The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (4175 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Org Design Remove filter
Risk management can accelerate AI adoption by lowering uncertainty for managers and investors, thereby affecting diffusion and productivity gains from AI.
Conceptual implication derived from the review's synthesis and discussion (policy/implication section); not supported by primary empirical testing within the reviewed literature.
low positive The Role of Risk Management as an Organizational Management ... AI adoption rate; diffusion speed; productivity gains from AI
Firms that adopt structured risk management for AI projects can reduce model failure, operational losses, and reputational costs—improving risk-adjusted returns on AI investment.
Theoretical and practical extrapolation from general RM frameworks and thematic findings in the literature; no AI-specific primary empirical studies included in the review.
low positive The Role of Risk Management as an Organizational Management ... model failure rates; operational losses; reputational costs; risk-adjusted retur...
Structured risk management can produce potential cost savings via reduced loss events and more efficient capital allocation.
Reported as a benefit across some reviewed studies and practitioner reports; the review notes lack of primary empirical quantification of effect sizes.
low positive The Role of Risk Management as an Organizational Management ... loss event frequency/severity; cost savings; capital allocation efficiency
Firms that design processes to preserve human diversity and elicit diverse AI outputs may capture greater productivity gains, increasing returns to organizational capability rather than to raw model access.
Theoretical implication and prescriptive recommendation based on observed homogenization; no direct causal firm-level evidence presented, inference based on economic reasoning.
low positive The Artificial Hivemind: Rethinking Work Design and Leadersh... firm-level productivity or returns to organizational capability versus model acc...
Investments to build trust in AI (transparency, reliability, training) are likely to have positive returns via higher adoption rates and realized AI benefits.
This is presented as an implication derived from observed positive associations between trust and outcomes; the study did not conduct cost–benefit or longitudinal causal tests of such investments in the reported analyses.
low positive Algorithmic Trust and Managerial Effectiveness: The Role of ... returns to trust-building investments (adoption rates, realized AI benefits) — i...
Practical levers to increase AI trust include transparency of AI models, demonstrated reliability, and manager-focused AI literacy/training.
Paper proposes these levers based on study findings and discussion (recommendations), but they were not tested experimentally in the reported cross-sectional survey.
low positive Algorithmic Trust and Managerial Effectiveness: The Role of ... AI trust level (proposed interventions to increase trust)
A stronger data-driven decision culture that stems from AI trust yields better operational and academic outcomes.
Study reports positive associations between AI trust → data-driven culture → operational and academic outcomes in survey-based analyses; however, the summary does not specify which operational/academic metrics were measured or sample size.
low positive Algorithmic Trust and Managerial Effectiveness: The Role of ... operational outcomes and academic outcomes (unspecified metrics)
On-Premise RAG provides a viable path for SMEs sensitive to security and cost to adopt advanced language capabilities without perpetual vendor fees or data exposure.
Synthesis of technology, organizational, and environment/security analyses (TOE framework) and implications section arguing SMEs can adopt on-prem RAG; presented as an implication rather than proven adoption data.
low positive An Empirical Study on the Feasibility Analysis of On-Premise... viability/adoptability for SMEs (security- and cost-sensitive adoption)
Vendors that embed robust cognitive interlocks into development platforms can command premium pricing by reducing downstream risk; verification features may become a competitive moat.
Market-structure and product-differentiation reasoning in the paper; no market data, pricing studies, or competitive analyses presented.
low positive Overton Framework v1.0: Cognitive Interlocks for Integrity i... vendor pricing premiums; market share attributable to verification features
Human verification (and automated verification infrastructure) becomes the limiting factor and a scarce complement to AI generation, raising demand and wages for verification expertise and tooling.
Theoretical labor-market analysis and complementarity argument in the paper; no labor market data or econometric estimates provided.
low positive Overton Framework v1.0: Cognitive Interlocks for Integrity i... demand for verification roles; wages for verification engineers; availability of...
AI contributes to flatter, more networked and modular organizational forms, with increased cross-functional coordination enabled by shared data platforms and real-time analytics.
