The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (4114 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Innovation Remove filter
The classifier generalizes well to Chinese patents based on citation and lexical validation.
Validation analyses described as citation-based and lexical validation applied to Chinese patents (paper states generalization to Chinese patents via these validation methods).
high positive AI Patents in the United States and China: Measurement, Orga... generalization / validity of classifier on Chinese patents
Our classifier substantially improves the existing USPTO approach, achieving 97.0% precision, 91.3% recall, and a 94.0% F1 score.
Reported classifier evaluation metrics (precision, recall, F1) presumably on held-out test data; comparison stated against the existing USPTO approach.
high positive AI Patents in the United States and China: Measurement, Orga... classification performance (precision, recall, F1)
We develop a high-precision classifier to measure artificial intelligence (AI) patents by fine-tuning PatentSBERTa on manually labeled data from the USPTO's AI Patent Dataset.
Methodological description in paper: fine-tuning PatentSBERTa on manually labeled USPTO AI Patent Dataset (manually labeled training data and model fine-tuning stated).
high positive AI Patents in the United States and China: Measurement, Orga... ability to classify patents as AI-related (classifier development)
Substituting subjective human preference with rigorous economic penalties provides a robust methodology for aligning autonomous agents in high-stakes, real-world environments.
Conclusion drawn from the authors' empirical study and the reported final-system performance; presented as a general methodological claim (supporting data referenced in paper but not detailed in excerpt).
high positive OOM-RL: Out-of-Money Reinforcement Learning Market-Driven Al... effectiveness of economic penalties as an alignment method
The final OOM-RL-aligned system achieved a stable equilibrium with an annualized Sharpe ratio of 2.06 in its mature phase.
Quantitative performance result reported for the mature phase of the system in the paper's abstract; Sharpe ratio provided as a single-number metric (no sample size, number of trading periods, or statistical significance reported in the excerpt).
The MAS abandoned overfitted hallucinations in favor of the Strict Test-Driven Agentic Workflow (STDAW), which enforces a Byzantine-inspired uni-directional state lock (RO-Lock) anchored to a deterministically verified ≥95% code coverage constraint matrix.
Design and outcome claim in the paper: introduction of STDAW/RO-Lock and reported enforcement of a ≥95% code coverage constraint as part of the aligned architecture (qualitative + a coverage threshold stated).
high positive OOM-RL: Out-of-Money Reinforcement Learning Market-Driven Al... code coverage (>=95%) and reduction in hallucinations / overfitting
The system evolved from a high-turnover, sycophantic baseline to a robust, liquidity-aware architecture over the course of the study.
Reported longitudinal observations from the 20-month empirical study described in the paper (qualitative system evolution claim; no numeric counts provided in excerpt).
high positive OOM-RL: Out-of-Money Reinforcement Learning Market-Driven Al... system architecture and behaviour (turnover rate, sycophancy, liquidity awarenes...
We introduce Out-of-Money Reinforcement Learning (OOM-RL): deploying agents into the non-stationary, high-friction reality of live financial markets to utilize capital depletion as an un-hackable negative gradient.
Methodological claim / novel paradigm introduced by the paper; described as implemented in the study (no numerical sample size given in excerpt).
high positive OOM-RL: Out-of-Money Reinforcement Learning Market-Driven Al... use of financial loss (capital depletion) as negative training signal for agent ...
The Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity reveals a convergence of complex phenomena across fields onto simple underlying design principles with important predictive value for future distributed production systems.
Synthesis claim in the paper arguing cross-field convergence and predictive value based on the theoretical model and conceptual examples; no empirical validation or forecasting trials reported.
high positive The Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity Optimises Productivit... predictive value of the model/principles for future distributed production syste...
The principles derived (including the Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity) can be used as a blueprint for constructing ideal distributed production systems; demonstrated by suggesting specific redesigns for compute systems executing large-scale AI.
Paper includes suggested redesigns for compute systems as demonstrations of the blueprint; these are proposed designs/illustrative applications rather than empirically validated interventions or trials.
high positive The Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity Optimises Productivit... design-guided performance improvements in compute systems for large-scale AI (pr...
The Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity applies recursively across all layers of nested production systems.
Theoretical claim within the paper arguing recursive applicability across nested system layers (e.g., neurons, firms, ecosystems); supported by conceptual reasoning and model exposition rather than empirical multi-layer tests.
high positive The Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity Optimises Productivit... emergence/spread of heterogeneity across nested layers
The communication topology determines the spatial scale over which heterogeneity spreads in distributed production systems.
Model-based theoretical argument in the paper linking topology to the spatial scale of heterogeneity; illustrated conceptually and via examples but not via empirical sample testing.
high positive The Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity Optimises Productivit... spatial scale/spread of heterogeneity as a function of communication topology
Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity: any distributed production system optimising for performance will converge on an increasingly heterogeneous configuration.
