The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (3231 claims)

Adoption
7395 claims
Productivity
6507 claims
Governance
5921 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
5192 claims
Org Design
3497 claims
Innovation
3492 claims
Labor Markets
3231 claims
Skills & Training
2608 claims
Inequality
1842 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 609 159 77 738 1617
Governance & Regulation 671 334 160 99 1285
Organizational Efficiency 626 147 105 70 955
Technology Adoption Rate 502 176 98 78 861
Research Productivity 349 109 48 322 838
Output Quality 391 121 45 40 597
Firm Productivity 385 46 85 17 539
Decision Quality 277 145 63 34 526
AI Safety & Ethics 189 244 59 30 526
Market Structure 152 154 109 20 440
Task Allocation 158 50 56 26 295
Innovation Output 178 23 38 17 257
Skill Acquisition 137 52 50 13 252
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 120 64 38 23 252
Employment Level 93 46 96 12 249
Firm Revenue 130 43 26 3 202
Consumer Welfare 99 51 40 11 201
Inequality Measures 36 106 40 6 188
Task Completion Time 134 18 6 5 163
Worker Satisfaction 79 54 16 11 160
Error Rate 64 79 8 1 152
Regulatory Compliance 69 66 14 3 152
Training Effectiveness 82 16 13 18 131
Wages & Compensation 70 25 22 6 123
Team Performance 74 16 21 9 121
Automation Exposure 41 48 19 9 120
Job Displacement 11 71 16 1 99
Developer Productivity 71 14 9 3 98
Hiring & Recruitment 49 7 8 3 67
Social Protection 26 14 8 2 50
Creative Output 26 14 6 2 49
Skill Obsolescence 5 37 5 1 48
Labor Share of Income 12 13 12 37
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Labor Markets Remove filter
The analysis raises policy implications emphasizing reskilling and education to address AI-driven changes in the labor market.
Policy discussion section summarized in the paper; draws on empirical findings and literature to recommend reskilling/education.
high positive Impact Of Artificial Intelligence (AI) On Employment reskilling / education needs
Moderate AI usage is associated with employment growth.
Part of the U-shaped relationship reported in the paper's empirical results; described qualitatively in the abstract/summary.
Under economy-wide deployment, the share of computer-vision-exposed labor compensation that is cost-effectively automatable rises sharply (relative to the firm-level 11% estimate).
Model counterfactuals or calibration scenarios comparing firm-level deployment vs economy-wide deployment; qualitative statement that share increases substantially.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... share of labor compensation automatable under economy-wide deployment
At the firm level, cost-effective automation captures approximately 11% of computer-vision-exposed labor compensation.
Calibration and implementation in computer vision; reported firm-level estimate from the framework.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... share of computer-vision-exposed labor compensation captured by cost-effective a...
Scale of deployment is a key determinant: AI-as-a-Service and AI agents spread fixed costs across users, sharply expanding economically viable tasks.
Modeling and calibration arguments showing fixed-cost spreading effects increase set of tasks for which automation is cost-effective; qualitative and quantitative comparisons in implementation.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... number/coverage of economically viable tasks (adoption potential) as a function ...
Because higher accuracy is disproportionately costly (convex cost), full automation is often not cost-minimizing; partial automation, where firms retain human workers for residual tasks, frequently emerges as the equilibrium.
Theoretical model combined with calibration (scaling laws + task mappings); equilibrium outcomes reported from the framework implementation.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... prevalence of partial automation vs full automation as cost-minimizing choices
We model automation intensity as a continuous choice in which firms minimize costs by selecting an AI accuracy level, from no automation through partial human-AI collaboration to full automation.
The paper develops a theoretical framework / model that treats automation intensity as a continuous decision variable; described as the central modeling approach.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... degree of automation (accuracy level chosen by firms)
Hukum diharapkan tidak hanya berfungsi sebagai alat perlindungan, tetapi juga sebagai instrumen strategis dalam mengelola transisi menuju masa depan kerja yang lebih inklusif, adil, dan berkelanjutan di era kecerdasan buatan.
