The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Digests 🎲

Evidence (2432 claims)

Adoption
5126 claims
Productivity
4409 claims
Governance
4049 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
2954 claims
Labor Markets
2432 claims
Org Design
2273 claims
Innovation
2215 claims
Skills & Training
1902 claims
Inequality
1286 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 369 105 58 432 972
Governance & Regulation 365 171 113 54 713
Research Productivity 229 95 33 294 655
Organizational Efficiency 354 82 58 34 531
Technology Adoption Rate 277 115 63 27 486
Firm Productivity 273 33 68 10 389
AI Safety & Ethics 112 177 43 24 358
Output Quality 228 61 23 25 337
Market Structure 105 118 81 14 323
Decision Quality 154 68 33 17 275
Employment Level 68 32 74 8 184
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 74 52 32 21 183
Skill Acquisition 85 31 38 9 163
Firm Revenue 96 30 22 148
Innovation Output 100 11 20 11 143
Consumer Welfare 66 29 35 7 137
Regulatory Compliance 51 61 13 3 128
Inequality Measures 24 66 31 4 125
Task Allocation 64 6 28 6 104
Error Rate 42 47 6 95
Training Effectiveness 55 12 10 16 93
Worker Satisfaction 42 32 11 6 91
Task Completion Time 71 5 3 1 80
Wages & Compensation 38 13 19 4 74
Team Performance 41 8 15 7 72
Hiring & Recruitment 39 4 6 3 52
Automation Exposure 17 15 9 5 46
Job Displacement 5 28 12 45
Social Protection 18 8 6 1 33
Developer Productivity 25 1 2 1 29
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Creative Output 15 5 3 1 24
Skill Obsolescence 3 18 2 23
Labor Share of Income 7 4 9 20
Clear
Labor Markets Remove filter
AI-driven NLP and ML can substantially reduce search frictions in Nairobi’s informal and gig economies by dynamically deriving individual skills and real-time market opportunities, then algorithmically matching youth to short-term work.
Pilot implementation of an end-to-end system combining NLP, ML and a matching algorithm deployed in Nairobi and compared qualitatively/aggregately against baseline informal search methods; paper summary does not report sample size, statistical tests, or numerical effect sizes.
medium positive AI-Driven Skill Mapping and Gig Economy Matching Algorithm f... search frictions (reduction), matching quality
Responsible implementation requires legal/liability clarity, continuous monitoring for performance drift and distributional shifts, usable explanations, baseline AI literacy for clinicians, and co-design with frontline radiology teams.
Synthesis of governance literature, implementation best-practice reports, and recommendations from usability and deployment studies.
medium positive Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... successful deployment metrics, monitoring alerts for drift, clinician comprehens...
Triage and automation can shorten time-to-diagnosis, increase throughput, and reduce time spent on repetitive tasks.
Observational deployment reports and simulation studies that measured time-to-report or throughput improvements in pilot settings (evidence heterogeneous and context-dependent).
medium positive Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... time-to-diagnosis, studies-per-hour per radiologist, time spent on repetitive ta...
Integration points for AI across the imaging pathway include acquisition (image quality/protocol selection), triage (prioritization), interpretation/reporting (detection, quantification, report pre-population), and post-interpretation (teaching, QA, model improvement loops).
Descriptive synthesis of reported implementations and proposed use cases in the literature and deployment reports across multiple institutions.
medium positive Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... site-level implementation metrics by workflow stage (e.g., reduced repeat scans,...
Human-AI collaboration can produce synergistic gains (diagnostic complementarity) when errors are uncorrelated and tasks are allocated to leverage comparative strengths.
Theoretical/analytical models of error complementarity and empirical reader studies showing instances where combined readings outperform either agent alone (evidence drawn from multiple small-to-moderate reader studies and simulations).
medium positive Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... combined diagnostic accuracy (aggregate sensitivity/specificity), reduction in m...
AI in radiology has clear potential to improve diagnostic performance and workflow efficiency.
