The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (3231 claims)

Adoption
7395 claims
Productivity
6507 claims
Governance
5921 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
5192 claims
Org Design
3497 claims
Innovation
3492 claims
Labor Markets
3231 claims
Skills & Training
2608 claims
Inequality
1842 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 609 159 77 738 1617
Governance & Regulation 671 334 160 99 1285
Organizational Efficiency 626 147 105 70 955
Technology Adoption Rate 502 176 98 78 861
Research Productivity 349 109 48 322 838
Output Quality 391 121 45 40 597
Firm Productivity 385 46 85 17 539
Decision Quality 277 145 63 34 526
AI Safety & Ethics 189 244 59 30 526
Market Structure 152 154 109 20 440
Task Allocation 158 50 56 26 295
Innovation Output 178 23 38 17 257
Skill Acquisition 137 52 50 13 252
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 120 64 38 23 252
Employment Level 93 46 96 12 249
Firm Revenue 130 43 26 3 202
Consumer Welfare 99 51 40 11 201
Inequality Measures 36 106 40 6 188
Task Completion Time 134 18 6 5 163
Worker Satisfaction 79 54 16 11 160
Error Rate 64 79 8 1 152
Regulatory Compliance 69 66 14 3 152
Training Effectiveness 82 16 13 18 131
Wages & Compensation 70 25 22 6 123
Team Performance 74 16 21 9 121
Automation Exposure 41 48 19 9 120
Job Displacement 11 71 16 1 99
Developer Productivity 71 14 9 3 98
Hiring & Recruitment 49 7 8 3 67
Social Protection 26 14 8 2 50
Creative Output 26 14 6 2 49
Skill Obsolescence 5 37 5 1 48
Labor Share of Income 12 13 12 37
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Labor Markets Remove filter
Overall, economic benefits from AI in radiology are plausible but conditional on human-AI interaction design, governance, workforce effects, and payment structures; net value is not determined by algorithmic accuracy alone.
Synthesis of the heterogeneous literature (laboratory, reader, observational, qualitative) and conceptual economic analysis highlighting dependencies beyond algorithmic performance.
medium mixed Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... net economic value/ROI, clinical outcomes, adoption and sustainability metrics
The net effect of AI on clinician burnout is ambiguous: tools can remove tedious tasks but may introduce new cognitive, administrative, and liability stresses.
Mixed qualitative and small-scale observational studies with variable findings on burnout-related measures after AI introduction.
medium mixed Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... burnout survey scores, task satisfaction, administrative burden metrics
Changes in workload composition can reduce routine burdens but may shift cognitive load to follow-up decisions and managing AI outputs.
Observational and qualitative studies of deployed systems reporting redistribution of tasks and clinician-reported changes in cognitive demands.
medium mixed Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... time allocation across task types, subjective cognitive workload scores, frequen...
Economic outcomes depend on complementarity versus substitution: AI that augments radiologists can raise output per worker; AI that substitutes tasks may reduce demand for certain diagnostic activities.
Theoretical economic frameworks and case studies of task reallocation in early deployments; empirical workforce-impact studies limited.
medium mixed Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... radiologist productivity metrics, employment levels/demand for diagnostic activi...
Automation bias can increase undue reliance on AI, while algorithmic aversion can drive underuse of helpful tools.
Cognitive and behavioral studies and reader simulations demonstrating both increased acceptance/overtrust in automated outputs in some settings and rejection/discounting of AI advice in others.
medium mixed Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... rates of clinician acceptance/use of AI recommendations, error rates when follow...
Real clinical value depends critically on how AI tools interact with radiologists in practice (integration design and human-AI interaction).
Conceptual models and synthesis of reader studies, simulation/interaction studies, usability and qualitative deployment evaluations that compare standalone algorithm performance versus clinician+AI workflows.
medium mixed Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... clinician-AI joint diagnostic performance, patient-relevant outcomes, workflow m...
Human capital is no longer defined solely by formal education or accumulated experience; it increasingly takes the form of a multidimensional system in which cognitive abilities, digital competencies, social and communicative skills, and ethical awareness interact and reinforce one another.
