The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (5539 claims)

Adoption
5539 claims
Productivity
4793 claims
Governance
4333 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
3326 claims
Labor Markets
2657 claims
Innovation
2510 claims
Org Design
2469 claims
Skills & Training
2017 claims
Inequality
1378 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 402 112 67 480 1076
Governance & Regulation 402 192 122 62 790
Research Productivity 249 98 34 311 697
Organizational Efficiency 395 95 70 40 603
Technology Adoption Rate 321 126 73 39 564
Firm Productivity 306 39 70 12 432
Output Quality 256 66 25 28 375
AI Safety & Ethics 116 177 44 24 363
Market Structure 107 128 85 14 339
Decision Quality 177 76 38 20 315
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 89 58 33 22 209
Employment Level 77 34 80 9 202
Skill Acquisition 92 33 40 9 174
Innovation Output 120 12 23 12 168
Firm Revenue 98 34 22 154
Consumer Welfare 73 31 37 7 148
Task Allocation 84 16 33 7 140
Inequality Measures 25 77 32 5 139
Regulatory Compliance 54 63 13 3 133
Error Rate 44 51 6 101
Task Completion Time 88 5 4 3 100
Training Effectiveness 58 12 12 16 99
Worker Satisfaction 47 32 11 7 97
Wages & Compensation 53 15 20 5 93
Team Performance 47 12 15 7 82
Automation Exposure 24 22 9 6 62
Job Displacement 6 38 13 57
Hiring & Recruitment 41 4 6 3 54
Developer Productivity 34 4 3 1 42
Social Protection 22 10 6 2 40
Creative Output 16 7 5 1 29
Labor Share of Income 12 5 9 26
Skill Obsolescence 3 20 2 25
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Clear
Adoption Remove filter
The future of AI must be guided by human-centered ethical principles, international cooperation, and strategic regulatory planning to ensure societal benefit and minimize systemic risks.
Concluding recommendation in the paper (normative/policy prescription); the abstract gives no empirical evidence or quantified analysis to demonstrate effectiveness of these measures.
medium positive AI for Good: Societal Impact and Public Policy societal benefit and minimization of systemic risks
Public governance is pivotal to ensuring equitable and accountable AI implementation.
Policy argument/conclusion presented in the paper; the abstract does not report empirical validation, case studies, or metrics supporting this causal claim.
medium positive AI for Good: Societal Impact and Public Policy equity and accountability of AI implementation
Workers with more sluggish beliefs remain overly optimistic in recessions, are hired at higher wages, and face a higher risk of separation.
Model results (with heterogeneous learning rates) and supporting survey patterns: slower-learning workers' beliefs lag the downturn, leading to higher accepted/hired wages in the model and higher simulated separation probabilities; the paper links these model outcomes to observed differences in transitions.
medium positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics worker-level belief bias in recessions, hired wages, and separation risk (probab...
Allowing for heterogeneity in workers' learning rates explains observed differences in employment transitions.
Extended model with heterogeneous worker learning rates calibrated/validated against observed employment transition patterns (comparison of simulated transition rates to empirical patterns from survey/administrative moments).
medium positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics employment transition probabilities (hire and separation rates across worker typ...
In equilibrium, the gap between firm and worker beliefs drives unemployment volatility.
Model simulations and equilibrium analysis after calibration show that differences between firm and worker beliefs amplify unemployment volatility (simulated/quantitative result based on the calibrated model).
medium positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics unemployment volatility (variance or standard deviation of unemployment rate in ...
More optimistic workers demand higher wages.
Correlation documented in the Michigan Survey of Consumers between individual optimism about macro conditions and reported wage demands/expectations (survey-based regression evidence linking optimism to higher demanded wages).
medium positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics worker demanded wage (self-reported wage demands) as a function of individual op...
High current usage, breadth of application, frequent use of AI tools for testing, and ease of use correlate strongly with future intended adoption.