Conceptual reasoning supported by cross-sector illustrative examples; no standardized cross-firm comparative empirical study reported in the book.
low positive Modern Management in the Age of Artificial Intelligence: Str... organizational structure metrics (hierarchy depth, modularity, cross-functional ...
When tasks are well matched to GenAI capabilities, firms can raise output per consultant and reduce time-per-task, thereby changing the marginal productivity of labor in consulting.
Inferred in the implications section from interview-based observations and the TGAIF framework; no reported quantitative measurement of output per consultant or time savings in the study.
low positive Where Automation Meets Augmentation: Balancing the Double-Ed... output per consultant; time-per-task; marginal productivity of labor
Dynamic oversight regimes (ongoing audits, continuous certification) are likely more effective than one-time approvals for managing risks from agentic AI.
Policy and governance argument based on the dynamic nature of agentic systems; presented as a recommendation rather than empirically validated.
low positive Visioning Human-Agentic AI Teaming: Continuity, Tension, and... effectiveness of dynamic oversight vs. one-time approvals in maintaining alignme...
Firms will place greater value on alignment-as-a-service, monitoring platforms, and certification/assurance products as agentic systems proliferate.
Market-structure and demand reasoning from the paper; proposed as an implication rather than empirically demonstrated.
low positive Visioning Human-Agentic AI Teaming: Continuity, Tension, and... market demand/value for alignment/monitoring services
DAR-capable systems that credibly implement transparent registers and controlled reversibility may face lower adoption frictions in high-stakes sectors, affecting market dynamics and insurer/purchaser willingness to pay.
Economics-oriented implication and conjecture in the paper about adoption dynamics and market effects; not empirically tested in the manuscript.
low positive Human–AI Handovers: A Dynamic Authority Reversal Framework f... adoption_rate_in_high-stakes_sectors; insurer_payment_terms; purchaser_willingne...
Demand will increase for complementary goods: orchestration platforms, testing/verification tools, secure code-generation services, and team-level integrations.
Projected market implication based on practitioner-identified frictions (quality, security, integration) in the Netlight study; speculative market prediction without market data.
low positive Rethinking How IT Professionals Build IT Products with Artif... market demand for AI-complementary tools and services
The need to orchestrate AI ensembles increases demand for skills in system design, AI-tooling, and coordination rather than only coding.
Authors' inference based on observed practitioner emphasis on supervision and integration tasks in the Netlight qualitative study; no labor market data provided.
low positive Rethinking How IT Professionals Build IT Products with Artif... demand for complementary skills (system design, AI-tooling, coordination)
First-mover and scale advantages are likely for firms that successfully integrate AI with robust oversight, potentially creating durable cost and service-quality advantages.
Theoretical and strategic analyses aggregated in the review; this is inferential and not supported by longitudinal competitive empirical studies within this paper.
low positive The Effectiveness of ChatGPT in Customer Service and Communi... market share, cost advantage, service-quality differentials attributable to earl...
Platforms combining high-volume generation with effective filtering/curation can create strong network effects and concentration in markets for AI-assisted ideation.
Market-structure reasoning and illustrative platform examples from the literature; no empirical market-wide causal studies reported in the review.
low positive ChatGPT as an Innovative Tool for Idea Generation and Proble... market concentration and network effects for ideation platforms
Firms that embed AI into collaborative workflows and invest in human curation may capture disproportionate returns (first-mover and scale advantages).
Theoretical/strategic argument supported by some applied case evidence and platform-market reasoning cited in the synthesis; the review notes absence of systematic causal firm-level evidence.
low positive ChatGPT as an Innovative Tool for Idea Generation and Proble... firm-level returns, market share, and competitive advantage
Generative AI will create complementarity: increasing returns to skills in evaluation, curation, synthesis, and domain expertise that integrate AI outputs.
Theoretical labor-economics reasoning supported by case studies and task-level studies showing demand for evaluation/curation skills in AI-assisted workflows; direct causal evidence on wage effects is limited in the reviewed literature.
low positive ChatGPT as an Innovative Tool for Idea Generation and Proble... demand for evaluative/curation skills; wage premia for such skills (not directly...
