The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (4114 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Innovation Remove filter
Topic-specific complaint trends (from LDA) provide additional predictive power for short-term abnormal returns beyond aggregate volume and sentiment.
Unsupervised LDA used to extract complaint topics at the firm–month level; inclusion of topic prevalence/trend variables in panel/ML models improves in-sample explanatory power and out-of-sample prediction accuracy relative to models using only volume and sentiment.
medium positive More than words: valuation of words for stock price by using... improvement in prediction accuracy for short-term abnormal returns (out-of-sampl...
Findings are robust to standard model specifications and inclusion of macroeconomic controls.
Authors report robustness checks across alternative specifications and models that include controls (e.g., GDP per capita, trade openness, human capital, institutional quality) with consistent positive effects of the technology variables.
medium positive Digital Technologies and Sustainable Development: Evidence f... Aggregate national SDG performance (composite/summary index)
Complementarities: interaction effects among FinTech, AI readiness, and Blockchain activity are positive — simultaneous development/use of multiple technologies produces larger SDG gains than isolated adoption.
Panel regression models estimated with interaction terms (e.g., AI × FinTech, AI × Blockchain, three-way interactions) on G20 2015–2023 data; reported positive and statistically significant interaction coefficients implying supra-additive effects.
medium positive Digital Technologies and Sustainable Development: Evidence f... Aggregate national SDG performance (composite/summary index)
AI readiness exhibits the largest individual association with national SDG performance among the three technologies (FinTech, AI, Blockchain).
Comparison of estimated coefficients from the same panel regression framework (FinTech, AI, Blockchain included separately); AI coefficient reported as largest in magnitude and statistically significant.
medium positive Digital Technologies and Sustainable Development: Evidence f... Aggregate national SDG performance (composite/summary index)
National-level Blockchain activity positively and significantly predicts improved national SDG performance across G20 economies (2015–2023).
Cross-country panel regression with a blockchain activity indicator on G20 country-year data (2015–2023); reported statistically significant positive coefficient controlling for standard macro variables.
medium positive Digital Technologies and Sustainable Development: Evidence f... Aggregate national SDG performance (composite/summary index)
National AI readiness positively and significantly predicts improved national SDG performance across G20 economies (2015–2023).
Cross-country panel regressions using an AI readiness indicator on G20 country-year data (2015–2023); reported statistically significant positive association controlling for macro covariates.
medium positive Digital Technologies and Sustainable Development: Evidence f... Aggregate national SDG performance (composite/summary index)
National-level FinTech adoption positively and significantly predicts improved national Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) performance across G20 economies (2015–2023).
Cross-country panel regression analysis of G20 country-year data from 2015–2023; FinTech adoption indicator included as a main independent variable; models report statistically significant positive coefficient for FinTech after including macro controls.
medium positive Digital Technologies and Sustainable Development: Evidence f... Aggregate national SDG performance (composite/summary index)
Aid and infrastructure investment (digital public goods, AI capacity building) act as economic channels of influence that shape recipient countries' technological trajectories and participation in AI value chains.
Qualitative examples of development initiatives and technology transfer cited in the comparative case work and literature review; no new cross‑national statistical analysis provided.
medium positive Smart Power and the Transformation of Contemporary Internati... recipient countries' technological trajectories and participation in AI value ch...
AI technologies are core instruments of smart power, affecting productivity, industrial competitiveness, and the ability to project influence via platforms, surveillance systems, and information controls.
Theoretical argument supported by literature on AI's economic and strategic effects; no new quantitative dataset provided in the paper.
medium positive Smart Power and the Transformation of Contemporary Internati... productivity, industrial competitiveness, and capabilities to project influence
Both states and non‑state actors (tech firms, NGOs, international organisations) can exercise smart power; balance and instruments vary by polity and strategic aims.
Comparative qualitative evidence from the paper's four case studies and secondary empirical studies cited in the literature review; examples of tech firms and IOs in policy documents and public diplomacy cases.
medium positive Smart Power and the Transformation of Contemporary Internati... who exercises influence (state vs non‑state actors) and variation in instrument ...
Smart power transcends simple compulsion/attraction binaries by foregrounding legitimacy, cooperative security, and governance as central mechanisms for durable influence.
Theoretical model building and interpretive synthesis of IR literature and illustrative case material from the four case studies; qualitative argumentation rather than new empirical estimation.
medium positive Smart Power and the Transformation of Contemporary Internati... durability of influence mediated by legitimacy, cooperative security, and govern...
In the digital era, states and non‑state actors operationalise smart power through three primary channels: diplomacy, development, and technology.
Comparative qualitative case studies of four actors (United States, China, European Union, Russia) plus synthesis of policy documents, public diplomacy examples, development initiatives, and technology behaviour drawn from the literature review.
medium positive Smart Power and the Transformation of Contemporary Internati... channels/vectors used to project smart power (diplomacy, development, technology...
