The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (4175 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Org Design Remove filter
AIGC creators achieve aggregate engagement comparable to HGC creators by producing content at high volume (a 'scale-over-preference' dynamic).
Analysis of creation and engagement patterns in the dataset showing that AIGC creators compensate for lower per-item engagement by higher production volume, yielding comparable aggregate engagement levels to HGC creators.
high positive Scale over Preference: The Impact of AI-Generated Content on... aggregate engagement per creator (total engagement across produced items)
Consumers show a marked preference for Human-Generated Content (HGC) over Artificial Intelligence-Generated Content (AIGC).
Comparative analysis of consumption behavior in the longitudinal dataset; the paper reports consumption metrics that indicate higher consumer preference for HGC versus AIGC (e.g., relative engagement per item).
high positive Scale over Preference: The Impact of AI-Generated Content on... consumer preference (relative engagement per content type)
Increasing the strictness of algorithmic control paradoxically increases the evolutionary fitness of coordinated resistance (e.g., coordinated log-offs).
Results from the EGT model and simulations showing fitness/payoff changes for coordinated resistance strategies as platform surveillance strictness parameter increases; model-only (no empirical N reported).
high positive THE RED QUEEN in the DASHBOARD: CO-EVOLUTIONARY DYNAMICS of ... evolutionary fitness (payoff) of coordinated resistance strategies
The future of transformative transformer-based AI is fundamentally many, not one.
Concluding synthesis and normative prediction based on the paper's theoretical arguments and literature synthesis; no empirical data or quantified projection provided in the excerpt.
high positive The Future of AI is Many, Not One architectural and organizational form of future transformative AI (multi-agent/d...
Developing diverse AI teams addresses critics' concerns that current models are constrained by past data and lack the creative insight required for innovation.
Argumentative claim drawing on conceptual critique of current models and the proposed remedy of diverse AI teams; supported by referenced disciplinary literatures but no empirical validation provided in the excerpt.
high positive The Future of AI is Many, Not One creative insight and capacity for innovation in AI systems
Having a diverse team broadens the search for solutions, delays premature consensus, and allows for the pursuit of unconventional approaches.
Theoretical/argumentative claim referencing literature in complex systems and organizational behavior as support; no quantitative evidence or sample reported in the excerpt.
high positive The Future of AI is Many, Not One search breadth, timing of consensus formation, and pursuit of unconventional sol...
Deep intellectual breakthroughs should be expected to come from epistemically diverse groups of AI agents working together rather than singular superintelligent agents.
Predictive/theoretical claim motivated by referenced research and formal results in complex systems, organizational behavior, and philosophy of science; no empirical experiment or sample size given in the excerpt.
high positive The Future of AI is Many, Not One occurrence of deep intellectual breakthroughs (scientific/innovative discoveries...
We should abandon the individual approach if we're hoping for AI to support groundbreaking innovation and scientific discovery.
Normative prescription based on theoretical argument and synthesis of literature from complex systems, organizational behavior, and philosophy of science; no empirical trial or quantified evaluation reported in the excerpt.
high positive The Future of AI is Many, Not One ability of AI to support groundbreaking innovation and scientific discovery
AI innovation achieves corporate low-carbon development by reorienting investment toward green assets.
Mechanism analysis reported in the paper (mediation/path analysis) using the same 21,428 firm-year observations; investment reorientation toward green assets identified as a mediation path.
high positive Artificial Intelligence Innovation, Internal Structure Optim... corporate carbon emission intensity (mediated via investment reorientation towar...
AI innovation achieves corporate low-carbon development by upgrading emission-reducing production processes.
Mechanism analysis reported in the paper (mediation/path analysis) on the 21,428 firm-year sample; production-process upgrades identified as a mediation path.
high positive Artificial Intelligence Innovation, Internal Structure Optim... corporate carbon emission intensity (mediated via production process upgrades)
AI innovation achieves corporate low-carbon development by optimizing low-carbon organizational governance.
Mechanism analysis reported in the paper (mediation/path analysis) using the same sample of 21,428 firm-year observations; paper identifies organizational governance optimization as one of three mediation paths.
high positive Artificial Intelligence Innovation, Internal Structure Optim... corporate carbon emission intensity (mediated via organizational governance chan...
With further development, this approach may exceed traditional methods regarding risk accuracy and help drive innovation in the insurance industry.