Narrative synthesis of laboratory evaluation studies, reader/comparison studies, and a limited number of observational deployment reports showing improved algorithm accuracy and some improvements in measured throughput or time-to-review in pilots (study sizes and settings heterogeneous; few large-scale RCTs).
medium positive Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... diagnostic accuracy (sensitivity/specificity), workflow efficiency (throughput, ...
Clinical-interface validation with real physicians on mobile devices confirmed the practical viability and usability of the HADT system and interface.
Paper reports an interface test with real doctors using the mobile interface as part of validation (number of physicians, tasks, and quantitative usability metrics not specified in the summary).
medium positive Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning Based Human-AI Online Di... practical viability / usability in clinical-interface testing (physician interac...
On public datasets HADT achieves superior accuracy/human-effort trade-offs compared to baselines (fully human, fully automated, and simpler assignment strategies).
Comparative evaluations reported in the paper on public medical-consultation datasets (baselines listed broadly; exact baseline implementations, dataset names, and quantitative comparisons not included in the provided summary).
medium positive Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning Based Human-AI Online Di... diagnostic accuracy and human effort relative to baseline methods
The execution machine uses masked hierarchical reinforcement learning with bottom-up training to ask informative symptom questions from a large symptom space.
Methodological description and reported training procedure in the paper (bottom-up training applied to the execution module; claimed to improve question selection; experimental validation referenced but details not provided in the summary).
medium positive Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning Based Human-AI Online Di... quality/informativeness of symptom questions; downstream diagnostic accuracy
A two-layer hierarchical reinforcement learning system—an assignment 'master' and an execution 'machine' (plus human doctors)—effectively balances accuracy and human cost.
Architectural design and experimental evaluation in the paper demonstrating trade-offs between diagnostic accuracy and human involvement using the hierarchical RL setup (experiments run on public datasets; exact sample sizes not given).
medium positive Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning Based Human-AI Online Di... trade-off between diagnostic accuracy and human effort
The Human-AI Diagnostic Team (HADT) framework can deliver near-expert-level online symptom inquiry and diagnosis while using very little human labor.
Performance reported on public datasets and clinical-interface tests with real physicians; described comparisons to expert-level performance in the paper's main finding (specific comparative statistics to experts not provided in the summary).
medium positive Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning Based Human-AI Online Di... quality of symptom inquiry / diagnostic performance (compared to expert-level)
HADT reached up to 89.4% diagnostic accuracy while requiring only 10.9% human effort.
Empirical results reported in the paper from experiments on public online medical-consultation datasets and clinical-interface validation with real doctors (dataset names and sample sizes not specified in the provided summary).
medium positive Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning Based Human-AI Online Di... diagnostic accuracy; human effort (proportion of turns/time requiring human doct...
AI-mediated collaboration will create new organizational roles and governance structures, such as AI mediators and verification/oversight roles.
Conceptual discussion of organizational implications and illustrative role examples; no organizational case studies with sample sizes reported.
medium positive AI as a universal collaboration layer: Eliminating language ... emergence of new roles (count/frequency) and governance structures within organi...
Autonomous AI agents can automate routine coordination tasks, follow-up, and some task execution, thereby reducing human coordination overhead.
Paper uses conceptual mapping of agent capabilities to coordination/execution functions and provides illustrative case scenarios; no experimental or field data presented.
medium positive AI as a universal collaboration layer: Eliminating language ... human coordination time / routine task overhead / automated task completion rate
Multimodal systems (integrating text, speech, images, video) broaden communication channels and thus can improve the range and fidelity of mediated communication.
Conceptual argument and illustrative examples in the paper describing how multimodal integration maps to communication functions; no empirical validation reported.
medium positive AI as a universal collaboration layer: Eliminating language ... breadth/fidelity of communication channels; information transmission quality
Multilingual language models reduce language barriers by translating and normalizing meaning across languages.