Kesimpulan dan rekomendasi normatif penulis berdasarkan analisis perundang-undangan dan literatur yang dikaji.
high positive Reformasi Hukum Ketenagakerjaan di Era Artificial Intelligen... peran hukum sebagai instrumen pengelolaan transisi tenaga kerja
Pengakuan 'hak atas pengembangan keterampilan berkelanjutan' (right to lifelong learning) penting dan perlu dimasukkan sebagai bagian integral dari perlindungan pekerja di era digital.
Klaim normatif dan rekomendasi kebijakan yang muncul dari studi konseptual dan tinjauan literatur komparatif.
high positive Reformasi Hukum Ketenagakerjaan di Era Artificial Intelligen... pengakuan hak atas pembelajaran berkelanjutan untuk pekerja
Diperlukan reformasi hukum yang lebih progresif dan adaptif, termasuk penguatan sistem jaminan sosial dan pembaruan kebijakan fiskal untuk menangani dampak AI.
Rekomendasi kebijakan yang disimpulkan dari analisis normatif dan komparatif serta tinjauan literatur dalam penelitian.
high positive Reformasi Hukum Ketenagakerjaan di Era Artificial Intelligen... kebutuhan reformasi hukum (jaminan sosial dan kebijakan fiskal)
Diperlukan dasar hukum bagi penerapan model kompensasi inovatif seperti Universal Basic Income (UBI), pajak otomasi, dan skema distribusi manfaat produktivitas AI.
Rekomendasi kebijakan hasil analisis normatif dan komparatif yang dikemukakan penulis berdasarkan tinjauan literatur.
high positive Reformasi Hukum Ketenagakerjaan di Era Artificial Intelligen... kebutuhan dasar hukum untuk mekanisme kompensasi inovatif (UBI, pajak otomasi, d...
Social security solutions must be adapted to evolving human-technology interactions to secure social justice and cohesion.
Normative conclusion/recommendation from the paper's discussion; advanced as a necessary policy direction without reported empirical validation in the provided text.
high positive IoT, artificial intelligence, cloud computing and robotics a... social justice and social cohesion via adapted social security solutions
Establishing contributory frameworks based on technology-generated income will ensure the sustainability of social protection in the era of labor displacement.
Presented as a novel policy proposal in the paper; stated as a solution with the asserted effect of ensuring sustainability rather than demonstrated via empirical testing or simulation within the text provided.
high positive IoT, artificial intelligence, cloud computing and robotics a... sustainability of social protection/social security financing
The Internet of Things (IoT) represents a transformative force, integrating digital intelligence with the physical world and catalyzing new relationships across economic sectors.
Stated as a conceptual assertion in the paper's introduction/overview; presented as a high-level literature-informed claim (no empirical sample or quantitative analysis reported).
high positive IoT, artificial intelligence, cloud computing and robotics a... integration of digital intelligence with the physical world and cross-sectoral e...
Proposition 2: An increase in the pace of technology creation (m(b) rising from m to m') generates a transitory increase in the skill premium (even if the increase is permanent, because new technologies eventually age).
Analytical result (proposition) proved in the paper's model appendix; intuition and special-case (γ=σ) illustrated in text.
high positive THE SKILL PREMIUM IN TIMES OF RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE transitional behavior of skill premium following a change in m(b)
The college premium rose first among young workers and later among older workers; a model extension that assumes younger workers have a comparative advantage in new technologies generates age-specific increases that account for half of the observed age gaps.
Extension of the model with worker demographics; calibration using CPS data on computer use by worker age (showing young workers used computers more intensively initially) and simulation comparing model to observed age-specific wage premium changes.
high positive THE SKILL PREMIUM IN TIMES OF RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE college premium by worker age (timing and magnitude of increase)
Slow diffusion, combined with the rapid pace of technology creation, accounts for 6.2 of the 8.7 log-point differential increase in the skill premium between high- and low-density regions over 1980–2005.