Smart power integrates hard power (coercion) and soft power (attraction) into a single legitimacy‑based model of global influence.
Conceptual/theoretical analysis built from a systematic literature review of classical and contemporary IR and strategic studies; model development in the paper (no original quantitative data).
medium positive Smart Power and the Transformation of Contemporary Internati... form and logic of international influence (legitimacy‑centred integration of coe...
Transparent, auditable AI systems and governance mechanisms are necessary to maintain public trust and democratic oversight.
Normative and governance-focused argument in the book; supported by conceptual reasoning rather than empirical public-opinion or audit studies in the blurb.
medium positive Governing The Future levels of public trust and effectiveness of democratic oversight tied to transpa...
Designing AI systems with participation and accessibility at their core is essential to prevent concentration of gains and widening inequalities.
Normative recommendation based on equity concerns and policy analysis; not empirically tested or quantified in the blurb.
medium positive Governing The Future distributional outcomes (concentration of gains) and measures of accessibility/p...
AI platforms can materially improve efficiency and resilience of supply chains, altering comparative advantage and regional integration dynamics.
Illustrative vignette (logistics optimization) and policy-analytic reasoning; no empirical supply-chain studies or measured efficiency gains reported in the blurb.
medium positive Governing The Future supply chain efficiency, resilience, and impacts on comparative advantage/region...
Labor-market policy should emphasize reskilling, algorithmic job-matching, and social safety nets to account for rapid compositional changes enabled by AI platforms.
Policy recommendation grounded in scenario analysis and applied-AI descriptions; no empirical evaluation or quantified labor market impact provided in the blurb.
medium positive Governing The Future reskilling uptake, job-matching efficiency, and adequacy of social safety nets
Policymakers need new institutional capacities to integrate AI-driven foresight into fiscal, trade, and labor policymaking.
Policy analysis and prescriptive argument in the book; illustrated with scenario reasoning but lacking empirical measurement of capacity gaps or interventions.
medium positive Governing The Future institutional capacity to incorporate AI-driven foresight into policy processes
Rather than replacing human judgment, AI augments foresight and adaptation, enabling resilient, inclusive, and participatory governance if guided by deliberate policy design.
Normative and conceptual argumentation with illustrative vignettes (e.g., policymaker vignette); no empirical validation or sample sizes reported.
medium positive Governing The Future governance resilience, inclusiveness, participatory engagement, and foresight/ad...
AI is transforming economic decision-making, governance, and value creation across sectors and countries.
Conceptual synthesis presented in the book/blurb; no empirical study or sample reported—claim supported by cross-sector examples and narrative argumentation.
medium positive Governing The Future extent of transformation in economic decision-making, governance, and value crea...
A certification/audit industry is likely to emerge (market for algorithm auditors, explainability tools, compliance software).
Market-outcome inference in the economics implications section; forecast based on anticipated demand for compliance/audit services following white‑box mandates.
medium positive Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research emergence and size of certification/audit firms and related service markets
The protocol projects and systematizes 16 anticipated constitutional rulings by the SCJN to create enforceable standards.
Legal-methodological approach described in the compendium: explicit projection and systematization of 16 anticipated SCJN rulings to derive standards.
medium positive Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research number of projected constitutional rulings (16) and their conversion into enforc...
Greater transparency and audit trails improve regulators’ ability to monitor concentration risks, model commonality and systemic vulnerabilities arising from algorithmic homogenization.
Policy analysis and regulatory design argument in the compendium, drawing on macroprudential principles and comparisons with European regulatory approaches; not empirically tested within the paper.
medium positive Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research regulatory monitoring capacity for concentration risk and systemic vulnerability
Regulatory certainty around rights‑based standards may reorient investment toward explainable AI, compliance tooling, audit services and governance technologies — creating a potential new sector of AI‑economics activity.
Projection based on market response theory and industry trends noted in the compendium; supported by comparative regulatory cases but not by quantified investment data in the paper.
medium positive Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research investment flows into explainable AI, compliance/audit tooling, governance techn...
Localized datasets and mandated disclosure could create public datasets and benchmarks that improve model fairness and enable new entrants.
Policy design proposal and comparative precedent examples in the corpus; normative expectation rather than demonstrated outcome.
medium positive Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research availability of public datasets/benchmarks; model fairness; market entry by new ...
Transparency standards can reduce information asymmetries between firms, borrowers and regulators, potentially lowering adverse‑selection problems in lending markets.
Theoretical economic argument grounded in market microstructure and information economics; supported by comparative regulatory literature in the corpus (no new empirical estimation reported).
medium positive Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research information asymmetry and adverse selection in lending markets
Non‑discrimination and fairness requirements (procedural standards and substantive tests) must be mandated to prevent biased exclusion in automated credit and financial services.
