The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (4857 claims)

Adoption
5586 claims
Productivity
4857 claims
Governance
4381 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
3417 claims
Labor Markets
2685 claims
Innovation
2581 claims
Org Design
2499 claims
Skills & Training
2031 claims
Inequality
1382 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 417 113 67 480 1091
Governance & Regulation 419 202 124 64 823
Research Productivity 261 100 34 303 703
Organizational Efficiency 406 96 71 40 616
Technology Adoption Rate 323 128 74 38 568
Firm Productivity 307 38 70 12 432
Output Quality 260 71 27 29 387
AI Safety & Ethics 118 179 45 24 368
Market Structure 107 128 85 14 339
Decision Quality 177 75 37 19 312
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 89 58 33 22 209
Employment Level 74 34 78 9 197
Skill Acquisition 98 36 40 9 183
Innovation Output 121 12 24 13 171
Firm Revenue 98 35 24 157
Consumer Welfare 73 31 37 7 148
Task Allocation 87 16 34 7 144
Inequality Measures 25 76 32 5 138
Regulatory Compliance 54 61 13 3 131
Task Completion Time 89 7 4 3 103
Error Rate 44 51 6 101
Training Effectiveness 58 12 12 16 99
Worker Satisfaction 47 33 11 7 98
Wages & Compensation 54 15 20 5 94
Team Performance 47 12 15 7 82
Automation Exposure 27 26 10 6 72
Job Displacement 6 39 13 58
Hiring & Recruitment 40 4 6 3 53
Developer Productivity 34 4 3 1 42
Social Protection 22 11 6 2 41
Creative Output 16 7 5 1 29
Labor Share of Income 12 6 9 27
Skill Obsolescence 3 20 2 25
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Clear
Productivity Remove filter
As AI becomes increasingly integrated into higher education, instructors and institutions face urgent questions about its implications for teaching, learning, scholarly practice, and for power, agency, and access.
Framing claim in the paper's introduction supported by literature context and reinforced by the study's analysis of practitioner (faculty) discussions on Reddit indicating concern/uncertainty. (The excerpt does not report survey or quantitative prevalence data on how widespread these concerns are.)
medium mixed A Critical AI Media Literacy Perspective on the Future of Hi... perceived urgency and breadth of questions raised by instructors/institutions re...
Through thematic content analysis, the study explores faculty perceptions, pedagogical tensions, and imaginative possibilities surrounding AI’s academic role.
Method stated by author: thematic content analysis of subreddit discussions to identify themes relating to faculty perceptions, pedagogical tensions, and imagined futures for AI in academia. (Exact number of themes, coding procedure, and sample size not provided in excerpt.)
medium mixed A Critical AI Media Literacy Perspective on the Future of Hi... identified themes related to faculty perceptions, pedagogical tensions, and imag...
Variations in prompt design influenced agents’ performance indicators, including response accuracy, task completion efficiency, coordination coherence, and error rates.
Experimental simulations with systematic variation of prompt designs and quantitative analysis of resulting performance indicators listed above. (Sample size, effect sizes, and statistical tests not specified in the provided excerpt.)
medium mixed Prompt Engineering for Autonomous AI Agents: Enhancing Decis... response accuracy; task completion efficiency; coordination coherence; error rat...
These findings underscore the importance of timing when evaluating demographic policy: stabilizing finances within a practical timeframe requires levers that improve the budget directly, rather than those that work through slow demographic channels.
Comparative timing analysis from multiple model scenarios showing faster fiscal improvement from direct budgetary levers (productivity, per-capita cost control) versus slow demographic interventions (fertility increases).
medium mixed Fiscal Dynamics in Japan under Demographic Pressure time required to stabilize fiscal indicators (e.g., deficit-to-GDP or nominal de...
Knowledge democratization through AI may reduce educational inequality but may also exacerbate digital divides and erode universities' social mobility function.
Theoretical and socio-political analysis considering opposing effects; framed as a conditional/mixed outcome without empirical measurement reported in the paper.
medium mixed Are Universities Becoming Obsolete in the Age of Artificial ... impact on educational inequality, digital divide, and universities' role in soci...
AI displacement potential varies substantially across university functions.