Model calibrated with estimated diffusion rates across regions from the text-based dataset; quantitative decomposition attributing portions of the regional differential to the mechanism.
high positive THE SKILL PREMIUM IN TIMES OF RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE regional differential increase in skill premium (log points) over 1980–2005
The mechanism explains why the college premium is higher in dense cities and why its increase was mainly urban.
Model extension incorporating regional diffusion of technologies combined with estimates of diffusion rates across locations (using the Kalyani et al. dataset); comparison of model predictions to documented urban–rural wage premium patterns.
high positive THE SKILL PREMIUM IN TIMES OF RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE college premium by city density
Total demand for college-educated workers increased by 100 log points since 1980; changes in the pace of technology creation account for one-third of that increase, with the remainder attributed to residual structural changes in production.
Model-based decomposition calibrated to data (demand and supply of college-educated workers since 1980); quantitative accounting exercise reported in the paper.
high positive THE SKILL PREMIUM IN TIMES OF RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE demand for college-educated workers (log points since 1980)
When calibrated to the observed pace of technology creation, the model generates a 28 log-point (32 percent) increase in the college premium between 1980 and 2010, which then flattens and begins to revert.
Quantitative calibration of the model to novel text-based technology data (arrival and diffusion) and wage series (CPS); simulation results.
high positive THE SKILL PREMIUM IN TIMES OF RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE college premium over 1980–2010
The data show a temporary increase in the pace of new technology creation beginning in the 1970s, accelerating in the 1980s, and tapering off in the 2000s.
Time series of identified new technologies from text-based measures (patent text/job posting linkage) covering 1976–2007 (as in Kalyani et al., 2025) used to measure arrival rates by cohort.
high positive THE SKILL PREMIUM IN TIMES OF RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE rate of arrival of new technologies (pace of technology creation)
The pace of technology creation is a key driver of the skill premium: a rapid pace of technology creation leads to a sustained increase in the skill premium (because skilled workers learn to use new technologies faster).
Theoretical model developed in the paper in which new technologies arrive exogenously and skilled workers have a comparative advantage in learning new technologies; supported by calibration using novel text-based data (patent text and job postings) and CPS wage data.
high positive THE SKILL PREMIUM IN TIMES OF RAPID TECHNOLOGICAL CHANGE skill premium (college wage premium)
Autor et al. (2024) show that the majority of current employment is in job specialties that did not exist in 1940, with new task creation driven by augmentation-type innovations.
Citation reported in the paper summarizing Autor et al. (2024); no sample size provided in excerpt.
high positive NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES share of employment in new job specialties (post-1940) and driver of new task cr...
Firms may not sufficiently account for non-monetary aspects of technological progress (well-being, safety, quality of work); a planner would include such considerations in steering technological progress.
Normative conclusion based on theoretical analysis comparing firm objective functions (profits) vs social planner objectives (including non-monetary utility).
high positive NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES attention to non-monetary aspects / inclusion in technological steering
The planner can raise social welfare by focusing technological progress on making goods cheaper that are disproportionately consumed by relatively poorer agents, thereby raising their real income.
Extension of the baseline model to multiple goods showing distributional gains via composition of price changes (real income channel).
high positive NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES real income of poorer agents / social welfare
When capital and labor are gross complements, a planner concerned with workers' welfare would favor capital-augmenting innovations to raise wages.
Analytical result from the model analyzing factor-augmenting technological progress and complementarity between capital and labor.
high positive NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES wages
A planner with sufficient welfare weight on workers will impose positive robot taxes, with the tax rate increasing in the planner's concern for workers' welfare.
Application of the baseline model to robot taxation; analytical derivation of optimal robot tax under planner preferences.
high positive NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES optimal robot tax rate
As labor's economic value diminishes, steering progress focuses increasingly on enhancing human well-being (non-monetary aspects) rather than labor productivity.
Theoretical discussion and model results in the paper showing planner's shifting objective when labor is devalued.
high positive NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES focus of technological steering (monetary productivity vs non-monetary well-bein...
