The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (4175 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Org Design Remove filter
The paper applies formal models from reliability engineering and information theory as post hoc interpretive lenses on context quality.
Paper text claiming the application of these formal models for interpretation.
high positive Context Engineering: A Practitioner Methodology for Structur... use of formal theoretical models
Context Engineering applies a staged four-phase pipeline (Reviewer to Design to Builder to Auditor).
Methodological description in the paper listing the four pipeline phases.
Context Engineering defines a five-role context package structure (Authority, Exemplar, Constraint, Rubric, Metadata).
Explicit specification in the paper of the five-role package components.
high positive Context Engineering: A Practitioner Methodology for Structur... structure/components of context package
This paper introduces Context Engineering, a structured methodology for assembling, declaring, and sequencing the complete informational payload that accompanies a prompt to an AI tool.
Methodological description in the paper (definition and presentation of the Context Engineering approach).
high positive Context Engineering: A Practitioner Methodology for Structur... existence/definition of a structured prompting methodology
This study contributes to AI adoption literature by isolating organizational technical capability and providing national-level evidence from an emerging ICT economy (Pakistan).
Authors' stated contribution based on their empirical analysis (survey of 110 ICT professionals in Pakistan) and focus on organizational technical capability as a distinct predictor.
high positive Drivers of AI Adoption: The Role of Innovation Attributes, O... scholarly contribution / evidence scope
Internal technological perceptions and readiness are stronger predictors of AI adoption than external forces in operating ICT firms in Pakistan.
Comparative interpretation of PLS-SEM findings from the 110-response survey showing internal factors (compatibility, technical capability, perceived benefits, complexity) had significant associations with adoption while external pressure did not.
high positive Drivers of AI Adoption: The Role of Innovation Attributes, O... AI adoption (relative importance of predictors)
Organizational technical capability demonstrates a strong influence on AI adoption; firms with mature digital systems are better prepared to integrate AI solutions.
Survey responses from 110 ICT professionals analyzed with SmartPLS-SEM indicated technical capability (organizational technical readiness) is a strong predictor of AI adoption.
Seamless compatibility with existing infrastructure plays a key role in encouraging AI adoption among ICT firms in Pakistan.
Survey of 110 national ICT professionals analyzed via PLS-SEM; compatibility (perceived suitability to current systems) was reported as a significant predictor of AI adoption.
Effective AI governance requires stronger policy capacity, clearer allocation of responsibility, and governance mechanisms that remain robust across divergent technological futures.
Conclusion of the article based on its analysis of uncertainty, adoption dynamics, and framework proposals; grounded in cited policy and scholarly sources.
high positive Governing frontier general-purpose AI in the public sector: ... requirements for effective AI governance (policy capacity, responsibility alloca...
The article proposes an adaptive governance framework for public institutions that integrates capability monitoring, risk tiering, conditional controls, institutional learning, and standards-based interoperability.
Normative framework proposed in the article, derived from the paper's synthesis of foresight reports and governance scholarship.
high positive Governing frontier general-purpose AI in the public sector: ... components and design of an adaptive governance framework for AI
The article reconstructs the conceptual foundations of the 'evidence dilemma', differentiated AI risk categories, and the limits of prediction.
Declared analytic activity in the article, based on synthesis of the International AI Safety Report 2026, OECD foresight, and recent scholarship.
high positive Governing frontier general-purpose AI in the public sector: ... conceptual framing of evidence gaps, AI risk typology, and prediction limits
Public governance for frontier AI should be based on adaptive risk management, scenario-aware regulation, and sociotechnical transformation rather than static compliance models.
Normative recommendation made by the article, supported by conceptual analysis and references to adaptive governance literature and policy documents.
high positive Governing frontier general-purpose AI in the public sector: ... preferred governance approach for frontier AI
Recent evidence indicates that AI capabilities are advancing rapidly, though unevenly.
Statement in article referencing recent empirical/foresight sources, e.g. International AI Safety Report 2026 and OECD foresight documents (sources cited in the paper).
high positive Governing frontier general-purpose AI in the public sector: ... rate and distribution of AI capability advancement
The governance of frontier general-purpose artificial intelligence has become a public-sector problem of institutional design, not merely a technical issue of model performance.
Conceptual argument presented in the article, drawing on synthesis of policy reports (International AI Safety Report 2026, OECD foresight) and scholarship in digital government.
high positive Governing frontier general-purpose AI in the public sector: ... public-sector institutional design requirements for frontier AI governance
Exploitative innovation is directly associated with long-term competitive performance.