Doctrinal analysis of jurisprudence and regulatory materials, comparative law review (Mexico ↔ Europe), and review of technical literature on algorithmic fairness in the ~4,200‑text forensic audit.
medium positive Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research incidence of biased exclusion in credit/financial services (discrimination outco...
A 'White Box' regulatory model — mandatory transparency, explainability, and forensic auditability — should be required for algorithms used in banking/fintech, particularly credit scoring.
Normative protocol design and synthesis of legal, regulatory and technical literature in the forensic audit; policy operationalization component of the compendium (method: doctrinal analysis and normative design).
medium positive Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research regulatory requirements for algorithmic transparency/explainability/auditability
Digital Sovereignty should be recognized as a fundamental human right protecting citizens’ control over algorithmic decisions affecting economic life.
Normative/doctrinal legal argumentation and comparative law synthesis across the compendium; grounded in rights‑based reasoning and alignment with international human‑rights norms (no experimental/empirical test).
medium positive Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research legal recognition of 'Digital Sovereignty' as a fundamental right (status/consti...
Verifiable compliance (privacy budgets, provenance, auditability) becomes a key economic input; demand for standards, attestation services, and transparent governance frameworks will grow.
Policy/economic argumentation and proposed governance layer including audit logs and policy controllers. No empirical adoption or demand measurements provided.
medium positive Privacy-Aware AI Advertising Systems: A Federated Learning F... demand for attestation/audit services and existence of verifiable compliance mec...
Prototype simulations indicate that decentralized training with coordination protocols can approach centralized personalization performance under realistic constraints (communication budgets, DP noise, heterogeneity).
Prototype/simulation-based evaluation described qualitatively in the paper. The paper emphasizes illustrative experiments; specific simulation parameters, dataset sizes, and numeric performance comparisons are not reported in detail.
medium positive Privacy-Aware AI Advertising Systems: A Federated Learning F... relative personalization performance (decentralized vs centralized; e.g., accura...
Re-conceptualizing federated learning as a socio-technical infrastructure (not merely a distributed optimizer) enables cross-platform personalized advertising that substantially reduces centralized data custody risks while retaining effective personalization, provided system design integrates secure aggregation, differential privacy, solutions for heterogeneous and delayed feedback, adversarial defenses, and explicit governance mechanisms.
High-level systems and conceptual design with a proposed multi-layer architecture; analytical discussion of privacy/accuracy trade-offs; prototype/simulation-based evaluation described qualitatively. No large-scale field deployment reported; simulations described without detailed sample sizes or numeric benchmarks.
medium positive Privacy-Aware AI Advertising Systems: A Federated Learning F... centralized data custody risk (qualitative reduction), personalization effective...
Complementarities matter: digitalization increases AGTFP more when combined with complementary investments and institutions (mechanization, R&D, cooperative organization).
Findings from mediation analysis and interaction/heterogeneity checks indicating larger effects where complementary inputs/institutions are present.
medium positive Digital rural development and agricultural green total facto... AGTFP (conditional on presence of complementary inputs/institutions)
Non-grain-producing provinces experience larger AGTFP gains from digital rural development than major grain-producing provinces.
Comparative sub-sample analysis (non-grain vs. major grain-producing regions) showing larger estimated effects in non-grain-producing areas.
medium positive Digital rural development and agricultural green total facto... AGTFP (by crop/region type)
Digital service capacity shows diminishing marginal returns: the marginal positive effect of digital services on AGTFP weakens at more advanced stages of digital-service development.
Panel threshold/modeling of nonlinearity indicating a decreasing marginal effect of the digital service sub-index on AGTFP at higher development levels.
medium positive Digital rural development and agricultural green total facto... AGTFP (effect conditional on digital service capacity)
Digitalization accelerates agricultural mechanization and the diffusion of agricultural R&D, which act as channels raising AGTFP.
Mediation analysis including mechanization rate and agricultural R&D input/technology diffusion indicators as mediators; reported significant indirect effects.
medium positive Digital rural development and agricultural green total facto... Mechanization rate and agricultural R&D (mediators); AGTFP (outcome)
Digital rural development strengthens cooperative organizational forms (farmer cooperatives), and this organizational upgrading contributes to higher AGTFP.
Mediation tests showing digitalization is associated with greater cooperative organization indicators, which in turn are associated with higher AGTFP.
medium positive Digital rural development and agricultural green total facto... Cooperative organization prevalence (mediator) and AGTFP
Digital rural development encourages larger-scale agricultural operations (land consolidation/scale expansion), which contributes to increases in AGTFP.
Mediation models that include farm scale/land transfer indicators as mediators and find significant indirect effects; analysis notes institutional constraints limit full realization.
medium positive Digital rural development and agricultural green total facto... Farm scale / land transfer (mediator) and AGTFP
Digital rural development raises AGTFP in part by promoting labor mobility and reallocating labor toward higher-productivity uses.