The welfare benefits of steering technology are greater the less efficient social safety nets are.
Analytical result from the paper's theoretical model comparing a planner who can/cannot perform transfers and evaluating steering as second-best when redistribution is costly.
high positive NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES welfare benefits of steering technological progress
Education and workforce development should shift focus from rote knowledge accumulation to cultivating skills in human-AI collaboration, creative problem-solving, and the design of novel economic domains.
Normative policy recommendation derived from the paper's framework and analysis of anticipated labor market changes (no empirical evaluation or trial data reported in the abstract).
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work educational focus / skill composition
Human-AI co-evolution will significantly increase individual productivity and open new frontiers of economic activity.
Projected outcome based on combined analysis of AI capabilities, historical patterns, and platform growth; the abstract does not report empirical measurement or sample sizes for this projection.
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work individual productivity and emergence of new economic activities
AI-driven productivity augmentation dramatically lowers the barriers to creating economic value, enabling the decentralized generation of employment.
Argument supported by paper's analysis of contemporary labor market dynamics and the growth of digital platforms; no quantified empirical estimates or sample sizes provided in the abstract.
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work barriers to entry for value creation / individual productivity
The transition to an AI-civilization will fundamentally restructure the mechanisms of employment creation from a centralized model (few organizations creating jobs for the many) to a decentralized ecosystem where individuals are empowered to generate their own employment opportunities.
Central thesis of the paper, motivated by theoretical argumentation and synthesis of contemporary data on labor markets and digital platforms (no empirical test or sample sizes specified in the abstract).
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work structure/mechanism of employment creation (centralized vs decentralized)
Historical precedents from past technological revolutions suggest that innovation tends to expand, rather than shrink, the scope of economic activity and employment in the long run.
Paper draws on analysis of economic history (qualitative historical analysis implied; no specific historical datasets or sample sizes provided in the abstract).
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work scope of economic activity and long-run employment levels
The productivity channel raises corporate cash flows and is equity-bullish.
Model mechanism described in the paper: productivity effects of AI increase corporate cash flows which, within the model, produce an equity-bullish effect on the ERP/valuations.
high positive When Does AI Raise the Equity Risk Premium? Displacement, Pa... corporate cash flows / equity risk premium
Endogenous structural break analysis identifies 2007 as the break year for AI introduction in India.
Empirical analysis reported in the paper using an endogenous structural break test applied to relevant time-series data (paper states 2007 was identified as the break year).
high positive Artificial Intelligence, Demand Switching and Sectoral Wage ... identified structural break year for AI introduction
A shift in preference towards non-traded AI services exacerbates income inequality among previously homogeneous workers in the non-traded sector (model finding).
Results from the paper's Finite Change General Equilibrium (theoretical) model which introduces AI as a shock in the non-traded sector and analyzes effects via price adjustments.
high positive Artificial Intelligence, Demand Switching and Sectoral Wage ... income inequality / wage differentials among homogeneous workers
Artificial intelligence (AI) induced services are a reality in India and other developing countries.
Statement in paper citing existence/emergence of AI-powered services (examples given: Windows Live, AI ride-hailing apps such as Ola and Uber); descriptive assertion rather than quantified empirical analysis in the paper.
high positive Artificial Intelligence, Demand Switching and Sectoral Wage ... presence/adoption of AI-induced services
The framework provides a roadmap for coordinated response across educational institutions, government agencies, and industry to ensure workforce resilience and domestic leadership in the emerging agentic finance era.
Authors' proposed integrated roadmap (prescriptive recommendation; no empirical testing or outcome measurement reported in the provided text).
high positive STRENGTHENING FINANCIAL WORKFORCE COMPETITIVENESS: A CURRICU... workforce resilience and domestic leadership in agentic finance
We develop a comprehensive government policy framework including: 1) Federal AI literacy mandates for post-secondary business education; 2) Department of Labor workforce retraining programs with income support for displaced financial professionals; 3) SEC and Treasury regulatory innovations creating market incentives for workforce development; 4) State-level workforce partnerships implementing regional transition support; and 5) Enhanced social safety nets for workers navigating career transitions during the estimated 5-15 year transformation period.