PLS-SEM analysis of survey data from 104 Portuguese B2B managers showing a significant direct path from exploitative innovation to performance.
high positive Generative AI Adoption in B2B Firms: Ethical Governance, Inn... long-term competitive performance
Exploratory innovation's association with long-term competitive performance operates indirectly through GenAI adoption (mediation).
Survey of 104 Portuguese B2B managers and PLS-SEM showing a mediated pathway from exploratory innovation to performance via GenAI adoption in the estimated model.
high positive Generative AI Adoption in B2B Firms: Ethical Governance, Inn... long-term competitive performance
GenAI adoption is positively associated with long-term competitive performance.
Survey data from 104 Portuguese B2B managers; association estimated via PLS-SEM in the study's structural model.
high positive Generative AI Adoption in B2B Firms: Ethical Governance, Inn... long-term competitive performance
Ethical governance is the strongest organisational correlate of long-term competitive performance.
Survey data from 104 Portuguese B2B managers; analysed using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modelling (PLS-SEM); reported as a comparative strength of model paths.
high positive Generative AI Adoption in B2B Firms: Ethical Governance, Inn... long-term competitive performance
Evidence-based frameworks for structural redesign that prioritize network density, decision proximity to information sources, and cross-boundary coordination mechanisms are foundational prerequisites for organizational agility.
Concluding synthesis of reviewed literature and empirical cases leading to proposed frameworks. The provided text labels the frameworks 'evidence-based' but does not present quantitative validation or implementation trial results in the excerpt.
The article draws on empirical cases from manufacturing, technology platforms, and healthcare delivery across North America, Europe, and East Asia to support its arguments.
Statement in the article that empirical cases from those sectors and regions were analyzed. The provided text does not specify the number of cases, selection criteria, or methodologies for the case analyses.
high positive People Don't Follow Strategy—They Follow Structure: Why Orga... breadth of empirical support (cross-sector, cross-region cases)
Structural reconfiguration enables adaptive behaviors that resist cultivation under traditional pyramid architectures, regardless of cultural interventions.
Claim derived from comparative analysis and empirical case studies referenced in the article; presented as an observation across cases from multiple industries and regions. No explicit statistical tests or counts reported in the provided text.
high positive People Don't Follow Strategy—They Follow Structure: Why Orga... adaptive behaviors / organizational adaptability
Flattening hierarchies and redistributing authority to operational edges fundamentally rewires information flow, decision velocity, and collaborative patterns.
Argument based on synthesis of research on organizational modularity and structural determinants of behavior; described as supported by empirical cases across sectors (manufacturing, technology platforms, healthcare). No numerical sample sizes or formal experimental details provided.
high positive People Don't Follow Strategy—They Follow Structure: Why Orga... information flow, decision velocity, collaborative patterns
Formal structure—specifically hierarchical configuration and decision-making architecture—exerts greater influence on employee behavior than culture change initiatives or compensation redesign.
Synthesis of organizational behavior, network science, and comparative institutional research cited in the article; stated comparison between structural determinants and culture/incentive interventions. No sample size or statistical details reported in the text provided.
The study synthesizes interdisciplinary literature spanning health informatics, regulatory policy, ethical AI design, and healthcare economics to examine how governance structures can balance innovation with accountability.
Methodological statement in the paper describing the scope of the literature review and interdisciplinary synthesis (description of methods / scope).
high positive Conceptual framework for AI governance, data privacy complia... scope and breadth of literature synthesis
The review contributes a unified conceptual model that clarifies relationships among governance, privacy assurance, and sustainable financing, offering guidance for designing resilient digital health systems that maintain ethical integrity, regulatory compliance, and economic viability.
Authors' stated contribution in the paper: a unified conceptual model produced by integrating findings across health informatics, policy, ethics, and economics literatures (conceptual synthesis).
high positive Conceptual framework for AI governance, data privacy complia... resilience of digital health systems (ethical integrity, regulatory compliance, ...
Linking governance maturity with economic resilience provides a structured pathway for policymakers, healthcare institutions, and technology developers to operationalize responsible AI in healthcare environments.