Correlational/regression analyses of survey variables (N=147) predicting respondents' stated future intention to increase AI tool use from measures of current usage, breadth of tool applications, frequency of testing-tool use, and perceived ease-of-use.
medium positive Developers in the Age of AI: Adoption, Policy, and Diffusion... Future intended adoption (intent to increase AI tool usage)
Developers report both productivity and quality gains from using AI tools.
Aggregate self-reported responses from 147 professional developers indicating perceived improvements in productivity and code quality associated with AI tool use.
medium positive Developers in the Age of AI: Adoption, Policy, and Diffusion... Perceived Productivity (PP); Perceived Code Quality (PQ)
There is no perceptual support for the Quality Paradox; PP is positively correlated with Perceived Code Quality (PQ) improvement.
Statistical analysis of survey measures (N=147) showing a positive correlation between respondents' Perceived Productivity scores and their Perceived Code Quality improvement scores; absence of evidence for a negative PP–quality relationship.
medium positive Developers in the Age of AI: Adoption, Policy, and Diffusion... Perceived Productivity (PP); Perceived Code Quality (PQ)
Frequent and broad AI tools use are the strongest correlates of both Perceived Productivity (PP) and quality, with frequency strongest.
Correlational analysis of self-reported survey responses from a sample of 147 professional developers measuring AI tool usage frequency and breadth and perceived outcomes (Perceived Productivity and Perceived Code Quality).
medium positive Developers in the Age of AI: Adoption, Policy, and Diffusion... Perceived Productivity (PP); Perceived Code Quality (PQ)
Through a comparative analysis of pioneering AI strategies in Rwanda, the United Kingdom, the United States, China, and Australia, this paper demonstrates how the DARE framework can serve as both a diagnostic tool to identify national gaps and a prescriptive blueprint for building a more equitable, human-centric automated future.
Reported method in abstract: comparative analysis of five countries (Rwanda, UK, US, China, Australia). The abstract claims demonstration but does not detail the analytic method, metrics, or sample beyond the five-country comparison.
medium positive The DARE framework: a global model for responsible artificia... utility of DARE as (a) diagnostic tool to identify national gaps and (b) prescri...
AI promises unprecedented productivity gains.
Asserted in abstract; no empirical evidence or quantification provided in the abstract.
medium positive The DARE framework: a global model for responsible artificia... national/economic productivity (general promise, not quantitatively measured in ...
Given current evidence, there is greater scope for task reconfiguration and augmentation in exposed occupations than for immediate large-scale displacement.
Synthesis of task-level capability mapping and occupational complementarity analysis showing that many exposed tasks are complementary (augmentable) rather than directly substitutable, and firm-level adoption evidence showing limited job losses to date.
medium positive Labor Futures Under Artificial Intelligence: Scenarios for t... relative likelihood of augmentation (task reconfiguration) versus outright job d...
Most jobs that are exposed to AI in the Philippines also exhibit high complementarity with AI, suggesting substantial scope for augmentation rather than immediate displacement.
Complementarity analysis using Philippine labor force data (task- and occupation-level measures of complementarities) together with task-level evidence on what generative AI can perform in practice.
medium positive Labor Futures Under Artificial Intelligence: Scenarios for t... degree of task/occupation complementarity with AI (interpreted as likelihood of ...
ERM adoption is associated with stronger organizational resilience during crises (for example, global pandemics).
Empirical studies from the reviewed literature—including studies covering crisis periods—report associations between ERM practices and resilience; specific study designs and sample sizes vary and are not detailed in the summary.
medium positive A Literature Review: Effect of Enterprise Risk Management (E... organizational resilience during crises (e.g., survival, continuity of operation...
ERM adoption improves MSMEs' access to external financing.
Reviewed empirical evidence reported in the article that links ERM adoption to enhanced external financing outcomes for firms; details of individual studies (methods, n) are not provided in the summary.
medium positive A Literature Review: Effect of Enterprise Risk Management (E... access to external financing (e.g., credit availability, loan terms)
ERM implementation is associated with sales growth and revenue stability for MSMEs.