Summary finding from the paper's comparative analysis of university functions; the paper provides ranked/percent estimates but does not report empirical sampling or statistical testing.
medium mixed Are Universities Becoming Obsolete in the Age of Artificial ... variation in AI displacement/substitutability across different university functi...
There is significant variation in psychological readiness for AI across generational cohorts, industry sectors, and organizational maturity levels.
Aggregated findings from emerging AI–HRM empirical studies referenced in the paper (no specific study counts or sample sizes provided in the summary).
medium mixed Developing Organizational Psychology Frameworks to Prepare t... psychological readiness for AI (by cohort, sector, and organizational maturity)
Harnessing the full potential and lifetime of GS-BESS requires intelligent operational strategies that balance technological performance, economic viability, and environmental sustainability.
Conclusion drawn from the systematic review of existing studies and frameworks (PRISMA-based literature synthesis). Specific empirical studies or quantitative sample sizes supporting trade-off analyses are not provided in the excerpt.
medium mixed Grid-Scale Battery Energy Storage and AI-Driven Intelligent ... BESS lifetime and operational performance balanced against economic and environm...
The research landscape on MPs is recent, heterogeneous, and rapidly growing, with limited synergies with existing construction datasets.
Synthesis of publication timelines, topic diversity, and cross-references in the included studies; qualitative assessment reported in the paper noting limited integration with existing construction datasets.
medium mixed The Material Passport for a Circular Construction Industry: ... research maturity (recency, heterogeneity, growth) and degree of integration wit...
Selection of human-LLM interaction archetype can influence LLM outputs and decisions.
Findings from the evaluation across clinical diagnostic cases (empirical comparison of archetypes' effects on outputs and decisions). Specific experimental details and sample size are not provided in the abstract.
medium mixed Who Does What? Archetypes of Roles Assigned to LLMs During H... changes in LLM outputs and decision outcomes associated with different human-LLM...
We evaluate these diverse archetypes across real-world clinical diagnostic cases to examine the potential effects of adopting distinct human-LLM archetypes on LLM outputs and decision outcomes.
Empirical evaluation described in the paper using real-world clinical diagnostic cases. Method: application of archetypes to clinical cases and comparison of resulting LLM outputs and decisions. Sample size and specific case details are not provided in the abstract.
medium mixed Who Does What? Archetypes of Roles Assigned to LLMs During H... LLM outputs and decision outcomes in clinical diagnostic cases
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) adoption is diffusing rapidly but its adoption is strikingly unequal.
Nationally representative UK survey data collected in 2023–2024 reporting adoption rates by subgroup; descriptive analysis of diffusion and disparities by demographic groups.
medium mixed Women Worry, Men Adopt: How Gendered Perceptions Shape the U... GenAI adoption rates (overall and by demographic groups)
Labour productivity developments in Slovakia were characterised by substantial short-term volatility during the study period.
Dynamics-of-change analysis of Eurostat labour productivity measures for Slovakia over 2021–2024 (time-series behaviour examined; exact productivity metric and sample size not specified in the summary).
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence Adoption and Labour Productivity in ... Labour productivity (aggregate national/enterprise-level productivity measure as...
More sophisticated AI-agent populations are not categorically better: whether increased sophistication helps or harms depends entirely on a single number—the capacity-to-population ratio—which can be known prior to deployment.
Combined empirical and mathematical findings in the paper showing that the effect of agent sophistication on collective outcomes is governed by the capacity-to-population ratio.
medium mixed Increasing intelligence in AI agents can worsen collective o... system-level benefit or harm as a function of agent sophistication and the capac...
Within the context of Nigeria, the adoption of advanced digital and AI-driven logistics solutions presents both a critical opportunity and a complex challenge for the country's seaports.
Analysis of secondary data sources focusing on Nigeria: academic literature by Nigerian scholars, Nigerian Ports Authority (NPA) performance reports, and policy documents as synthesized in the study.
medium mixed Digital and Ai-Driven Logistics in Nigeria’s Maritime Supply... adoption feasibility and implementation outcomes for Nigerian seaports (opportun...
AI is transforming jobs that are technical in nature.