Conceptual synthesis of capabilities (multilingual LMs) and mapping to coordination function (translation/normalization); supported in paper by illustrative examples rather than empirical testing.
medium positive AI as a universal collaboration layer: Eliminating language ... degree of language barrier reduction / fidelity of cross-language meaning transf...
Digital skills have surpassed traditional educational attainment to become a core human-capital element determining labor market performance in South Korea.
Interpretation based on regression results from the extended Mincerian wage equation applied to KLIPS micro-data showing sizable and significant wage premiums for digital skills even after controlling for years of education and other covariates.
medium positive Measuring the Economic Returns of Vocational Digital Skills ... labor market performance proxied by wages/worker compensation
For graduates of Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET), acquiring advanced digital skills significantly narrows the income gap with general higher education graduates.
Heterogeneity analysis on KLIPS micro-data examining interaction of educational pathway (TVET vs general higher education) with possession of advanced digital skills in extended Mincerian wage regressions; the result reported is a significant narrowing of the earnings gap (no numeric magnitude given in the excerpt).
medium positive Measuring the Economic Returns of Vocational Digital Skills ... relative earnings/income gap between TVET graduates and general higher education...
The findings provide valuable insights for entrepreneurs, policymakers, and academic institutions to implement adaptive strategies for sustainable and inclusive entrepreneurial growth in the era of artificial intelligence.
Authors' implications/conclusions based on the study results (n=350; statistical analyses) recommending adaptive strategies targeted at stakeholders.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... policy and practice guidance for sustainable and inclusive entrepreneurial growt...
AI functions as a strategic enabler that reshapes entrepreneurial practices, labour dynamics, and innovation strategies.
Conclusion drawn from the study's quantitative findings (survey of 350, regression/SEM results) that linked AI adoption to changes in opportunity recognition, labour substitution, and innovation processes.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... overall entrepreneurial practices, labour dynamics, and innovation strategy orie...
AI-driven innovation processes accelerated product development, improved operational efficiency, and supported experimentation, thereby strengthening entrepreneurial performance.
Survey data from 350 AI-adopting SMEs analyzed with regression and SEM showing positive associations between AI adoption and measures of product development speed, operational efficiency, experimentation, and overall entrepreneurial performance.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... product development speed, operational efficiency, experimentation capability, e...
AI facilitated labour substitution by automating repetitive tasks, allowing human resources to focus on creative and analytical roles.
Responses from the same sample (n=350) of AI-adopting SME entrepreneurs/managers; descriptive statistics and inferential analyses (regression/SEM) linking AI adoption to increased automation and role reallocation.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... labour substitution / automation of routine tasks and reallocation of human role...
AI adoption significantly enhanced opportunity recognition by enabling entrepreneurs to identify emerging market trends, assess risks, and make informed strategic decisions.
Quantitative survey of 350 entrepreneurs and managers of SMEs who had adopted AI; relationships tested using regression analysis and structural equation modelling (SEM) reported a significant positive effect of AI adoption on opportunity recognition.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... opportunity recognition (ability to identify market trends, assess risks, make s...
Sustainable human capital development requires coordinated interaction between education systems, employers, and public institutions.
Normative recommendation derived from the paper's systemic analysis and comparative review of institutional responses; no empirical policy evaluation or quantified cross-country causal analysis reported.
medium positive EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... sustainability of human capital development (systemic coordination effects)
Alignment of educational strategies with labor market dynamics is necessary to support effective reskilling and upskilling.
Supported by comparative assessment of international practices and systemic analysis linking education strategies to labor market requirements; evidence is analytical rather than experimental or longitudinally quantified in the paper.
medium positive EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... effectiveness of reskilling/upskilling and labor-market responsiveness
Effective reskilling and upskilling depend on the development of continuous learning ecosystems.
Analytical conclusion drawn from organizational learning models and international practice comparison; no controlled trials or quantitative evaluation of specific ecosystems reported.
medium positive EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... effectiveness of reskilling and upskilling programs
As technological change accelerates, the ability of individuals and organizations to adapt becomes a central condition of economic resilience and long-term competitiveness.