Aggregate findings from empirical studies included in the literature review indicating links between ERM adoption and sales/revenue outcomes; original sample sizes and methods vary by study and are not specified in the summary.
medium positive A Literature Review: Effect of Enterprise Risk Management (E... sales growth; revenue stability
ERM adoption is generally associated with improved financial performance of MSMEs.
Synthesis of empirical studies reviewed in the literature review, primarily from emerging economies; specific study designs and sample sizes vary across the reviewed literature (not reported in the summary).
medium positive A Literature Review: Effect of Enterprise Risk Management (E... financial performance (e.g., profitability, return on assets/equity)
Adopting a standardised yet flexible approach to incentive design can help produce more reliable and generalizable knowledge in human–AI decision-making research.
Authors' argument/recommendation based on their thematic review and the proposed framework (this is a normative claim; no empirical validation provided in excerpt).
medium positive Incentive-Tuning: Understanding and Designing Incentives for... reliability and generalizability of findings from human–AI decision-making studi...
Human judgement remains paramount for high-stakes decision-making.
Assertion in the paper framing the motivation for human–AI collaboration research (based on prior literature and domain practice; no specific empirical data or sample sizes provided in excerpt).
medium positive Incentive-Tuning: Understanding and Designing Incentives for... reliance on human judgement in high-stakes decisions (conceptual/literature-leve...
AI has revolutionised decision-making across various fields.
Statement in paper's introduction summarizing prior work and trends (literature-level claim; no specific studies or sample sizes provided in excerpt).
medium positive Incentive-Tuning: Understanding and Designing Incentives for... degree/extent of AI adoption and impact on decision-making processes (general, l...
Overall, the framework improves efficiency, fairness, and quality of care in hospital workforce management.
Aggregate conclusion drawn from experiments (forecasting metrics, scheduling conflict/fairness improvements, performance evaluation results, stress tests, and pilot deployment outcomes) described in the paper.
medium positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... efficiency (operational metrics), fairness (Gini coefficient/roster equity), and...
Pilot deployments of the framework demonstrated tangible benefits, including an 18% reduction in patient waiting times and a 14% improvement in satisfaction scores.
Reported outcomes from pilot deployments (real-world trials); the number of pilot sites, duration, patient/sample sizes, and baseline comparison methodology are not detailed in the provided text.
medium positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... patient waiting times (percent reduction) and patient satisfaction scores (perce...
Stress tests confirmed scalability: solver times remained under 95 seconds for instances with 1,000 staff members.
Scalability/stress testing reported in the paper using scheduling solver on problem instances with up to 1,000 staff; hardware and solver configuration not specified in the excerpt.
medium positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... solver runtime (seconds) for scheduling problem with 1,000 staff
The performance evaluation framework analysis revealed 74% positive patient feedback.
Reported result from NLP analysis of patient surveys in the experiments; the number of patient survey responses and timeframe are not provided in the excerpt.
medium positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... percentage of patient feedback classified as positive
The intelligent staff scheduling module reduces scheduling conflicts by 41% compared to conventional methods while improving fairness (Gini coefficient = 0.08).
Results from scheduling optimization experiments reported in the paper; comparison against unspecified 'conventional methods'; specific experimental sample sizes (number of staff/rosters used for the comparison) not provided in the excerpt.
medium positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... number/percentage of scheduling conflicts and fairness measured by Gini coeffici...
Workforce demand forecasting using LSTM, XGBoost, and Random Forest models predicts patient admissions and staffing needs, with LSTM achieving the best performance (MAE = 6.1, R2 = 0.91).
Experimental comparison of ML models on synthetic and real hospital datasets; reported forecasting metrics MAE and R2 for LSTM (other models' metrics not quoted in the provided text). The specific dataset size and train/test splits are not reported in the excerpt.
medium positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... forecasting accuracy (MAE and R2 for predicted patient admissions/staffing needs...
The study's findings provide strategic guidance for firms seeking long-term sustainable growth through reliance on generative AI to improve ESG performance.
Interpretation and managerial implications drawn from the empirical results of the panel analyses (2012–2024 Chinese A-share sample); presented as implications/recommendations in the paper's discussion section.
medium positive How Can Generative AI Promote Corporate ESG Performance? Evi... corporate ESG performance and long-term sustainable growth (managerial/strategic...
