The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Digests 🎲

Evidence (2954 claims)

Adoption
5126 claims
Productivity
4409 claims
Governance
4049 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
2954 claims
Labor Markets
2432 claims
Org Design
2273 claims
Innovation
2215 claims
Skills & Training
1902 claims
Inequality
1286 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 369 105 58 432 972
Governance & Regulation 365 171 113 54 713
Research Productivity 229 95 33 294 655
Organizational Efficiency 354 82 58 34 531
Technology Adoption Rate 277 115 63 27 486
Firm Productivity 273 33 68 10 389
AI Safety & Ethics 112 177 43 24 358
Output Quality 228 61 23 25 337
Market Structure 105 118 81 14 323
Decision Quality 154 68 33 17 275
Employment Level 68 32 74 8 184
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 74 52 32 21 183
Skill Acquisition 85 31 38 9 163
Firm Revenue 96 30 22 148
Innovation Output 100 11 20 11 143
Consumer Welfare 66 29 35 7 137
Regulatory Compliance 51 61 13 3 128
Inequality Measures 24 66 31 4 125
Task Allocation 64 6 28 6 104
Error Rate 42 47 6 95
Training Effectiveness 55 12 10 16 93
Worker Satisfaction 42 32 11 6 91
Task Completion Time 71 5 3 1 80
Wages & Compensation 38 13 19 4 74
Team Performance 41 8 15 7 72
Hiring & Recruitment 39 4 6 3 52
Automation Exposure 17 15 9 5 46
Job Displacement 5 28 12 45
Social Protection 18 8 6 1 33
Developer Productivity 25 1 2 1 29
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Creative Output 15 5 3 1 24
Skill Obsolescence 3 18 2 23
Labor Share of Income 7 4 9 20
Clear
Human Ai Collab Remove filter
Nursery crops represent a niche market opportunity for automation, robotics, and engineering companies to invest R&D capital, particularly because operating environments are neither uniform nor protected from weather extremes.
Paper's market analysis/opinion about R&D opportunities in nursery automation; no market size or investment data provided in the excerpt.
low positive Current Labor Challenges and Opportunities in Nursery Crops ... market opportunity for automation/robotics R&D in nursery crops
Adoption of automation by nursery operations may help retain current workers and attract new employees.
Paper's proposed/anticipated effect of automation on workforce retention and attraction; presented as a potential benefit rather than demonstrated causal evidence in the excerpt.
low positive Current Labor Challenges and Opportunities in Nursery Crops ... worker retention and recruitment in nursery operations
In the AI era, sustainable competitive advantage is rooted not in the technology itself, but in an organization's fundamental capacity to learn.
Normative/conceptual conclusion drawn from the paper's theoretical framework (dynamic capabilities and absorptive capacity emphasis). No empirical evidence or longitudinal validation provided.
low positive Resilience Coefficient: Measuring the Strategic Adaptability... sustainable competitive advantage as a function of organizational learning capac...
The framework provides leaders with a diagnostic tool for guiding transformation in the AI era.
Practical implication offered in the paper (proposed diagnostic framework). The paper does not report empirical trials, user testing, or validation of the tool.
low positive Resilience Coefficient: Measuring the Strategic Adaptability... utility of diagnostic tool for leadership decision-making in organizational tran...
The ultimate effect of AI is determined not by its technical specifications but by an organization's absorptive capacity and its ability to learn, integrate knowledge, and adapt.
Theoretical integration of dynamic capabilities and micro-foundations in the paper; conditional model proposed. The paper does not report empirical testing or sample data to validate this conditioning effect.
low positive Resilience Coefficient: Measuring the Strategic Adaptability... impact of AI on organizational outcomes (performance/advantage) conditional on a...
AI reshapes organizations by rewriting routines, shifting mental models (cognitive frameworks), and redirecting resources.
Conceptual delineation within the paper identifying three loci of AI impact (routines, mental models, resources). No empirical measures or sample size provided.
low positive Resilience Coefficient: Measuring the Strategic Adaptability... changes in organizational routines, cognitive frameworks, and resource allocatio...
AI functions as a catalytic force that operates on an organization's foundational elements and actively reshapes how institutions function.