Result of the paper's synthesis combining systemic analysis and comparative assessment of international practices; conceptual/qualitative evidence rather than quantified measurement across populations.
medium mixed EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... composition/dimensionality of human capital (cognitive abilities, digital compet...
Ongoing digital transformation and the widespread adoption of artificial intelligence are reshaping the formation, structure, and practical use of human capital in modern economies.
Paper's core analytical conclusion based on systemic analysis, comparative assessment of international practices, and analytical generalization of organizational learning models; no primary quantitative sample size or experimental data reported.
medium mixed EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... formation, structure, and practical use of human capital
Generative AI is not purely a job-destroying technology but a task-transforming force that reshapes skill requirements and occupational structures.
Synthesis of empirical studies and systematic reviews reported in the paper showing task reallocation, skill shifts, and occupational restructuring (study details not specified in excerpt).
medium mixed The Impact of Generative AI on the Future of Employment: Opp... task composition, skill requirements, and occupational structure
There is a decline in mid‑skilled occupations, such as operations and management (O&M), accompanied by an increase in high‑skilled jobs that require skills in artificial intelligence (AI), data analytics, and engineering.
Reported pattern from the systematic literature review and recent studies/reports cited by the paper noting occupational declines in mid‑skilled O&M roles and rises in high‑skill technical roles; the summary does not specify which studies or their sample sizes.
medium mixed Job Polarization in Solar Power Plants: A Systematic Literat... counts or share of jobs by skill level (mid‑skilled O&M vs high‑skilled AI/data/...
With renewable energy (RE), particularly the scale of solar power expansion in India, the job scenario is changing.
Stated conclusion from the paper's systematic literature review drawing on recent reports and studies about RE/solar expansion in India; no primary data or sample size reported in the summary.
medium mixed Job Polarization in Solar Power Plants: A Systematic Literat... overall job scenario / employment composition in the Indian solar energy sector
Factors identified as relevant to AI emergence/adoption include Technology Adoption Rate (AI1), Government Policies and Regulations (AI2), Labor Market Dynamics (AI3), Technological Advancements (AI4), Corporate Strategies (AI5), and Socio-cultural Factors (AI6).
Author-provided list of factors in the paper; no empirical quantification, weighting, or methodology for selecting these factors is given in the excerpt.
medium mixed A Study on Work-Life Balance of Women Employees in the IT Se... presence/role of listed drivers in AI emergence or adoption
These findings have important implications for understanding how political ideology may influence party members’ perspectives on AI in relation to labor markets, job losses, and regulation in OECD countries.
Interpretive implication drawn by the authors from their reported results (synthesis rather than a new empirical claim).
medium mixed Political Ideology, Artificial Intelligence (AI), and Labor ... influence of political ideology on perspectives concerning AI and labor-market p...
Political ideology shapes party members’ positions on AI education and training programs intended to assist workers in environments where AI is more prevalent.
Inferred finding stated by the authors based on content analysis of party member statements; the excerpt indicates the authors examined positions on AI education/training but does not provide specific results or metrics.
medium mixed Political Ideology, Artificial Intelligence (AI), and Labor ... support for or emphasis on AI-related education and training programs among part...
Political ideology significantly affects party members’ views on the need for government regulations to protect workers from labor market disruptions caused by AI.
Reported finding from the paper's content analysis of media interviews, speeches, and debates by party members in OECD countries (2016–2025); details on coding categories, inter-rater reliability, and quantitative significance measures are not included in the excerpt.
medium mixed Political Ideology, Artificial Intelligence (AI), and Labor ... endorsement or concern about government regulation to protect workers from AI-re...
Political ideology significantly affects party members’ concerns regarding AI-related job losses.
Result reported by the authors based on content-analysis of party member comments and statements across OECD countries (2016–2025); specific analytic procedures, coding scheme, sample size, and statistical tests are not provided in the excerpt.
medium mixed Political Ideology, Artificial Intelligence (AI), and Labor ... level/degree of concern about AI-related job losses among party members
Evidence on apprenticeship reforms indicates a shift toward higher-level qualifications and younger participants, while overall apprenticeship participation has declined.