Lowered cost and time of ideation and early-stage R&D due to generative AI may accelerate innovation cycles and reduce firms' search costs.
Inference from studies reporting reduced time-to-prototype and increased ideation; this is an economic interpretation rather than directly measured long-run firm-level innovation rates in the reviewed studies.
low positive ChatGPT as an Innovative Tool for Idea Generation and Proble... time-to-prototype; search costs; firm-level innovation cycle length (largely unm...
Firms that successfully integrate trustworthy, accurate AI can achieve faster strategic pivots and potentially gain competitive advantages and higher returns to organizational capital that embeds AI capabilities.
Associations between perceived trust/accuracy and organizational agility indicators in the quantitative analysis, plus qualitative case-like interview evidence suggesting competitive benefits; explicit causal estimates of returns not provided (implication is inferential).
low positive Human-AI Synergy in Financial Decision-Making: Exploring Tru... strategic pivot speed; competitive advantage; returns to organizational capital
Improved matching from predictive tools can shorten vacancy durations and improve reallocation dynamics in labor markets.
Implication from the review citing reported improvements in candidate screening and matching in some included studies; identified as a mechanism for labor-market effects.
low positive Data-Driven Strategies in Human Resource Management: The Rol... vacancy duration, match quality, labor market fluidity
k-QREM and its estimator provide useful behavioral primitives for applied AI-economics tasks (platform design, auctions, simulations), enabling richer modeling of boundedly rational agents and within-level heterogeneity.
Discussion and proposed applications section in the paper: authors illustrate potential uses and argue suitability based on the model's expressive structure and improved performance in numerical tests; no field experimental validation reported.
low positive k-QREM: Integrating Hierarchical Structures to Optimize Boun... proposed applicability / model expressiveness (qualitative)
A standardized governance pattern lowers coordination and compliance costs across business units, potentially increasing adoption and accelerating diffusion of advanced automation.
Theoretical claim supported by case-level practitioner observations and economic reasoning; no empirical diffusion or adoption-rate data provided.
low positive Governed Hyperautomation for CRM and ERP: A Reference Patter... automation adoption rate across business units; coordination/compliance costs
The reference pattern yields benefits including faster, safer scaling of automation across business units, reduced compliance incidents and data-exposure risk, and better accountability and traceability of automated decisions.
Claimed benefits supported by practitioner anecdotes and multi-sector implementation descriptions; no large-sample quantitative estimates or causal inference reported.
low positive Governed Hyperautomation for CRM and ERP: A Reference Patter... automation rollout time; number/rate of compliance incidents; data breach incide...
Embedding compliance features into automation can reduce regulatory fines and litigation risk, thereby affecting firm risk profiles and cost of capital.
Theoretical implication drawn from aligning governance with compliance objectives; no empirical evidence linking the proposed pattern to reduced fines or changes in cost of capital in the paper.
low positive Governed Hyperautomation for CRM and ERP: A Reference Patter... regulatory fines/litigation incidents; firm risk profile; cost of capital (hypot...
The framework is applicable across multiple sectors and aligns with industry best practices; it is presented as a deployable pattern rather than a one-size-fits-all product.
Authors' assertion based on multi-sector practitioner examples and alignment with documented industry practices (qualitative). Details on sector coverage and case selection are limited.
low positive Governed Hyperautomation for CRM and ERP: A Reference Patter... cross-sector applicability and alignment with best practices (qualitative/applic...
The proposed governed hyperautomation pattern yields benefits including faster scaling of automation, reduced operational risk, maintained regulatory compliance, and preserved long-term system integrity.
Claim grounded in conceptual argument and practitioner case-based illustrations; no large-scale quantitative evaluation or causal inference provided in the paper.
low positive Governed Hyperautomation for CRM and ERP: A Reference Patter... automation deployment speed; operational risk incidents; regulatory compliance i...
Faster iterative experimental cycles enabled by LLM orchestration may increase returns to experimental R&D and change the optimal allocation between computation, instrumentation, and labor.