Statement of a derived principle from the paper's model (theoretical derivation/argument); demonstration via model reasoning and examples rather than empirical testing; no sample size reported.
high positive The Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity Optimises Productivit... degree of heterogeneity in agent/configuration space
A small set of underlying laws generates the complex dynamics observed across fields (biology, economics, neuroscience, computing).
Theoretical argument and synthesis across disciplines within the paper; no empirical or experimental sample size reported.
high positive The Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity Optimises Productivit... explanatory coverage of complex system dynamics
The Distributed Production System model captures how agent heterogeneity, resource constraints, communication topology, and task structure jointly determine the productivity, efficiency, and robustness of distributed systems across biology, economics, neuroscience, and computing.
Presentation of a unified theoretical model (Distributed Production System) in the paper; conceptual/mathematical development and cross-disciplinary argumentation; no empirical sample size reported.
high positive The Principle of Maximum Heterogeneity Optimises Productivit... productivity, efficiency, and robustness of distributed systems
Relatedness-based simulations identify, when it exists, for each country the Simplest Single Sovereignty Enhancing Technology (SSSET), i.e., the most feasible single new technological direction associated with the largest expected improvement in relative geoeconomic positioning.
Simulation/relatedness analysis described in paper: for each country, relatedness-based (proximity) simulations used to propose the single most feasible technology (SSSET) expected to yield the largest improvement in geoeconomic position.
high positive The Geoeconomics of Venture Capital An Economic Complexity A... identified SSSET per country (predicted improvement in geoeconomic positioning)
The United States and Israel consistently occupy a marked 'high-diversity/low-ubiquity' position and lead the GCI ranking, followed by China, France, Japan, and Germany.
Empirical ranking produced by the GCI measure applied to the 17-country sample (paper reports ordering and characterization of US and Israel positions).
high positive The Geoeconomics of Venture Capital An Economic Complexity A... GCI ranking and characterization ('high-diversity/low-ubiquity')
Cloud Computing, Cybersecurity Tools, and Medtech exhibit the highest ETGCI values, reflecting concentration of specialization in a small set of leading countries.
Empirical result computed from ETGCI values derived from the RVA specialization matrix; paper reports these domains as having the highest ETGCI (implying concentration among high-GCI countries).
high positive The Geoeconomics of Venture Capital An Economic Complexity A... ETGCI value (degree to which domain specialization is concentrated among high-GC...
From this matrix we derive two eigenvector-based measures: a Geoeconomic Complexity Index (GCI) that ranks countries by the composition of their venture specializations, and an Emerging Technology Geoeconomic Complexity Index (ETGCI) that ranks domains by the extent to which specialization is concentrated among high-GCI countries.
Methodological claim: eigenvector centrality/complexity approach applied to the RVA-based specialization matrix to derive two indices (GCI for countries, ETGCI for domains).
high positive The Geoeconomics of Venture Capital An Economic Complexity A... Geoeconomic Complexity Index (GCI) and Emerging Technology Geoeconomic Complexit...
We construct an RVA-based country-technology specialization matrix for the 17 countries with the highest aggregate VC funding.
Methodological statement in paper: Revealed Venture Advantage (RVA) metric computed and used to build country-by-technology specialization matrix restricted to top 17 countries by aggregate VC funding.
high positive The Geoeconomics of Venture Capital An Economic Complexity A... country-technology specialization (RVA)
We map venture-backed startups to 18 emerging technology domains via a probabilistic multi-label large-language-model classifier using Crunchbase firm- and deal-level data.
Methodological description in paper: Crunchbase firm- and deal-level data used; classification into 18 domains performed with a probabilistic multi-label LLM classifier (paper states this pipeline).
high positive The Geoeconomics of Venture Capital An Economic Complexity A... assignment of startups to emerging technology domains
Overall, BDA functions as a performance amplifier, yielding higher returns for ventures well-positioned to leverage its potential.
Synthesis conclusion from empirical findings across multiple outcomes (survival, costs, sales, employee growth, financing) in the sample of German start-ups.
high positive Big data-based management decisions and start-up performance performance/returns to adopters
For high-performing BDA adopters, employee growth is even more pronounced.
Heterogeneity analysis in the paper indicating stronger employee growth among high-performing BDA adopters in the German start-up sample.
high positive Big data-based management decisions and start-up performance employee growth (headcount growth) for high-performing adopters
For high-performing BDA adopters, increases in sales are even more pronounced.
Paper reports heterogeneity analysis showing stronger sales effects among high-performing adopters in the German start-up sample.
high positive Big data-based management decisions and start-up performance sales (revenue levels) for high-performing adopters
Conditional on survival, BDA adopters are more likely to attract venture capital financing.