Analytical generalization from organizational learning models and systemic analysis of labor-market dynamics; supported by comparative observations but not by a reported empirical causal study.
medium positive EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... economic resilience and long-term competitiveness (as related to adaptive capaci...
New employment opportunities are emerging in AI-complementary occupations.
Findings from job-posting analyses and other empirical studies summarized in the paper that identify growth in AI-complementary job listings and roles (specific metrics not provided in excerpt).
medium positive The Impact of Generative AI on the Future of Employment: Opp... demand for AI-complementary occupations / job opportunities
Generative AI (GenAI), particularly tools such as ChatGPT and Gemini, has rapidly transformed the global technological landscape.
Qualitative/observational statement in paper citing the rapid public adoption of GenAI tools since late 2022; no specific empirical sample sizes reported in the text provided.
medium positive The Impact of Generative AI on the Future of Employment: Opp... technological landscape / adoption of GenAI tools
Vocational graduates who undergo strong work-based training demonstrate competitive and sometimes superior long-term employment trajectories compared with other pathways.
Comparative empirical studies and secondary analyses referenced in the paper that link work-based vocational training to favorable long-term outcomes (the summary does not provide exact studies, effect sizes, or sample sizes).
medium positive Balancing Higher Education, Vocational Training, and Lifelon... long-term employment trajectories for vocational graduates (career progression, ...
Higher education graduates generally experience favorable employment outcomes.
Synthesis of prior empirical studies and secondary labor-market indicators cited in the paper indicating better employment prospects for higher education graduates (no specific effect sizes or sample n given in the summary).
medium positive Balancing Higher Education, Vocational Training, and Lifelon... employment outcomes for higher education graduates (employment rates, job qualit...
There has been substantial growth in higher education attainment across the countries examined.
Descriptive results drawn from secondary data and comparative empirical studies documenting trends in higher education enrollment and attainment (paper does not report specific country list or sample sizes in the summary).
medium positive Balancing Higher Education, Vocational Training, and Lifelon... higher education attainment rates / enrollment growth
The findings provide practical guidance for entrepreneurs on building adaptive, AI-integrated organizations by redefining hiring, decision processes, and learning practices.
Prescriptive recommendations derived from the interview analysis and observed patterns in the sample of entrepreneurs (qualitative grounding; specific examples or measured impacts not provided in the excerpt).
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... recommended organizational practices (hiring, decision processes, learning pract...
Hybrid decision architectures have emerged: startup-specific configurations where algorithmic reasoning and human judgment recursively interact to shape decisions, roles and routines.
Thematic synthesis of interview data identifying recurring patterns of human–AI recursive interaction in decision-related practices across the studied startups (qualitative evidence; no quantitative counts reported).
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... composition and interaction patterns of decision-making architectures (human vs....
Entrepreneurs who founded startups after ChatGPT's release integrated AI into their post-release ventures.
Direct accounts from the subset of interviewees who founded startups after ChatGPT's release describing AI incorporation in those ventures (qualitative interview evidence; sample details not given).
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... presence/extent of AI integration in newly founded ventures
AI is becoming embedded in the architecture of startups rather than serving only as a task-automation tool.
Interview data and qualitative analysis identifying patterns of AI integration across startup roles, routines and structures (derived from the same semi-structured interview sample; exact N not provided).
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... degree and nature of AI integration into organizational architecture (roles, rou...
Facilitated access to AI following the release of ChatGPT is transforming how startups organize and make decisions.
Qualitative study using semi-structured interviews with entrepreneurs who founded startups both before and after ChatGPT's release and who integrated AI into their post-release ventures; thematic/qualitative analysis of interview data. (Sample size not reported in the provided excerpt.)
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... organizational structure and decision-making processes in startups
Perceived autonomy enhances the positive effect of perceived algorithmic standardized guidance on riders' outcomes (i.e., strengthens the beneficial impact on mental health and reduction in risky riding via work pressure).