Synthesis of reform evaluations and comparative studies on apprenticeship systems presented in the paper (summary does not identify which reforms/countries or provide participation statistics).
medium mixed Balancing Higher Education, Vocational Training, and Lifelon... apprenticeship qualification levels, age distribution of participants, overall p...
Participation in adult education and training has increased overall but remains uneven across age groups and skill levels.
Secondary data and comparative evidence cited in the paper showing rising adult learning participation with heterogeneity by age and skill level (no numerical breakdown provided in the summary).
medium mixed Balancing Higher Education, Vocational Training, and Lifelon... participation rates in adult education/training by age group and skill level
Facilitated access to AI reconfigures startup roles, organizational structures, and decision routines.
Analytic findings from semi-structured interviews pointing to changes in role definitions, reporting lines, and decision-making routines after AI adoption (qualitative evidence; sample size not specified).
medium mixed Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... roles, organizational structure, and decision routines
Artificial intelligence (AI) is poised to transform the distribution and sources of income.
Analytical assertion in the paper (theoretical/policy analysis); no empirical data or specific study citations provided in the excerpt.
medium mixed Taxing AI distribution and sources of income
Artificial intelligence (AI) has redefined what it means to perform, achieve and succeed.
Stated as a conceptual claim in the paper's purpose/introduction; supported by theoretical argument and literature synthesis (leadership theory, emotional intelligence research, AI ethics). No empirical sample, experiments, or quantitative data provided in the paper.
medium mixed Deconstructing success: why being human still matters definition/criteria of 'success' (conceptual)
AI adoption generates different effects across different occupations.
Summary statement based on analysis of publicly available labor market data (occupational-level heterogeneity asserted but specific datasets, sample sizes, and methods not described).
medium mixed Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... occupation-specific employment and productivity outcomes
AI is not an unprecedented disruption; its effects can be situated within established economic frameworks related to automation and task substitution.
Conceptual analysis comparing recent AI developments to historical automation and task-substitution frameworks; empirical grounding claimed via publicly available labor market and productivity data (details not provided).
medium mixed Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... magnitude and character of economic disruption relative to past automation episo...
Firm learning raises the persistence of the economy's response to shocks but dampens volatility.
Quantitative model experiments: introducing firm learning into the calibrated model increases impulse-response persistence to shocks (higher persistence) while reducing the magnitude/variance of fluctuations (lower volatility) in simulated aggregate variables.
medium mixed Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics persistence of aggregate responses to shocks (e.g., autocorrelation/impulse-resp...
The rapid global proliferation of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has created a profound paradox: while promising unprecedented productivity gains, its current trajectory exacerbates labor market polarization, deepens inequality, and threatens to fracture the 20th-century social contract.
Asserted in abstract; no empirical methods, datasets, or sample sizes described in the abstract (presumably supported in paper by literature review/argumentation).
medium mixed The DARE framework: a global model for responsible artificia... productivity gains; labor market polarization; inequality; integrity of the 20th...
AI’s labor market impacts in the Philippines are not technologically predetermined; outcomes will depend on policy choices related to skills development, governance, social protection, and innovation.
Integrated conceptual framework in the paper linking AI capabilities, occupational structure, and institutional mediation, supported by the scenario analysis which shows divergent outcomes conditional on policy settings.
medium mixed Labor Futures Under Artificial Intelligence: Scenarios for t... direction and magnitude of labor market impacts conditional on policy interventi...
Observed AI adoption patterns in the Philippines to date are cautious, with limited job loss but growing task reconfiguration and emerging skills gaps.
Firm- and worker-level evidence on AI adoption (surveys/interviews and/or administrative firm adoption data described in the paper) documenting current adoption practices, reported job impacts, task changes, and reported skill shortages.
medium mixed Labor Futures Under Artificial Intelligence: Scenarios for t... incidence of job losses, prevalence of task reconfiguration, and occurrence of r...
A significant share of Philippine employment is exposed to generative AI—particularly in service-sector and BPO-related occupations.
Occupational exposure analysis using Philippine labor force data (occupational employment shares and task-content measures) combined with task-level evidence on generative AI capabilities.
medium mixed Labor Futures Under Artificial Intelligence: Scenarios for t... proportion/share of employment (by occupation and sector) classified as exposed ...