Empirical finding in the paper that surviving BDA adopters have a greater likelihood of obtaining venture capital, based on the sample of German start-ups.
high positive Big data-based management decisions and start-up performance access to financing (venture capital uptake)
Conditional on survival, BDA adopters show stronger employee growth.
Paper reports greater employee growth for surviving BDA adopters compared with non-adopters based on empirical data from German start-ups.
high positive Big data-based management decisions and start-up performance employee growth (headcount growth)
Conditional on survival, BDA adopters have higher sales.
Conditional (survivor) analysis reported for adopters versus non-adopters in a large sample of German start-ups.
The policy’s impact on inclusive green growth is most pronounced in cities with areas between 5,000 and 10,000 square kilometers.
Subgroup analysis by city area within the DID framework showing the largest estimated policy effect for cities whose area is between 5,000 and 10,000 km^2 (sample size not reported).
high positive How does green digital economy policy enable inclusive green... Inclusive green growth (heterogeneous effect by city area)
The policy exhibits spatial spillover effects on neighboring regions that diminish progressively with distance (spatial decay).
Spatial analysis of policy effects across neighboring regions showing declining effect sizes as geographic distance increases (details and sample size not reported).
high positive How does green digital economy policy enable inclusive green... Inclusive green growth in neighboring cities/regions (spillover magnitude decrea...
Mechanism tests indicate the policy primarily enhances inclusive green growth by strengthening public environmental participation.
Mechanism/mediation tests reported in the study (presumably within the DID framework) showing an increase in measures of public environmental participation associated with the policy and linked to inclusive green growth (sample size not reported).
high positive How does green digital economy policy enable inclusive green... Inclusive green growth (mediated by public environmental participation)
Mechanism tests indicate the policy primarily enhances inclusive green growth by strengthening government environmental participation.
Mechanism/mediation tests reported in the study (presumably within the DID framework) showing an increase in measures of government environmental participation associated with the policy and linked to inclusive green growth (sample size not reported).
high positive How does green digital economy policy enable inclusive green... Inclusive green growth (mediated by government environmental participation)
The policy's positive impact on inclusive green growth is particularly pronounced in non-traditional industrial cities.
Heterogeneity/subsample analysis within the DID framework comparing treated non-traditional industrial cities to others (sample size not reported).
high positive How does green digital economy policy enable inclusive green... Inclusive green growth (relative effect size larger in non-traditional industria...
The policy's positive impact on inclusive green growth is particularly pronounced in digital economy clusters.
Heterogeneity/subsample analysis within the DID framework comparing treated cities located in digital economy clusters to others (sample size not reported).
high positive How does green digital economy policy enable inclusive green... Inclusive green growth (relative effect size larger in digital economy clusters)
The policy's positive impact on inclusive green growth is particularly pronounced in high-quality development pilot zones.
Heterogeneity/subsample analysis within the DID framework comparing treated cities in high-quality development pilot zones to others (sample size not reported).
high positive How does green digital economy policy enable inclusive green... Inclusive green growth (relative effect size larger in high-quality pilot zones)
The 2015 Green Data Center Pilot Policy effectively promotes inclusive green growth in cities, increasing the average annual growth rate of inclusive green growth by 0.9 percentage points.
Quasi-natural experiment using the 2015 Green Data Center Pilot Policy as treatment, analyzed with a difference-in-differences (DID) econometric approach on city-level data (sample size not reported in the provided text).
high positive How does green digital economy policy enable inclusive green... Average annual growth rate of inclusive green growth
Policy implication: regionally differentiated strategies are needed to harness the mechanisms through which digital–intelligent integration reduces carbon intensity in different contexts.
Inference drawn from empirical findings of heterogeneous, geographically constrained spillovers and identified mediating mechanisms (policy recommendation stated in the paper).
high positive Research on the Pathways and Spatial Effects of Digital–Inte... policy formulation (regional differentiation)
The scientific novelty of the work is to interpret omniscalers as structural actors of a new phase of technological races and to refine the concept of digital inequality as inequality of access, control, and scaling.
Author's stated contribution based on theoretical synthesis and conceptual innovation (no external empirical validation reported).
high positive OMNISCALER AND NEW TECHNOLOGICAL RACES: DIGITAL INEQUALITY I... conceptual reframing of omniscalers and digital inequality
Arenas of competition function as interconnected structural nodes of the contemporary economy, and recognizing them is key to understanding global transformations driven by digital and AI-related competition.
Theoretical argument and systematization combining approaches to digital development and technological races; no empirical network analysis reported.
high positive OMNISCALER AND NEW TECHNOLOGICAL RACES: DIGITAL INEQUALITY I... interconnectedness and structural centrality of competition arenas in the econom...