Interaction/moderation effects tested via SEM on 466 Chinese food delivery riders; results reported that perceived autonomy amplifies the beneficial pathways from standardized guidance.
Perceived autonomy mitigates (buffers) the negative effect of perceived algorithmic tracking evaluation on risky riding behavior (i.e., reduces the tendency toward risky riding driven by tracking evaluation via work pressure).
Moderation analysis within SEM using sample of 466 Chinese delivery riders with bootstrapped tests for interaction effects between tracking evaluation and perceived autonomy.
Perceived autonomy mitigates (buffers) the negative effect of perceived algorithmic tracking evaluation on riders' outcomes (i.e., reduces the adverse impact on mental health and risky riding via work pressure).
Moderation tested in SEM on data from 466 Chinese food delivery riders; interaction effects reported indicating perceived autonomy weakens the negative pathways from tracking evaluation.
Perceived algorithmic standardized guidance improves food delivery riders' mental health by reducing work pressure.
466 Chinese food delivery riders; SEM and bootstrapping testing mediation (standardized guidance -> work pressure -> mental health) within JD-R framework.
Perceived algorithmic behavioral constraint promotes risky riding behavior among food delivery riders through increased work pressure.
Data from 466 Chinese food delivery riders; mediation tested using SEM and bootstrapping showing behavioral constraint -> work pressure -> risky riding behavior.
Perceived algorithmic tracking evaluation promotes risky riding behavior among food delivery riders through increased work pressure.
Survey data from 466 Chinese food delivery riders; SEM and bootstrapping used to test mediation (tracking evaluation -> work pressure -> risky riding behavior).
Algorithms now surpass human capability in processing speed, pattern recognition and data-driven decision-making.
Asserted in the paper's opening claims as a general factual premise; grounded in the paper's literature grounding but no original empirical tests or sample reported.
medium positive Deconstructing success: why being human still matters processing speed, pattern recognition capability, data-driven decision-making pe...
Research on large language models (LLMs) has increased especially after the release of ChatGPT.
Temporal/topic-prevalence analysis in the corpus indicating a rise in LLM-related topic weight following the ChatGPT release date.
medium positive Mapping the Landscape of the Economics of AI Literature: Gap... time-series change in share of papers on LLMs (increase in LLM-topic prevalence ...
There is significant research concentration on AI applications in supply chains, labor markets, and large language models (LLMs).
Topic-modeling results showing relatively high prevalence of topics labeled as supply chains, labor markets, and LLMs in the >4,600-paper corpus.
medium positive Mapping the Landscape of the Economics of AI Literature: Gap... prevalence (share or weight) of papers categorized under supply chains, labor ma...
Education, reskilling, and institutional responses are important in shaping the economic outcomes of artificial intelligence.
Policy implication derived from the observed/modeled heterogenous effects of AI on occupations and productivity; presented as a normative recommendation rather than an empirically tested result in the provided text.
medium positive Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... effectiveness of workforce policies as measured by post-intervention employment,...
Productivity gains associated with AI may support long-term economic growth.
Reference to productivity data and growth theory linking productivity improvements to long-run growth; the paper states this as a potential outcome but does not provide quantified long-run estimates or empirical identification in the excerpt.
medium positive Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... aggregate productivity (e.g., output per worker) and long-run GDP growth
AI complements higher-skill labor.
Interpretation of labor market data patterns and theoretical task-complementarity arguments presented in the paper; empirical details (which datasets, estimation strategy, sample size) are not provided in the text excerpt.
medium positive Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... employment levels, wages, or productivity of higher-skill workers
Artificial intelligence is a skill-biased technological innovation.
Framing and argumentation in the paper situating AI within the skill-biased technical change literature; references to analyses of publicly available labor market and productivity data (sources, time periods, and sample sizes not specified in the text).
medium positive Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... relative labor demand / wages by skill level (skilled vs. unskilled)