Author-presented policy framework and recommendations (policy design proposals and an asserted 5–15 year transformation timeframe; no empirical evaluation reported).
high positive STRENGTHENING FINANCIAL WORKFORCE COMPETITIVENESS: A CURRICU... policy adoption and worker support measures during technological transition
We propose a multi-layered integration strategy for higher education encompassing: 1) Foundational AI literacy modules for all business students; 2) A specialized "Agentic Financial Planning" course with hands-on labs; 3) AI-augmented redesign of core courses (Investments, Portfolio Management, Ethics); 4) Interdisciplinary project-based learning with Computer Science; and 5) A governance and policy module addressing regulatory compliance (NIST AI RMF, SEC regulations).
Proposed curricular framework presented by the authors (recommendation/proposal, not empirically tested within the paper).
high positive STRENGTHENING FINANCIAL WORKFORCE COMPETITIVENESS: A CURRICU... student AI-related skills and preparedness for agentic finance roles
Recommended regulatory responses include algorithmic transparency mandates, mandatory mental health risk audits, participatory co-design, human review of deactivations, and minimum wage protections aligned with ILO principles.
Authors' policy recommendations derived from the review's synthesis and identified psychological risks.
high positive Algorithmic Control and Psychological Risk in Digitally Mana... policy/regulatory interventions recommended
Investments in education and training are crucial for mitigating AI-induced employment disruptions and enhancing workforce adaptability.
Policy recommendation drawn from the paper's empirical findings (PLS-SEM, n = 351) and discussion.
Job displacement intensifies the demand for new skills, highlighting the need for reskilling and upskilling initiatives.
Finding reported from the study's PLS-SEM analysis of survey responses (n = 351).
AI has also fostered employment growth in emerging industries.
Empirical finding reported from the study's analysis of survey data (PLS-SEM, n = 351).
Policy should address not only the aftermath of AI labor displacement but also the competitive incentives that drive it.
Normative implication drawn from the model's findings; recommendation in the paper's conclusion based on theoretical results.
high positive The AI Layoff Trap policy focus (prevention of displacement through regulation of competitive incen...
Only a Pigouvian automation tax can eliminate the excess automation in the model.
Theoretical welfare analysis demonstrating that a properly set Pigouvian tax that internalizes the demand externality restores the socially optimal level of automation in the model; analytical result, no empirical sample.
high positive The AI Layoff Trap restoration of socially optimal automation level / prevention of excess displace...
Human-replacing technologies have a strategic role in enhancing industrial productivity and ensuring the long-term resilience of Ukraine’s mining and metallurgical sector amid workforce shortages and structural labour-market changes due to war and demographic decline.
Integrated sectoral assessment in the paper combining current context (workforce shortages, structural changes), literature on technology-driven productivity/resilience, and industry-specific considerations; presented as a high-level conclusion.
high positive Human-replacing technologies as a driver of labour productiv... industrial productivity and sectoral resilience
Integrating ergonomic assessments and human–systems–interaction approaches into automation projects is important to prevent cognitive overload, occupational stress and operational risks for control‑room operators.
Recommendation and emphasis in the paper, supported by references to ergonomics and human-factors literature; presented as a preventive/mitigative approach rather than a quantified empirical result for the sector.
high positive Human-replacing technologies as a driver of labour productiv... cognitive overload, occupational stress, operational risk (errors/incidents)
Successful technological modernization requires continuous investment in human capital, reskilling and the development of digital and engineering competencies.
Policy/recommendation based on the paper's synthesis of the sector analysis and literature on skill requirements and technology adoption; not presented as an original empirical estimate in the summary.
high positive Human-replacing technologies as a driver of labour productiv... effectiveness of modernization efforts via training/reskilling investments