Digital inequality evolves from asymmetry in access to knowledge, infrastructure, and digital markets toward inequality in control over critical technological nodes and the ability to scale advantages across several high-dynamics arenas.
Theoretical differentiation and chronological framing developed via comparative and structural-logical analysis; no empirical longitudinal data reported.
high positive OMNISCALER AND NEW TECHNOLOGICAL RACES: DIGITAL INEQUALITY I... evolutionary shift in the nature of digital inequality (from access to control/s...
The 'AI foundation'—semiconductors, cloud services, and AI software and services—serves as the core platform of current technological races.
Conceptual synthesis and structural-logical argument drawing on literature about digital infrastructure and AI; no empirical measurement provided.
high positive OMNISCALER AND NEW TECHNOLOGICAL RACES: DIGITAL INEQUALITY I... role of semiconductors, cloud services, and AI software as core platform enablin...
Digital inequality manifests at micro-, meso-, and macro-levels as asymmetry between firms, sectors, countries, and regions.
Analytical mapping and theoretical systematization (comparative method); no empirical counts or samples reported.
high positive OMNISCALER AND NEW TECHNOLOGICAL RACES: DIGITAL INEQUALITY I... asymmetry in access/control across firms, sectors, countries, regions
Digital inequality increasingly concerns access to scaling infrastructures (control over critical nodes) rather than only formal access to technologies.
Theoretical generalization and comparative reasoning across arenas of competition; no quantitative data reported.
high positive OMNISCALER AND NEW TECHNOLOGICAL RACES: DIGITAL INEQUALITY I... relative access and control over scaling infrastructures
Omniscalers scale infrastructural capabilities that are reusable across multiple technological and market environments, thereby generating cumulative self-reinforcing effects.
Theoretical argument and systematization; illustrative conceptual analysis rather than empirical measurement.
high positive OMNISCALER AND NEW TECHNOLOGICAL RACES: DIGITAL INEQUALITY I... generation of cumulative self-reinforcing effects from reusable infrastructural ...
Omniscalers emerge as a new type of corporate actor capable of transferring accumulated infrastructural, financial, innovation, and data advantages across several arenas of competition simultaneously.
Conceptual definition and theoretical generalization using comparative and structural-logical methods (no empirical sample reported).
high positive OMNISCALER AND NEW TECHNOLOGICAL RACES: DIGITAL INEQUALITY I... ability to transfer accumulated advantages across multiple arenas
Contemporary competition is shifting from rivalry over individual markets toward control over scaling infrastructures that enable data processing, computing capacity, digital integration, and the diffusion of new business models.
Theoretical argumentation based on structural-logical analysis, comparative method, systematization, and theoretical generalization (no empirical sample reported).
high positive OMNISCALER AND NEW TECHNOLOGICAL RACES: DIGITAL INEQUALITY I... control over scaling infrastructures (data processing, computing capacity, digit...
The next stage of research should not treat forecasting, allocation, and ESG-related corporate finance as separate literatures; instead, future work should build integrated frameworks in which market prediction, portfolio design, and firm-level sustainable finance analysis are jointly modeled under explicit assumptions about data quality, decision frequency, and accountability.
Central recommendation/conclusion of the review advocating future integrated research frameworks (normative guidance based on the literature synthesis).
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Financial Decision-Making recommended direction for future research integration and modeling assumptions
AI is used not only to predict ESG ratings and financial constraints but also to identify firm heterogeneity, financing frictions, and disclosure-based signals.
Summary of corporate finance and sustainable finance literature in the review indicating applications of AI to predict ESG ratings, financial constraints and to detect firm-level heterogeneity and signals (survey-based; no single sample size).
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Financial Decision-Making use of AI for predicting ESG ratings, financial constraints, and identifying fir...
The review synthesizes the evolution of forecasting methods from classical econometric models to recurrent neural networks, transformers, and hybrid architectures.
Literature synthesis reported in the paper; descriptive summary of methodological developments across forecasting literature (no empirical sample reported).
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Financial Decision-Making methodological evolution in financial forecasting
These domains should be interpreted as parts of a broader decision architecture in which algorithms extract signals from noisy data, transform those signals into investment or financing choices, and then evaluate outcomes under multiple objectives that increasingly include environmental, social, and governance criteria.
Normative/conceptual proposal presented in the review arguing for an integrated interpretive framework (theoretical argument drawing on surveyed literature).
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Financial Decision-Making integration of forecasting, allocation, and ESG objectives into a decision archi...
Artificial intelligence has become a major methodological force in financial decision-making.
Statement from the paper's abstract/overview describing AI's role; based on a literature review across financial decision-making domains (no empirical sample reported).
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Financial Decision-Making role/adoption of AI in financial decision-making