Proposal in the paper connecting governance maturity levels (conceptual) to organizational economic resilience based on cross-disciplinary literature (theoretical linkage from review).
high positive Conceptual framework for AI governance, data privacy complia... economic resilience / operationalization of responsible AI
Financial sustainability of digital health systems can be supported through value-based healthcare models, cost optimization strategies, and scalable digital infrastructure that preserve compliance obligations.
Conceptual analysis and literature synthesis across healthcare economics and digital infrastructure studies presented in the review (literature review / conceptual proposal).
high positive Conceptual framework for AI governance, data privacy complia... financial sustainability (cost structure, revenue models, ability to support ong...
Privacy-by-design architectures, secure data interoperability, and compliance automation contribute to trust, institutional legitimacy, and long-term adoption of digital health solutions.
Synthesis of literature on privacy engineering, interoperability standards, and compliance technologies presented in the review (literature review; inferred causal linkages discussed).
high positive Conceptual framework for AI governance, data privacy complia... trust / institutional legitimacy / long-term adoption rate of digital health sol...
The framework gives particular attention to algorithmic transparency, risk management, regulatory alignment, and lifecycle oversight of AI-enabled health systems operating under evolving privacy regulations (e.g., data protection laws and cross-border data governance standards).
Descriptive emphasis within the proposed framework, based on cited literatures in regulatory alignment and algorithmic governance (literature synthesis / conceptual emphasis).
high positive Conceptual framework for AI governance, data privacy complia... regulatory alignment and lifecycle oversight
This review develops a comprehensive conceptual framework that integrates AI governance principles, data privacy compliance mechanisms, and financially sustainable operational models within digital health ecosystems.
The paper's primary contribution is a proposed conceptual framework derived from synthesizing interdisciplinary literatures (conceptual framework produced by authors based on literature review).
high positive Conceptual framework for AI governance, data privacy complia... existence of an integrated governance/privacy/finance framework
The rapid expansion of digital health technologies driven by artificial intelligence has transformed healthcare delivery, clinical decision-making, and health data management.
Narrative synthesis in the review paper drawing on interdisciplinary literature in health informatics, clinical AI studies, and health data management (literature review / conceptual synthesis).
high positive Conceptual framework for AI governance, data privacy complia... clinical decision-making quality / healthcare delivery and data management
Experimental evidence confirms that AI tools raise worker productivity.
Statement in paper referencing experimental studies (no specific study, method, or sample size reported in the excerpt).
The paper argues for a fundamental decoupling of semantic intent from human-readable representation.
Conceptual/design claim made by the authors as a recommended shift in representation strategy for agentic consumers; presented as argumentation rather than empirically tested in abstract.
high positive Beyond Human-Readable: Rethinking Software Engineering Conve... alignment between semantic intent encoding and human-readable formats
We extend the semantic density principle to propose rehabilitation of classical anti-patterns and introduce the program skeleton concept for agentic code navigation.
Design/position claims and proposed constructs presented in the paper (program skeleton concept and re-evaluation of anti-patterns) without empirical validation reported in abstract.
high positive Beyond Human-Readable: Rethinking Software Engineering Conve... suitability of classical anti-patterns and program skeletons for agentic navigat...
Aggressive compression reduced input tokens by 17%.
Reported numeric result from the controlled experiment comparing compressed logs to other conditions; sample size not specified in abstract.
We propose a key design principle: semantic density optimization, eliminating tokens that carry zero information while preserving tokens that carry high semantic value.
Proposal/design principle presented in the paper; theoretical justification provided and (per paper) subsequently validated by experiment.
high positive Beyond Human-Readable: Rethinking Software Engineering Conve... information/content efficiency of token representations for agentic consumers
Above the Accountability Horizon, distributed accountability mechanisms become necessary.
Derived implication from the Accountability Incompleteness Theorem and the paper's discussion of policy responses; theoretical argument rather than empirical evidence.
high positive The Accountability Horizon: An Impossibility Theorem for Gov... necessity of distributed accountability mechanisms conditional on compound auton...
Experiments on 3,000 synthetic collectives confirm all predictions with zero violations.
Reported simulation experiments: N = 3,000 synthetic Human-Agent Collectives evaluated against the theoretical predictions; reported outcome was zero violations of the predicted impossibility/conditions.
high positive The Accountability Horizon: An Impossibility Theorem for Gov... number of violations of the theoretical predictions (violations of impossibility...
Below the threshold (Accountability Horizon), legitimate frameworks exist, establishing a sharp phase transition between regimes where the four properties can and cannot be satisfied.