Economic argumentation about iterative cycles and returns to capital/labor; proposed rather than empirically demonstrated.
low positive ChatMicroscopy: A Perspective Review of Large Language Model... returns to experimental R&D and allocation of spending across computation, instr...
AI should serve precision and purpose in public policy — improving foresight, enabling better trade-offs, and preserving democratic accountability.
Normative policy prescription and conceptual argumentation in the book; no empirical testing or quantified outcomes reported.
low positive Governing The Future policy foresight quality, decision trade-off management, and preservation of dem...
AI-driven systems should empower people with knowledge and pathways to participate in global markets rather than concentrate gains.
Normative recommendation derived from policy analysis and value judgments in the book; not supported by empirical evidence in the blurb.
low positive Governing The Future distribution of economic gains and levels of participation in global markets
Firms that effectively implement governed hyperautomation may realize sustainable efficiency and reliability advantages, potentially increasing market concentration in some sectors unless governance costs level the playing field.
Strategic and competitive-dynamics argument derived from case examples and best-practice synthesis; no sector-level empirical concentration measures presented.
low positive Governed Hyperautomation for CRM and ERP: A Reference Patter... firm-level efficiency/reliability gains and sector market concentration
Standardized governance patterns reduce information asymmetries, enabling insurers and regulators to better price and manage enterprise AI risks.
Policy implication argued from the existence of standardized governance artifacts (audit trails, certifications) and industry practice; conceptual, no empirical insurer/regulator data presented.
low positive Governed Hyperautomation for CRM and ERP: A Reference Patter... ability of insurers/regulators to assess/price/manage enterprise AI risk
Embedding governance reduces downside risks (compliance fines, data breaches), improving expected net returns of automation investments and lowering the adoption threshold for risk-averse firms.
Conceptual cost-benefit argument and industry best-practice examples; lacking quantitative measurement of returns or threshold shifts.
low positive Governed Hyperautomation for CRM and ERP: A Reference Patter... expected net returns on automation investments and adoption threshold for firms
Authors propose the 'AI orchestra' concept: future development will involve coordinated ensembles of specialized AI agents (code generation, test generation, dependency analysis, security scanning) orchestrated by humans and higher-level controllers.
Theoretical/conceptual argument by the authors grounded in qualitative findings from Netlight (practitioner reports of multiple tools and coordination frictions); this is a forward-looking synthesis rather than an empirically established fact.
low speculative Rethinking How IT Professionals Build IT Products with Artif... anticipated architecture of AI tool ecosystems (multiple specialized agents coor...
Canvas Design Principles aimed at reducing algorithmic myopia matter for welfare and regulatory concerns: better adaptive behavior reduces mispricing/misattribution risks but raises questions about transparency, accountability, and systemic amplification of shocks.
Policy and governance implication inferred from the claimed reductions in algorithmic myopia and increased adaptivity; study does not report direct welfare/regulatory impact measurements.
speculative mixed The Algorithmic Canvas: On the Autopoietic Redefinition of S... algorithmic governance externalities (mispricing risk, transparency, accountabil...
Faster, more accurate identification of demand shifts can compress the window for first‑mover advantages, intensify competitive dynamics, and raise the premium on organizational agility and human–AI integration capabilities.
Theoretical implication derived from observed improvements in signal detection (~5.8×) and resilience; not directly measured as market‑level competitive outcomes in the study.
speculative mixed The Algorithmic Canvas: On the Autopoietic Redefinition of S... market dynamics (first‑mover window, competitive intensity) — theoretical implic...
Product teams evaluating LLM-powered features rely on a spectrum of practices—from informal “vibe checks” to organizational meta-work—to cope with LLMs’ unpredictability.
Qualitative interview study with 19 practitioners; thematic coding of transcripts produced descriptions of a range of evaluation practices used by teams.
medium-high mixed Results-Actionability Gap: Understanding How Practitioners E... types of evaluation practices used by product teams
Improved throughput and lower travel costs can induce additional travel demand (rebound), partially offsetting congestion/emissions gains unless paired with demand-management measures.