AI alters job structures, workflow patterns, and human roles in decision-making processes.
Thematic content analysis of recent accredited journal literature as part of the qualitative library research (sources not enumerated).
medium mixed THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE WORKPLACE: OPPO... job structure, workflow patterns, decision-making roles
AI is fundamentally transforming the workplace by creating new opportunities, intensifying challenges, and redefining professional skills.
Qualitative library research: systematic documentation and thematic content analysis of recent accredited journal sources (number of sources not specified).
medium mixed THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE WORKPLACE: OPPO... overall workplace transformation (opportunities, challenges, skill redefinition)
The actions of large employers in an occupation or industry affect local and national wages, employment and output.
Theoretical/empirical claim in the paper; excerpt does not supply empirical methods, identification, or sample sizes demonstrating these effects.
medium mixed Labor Market Power: From Micro Evidence to Macro Consequence... local and national wages, employment, and output
As AI becomes increasingly integrated into higher education, instructors and institutions face urgent questions about its implications for teaching, learning, scholarly practice, and for power, agency, and access.
Framing claim in the paper's introduction supported by literature context and reinforced by the study's analysis of practitioner (faculty) discussions on Reddit indicating concern/uncertainty. (The excerpt does not report survey or quantitative prevalence data on how widespread these concerns are.)
medium mixed A Critical AI Media Literacy Perspective on the Future of Hi... perceived urgency and breadth of questions raised by instructors/institutions re...
Through thematic content analysis, the study explores faculty perceptions, pedagogical tensions, and imaginative possibilities surrounding AI’s academic role.
Method stated by author: thematic content analysis of subreddit discussions to identify themes relating to faculty perceptions, pedagogical tensions, and imagined futures for AI in academia. (Exact number of themes, coding procedure, and sample size not provided in excerpt.)
medium mixed A Critical AI Media Literacy Perspective on the Future of Hi... identified themes related to faculty perceptions, pedagogical tensions, and imag...
AI reshapes traditional power structures, challenges regulatory frameworks, and redefines global governance mechanisms.
Broad analytic claim supported by comparative policy analysis and qualitative document review; the paper frames this as an overarching conclusion without reporting quantitative indicators or case counts.
medium mixed The Geopolitics of Artificial Intelligence: Power, Regulatio... change in traditional power structures, regulatory frameworks, and global govern...
The geopolitics of AI constitutes not only a competition for technological supremacy but also a contest over the moral and institutional foundations of global governance.
Theoretical synthesis drawing on international relations theories (realism, liberal institutionalism, constructivism) and comparative policy analysis; presented as an interpretive conclusion rather than empirically quantified.
medium mixed The Geopolitics of Artificial Intelligence: Power, Regulatio... relative importance of moral and institutional foundations versus technological ...
AI represents a new dimension of geopolitical power that influences how states project authority, regulate innovation, and negotiate global norms.
Argument based on comparative policy analysis and qualitative document review of state and multilateral policy documents (specific documents and number not enumerated in text).
medium mixed The Geopolitics of Artificial Intelligence: Power, Regulatio... state capacity to project authority, regulate innovation, and negotiate global n...
Artificial intelligence (AI) has emerged as one of the most transformative forces shaping the 21st-century international order.
Conceptual claim supported by literature review and theoretical framing in the paper (no empirical sample or quantitative data reported).
medium mixed The Geopolitics of Artificial Intelligence: Power, Regulatio... degree of transformation of the 21st-century international order
These findings underscore the importance of timing when evaluating demographic policy: stabilizing finances within a practical timeframe requires levers that improve the budget directly, rather than those that work through slow demographic channels.
Comparative timing analysis from multiple model scenarios showing faster fiscal improvement from direct budgetary levers (productivity, per-capita cost control) versus slow demographic interventions (fertility increases).
medium mixed Fiscal Dynamics in Japan under Demographic Pressure time required to stabilize fiscal indicators (e.g., deficit-to-GDP or nominal de...
AI innovation effects on employment are cumulative and stage-specific over time.