Theoretical claim and conceptual argument developed in the paper (framework-level assertion). No empirical testing or sample reported.
low positive Resilience Coefficient: Measuring the Strategic Adaptability... degree of organizational transformation (structural/routine change)
Designing AI systems that are transparent, ethical, and inclusive is important to support adoption among both tech-savvy and less technologically adept consumers.
Normative/recommendation derived from study findings and synthesis (authors' interpretation/recommendation based on empirical results and literature integration).
low positive Role of artificial intelligence on consumer buying behavior:... adoption and trust across consumer segments (tech-savvy vs. less technologically...
Embedding managerial control, ethical reasoning, and contextual evaluation in AI-assisted workflows minimizes effects of algorithmic bias and automation bias and enhances workforce confidence.
Theoretical assertion supported by conceptual argument and literature integration in the paper. No empirical test, experimental manipulation, or quantitative measurement provided.
low positive Designing Human–AI Collaborative Decision Analytics Framewor... algorithmic bias, automation bias, workforce confidence
Through continuous learning (including lifelong learning) and fostering a culture of innovation, businesses can use the full potential of GenAI, ensuring growth and efficiency and equipping employees with the technical skills needed in an AI-enhanced world.
Conceptual claim grounded in literature review and thematic analysis; empirical measures of business growth, efficiency, or workforce technical skill gains are not reported in the abstract.
low positive GenAI Role in Redefining Learning and Skilling in Companies business growth, operational efficiency, and employee technical skill levels
Companies need to adopt a human-centric approach to GenAI implementation to empower employees and support clients.
Argument supported by literature review and conceptual analysis; additionally informed by analysis of tasks across occupations (Erasmus+ projects) and discussions with trainers/educators. No empirical evaluation of organizations that adopted this approach is reported in the abstract.
low positive GenAI Role in Redefining Learning and Skilling in Companies employee empowerment and client support (qualitative/organizational outcomes)
The study advocates that IT organizations should ensure comprehensive AI literacy among employees by integrating best practices from the industry.
Policy/recommendation made in the paper's conclusions; no empirical intervention or measured effect described in the excerpt.
low positive Economic Implications of Adopting Artificial Intelligence fo... employee AI literacy levels and organizational adoption of AI best practices
Employees should actively utilize AI tools and models to enhance innovation and productivity within their respective roles.
Recommendation advanced by the authors; no outcome measures or experimental evidence provided in the excerpt to quantify the effect.
low positive Economic Implications of Adopting Artificial Intelligence fo... employee-level innovation and productivity when using AI tools
AI advancements have fundamentally altered the nature of work, shifting it from labor intensive processes to software-driven operations.
Stated claim in the paper's background; no specific empirical measure or result reported here.
low positive Economic Implications of Adopting Artificial Intelligence fo... automation level / shift from manual to software-driven tasks
Embedding games within broader DST ecosystems (market platforms, precision-agriculture systems, carbon accounting services) could unlock monetization routes (carbon markets, ecosystem service payments) and reduce transaction costs.
Argumentative synthesis grounded in examples of integration potential; few empirical studies have measured monetization outcomes or transaction cost reductions directly.
low positive Serious games and decision support tools: Supporting farmer ... Participation in carbon markets/payments, transaction costs, monetization revenu...
If GenAI materially speeds design iteration, firms could increase throughput, reduce time-to-market, or lower costs for certain design services, potentially expanding supply and putting downward pressure on prices for commoditized outputs.
Authors' implication based on qualitative reports of faster iteration in interviews; no empirical productivity or price data collected in the study.
low positive Human–AI Collaboration in Architectural Design Education: To... productivity (throughput, time-to-market) and price effects for design services
GenAI appears to automate or accelerate routine, exploratory, and generative sub-tasks (early ideation, variant generation), while human designers retain evaluative judgment, contextualization, and final creative synthesis—indicating task-level complementarity rather than full substitution.
Authors' interpretation of interview data where students report GenAI speeding ideation and generating variants, combined with theoretical discussion; no quantitative task-time measures reported.
low positive Human–AI Collaboration in Architectural Design Education: To... task-level division of labor: automation vs human-held tasks (complementarity/su...
The program can reduce skill mismatches and increase effective labor supply in targeted sectors, altering relative demand for AI-complementary vs. AI-substitutable tasks.