Asserted in the paper's conceptual discussion of dual impacts; presented without empirical measurement or reported sample data in this paper.
medium mixed ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, AUTOMATION, AND THE CHANGING PATTER... nature of technical jobs (degree/type of transformation)
In the sentiment-analysis task, individual differences in user characteristics shape how users respond to AI explanations.
Results from the preregistered sentiment-analysis experiment reported in the paper indicating interaction effects between user characteristics and explanation types. (Exact sample size and statistical details not provided in the excerpt.)
medium mixed Who Needs What Explanation? How User Traits Affect Explanati... users' responses to AI explanations (behavioral measures in the sentiment-analys...
Data maturity, ethical governance of algorithms, and industry type shape business performance in AI-augmented workflows.
Moderator/subgroup analyses and qualitative synthesis across the reviewed studies indicating these contextual factors influence outcomes; based on the 85-publication review.
medium mixed ALGORITHMIC DETERMINISM VERSUS HUMAN AGENCY: A SYSTEMATIC RE... business performance / operational productivity as moderated by data maturity, g...
Most moderators tested in the analyses have a considerable influence on the relationship between AI use and business performance.
Moderator analyses reported in the meta-analysis (unspecified number of moderators) across the sample of reviewed studies (n=85).
medium mixed ALGORITHMIC DETERMINISM VERSUS HUMAN AGENCY: A SYSTEMATIC RE... moderation of AI → business performance effect (changes in effect size)
Digital transformation reshapes labor markets.
Paper asserts effects on labor markets (skills demand, employment patterns); the abstract lacks details on labor market data, sample sizes, or econometric analyses used to substantiate this claim.
medium mixed ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN THE CONTEXT OF DIGITALIZATION – CASE... labor market outcomes (employment levels, skill composition, wage distribution)
AI, blockchain, and big data analytics affect productivity, investment strategies, labor markets, and regulatory frameworks.
Stated in the paper as impacts analyzed; the abstract does not specify the data, methods, or scope used to measure these impacts.
medium mixed ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN THE CONTEXT OF DIGITALIZATION – CASE... productivity; investment strategy choices; labor market outcomes (employment, sk...
Digital transformation through artificial intelligence (AI), blockchain technology (BT), and big data (BD) analytics reconfigures economic mechanisms at both micro- and macroeconomic levels.
Paper-level analytic claim referencing impacts of AI, blockchain, and big data; detailed empirical methodology and sample information not described in the abstract.
medium mixed ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN THE CONTEXT OF DIGITALIZATION – CASE... economic mechanisms/relations at microeconomic (firms, markets) and macroeconomi...
This mainstream narrative about what AI is and what it can do is in tension with another emerging use case: entertainment.
Authors' conceptual argument contrasting dominant productivity-oriented narratives with observed/emerging entertainment uses; no quantified data in the excerpt.
medium mixed AI as Entertainment dominant narrative versus emerging use-case prevalence (productivity-oriented vs...
A consistent finding is that implementation outcomes are determined by institutional conditions rather than algorithmic performance.
Synthesis across the 81 reviewed sources indicating recurring patterns where institutional factors (governance, reimbursement, workforce, regulations) drive implementation success more than raw algorithmic accuracy. Specific studies supporting this pattern are not named in the abstract.
medium mixed Agentic AI for Ageing Healthcare Systems in Advanced Economi... implementation outcomes (adoption, scale-up, effectiveness) relative to institut...
The fast spread of artificial intelligence (AI) in U.S. organizations has radically altered the managerial decision-making process.
Statement based on a conceptual research design and integration of interdisciplinary literature (literature review). No empirical sample or quantitative data reported.
medium mixed Designing Human–AI Collaborative Decision Analytics Framewor... managerial decision-making process (structure, speed, inputs)
The increasing integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into organizational decision-making has fundamentally reshaped how managers analyze information, evaluate alternatives, and exercise judgment.
Synthesis of interdisciplinary literature presented in this conceptual meta-analysis; no primary empirical sample or quantitative effect sizes reported in the abstract (literature review basis).
medium mixed Reframing Organizational Decision-Making in the Age of Artif... managerial decision processes (information analysis, alternative evaluation, jud...
In digital tourism, there is both substitution potential (virtual experiences, demand management) and rebound risks that may offset emissions reductions.