Forward-looking claim by the authors extrapolating from current prototype results and potential improvements; no empirical evidence provided that it already exceeds traditional methods.
high positive AI in Insurance: Adaptive Questionnaires for Improved Risk P... risk assessment accuracy and industry innovation
ARQuest shows great potential to improve user satisfaction and streamline insurance processes.
Interpretation based on experimental findings (fewer questions, user preference) and the proposed framework; forward-looking claim rather than a fully established empirical result.
high positive AI in Insurance: Adaptive Questionnaires for Improved Risk P... user satisfaction and process streamlining
Adaptive versions were preferred by users for their more fluid and engaging experience.
User preference reported from the experiments (qualitative/user feedback or preference metric); specific measures and sample size not provided in excerpt.
high positive AI in Insurance: Adaptive Questionnaires for Improved Risk P... user preference / perceived fluidity and engagement
Adaptive versions powered by GPT models required fewer questions.
Experimental result reported in paper comparing question counts between adaptive GPT-powered questionnaires and traditional questionnaires; no numeric counts or sample sizes provided in the excerpt.
high positive AI in Insurance: Adaptive Questionnaires for Improved Risk P... number of questions required (survey length / task completion effort)
Techniques such as social media image analysis, geographic data categorization, and Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) are used to extract meaningful user insights and guide targeted follow-up questions.
Described methods/techniques used within the ARQuest system implementation in the paper.
high positive AI in Insurance: Adaptive Questionnaires for Improved Risk P... ability to extract user insights and guide follow-up questions
The ARQuest framework introduces a new approach to underwriting by using Large Language Models (LLMs) and alternative data sources to create personalized and adaptive questionnaires.
Methodological contribution described in the paper (framework design); description of components and intended function rather than a quantified outcome.
high positive AI in Insurance: Adaptive Questionnaires for Improved Risk P... personalization and adaptiveness of questionnaires
Only interventions that reshape risk allocation can plausibly shift stable system-level behaviour.
Argument based on the paper's game-theoretic reasoning and stylised example (theoretical claim; no empirical testing reported in the abstract).
high positive Incentives, Equilibria, and the Limits of Healthcare AI: A G... ability of interventions to shift stable system-level behaviour
Artificial intelligence (AI) is widely promoted as a promising technological response to healthcare capacity and productivity pressures.
Author assertion in the paper's introduction/abstract, based on literature/policy discourse (no empirical sample or quantitative analysis reported in the abstract).
high positive Incentives, Equilibria, and the Limits of Healthcare AI: A G... promotion of AI as a solution to healthcare capacity and productivity pressures
Improvements in operational resilience enhance firms' capacity for sustainable development.
Further analysis in the paper showing a positive relationship between OR improvements and indicators of firms' sustainable development capacity.
high positive Does Artificial Intelligence Improve the Operational Resilie... capacity for sustainable development
The enabling effect of AI on operational resilience is more pronounced for capital-intensive enterprises.
Heterogeneity/subsample analysis showing larger AI effects on OR for capital-intensive firms.
high positive Does Artificial Intelligence Improve the Operational Resilie... operational resilience (OR) — heterogeneous treatment effect by capital intensit...
The enabling effect of AI on operational resilience is more pronounced for technology-intensive enterprises.
Heterogeneity/subsample tests reported in the paper indicating stronger AI effects on OR for technology-intensive firms.
high positive Does Artificial Intelligence Improve the Operational Resilie... operational resilience (OR) — heterogeneous treatment effect by technology inten...
The enabling effect of AI on operational resilience is more pronounced for enterprises in the growth stage.
Heterogeneity/subsample analysis showing larger AI-induced OR gains among firms classified as in the growth stage.
high positive Does Artificial Intelligence Improve the Operational Resilie... operational resilience (OR) — heterogeneous treatment effect by firm life-cycle ...
The enabling effect of AI on operational resilience is more pronounced for enterprises located in the coastal eastern region.
Heterogeneity/subsample analysis reported in the paper showing larger AI effects for firms in the coastal eastern region compared to other regions.
high positive Does Artificial Intelligence Improve the Operational Resilie... operational resilience (OR) — heterogeneous treatment effect by region
AI promotes operational resilience by optimizing supply chain allocation performance.
Mechanism tests in the paper linking AI adoption to improved supply chain allocation/performance metrics, which are associated with higher OR.
high positive Does Artificial Intelligence Improve the Operational Resilie... supply chain allocation performance
Application of AI significantly enhances corporate operational resilience (OR).