Theoretical economic reasoning presented in the paper as a caveat; not directly measured in the simulation experiments (no induced-demand dynamic experiments reported).
speculative mixed Data-driven generalized perimeter control: Zürich case study net congestion and emissions accounting for possible induced travel demand
There is a social welfare trade‑off between personalization value (higher AAR) and normative/social risk (higher MR); optimal policy and product design should balance these using BenchPreS metrics.
Analytical argument combining empirical findings (trade‑off between AAR and MR) with economic welfare considerations; the paper does not present formal welfare estimates or market experiments.
speculative mixed BenchPreS: A Benchmark for Context-Aware Personalized Prefer... Trade‑off between personalization benefits (AAR) and social/normative risk (MR) ...
Organizational heterogeneity in strategic backing and mentoring explains variation in benefits from AI adoption across firms and sectors, contributing to cross-firm productivity dispersion.
Theoretical claim linking organizational moderators to heterogeneous adoption outcomes; proposed as an empirical research direction without data provided.
speculative mixed Revolutionizing Human Resource Development: A Theoretical Fr... heterogeneity in firm-level AI productivity gains; cross-firm productivity dispe...
Managerial and peer mentoring styles (e.g., directive vs. developmental mentoring) influence how affordances are perceived and actualized, affecting learning, trust, and task allocation in human–AI collaboration.
Theoretical argument drawing on mentoring and organizational behavior literatures integrated with AST/AAT; no empirical tests or sample presented.
speculative mixed Revolutionizing Human Resource Development: A Theoretical Fr... learning outcomes, trust in AI/human–AI teams, task allocation decisions
Organizational forms may shift (e.g., flatter, more modular organizations; increased platform-mediated teams) because easier global coordination changes the cost-benefit calculus for outsourcing and insourcing.
Conceptual mapping from reduced coordination costs to organizational design implications and illustrative examples; no firm-level empirical case studies or panel data presented.
speculative mixed AI as a universal collaboration layer: Eliminating language ... organizational structure metrics (hierarchy depth, modularity, use of platform-m...
AI-mediated reduction in language frictions could compress wage premia tied to language skills, reduce demand for pure translation/transcription roles, and increase demand for AI-supervisory, verification, and model-prompting roles.
Theoretical labor-market implications and illustrative scenarios linking reduced language frictions to labor supply/demand shifts; no empirical labor-market analysis or sample data included.
speculative mixed AI as a universal collaboration layer: Eliminating language ... wage premia for language skills; employment levels in translation vs. AI-supervi...
The adoption of AI governance programmes by military institutions will have strategic implications.
Hypothesis stated by the author; presented as forward-looking analysis without accompanying empirical modeling, historical analogues, or measured strategic outcomes in the provided text.
speculative mixed AI governance for military decision-making: A proposal for m... strategic implications for military institutions and national security resulting...
Findings have important implications for enterprise strategy and economic policy in early-stage AI adoption environments.
Discussion and policy implications drawn from the paper's theoretical framework and empirical results; not tested empirically within the paper.
speculative mixed The complementarity trap: AI adoption and value capture n/a (policy/strategy implications aimed at improving productivity capture from A...
Women in Ireland use advanced digital skills at rates broadly comparable to women elsewhere in Europe; Ireland's large gender gap instead reflects particularly high rates of advanced digital task use among men.
Cross-country comparison of female rates of advanced digital task use in ESJS descriptive tables; comparison highlights that Irish female rates are similar to European female averages while Irish male rates are unusually high.
medium-high mixed Squandered skills? Bridging the digital gender skills gap fo... Share (%) of women performing advanced digital tasks in Ireland versus the Europ...
Differences in observable worker and job characteristics (education, field of study, occupation, sector) explain only a minority of the Europe-wide gender gap in advanced digital task use, accounting for around 30% on average.
Decomposition analysis (e.g., Oaxaca–Blinder style) applied to ESJS data to partition the gender gap into explained (observable characteristics) and unexplained components. (Exact sample sizes by subgroup not reported in excerpt.)
medium-high mixed Squandered skills? Bridging the digital gender skills gap fo... Proportion (%) of the gender gap in advanced digital task use explained by obser...