Sectoral case synthesized from peer-reviewed studies and reports on digital tourism and travel demand (review-level evidence; no single empirical sample size).
medium mixed The synergy of digital innovation and green economy: A syste... tourism demand patterns, substitution to virtual experiences, and net emissions ...
Sustainable infrastructure and energy-transition analyses must account for hydrogen value chains and the substantial energy footprint of digital systems (data centers and AI workloads).
Review of sectoral studies on hydrogen supply chains and studies estimating energy use of data centers and AI workloads (review synthesis; specific lifecycle analyses and energy-use studies referenced in paper).
medium mixed The synergy of digital innovation and green economy: A syste... life-cycle carbon emissions of hydrogen value chains; energy consumption/carbon ...
The convergence of green finance and computing — especially automated ESG assessment — expands monitoring capacity but also amplifies measurement divergence and greenwashing risks.
Review of literature on automated ESG tools, sustainable finance, and computational assessment methods (synthesis of empirical and conceptual studies; no single sample size reported).
medium mixed The synergy of digital innovation and green economy: A syste... monitoring capacity (coverage/frequency of ESG assessments); measurement diverge...
AI and digitalization are restructuring labor markets, producing wage polarization and rents, with outcomes mediated by labor-market institutions.
Review of labor-market literature on AI/digitalization effects (aggregate synthesis of empirical studies and theoretical papers; review does not report an aggregated sample size).
medium mixed The synergy of digital innovation and green economy: A syste... wage distribution/polarization and economic rents captured by workers or firms
Progressing from ChatGPT 3.5 to 4.0 produced three distinct effect scenarios across markets, which reinforce the paper's inflection point conjecture.
Empirical comparison/analysis of the effects associated with different ChatGPT versions (3.5 vs 4.0) on online labor markets; method implied to be similar DiD or temporal comparison. (Specific sample sizes and the definitions of the three scenarios are not provided in the abstract.)
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence and Jobs: Has the Inflection Point A... market-level effects on work volume and earnings (categorized into three effect ...
The authors developed a Cournot competition model that identifies an inflection point for each market: before this point human workers benefit from AI enhancements; beyond this point human workers would be replaced.
Theoretical modeling via a Cournot competition framework constructed by the authors to characterize market dynamics and derive an inflection point; this is a model-based (analytical) result rather than an empirical estimate.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence and Jobs: Has the Inflection Point A... market-level outcomes determining whether human labor benefits (e.g., output/ear...
AI adoption rates differ across countries and firm sizes.
Descriptive/empirical comparisons using AI diffusion indicators and firm-level data from the four named Central and Eastern European countries; heterogeneity by firm size reported.
medium mixed The complementarity trap: AI adoption and value capture AI adoption rate (diffusion indicators by country and firm size)
AI productivity effects are not direct but conditional on organizational readiness.
Empirical analysis of firm-level data covering Serbia, Croatia, Czechia, and Romania combined with AI diffusion indicators; conditional/interaction analysis implied by framing (paper reports that productivity effects depend on organizational factors).
medium mixed The complementarity trap: AI adoption and value capture firm-level productivity (productivity effects of AI adoption conditional on orga...
AI drives changes in economic growth.
The paper synthesizes theoretical and empirical arguments from the literature about AI's role for economic growth; the review itself does not present new growth accounting or causal estimates.
medium mixed The Future of Work in the Age of AI: Economic Implications, ... economic growth (GDP growth or long-run growth trajectories) as discussed in the...
AI influences income and wage disparity.
Review discussion of research linking technological change and differential wage/income outcomes; no original econometric analysis or dataset presented in this paper.
medium mixed The Future of Work in the Age of AI: Economic Implications, ... income inequality / wage dispersion
AI adoption affects productivity levels.
Discussion and synthesis of existing economic literature on AI and productivity included in the review; the paper does not report primary empirical estimates or a quantified effect size.
medium mixed The Future of Work in the Age of AI: Economic Implications, ... productivity (e.g., output per worker or total factor productivity) as discussed...
By 2024Q2 the RL-FRB/US model produced a PCPI of 317.9 versus FRB/US model: 312.3 (reported as evidence of more effective inflation management).