Staggered DID estimation exploiting AIIAPZ policy as quasi-natural experiment on Chinese A-share listed manufacturing firms (2012–2023); main regression results reported as significant.
high positive Does Artificial Intelligence Improve the Operational Resilie... operational resilience (OR)
Effective collaboration with AI for software engineering (SE) tasks may benefit from functional design rather than replicating human SEI traits, thereby redefining collaboration as functional alignment.
Authors' conclusion and recommendation derived from qualitative interview evidence (10 practitioners) and the proposed concept of functional equivalents.
high positive Bridging the Socio-Emotional Gap: The Functional Dimension o... effectiveness of human-AI collaboration in SE tasks
The authors introduce the concept of 'functional equivalents': technical capabilities (internal cognition, contextual intelligence, adaptive learning, and collaborative intelligence) that achieve collaborative outcomes comparable to human SEI attributes.
Conceptual contribution proposed by the authors based on interview findings and theoretical argumentation (no quantitative validation reported).
high positive Bridging the Socio-Emotional Gap: The Functional Dimension o... ability of technical capabilities to achieve collaborative outcomes comparable t...
Socio-emotional intelligence (SEI) enhances collaboration among human teammates.
Stated as background in the paper (no primary data from this study provided to support the claim).
high positive Bridging the Socio-Emotional Gap: The Functional Dimension o... quality of collaboration among human teammates
Results may be applied in the development of financial institution strategies, regulatory frameworks, risk management systems and professional training programmes.
Applied implications drawn from the literature synthesis and comparative analysis; presented as potential uses rather than empirically validated interventions.
high positive Implications of Big Data Technologies for the Resilience of ... applicability of study results to strategy, regulation, risk management and trai...
Significant changes in human resource needs are occurring, with growing demand for analysts and specialists combining financial and technological competencies.
Conclusion from literature review and synthesis of international studies on labour demand in finance under Big Data/AI adoption; no original labour-market survey included.
high positive Implications of Big Data Technologies for the Resilience of ... demand for combined financial-technological specialists
Big Data and AI technologies significantly improve efficiency, risk assessment accuracy, fraud detection and financial inclusion.
The paper reports results from a qualitative analysis of recent academic literature, comparative analysis of sector-specific applications, and synthesis of empirical findings from international studies; no primary sample size reported.
high positive Implications of Big Data Technologies for the Resilience of ... efficiency; risk assessment accuracy; fraud detection; financial inclusion
Secondary empirical evidence from Colombia's EDIT manufacturing survey (N=6,799 firms) shows that management practice quality amplifies the return to technology investment (interaction coefficient 0.304, p<0.01).
Secondary empirical analysis of EDIT manufacturing survey data; sample size reported as N = 6,799 firms; regression interaction term reported as coefficient 0.304 with p < 0.01.
high positive From Automation to Augmentation: A Framework for Designing H... return to technology investment (firm-level productivity/performance)
We endogenize the augmentation function as phi(D, W), where W is a five-dimensional workplace design vector (AI interface design, decision authority allocation, task orchestration, learning loop architecture, psychosocial work environment), and prove that human-centric design is profit-maximizing when the workforce's augmentable cognitive capital exceeds a critical threshold.
Theoretical model and formal proof presented in the paper (analytical derivation of phi(D,W) and threshold condition).
high positive From Automation to Augmentation: A Framework for Designing H... profit-maximization / firm performance under human-centric design
The ManagerWorker two-agent pipeline (expensive text-only manager + cheaper worker with repo access) can substitute expensive execution by using expensive reasoning in the manager and cheaper execution in the worker.
System design description plus empirical results on 200 SWE-bench Lite instances showing parity in success rates between a strong-manager/weak-worker pipeline and a strong single agent while using fewer strong-model tokens.
high positive Can AI Models Direct Each Other? Organizational Structure as... ability to substitute expensive execution with expensive reasoning (operationali...
A minimal review-only manager loop adds only 2 percentage points over the baseline, whereas structured exploration and planning by the manager add 11 percentage points, demonstrating that active direction (not mere reviewing) produces most of the benefit.
Ablation-style comparison of pipeline variants on the 200-instance SWE-bench Lite evaluation: review-only manager loop versus manager with structured exploration and planning; reported improvements in percentage points.
high positive Can AI Models Direct Each Other? Organizational Structure as... improvement in task success rate (percentage-point increase)
A strong manager directing a weak worker achieves a 62% success rate on software-engineering tasks, matching a strong single agent which achieves 60%, while using a fraction of the strong-model token usage.
