2018-2026) reporting observed changes in administrative architectures; specific studies not enumerated in abstract.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence, Public Policy and Governance - impl... institutional/administrative architecture (shift from street-level to system-lev...
As a General-Purpose Technology (GPT), Artificial Intelligence (AI) is fundamentally reconfiguring state capacity, as well as the mechanics of global economic management.
Systematic review of current research studies (2018-2026) conducted following PRISMA guidelines; synthesis of literature claiming broad institutional and macroeconomic effects. Number of studies not specified in abstract.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence, Public Policy and Governance - impl... state capacity and the mechanics of global economic management
Uncertainty-aware exploration (in algorithms) alters fairness metrics compared to policies that ignore uncertainty.
Results from simulation experiments compare uncertainty-aware exploration policies to baseline policies and report changes in fairness metrics (as described in the abstract and results).
Operationalizing hardware-based governance must address transition realities including legacy hardware, attestation at scale, and protection of civil liberties.
Policy implementation analysis in the paper identifying practical challenges to deploying hardware-layer controls (conceptual/operational analysis; no empirical trial data provided).
high mixed The Open-Weight Paradox: Why Restricting Access to AI Models... practical hurdles to governance deployment (legacy hardware, attestation scalabi...
AI is increasingly being integrated into both existing and newly emerging digital infrastructures, altering their architecture, functional role, and strategic significance as these systems begin to operate as embedded cognitive infrastructures shaping knowledge production, decision-making, and institutional processes.
Conceptual and descriptive claim presented by the paper (theoretical analysis/literature-informed observation). No empirical sample size or quantitative methods reported in the provided text.
high mixed Digital Sovereignty in the Global Cognitive-Informational Or... change in the architecture/role of digital infrastructures and their effect on k...
Variable importance improvements to zero-shot tabular classification produce mixed results with respect to algorithmic fairness.
Authors report experiments applying variable-importance-based adjustments to zero-shot LLM tabular classification and evaluating resulting algorithmic fairness outcomes; described as producing mixed results. (Sample size not provided in abstract.)
high mixed Auditing LLMs for Algorithmic Fairness in Casenote-Augmented... algorithmic fairness (classification error disparities) resulting from variable-...
Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) verified correlations among educational background, gender inclusiveness, digital literacy, and perceived algorithmic fairness.
Paper reports use of CFA and SEM to test relationships among those variables; reliability/fit supported by Composite Reliability (CR), Average Variance Extracted (AVE), and model-fit indicators.
high mixed A Machine Learning Perspective on FinTech-Driven Inclusion: ... correlations among educational background, gender inclusiveness, digital literac...
The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies, particularly generative AI and large language models, has reignited debates about the future of work and the potential for widespread labor market disruption.
Statement in the paper's introduction/abstract citing recent empirical studies, industry reports, and ongoing debates; no original sample or numerical evidence reported in the abstract.
Outcomes of AI deployment in labor-market settings depend on complementary organizational practices, workers’ access to skills, and the regulatory environment.
Synthesis-derived moderator/ mechanism claim from qualitative analysis of the 19 included studies identifying organizational practices, skill access, and regulation as contextual moderators.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence in the Labor Market: Evidence on Wor... inclusion/exclusion outcomes contingent on moderators
If employment losses are relatively small and productivity gains are realised, AI adoption could boost Exchequer revenues. But if job displacement is sizeable, tax receipts fall while welfare spending rises, resulting in potentially large pressures on the public finances.
Conditional fiscal scenarios simulated in the report combining employment, wage and benefit changes with the public finance implications (tax receipts and welfare spending); reported as scenario-based outcomes.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence and income inequality in Ireland Exchequer revenues / tax receipts and welfare spending
Ireland’s tax and welfare system absorbs most of the income loss for lower income households, and roughly half of the loss for households at the top of the income distribution.
Microsimulation using SWITCH to model taxes and transfers applied to simulated income changes across income groups; reported as a finding in the report.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence and income inequality in Ireland net income after taxes and transfers (absorption of income loss)
India exhibits a distinctive polarisation pattern: a shrinking middle-skill workforce alongside a persistently large low-skill labour segment.
Descriptive analysis of secondary data and official reports from 2020–2024 comparing occupational and skill distributions in India.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence and labour market polarisation in In... changes in the share of labour across skill bands (middle vs low skill)
Model behaviors vary strongly with levels of reasoning and with users' inferred socio-economic status.
Reported findings from evaluations that varied model reasoning prompts/levels and user socio-economic status signals; paper states behavior differences across these dimensions. Abstract does not give sample sizes or exact quantitative differences.
high mixed Ads in AI Chatbots? An Analysis of How Large Language Models... variation in model behavior by reasoning level and inferred socio-economic statu...
The inequality-reducing impact of AI is weaker when carbon inequality is measured by the Theil index, implying persistent structural divides between advanced and less developed regions.
Same provincial panel dataset (2003–2021) with the Theil index as the dependent variable; results show a weaker (and impliedly less robust) association between AI development and Theil-measured carbon inequality.
high mixed Artificial intelligence, green innovation, and regional carb... carbon inequality (Theil index)
Residual within-task group dynamics dominate the magnitude of the gender wage gap, though task-based employment and wage channels are important for timing and direction of changes in gender inequality in the formal sector.
Decomposition analysis partitioning the gender wage gap into within-task residuals and task-based employment and wage components, with residuals accounting for the largest share of the gap but task channels explaining temporal shifts.
high mixed Routine-Biased Technological Change and the Gender Wage Gap ... relative contribution of within-task residuals versus task-based channels to the...
The analysis focuses on formal wage workers in Indonesia from 2001 to 2019.
Stated sample and timeframe in the study description; analyses use data on formal wage workers in Indonesia covering 2001–2019.
high mixed Routine-Biased Technological Change and the Gender Wage Gap ... sample population and timeframe
AI technologies and digital platforms have fundamentally altered the organization of work and modes of value realization.
Synthesis of contemporary literature and theoretical analysis in a conceptual study (no empirical sample reported).
high mixed The labor theory of value in the era of artificial intellige... organization of work and modes of value realization in platform economies
Using pre-existing exposure as an instrument for ChatGPT adoption in a long-difference IV design, ChatGPT adoption causes households to spend more time on digital leisure activities while leaving total time spent on productive online activities unchanged.
IV long-difference empirical design: instrumenting household adoption with pre-ChatGPT exposure (2021 browsing); outcome measured as changes in categorized browsing durations (LLM-based classification into 'leisure' vs 'productive' sites); controls include demographic-by-region fixed effects and browsing composition controls.
high mixed https://arxiv.org/pdf/2603.03144 change in time spent on digital leisure activities and total time on productive ...