Mediation analysis using the same provincial panel (2012–2022) showing significant indirect effects through labor reallocation/factor allocation variables.
medium positive Digital rural development and agricultural green total facto... Labor mobility / factor reallocation (mediator) and AGTFP (outcome)
Robustness checks and sensitivity analyses (alternative mappings, sector aggregation, price/base-year choices) are performed or at least implied to assess the stability of VIS results.
Paper notes cross-checks with alternative mappings and sensitivity tests to examine stability; specifics depend on paper details.
medium positive Measuring labor productivity dynamics in U.S. industrial and... sensitivity/stability of VIS productivity estimates to mapping and aggregation c...
VIS provides a framework to quantify cross-sectoral labor spillovers and dependencies.
Input–output based VIS construction attributes upstream labor requirements to final sectors, enabling accounting of cross-sector labor embodied in outputs (demonstrated in the electricity case study).
medium positive Measuring labor productivity dynamics in U.S. industrial and... quantified upstream labor spillovers/dependencies across sectors
VIS enables robust estimation of productivity trends over time that can inform policy, planning, and comparative analysis across sectors.
VIS produces annual time-series productivity measures using 2014–2023 data; authors argue these trend estimates are suitable for policy and comparative use.
medium positive Measuring labor productivity dynamics in U.S. industrial and... trend estimates of labor productivity over 2014–2023 at VIS/subsystem level
VIS captures interactions among generation, distribution, storage, and consumption consistent with Integrated Energy Systems concepts.
VIS mapping and analysis applied to electricity subsystem sectors (generation, distribution, storage, consumption) showing interconnections via input–output relationships.
medium positive Measuring labor productivity dynamics in U.S. industrial and... representation of inter-sectoral linkages among energy subsystem components
Because DPP benefits accrue systemically (e.g., improved circularity), private incentives to adopt may be insufficient and thus policy interventions, subsidies, or consortium governance are needed to correct underinvestment and coordination failures.
Inference from stakeholder survey responses and theoretical public‑good/coordination failure reasoning presented in the paper; not directly established by causal empirical tests in the study.
medium positive (calls for policy) Integrating knowledge management and digital product passpor... need for coordinated policy/collective action to realize systemic DPP benefits
Convergence in the literature and concentration of influential authors suggest rapid standard‑setting; analogous real‑world concentration of model/platform providers could affect competitive dynamics and access to algorithmic capabilities.
Observation of lexical convergence and author concentration in bibliometric analyses; extrapolated implication to market structure based on comparative reasoning.
low mixed Generative AI and the algorithmic workplace: a bibliometric ... inference about standard‑setting dynamics and potential market concentration eff...
Adoption of GenAI may deliver productivity gains for adopters but also generate 'winner‑take‑most' dynamics (first‑mover advantages, network effects), with implications for wage dispersion and market concentration.
Argument based on literature convergence, theoretical reasoning about platform/model concentration and potential network effects; not directly measured in the bibliometric study.
low mixed Generative AI and the algorithmic workplace: a bibliometric ... potential effects on firm productivity, market concentration, and wage dispersio...
Decentralised decision‑making mediated by GenAI may lower some internal transaction costs (faster local decisions) but raise coordination costs absent new governance mechanisms.
Theoretical implication drawn in the discussion/implications section based on conceptual mapping of literature; no direct causal empirical test in the bibliometric data.
low mixed Generative AI and the algorithmic workplace: a bibliometric ... hypothesised effect on internal transaction costs and coordination costs
Autonomous agents in industries like mobility and manufacturing will affect labor demand; the speed and distribution of displacement or augmentation depends on interoperability and upgrade cycles.
Labor‑economics reasoning and scenario analysis; conceptual and conditional statement without empirical labor market modeling or data.
low mixed The Internet of Physical AI Agents: Interoperability, Longev... labor demand, displacement/augmentation rates, distribution of employment effect...
FederatedFactory's synthesized datasets allow organizations with data scarcity to obtain balanced training sets without sharing raw data, but training generative modules may incur nontrivial compute costs and require certification/trust frameworks.
Paper discussion weighing practical costs and adoption incentives: acknowledges compute cost to train generative modules and the need for certification to ensure modules are safe/non-leaking. This is a reasoned assessment, not an empirical measurement.
low mixed FederatedFactory: Generative One-Shot Learning for Extremely... compute/training cost (qualitative), need for certification/trust frameworks (qu...
Marginal returns to generating additional early-stage candidates may diminish unless AI also reduces attrition rates later in development.
Economic reasoning based on portfolio theory and observed persistence of late-stage attrition; presented as implication/recommendation rather than empirically tested claim.
low mixed Learning from the successes and failures of early artificial... marginal return per additional candidate; attrition rates at later R&D stages