Empirical evaluation on 200 instances from SWE-bench Lite across five pipeline configurations and model pairings; measured task success rates and token usage for manager-worker pipelines versus single-agent baselines.
high positive Can AI Models Direct Each Other? Organizational Structure as... task success rate (percentage of tasks solved)
Overall, the HCT is a robust, accurate, and transparent alternative to the AI-as-advisor approach, offering a simple mechanism to tap into the wisdom of hybrid crowds.
Overall conclusion drawn from the empirical comparisons across datasets and analyses described in the paper (summary statement in abstract).
high positive Beyond AI advice -- independent aggregation boosts human-AI ... overall decision-making performance / robustness / transparency
Using signal detection theory, the paper finds that the HCT outperforms the AI-as-advisor approach because people cannot discriminate well enough between correct and incorrect AI advice.
Analysis in the paper applying signal detection theory to the empirical results (as stated in abstract).
high positive Beyond AI advice -- independent aggregation boosts human-AI ... discriminability between correct and incorrect AI advice (signal detection metri...
The HCT also performed better in almost all cases in which the AI offered an explanation of its judgment.
Empirical results on the subset of four datasets with AI explanations (abstract reports HCT performed better in 'almost all' of these cases).
high positive Beyond AI advice -- independent aggregation boosts human-AI ... decision accuracy when AI provides explanations
The HCT outperformed the AI-as-advisor approach in all datasets.
Empirical comparisons reported across the 10 datasets (statement in abstract that HCT 'outperformed' in all datasets). Specific performance metrics not provided in abstract.
high positive Beyond AI advice -- independent aggregation boosts human-AI ... decision accuracy / task performance
The results (conceptual/model results) support corporate GenAI policies, leadership development programs, and HR assessment of leader readiness for GenAI-enabled delegation and communication.
Practical implications and recommendations section arguing policy and HR applications based on the conceptual model.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... policy and HR adoption/application
The article introduces an EI-driven trust-calibration framework as an explanatory mechanism showing when generative AI improves leadership effectiveness and when it amplifies managerial errors.
Novel theoretical framework developed in the paper synthesizing EI, trust calibration, and psychological safety to explain boundary conditions of AI in leadership.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... leadership effectiveness (and amplification of managerial errors)
The paper provides an operationalization toolkit including measures: GenAI use intensity; delegation quality indices (clarity, boundaries, success criteria); communication quality indices (empathy, tone, transparency); psychological safety markers; and behavioral trust-calibration measures.
Operationalization section in the paper listing suggested indices and markers for empirical measurement.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... measurement constructs for empirical studies (e.g., GenAI use intensity, delegat...
As a follow-up validation path, the paper proposes a two-wave time-lag design and 180° assessment (leader + subordinates) to reduce common-method bias.
Methodological proposal in the paper describing longitudinal and multi-rater validation approaches.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... robustness/validity of empirical findings (reduction of common-method bias)
The paper proposes a 'Package B' rapid empirical design: a randomized online experiment manipulating access to generative AI in core managerial tasks (decision, delegation, team communication), combined with EI measurement and trust-calibration indicators.
Methodology section proposing the rapid randomized online experiment design as the primary empirical test.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... experimental test of human–AI leadership effects
Emotional intelligence strengthens the positive impact of generative AI on managerial outcomes when trust is properly calibrated and psychological safety is maintained.
Conceptual model and integrative argument combining EI, trust-calibration, and psychological safety; supported by proposed empirical test design.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... managerial outcomes (e.g., decision quality)
The paper conceptualizes human–AI leadership as an integrated managerial competence.
Conceptual modeling presented in the paper integrating EI theory, psychological safety, and trust calibration (theoretical synthesis).
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... human–AI leadership competence (integrated managerial competence)
Large language model (LLM) use can improve observable output and short-term task performance.
Paper synthesizes empirical findings from human–AI interaction studies, learning-research experiments, and model-evaluation work indicating improved produced outputs and short-term task performance when humans use LLMs; no single pooled sample size or unified effect estimate is reported in the paper.
high positive Beyond the Steeper Curve: AI-Mediated Metacognitive Decoupli... observable output quality and short-term task performance
These empirical insights provide actionable guidelines advocating dynamically routed architectures that adapt their collaborative structures to real-time task complexity.
Authors' recommendation derived from reported empirical findings comparing architectures under varying time budgets and task complexities (prescriptive claim based on study results).
high positive An Empirical Study of Multi-Agent Collaboration for Automate... effectiveness of dynamically routed architectures in matching collaborative stru...