Reported price index (PCPI) simulation outputs for 2024Q2 from the comparative model runs in the paper; the paper interprets the difference as improved inflation management.
medium mixed Fiscal Policy Towards Optimizing Macroeconomic Indicators by... PCPI (price index) at 2024Q2
Smaller models augmented with curated Skills can match the performance of larger models without Skills (model–skill tradeoff).
Cross-size performance comparisons reported across seven agent–model configurations showing that certain smaller model + curated-Skill pairings achieve pass rates comparable to larger model baselines without Skills. Analysis uses the SkillsBench trajectories (7,308 total) to support tradeoff claims.
medium mixed SkillsBench: Benchmarking How Well Agent Skills Work Across ... task pass rate (cross-model comparisons)
Education systems, training/reskilling, labor market institutions, industrial policy, and social safety nets mediate the net employment outcomes of AI adoption.
Policy and institutional analysis grounded in labor economics theory; presented as a mediating mechanism in the synthesis rather than demonstrated with empirical causal estimates or sample-based intervention studies.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... net employment outcomes conditional on institutional/policy interventions (emplo...
Knowledge industries exhibit significant complementarities as AI augments cognitive tasks, although some research and analytical roles may be automated.
Theory-based assessment of cognitive-task complementarity and substitution; synthesis rather than empirical occupational-level measurement or causal estimates provided in the paper.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... employment and task composition in knowledge industries; extent of cognitive-tas...
In services, routine service tasks are vulnerable to AI, while high-contact and creative services are less vulnerable; digital platform services are likely to expand.
Task-level sectoral reasoning and qualitative examples in services; no empirical sectoral employment dataset or quantified vulnerability scores reported in the paper.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... service-sector employment by task type; growth of digital platform services
Manufacturing has strong automation potential but also opportunities in advanced manufacturing and maintenance/engineering roles.
Sector-specific analysis combining task vulnerability to automation with emergence of advanced manufacturing tasks; presented as theoretical/qualitative assessment rather than measured manufacturing employment trajectories from a stated sample.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... manufacturing employment by task (automation-vulnerable vs. new advanced/mainten...
Distributional effects will include wage polarization (rising returns to high-skill labor and pressure on middle-skill wages) and uneven regional impacts.
Application of SBTC and task-based wage theory to AI adoption; sectoral and regional heterogeneity discussed qualitatively. No new wage-distribution panel or cross-country regression evidence reported in the paper.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... wage distribution (polarization); regional employment and wage heterogeneity
Short- to medium-run transitional unemployment, wage polarization, and sector- and country-level heterogeneity are likely.
Temporal-mismatch argument from task-based substitution and SBTC frameworks; sectoral assessment across manufacturing, services, knowledge industries. Evidence is theoretical/synthesized rather than from a stated empirical panel or cross-sectional dataset.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... transitional unemployment; wage distribution (polarization); cross-sector/countr...
Net employment outcomes depend more on institutions and policy than on technology alone.
Comparative treatment of advanced versus developing economies and policy/institutional analysis; grounded in economic theory rather than primary empirical causal estimates (no sample sizes or identification strategies reported).
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... net employment change (jobs lost vs. created) conditional on institutional/polic...
AI will substantially restructure labor markets.
Theory-driven sectoral analysis and task-based arguments (synthesis of labor economics frameworks). No primary empirical dataset or quantified cross-country sample reported in the paper.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... labor market composition / occupational structure
Knowledge industries exhibit strong complementarities with AI but also face task-level automation (e.g., routine analysis) that changes job content.
Literature synthesis on AI adoption in knowledge sectors and task-based mapping showing both complementarities and partial task substitution.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... task composition, job content, employment and wages in knowledge-sector occupati...
Services show mixed effects: routine clerical and customer-service tasks are vulnerable, while personalized, creative, and relational services are less so.
Task-level synthesis of service-sector automation exposure studies and conceptual analysis of task complementarities in relational services.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... employment and task composition in service occupations (clerical, customer-servi...
Manufacturing faces high automation potential for routine production tasks but also opportunities in advanced manufacturing and robotics maintenance.
Cross-sectoral analysis and literature on automation in manufacturing; theoretical task mapping indicating routine task exposure and emergence of maintenance/advanced roles.
medium mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... manufacturing employment by task (routine vs. advanced), demand for robotics/mai...