Extended temporal analysis of cumulative and stage-specific impacts using the 268-city panel (2010–2023).
medium mixed How Does AI Innovation Affect Urban Employment in China? A M... urban employment scale across stages/time
Knowledge democratization through AI may reduce educational inequality but may also exacerbate digital divides and erode universities' social mobility function.
Theoretical and socio-political analysis considering opposing effects; framed as a conditional/mixed outcome without empirical measurement reported in the paper.
medium mixed Are Universities Becoming Obsolete in the Age of Artificial ... impact on educational inequality, digital divide, and universities' role in soci...
AI displacement potential varies substantially across university functions.
Summary finding from the paper's comparative analysis of university functions; the paper provides ranked/percent estimates but does not report empirical sampling or statistical testing.
medium mixed Are Universities Becoming Obsolete in the Age of Artificial ... variation in AI displacement/substitutability across different university functi...
The Photo Big 5 provides predictive power comparable to race, attractiveness, and educational background.
Comparative predictive-performance analyses reported in the paper that evaluate Photo Big 5 against observables such as race, measured attractiveness, and education background within the same sample.
medium mixed AI Personality Extraction from Faces: Labor Market Implicati... predictive power for labor-market outcomes (e.g., compensation, job matching)
In a 2021 national labor survey, no single task was automated by more than 57% of respondents, compared with a maximum of 52% in the mid-2000s.
National labor survey results (mid-2000s vs 2021) as reported in the paper; survey details and sample size are not included in the excerpt.
medium mixed Current Labor Challenges and Opportunities in Nursery Crops ... maximum task-specific automation prevalence among survey respondents
Selection of human-LLM interaction archetype can influence LLM outputs and decisions.
Findings from the evaluation across clinical diagnostic cases (empirical comparison of archetypes' effects on outputs and decisions). Specific experimental details and sample size are not provided in the abstract.
medium mixed Who Does What? Archetypes of Roles Assigned to LLMs During H... changes in LLM outputs and decision outcomes associated with different human-LLM...
We evaluate these diverse archetypes across real-world clinical diagnostic cases to examine the potential effects of adopting distinct human-LLM archetypes on LLM outputs and decision outcomes.
Empirical evaluation described in the paper using real-world clinical diagnostic cases. Method: application of archetypes to clinical cases and comparison of resulting LLM outputs and decisions. Sample size and specific case details are not provided in the abstract.
medium mixed Who Does What? Archetypes of Roles Assigned to LLMs During H... LLM outputs and decision outcomes in clinical diagnostic cases
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) adoption is diffusing rapidly but its adoption is strikingly unequal.
Nationally representative UK survey data collected in 2023–2024 reporting adoption rates by subgroup; descriptive analysis of diffusion and disparities by demographic groups.
medium mixed Women Worry, Men Adopt: How Gendered Perceptions Shape the U... GenAI adoption rates (overall and by demographic groups)
There is little existing knowledge about how the public perceives AI’s labor market impact and how those perceptions affect democratic attitudes and behaviors.
Literature gap claim motivating the study (based on authors' review of prior research; not empirically tested here).
medium mixed Perceiving AI as labor-replacing reduces democratic legitima... state of the literature / knowledge (extent of empirical evidence on public perc...
Experts remain divided on whether AI will primarily displace human labor or generate new employment opportunities.
Statement based on prior literature and expert commentary cited in the paper (no new empirical test in this study).
medium mixed Perceiving AI as labor-replacing reduces democratic legitima... expert opinion (division in forecasts about AI's net effect on employment)
Within the context of Nigeria, the adoption of advanced digital and AI-driven logistics solutions presents both a critical opportunity and a complex challenge for the country's seaports.
Analysis of secondary data sources focusing on Nigeria: academic literature by Nigerian scholars, Nigerian Ports Authority (NPA) performance reports, and policy documents as synthesized in the study.
medium mixed Digital and Ai-Driven Logistics in Nigeria’s Maritime Supply... adoption feasibility and implementation outcomes for Nigerian seaports (opportun...
AI is transforming jobs that are technical in nature.
Asserted in the paper's conceptual discussion of dual impacts; presented without empirical measurement or reported sample data in this paper.
medium mixed ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, AUTOMATION, AND THE CHANGING PATTER... nature of technical jobs (degree/type of transformation)