Economic argument in paper (theoretical); no empirical tests or sample reported.
low positive Curriculum engineering: organisation, orientation, and manag... skill mismatch indicators, effective labor supply in targeted sectors, demand fo...
Better-aligned curricula can raise the productivity and employability of graduates, shifting returns to human capital and affecting wage distribution by skill.
Theoretical economic reasoning and program rationale presented in paper; no empirical causal evidence provided.
low positive Curriculum engineering: organisation, orientation, and manag... graduate productivity, employability (placement/wage outcomes), wage distributio...
Advantages of the program include traceability, improved career-alignment and employability, audit readiness, and support for innovation through modelling and data analysis.
Paper lists these as intended advantages (asserted benefits); no empirical outcome data provided.
low positive Curriculum engineering: organisation, orientation, and manag... traceability metrics, career-alignment indicators, employability (placement rate...
Regulation and workforce policy should be calibrated to interaction level: stronger oversight and validation for AI-augmented/automated systems and workforce policies (reskilling, credentialing) to manage transition to Human+ roles.
Policy recommendations based on the taxonomy and implications drawn from the four qualitative case studies and conceptual analysis.
low positive Toward human+ medical professionals: navigating AI integrati... regulatory stringency by system type, workforce reskilling/credentialing uptake
Practitioners should combine the manufacturing operation tree with AI methods and real operational data to create validated, policy‑aware simulation tools that support economic decision making.
Practical guidance and proposed integration steps in the paper; presented as recommended practice rather than demonstrated case examples.
low positive A Review of Manufacturing Operations Research Integration in... existence and effectiveness of validated, policy‑aware simulation tools for deci...
The proposed roadmap can produce simulations that are realistic, validated against industry data, and useful for decision makers—supporting agility, resilience, and data‑driven planning.
Conceptual roadmap and recommendations in the paper; no empirical demonstrations or validation studies included.
low positive A Review of Manufacturing Operations Research Integration in... simulation realism, validation status, decision usefulness, organizational agili...
Functional and instrumental value of AI systems can speed organizational adoption via increased trust, implying economic importance of demonstrable productivity gains and clear ROI.
Interpretation/implication drawn from the study's empirical finding that functional/instrumental values increase initial trust and that trust positively affects adoption; this is an inference rather than a directly tested macroeconomic effect in the paper.
low positive Reimagining Stakeholder Engagement Through Generative AI: A ... Organizational adoption speed / diffusion (implied)
Policy instruments such as open-data mandates, compute-sharing incentives, and conditionality in R&D funding can help ensure equitable validation and local engagement in climate-AI development.
Policy recommendations grounded in normative analysis and analogies to existing public-good interventions; no empirical evaluation of these specific instruments provided in the paper.
low positive The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Adoption of policy instruments and subsequent changes in equity of validation pr...
Economists should prioritize research to quantify returns to investments in CDPI versus private compute, estimate economic costs of maladaptation from biased AI outputs, and design incentive-compatible mechanisms for data sharing and co-production.
Research agenda and recommendations presented by the authors; this is a suggested empirical/theoretical program rather than a tested result.
low positive The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Feasibility and quantified returns of policy/research interventions (e.g., CDPI ...
Establishing Climate Digital Public Infrastructure (CDPI)—shared, interoperable data and compute resources, standards, and governance—can democratize access and reduce inequities in climate-AI.
Policy proposal and normative argument drawing analogies to public goods (observational networks, satellites); no empirical evaluation of CDPI implementations presented.
low positive The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Access to compute/data, interoperability, and distributional equity in climate-A...
Shifting from a model-centric to a data-centric approach (improving data quality, representativeness, and governance) will mitigate the harms caused by current infrastructural asymmetries.
Normative recommendation grounded in conceptual arguments and illustrative examples; not supported by empirical interventions or randomized/controlled comparisons in the paper.
low positive The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Improvements in data representativeness, model performance, and equity of output...
Policy and governance should preserve worker agency (participatory design, transparency, clear accountability) and support training and institutional mechanisms (collective bargaining, workplace representation) to negotiate value-sharing from AI productivity gains.
Normative policy recommendation by authors derived from qualitative findings (workshops with 15 UX designers) that highlighted agency and distributional concerns.
low positive The Values of Value in AI Adoption: Rethinking Efficiency in... worker agency and value-sharing mechanisms (policy-targeted outcomes; recommende...