Constructive existence results and theoretical arguments in the paper showing frameworks that satisfy the axioms when compound autonomy is below the defined threshold.
high positive The Accountability Horizon: An Impossibility Theorem for Gov... existence/non-existence of legitimate accountability frameworks as a function of...
We introduce Human-Agent Collectives, a formalisation of joint human-AI systems where agents are modelled as state-policy tuples within a shared structural causal model.
Paper provides a formal model/definition called Human-Agent Collectives (mathematical formalisation and definitions).
high positive The Accountability Horizon: An Impossibility Theorem for Gov... formal representation of joint human-AI systems
Existing accountability frameworks for AI systems, legal, ethical, and regulatory, rest on a shared assumption: for any consequential outcome, at least one identifiable person had enough involvement and foresight to bear meaningful responsibility.
Stated as background assumption in the paper's introduction/abstract; supported by citation to prior legal/ethical/regulatory frameworks (normative claim about literature). No empirical test reported in this paper.
high positive The Accountability Horizon: An Impossibility Theorem for Gov... attributability of responsibility for consequential outcomes
Tiny sharing incentives improve models with weak cooperation.
Experimental intervention reported in the paper: adding small sharing incentives and observing improved cooperation among weakly-cooperative models (stated in abstract; no quantitative effect size or sample size provided there).
high positive More Capable, Less Cooperative? When LLMs Fail At Zero-Cost ... cooperation / collective performance under small incentive intervention
Explicit protocols double performance for low-competence models.
Experimental intervention reported in the paper: introducing explicit protocols in the multi-agent setup and observing a doubling of performance for low-competence models (stated in abstract; no sample size reported there).
high positive More Capable, Less Cooperative? When LLMs Fail At Zero-Cost ... model/team performance under explicit protocol intervention
OpenAI o3-mini reaches 50% of optimal collective performance.
Experimental measurement of collective performance for OpenAI o3-mini in the paper's multi-agent setup (value reported in abstract; no sample size provided there).
high positive More Capable, Less Cooperative? When LLMs Fail At Zero-Cost ... collective performance (percent of optimal group revenue)
The core thesis is alignment-through-accountability: if each agent is aligned with its human owner through the accountability chain, then the collective converges on behavior aligned with human intent -- without top-down rules.
Central theoretical thesis of the paper; presented as a hypothesis to be evaluated rather than as an empirically demonstrated result in the excerpt.
high positive AgentCity: Constitutional Governance for Autonomous Agent Ec... convergence of collective agent behavior to human intent via accountability chai...
We propose the Separation of Power (SoP) model, a constitutional governance architecture deployed on public blockchain that breaks this monopoly through three structural separations: agents legislate operational rules as smart contracts, deterministic software executes within those contracts, and humans adjudicate through a complete ownership chain binding every agent to a responsible principal.
Design proposal / governance architecture presented in the paper; the text asserts that the model 'breaks this monopoly' but provides no experimental results in the excerpt to validate that claim.
high positive AgentCity: Constitutional Governance for Autonomous Agent Ec... reduction/elimination of 'Logic Monopoly' via structural separations
Those incentivized for originality rely on the model more selectively for brainstorming, proofreading, and targeted edits.
Behavioral/usage measures from the RCT indicating task-level patterns of AI use (described qualitatively in excerpt; no quantitative task-level usage breakdown provided).
high positive Incentives shape how humans co-create with generative AI types of tasks for which AI is used (brainstorming, proofreading, targeted edits...
Participants rewarded for originality relative to peers produce collectively more diverse writing than those rewarded for quality alone.
Randomized assignment to incentive conditions (originality reward vs. quality reward) in the pre-registered RCT on a creative writing task (no sample size or numerical effect provided in excerpt).
high positive Incentives shape how humans co-create with generative AI collective diversity of writing
Early evidence has shown that generative AI can increase individual-level productivity.
Statement refers to prior literature/early studies (no specific study, sample size, or method reported in the excerpt).
high positive Incentives shape how humans co-create with generative AI individual-level productivity
Much of the business and management literature approaches artificial intelligence primarily as a technological capability that enhances efficiency and productivity.
Literature review / characterization of existing business and management literature cited in the paper; no quantitative synthesis or meta-analysis reported.
high positive Algorithmic Agency and the Posthuman Economy: Artificial Int... portrayal of AI in business literature as a capability that enhances efficiency ...