The positive impact of DDDM on international firm performance is amplified by state ownership.
Reported interaction/moderation result in the paper indicating that state ownership increases the strength of the DDDM–performance relationship (specific empirical details not provided in the excerpt).
medium positive The data-driven decision-making, sustainable value creation,... international firm performance (as moderated by state ownership)
The positive impact of DDDM on international firm performance is amplified by greater foreign shareholding.
Reported interaction/moderation finding in the paper showing that higher foreign shareholding enhances the positive DDDM–performance effect (detailed statistics and sample description not included in the excerpt).
medium positive The data-driven decision-making, sustainable value creation,... international firm performance (as moderated by foreign shareholding)
The positive impact of DDDM on international firm performance is amplified by higher market competition.
Reported interaction/moderation result in the paper indicating that market competition strengthens the DDDM–performance relationship (specific interaction coefficients, significance levels, and sample details not provided in the excerpt).
medium positive The data-driven decision-making, sustainable value creation,... international firm performance (as moderated by market competition)
DDDM positively relates to sustainability vision co-creation (future external).
Listed in the paper's framework as the future external dimension through which DDDM generates sustainable value and influences performance (empirical backing not specified in the excerpt).
medium positive The data-driven decision-making, sustainable value creation,... sustainability vision co-creation (future external metric)
DDDM positively relates to sustainability information disclosure (current external).
Identified as a current external mechanism in the paper's framework linking DDDM to improved international firm performance (supporting analyses not detailed in the excerpt).
medium positive The data-driven decision-making, sustainable value creation,... sustainability information disclosure (current external metric)
DDDM positively relates to green innovation (future internal).
Included in the paper's framework as one of the four mechanisms through which DDDM creates sustainable value and affects firm performance (empirical support details not provided in the excerpt).
medium positive The data-driven decision-making, sustainable value creation,... green innovation (future internal sustainability metric)
DDDM positively relates to pollution prevention (current internal) activities.
Part of the paper's framework and reported findings tying DDDM to the 'pollution prevention' dimension (empirical support details not included in the excerpt).
medium positive The data-driven decision-making, sustainable value creation,... pollution prevention activity/effort (current internal sustainability metric)
DDDM creates sustainable value for firms and thereby enhances international firm performance across four dimensions: pollution prevention (current internal), green innovation (future internal), sustainability information disclosure (current external), and sustainability vision co-creation (future external).
The paper presents a developed conceptual/framework explanation linking DDDM to sustainable value creation across the four specified dimensions; the excerpt does not specify whether these links are supported by mediation analysis or qualitative/theoretical argumentation.
medium positive The data-driven decision-making, sustainable value creation,... international firm performance (mediated by sustainable value dimensions)
Data-driven decision-making (DDDM) positively impacts international firm performance.
Empirical analysis reported in the paper in which DDDM is quantified using AI language models (BERT and ChatGLM2-6B) and related statistically to measures of international firm performance (details on sample size and statistical tests not provided in the excerpt).
medium positive The data-driven decision-making, sustainable value creation,... international firm performance
AI-supported HR processes would have produced measurable increases in output per worker (labor productivity).
Counterfactual simulations and predictive estimates from the industrial firm dataset projecting output per worker under AI-HRM scenarios.
medium positive Artificial Intelligence and Human Resource Management: A Cou... output per worker; labor productivity
AI-HRM would have led to better alignment between training and production needs (improved targeting of training intensity to production requirements).
Model links training intensity to production outcomes and projects improved training–production alignment under AI-supported HR processes via regression-based simulations. (Quantitative magnitudes not specified in the description.)
medium positive Artificial Intelligence and Human Resource Management: A Cou... training–production alignment; training intensity matched to production needs
Firms characterized by high labor intensity, rigid hierarchical structures, and limited coordination mechanisms would have experienced the strongest efficiency and productivity gains under an AI-HRM scenario.