Clinic-aware designs and reliable validation can enable clearer evidence of value, facilitating payer reimbursement, value-based care contracts, and new pricing models for AI-enabled medical devices and services.
Policy and reimbursement implications discussed by clinicians and industry participants during the workshop and summarized in the workshop report (NSF workshop, Sept 26–27, 2024).
low positive Report for NSF Workshop on Algorithm-Hardware Co-design for ... payer reimbursement approvals, value-based contract adoption, and pricing model ...
Scalable validation ecosystems and continuous objective measures reduce information asymmetries between developers, clinicians, and payers, lowering commercialization and regulatory risk, which raises private returns and speeds adoption.
Economic implications and causal argument set out in the workshop summary based on expert judgement and theory discussed at the NSF workshop (Sept 26–27, 2024).
low positive Report for NSF Workshop on Algorithm-Hardware Co-design for ... information asymmetry indicators, commercialization/regulatory risk measures, fi...
Procedural material modeling (Perlin noise) is a promising technique for robust policy learning and can reduce the need for extensive real-world data collection.
Implication stated in the paper's discussion: authors suggest procedural variation via Perlin noise aided robust policy learning and improved sim-to-real transfer; empirical quantification of reduced real data needs is not provided in the summary.
low positive Learning Adaptive Force Control for Contact-Rich Sample Scra... robustness of learned policy / reduction in required real-world training data (c...
Perception providing the material's location inside the vial was used to guide the agent.
Paper summary states perception input (material location) was provided to the agent; sensing modality and accuracy/details of perception are not specified.
low positive Learning Adaptive Force Control for Contact-Rich Sample Scra... availability/usability of material location information to the agent (perception...
Privacy-preserving accountability logs can support ex post adjudication, insurance products, and reputational dynamics, reducing moral hazard.
Conceptual claim: protocol includes privacy-minded logs; paper argues potential for post-hoc review and insurance. No empirical tests of adjudication or insurance products provided.
low positive Task-Aware Delegation Cues for LLM Agents effectiveness of accountability logs for adjudication/insurance (theoretical)
Observable capability and coordination-risk signals enable more granular pricing, risk-based contracts, and differentiated service tiers (e.g., primary-only vs primary+auditor).
Policy/economic implication argued conceptually in the paper; no empirical pricing experiments or market data provided.
low positive Task-Aware Delegation Cues for LLM Agents granularity in pricing and contracting (theoretical)
High capability profiles for some tasks will shift delegation toward agents (automation) and reallocate human labor toward supervision, auditing, and low-win-rate tasks.
Projection based on capability profiles and economic reasoning in the paper; presented as implications rather than empirically demonstrated. No labor-market empirical data provided.
low positive Task-Aware Delegation Cues for LLM Agents task allocation between agents and human labor (theoretical prediction)
Better matching of tasks to agent competencies improves allocative efficiency across task markets.
Theoretical/economic claim derived from capability profiles enabling improved matching; no empirical market experiments or measurements reported in the summary (field experiments suggested as future work).
low positive Task-Aware Delegation Cues for LLM Agents allocative efficiency in task markets (theoretical)
Task-aware signals reduce search and screening costs by acting like quality/reliability metrics in delegation markets.
Economic implication argued conceptually in the paper: task-conditioned capability and coordination-risk signals function as observable quality metrics, reducing transaction costs. This is a theoretical argument; no empirical market-level test reported.
low positive Task-Aware Delegation Cues for LLM Agents search and screening costs in delegation (theoretical)
There is a strong complementarity between AI investments and organizational change: firms with better leadership, cross-functional processes, and data practices capture disproportionate benefits, implying increasing returns to scale and potential winner-take-most dynamics.
Authors' theoretical inference from cross-case patterns and economic reasoning; supported qualitatively by cases showing disproportionate gains in better-managed firms.
low positive Optimizing integrated supply planning in logistics: Bridging... firm-level performance gains and potential market concentration effects
Firms that can credibly supply explainability and governance may capture a premium—explainability can be a competitive differentiator and a signal of quality and lower regulatory risk.
Conceptual synthesis and market-structure arguments from the reviewed literature; reviewed studies provide theoretical and some qualitative support but not systematic market-price estimates.
low positive Explainable AI in High-Stakes Domains: Improving Trust, Tran... firm market premium / competitive advantage
Policy should incentivize transparency, auditability, standards for human–AI interfaces, workforce development, certification of teaming practices, and liability frameworks to ensure accountability and equitable outcomes.
Normative recommendation based on ethical and governance considerations synthesized in the paper; not supported by policy evaluation evidence within the paper.
low positive Toward a science of human–AI teaming for decision-making: A ... policy outcomes such as levels of transparency, auditability, workforce skill de...
Orchestrating attention and interrogation through interface and workflow design helps manage what humans and AI focus on and how they challenge/verify each other, thereby reducing errors and misuse.
Prescriptive claim grounded in human factors and HCI literature synthesized by the authors; the paper suggests these mechanisms but does not report empirical trials demonstrating effects.
low positive Toward a science of human–AI teaming for decision-making: A ... error detection rates, misuse rates, verification frequency, and decision accura...
Design principles (define goals/constraints, partition roles, orchestrate attention/interrogation, build knowledge infrastructures, continuous training/evaluation) are necessary design levers to build high-performing, transparent, trustworthy, and equitable Human–AI teams.
Prescriptive synthesis from reviewed literatures and conceptual modeling; these principles are proposed heuristics rather than empirically validated interventions in the paper.
low positive Toward a science of human–AI teaming for decision-making: A ... team performance metrics (performance, transparency/trust measures, equity indic...
Firms that design processes to preserve human diversity and elicit diverse AI outputs may capture greater productivity gains, increasing returns to organizational capability rather than to raw model access.
Theoretical implication and prescriptive recommendation based on observed homogenization; no direct causal firm-level evidence presented, inference based on economic reasoning.
low positive The Artificial Hivemind: Rethinking Work Design and Leadersh... firm-level productivity or returns to organizational capability versus model acc...
Investments to build trust in AI (transparency, reliability, training) are likely to have positive returns via higher adoption rates and realized AI benefits.
This is presented as an implication derived from observed positive associations between trust and outcomes; the study did not conduct cost–benefit or longitudinal causal tests of such investments in the reported analyses.
low positive Algorithmic Trust and Managerial Effectiveness: The Role of ... returns to trust-building investments (adoption rates, realized AI benefits) — i...
Practical levers to increase AI trust include transparency of AI models, demonstrated reliability, and manager-focused AI literacy/training.
Paper proposes these levers based on study findings and discussion (recommendations), but they were not tested experimentally in the reported cross-sectional survey.
low positive Algorithmic Trust and Managerial Effectiveness: The Role of ... AI trust level (proposed interventions to increase trust)
A stronger data-driven decision culture that stems from AI trust yields better operational and academic outcomes.
Study reports positive associations between AI trust → data-driven culture → operational and academic outcomes in survey-based analyses; however, the summary does not specify which operational/academic metrics were measured or sample size.
low positive Algorithmic Trust and Managerial Effectiveness: The Role of ... operational outcomes and academic outcomes (unspecified metrics)
The dissertation implies policy interventions (subsidies, tax incentives, training and integration assistance) can accelerate welfare-improving AI adoption by helping firms overcome the early negative part of the U-shaped profit profile.
Policy implication derived from the theoretical U-shaped profit relationship and model interpretation; not supported by randomized or quasi-experimental policy evaluation in the provided summary.
low positive MODELING HOSPITALITY AND TOURISM STRATEGIES AI adoption rate and welfare-improving adoption timing
Vendors that embed robust cognitive interlocks into development platforms can command premium pricing by reducing downstream risk; verification features may become a competitive moat.
Market-structure and product-differentiation reasoning in the paper; no market data, pricing studies, or competitive analyses presented.
low positive Overton Framework v1.0: Cognitive Interlocks for Integrity i... vendor pricing premiums; market share attributable to verification features
Human verification (and automated verification infrastructure) becomes the limiting factor and a scarce complement to AI generation, raising demand and wages for verification expertise and tooling.
Theoretical labor-market analysis and complementarity argument in the paper; no labor market data or econometric estimates provided.
low positive Overton Framework v1.0: Cognitive Interlocks for Integrity i... demand for verification roles; wages for verification engineers; availability of...