Heterogeneity analysis within the regression-based simulation results from the industrial firm dataset (counterfactual projections by firm-type characteristics). (Details on how many firms fell into each category not provided.)
medium positive Artificial Intelligence and Human Resource Management: A Cou... efficiency gains; productivity gains (e.g., output per worker)
AI-driven HRM (AI-HRM) could have increased organizational efficiency and workforce performance (profitability, operational efficiency, defect reduction, and total output) in historical industrial firms.
Counterfactual analytical model built from an industrial firm dataset; regression-based simulations and predictive estimation linking HR indicators to organizational outcomes. (Dataset sample size and period not specified in the description.)
medium positive Artificial Intelligence and Human Resource Management: A Cou... profitability; operational efficiency; defect rate; total output
AI-assisted tools have shown promise in improving detection rates and workflow efficiency in gastroenterology.
Background statement referencing prior work and the studies included in the review that reported improved detection and efficiency.
medium positive How Do AI-Assisted Diagnostic Tools Impact Clinical Decision... detection rates and workflow efficiency
AI reduced reading time by 30% in some studies.
Reported finding in the review summarizing time-efficiency outcomes from subset of included studies (magnitude reported as 30% reduction).
medium positive How Do AI-Assisted Diagnostic Tools Impact Clinical Decision... reading time / workflow efficiency
Among 40 included studies, AI demonstrated high diagnostic accuracy, with sensitivities and specificities exceeding 90% in lesion detection.
Aggregate result reported in the review summarizing diagnostic performance across the 40 included studies.
medium positive How Do AI-Assisted Diagnostic Tools Impact Clinical Decision... diagnostic performance (sensitivity and specificity for lesion detection)
Population growth shows a significant positive effect on GDP growth across the countries in the sample.
Population growth entered as a regressor and reported significant positive association with GDP growth in the panel models (OLS, FE, Difference and System GMM); exact magnitude and significance levels not provided in the summary.
medium positive The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Economic Growth: Syst... GDP growth (national GDP growth rate)
Government expenditure shows a significant positive effect on GDP growth across the countries in the sample.
Positive and statistically significant coefficients on government expenditure reported in the applied econometric models (OLS, FE, Difference and System GMM); government spending included as a control macroeconomic determinant (sample/time not specified).
medium positive The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Economic Growth: Syst... GDP growth (national GDP growth rate)
Gross fixed capital formation (GFCF) has a significant positive effect on GDP growth across the countries in the sample.
Estimated positive and statistically significant coefficients on GFCF in the panel regressions (OLS, FE, Difference and System GMM); GFCF included as a macroeconomic determinant in the model (sample size/time period not provided).
medium positive The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Economic Growth: Syst... GDP growth (national GDP growth rate)
By mapping current evidence and identifying critical barriers, this review provides a foundational roadmap for researchers, policymakers, and practitioners aiming to leverage AI for inclusive economic growth in Jaipur’s micro‑enterprise sector.
Authors' concluding claim about the contribution of the review based on synthesized findings and identified barriers; presented as the paper's intended utility.
medium positive Role of AI in Enhancing Work Efficiency and Opportunities fo... availability of a synthesized roadmap/guidance for stakeholders to promote inclu...
Targeted interventions—such as subsidized AI training programs, public–private partnerships to upgrade micro‑enterprise infrastructure, and gender‑responsive regulatory policies—are necessary to realize AI’s full benefits for women entrepreneurs.
Authors' recommendations derived from the review findings (identification of barriers leads to proposed interventions); recommendations presented as remedies to the synthesized gaps.
medium positive Role of AI in Enhancing Work Efficiency and Opportunities fo... anticipated realization of AI benefits for women entrepreneurs (through proposed...
AI enables flexible, remote work arrangements that better accommodate women’s socio‑cultural needs.
Synthesis of qualitative and/or quantitative evidence in the included articles indicating AI‑enabled remote/flexible work arrangements and their fit with socio‑cultural constraints affecting women entrepreneurs.
medium positive Role of AI in Enhancing Work Efficiency and Opportunities fo... work arrangement flexibility and capacity for remote work among women entreprene...