The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (2469 claims)

Adoption
5539 claims
Productivity
4793 claims
Governance
4333 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
3326 claims
Labor Markets
2657 claims
Innovation
2510 claims
Org Design
2469 claims
Skills & Training
2017 claims
Inequality
1378 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 402 112 67 480 1076
Governance & Regulation 402 192 122 62 790
Research Productivity 249 98 34 311 697
Organizational Efficiency 395 95 70 40 603
Technology Adoption Rate 321 126 73 39 564
Firm Productivity 306 39 70 12 432
Output Quality 256 66 25 28 375
AI Safety & Ethics 116 177 44 24 363
Market Structure 107 128 85 14 339
Decision Quality 177 76 38 20 315
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 89 58 33 22 209
Employment Level 77 34 80 9 202
Skill Acquisition 92 33 40 9 174
Innovation Output 120 12 23 12 168
Firm Revenue 98 34 22 154
Consumer Welfare 73 31 37 7 148
Task Allocation 84 16 33 7 140
Inequality Measures 25 77 32 5 139
Regulatory Compliance 54 63 13 3 133
Error Rate 44 51 6 101
Task Completion Time 88 5 4 3 100
Training Effectiveness 58 12 12 16 99
Worker Satisfaction 47 32 11 7 97
Wages & Compensation 53 15 20 5 93
Team Performance 47 12 15 7 82
Automation Exposure 24 22 9 6 62
Job Displacement 6 38 13 57
Hiring & Recruitment 41 4 6 3 54
Developer Productivity 34 4 3 1 42
Social Protection 22 10 6 2 40
Creative Output 16 7 5 1 29
Labor Share of Income 12 5 9 26
Skill Obsolescence 3 20 2 25
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Clear
Org Design Remove filter
Tasks that workers associate with a sense of agency or happiness may be disproportionately exposed to AI.
Empirical finding based on the paper's worker and developer surveys on 171 tasks, with LM scaling to 10,131 tasks; phrased cautiously in the paper as 'may be' disproportionately exposed.
medium negative Are We Automating the Joy Out of Work? Designing AI to Augme... association between task-level perceived meaningfulness dimensions (agency, happ...
There is a growing tension between relatively rigid education and training systems and the rapidly changing skill requirements of digitally driven labor markets.
Argument motivated and supported by comparative assessment of international practices and systemic analysis; descriptive/comparative evidence rather than quantified empirical testing.
medium negative EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... alignment between education/training systems and labor market skill requirements
Information saturation from AI output contributes to cognitive overload among employees.
Grounded in the paper's application of cognitive load theory to findings from surveys and organizational research; the excerpt gives no direct measures of information volume or its direct cognitive effects.
medium negative When AI Assistance Becomes Cognitive Overload: Understanding... information overload / cognitive load indicators
Extensive AI use correlates with measurable productivity losses.
Paper states this correlation is observed in organizational research and large-scale surveys; the excerpt lacks details on productivity measures, sample sizes, or statistical controls.
medium negative When AI Assistance Becomes Cognitive Overload: Understanding... productivity (organizational performance metrics or measured output)
Extensive AI use correlates with increased decision fatigue.
Reported correlation based on the same cited large-scale surveys and organizational research; no methodological details or effect sizes provided in the excerpt.
medium negative When AI Assistance Becomes Cognitive Overload: Understanding... decision fatigue (self-reported or performance-based decision metrics)
Extensive AI use correlates with increased turnover intention among employees.
Paper reports correlations observed in recent large-scale surveys and organizational research; the excerpt does not provide correlation coefficients, sample sizes, or control variables.
medium negative When AI Assistance Becomes Cognitive Overload: Understanding... turnover intention (self-reported intent to leave)
AI-augmented work environments create cognitive overload through information saturation, relentless task-switching, and the demanding oversight of multiple AI agents.
Synthesis in the paper drawing on research on human-AI collaboration and cognitive load theory and citing organizational research; specific empirical methods or sample sizes not provided in the excerpt.
medium negative When AI Assistance Becomes Cognitive Overload: Understanding... cognitive overload (e.g., measured cognitive load, information processing strain...
Employees using AI extensively report significant mental fatigue, dubbed 'AI brain fry.'
Stated in the paper as derived from recent large-scale surveys and organizational research; no specific sample size, survey instrument, or statistical details provided in the text excerpt.
medium negative When AI Assistance Becomes Cognitive Overload: Understanding... self-reported mental fatigue ("AI brain fry")
O SCF é expandido para uma camada de segunda ordem (SCF-E) que incorpora déficit de imaginação tecnocultural e governança simbólica, explicando por que a IA permanece em pilotos e não se converte em capacidade organizacional.
Extensão conceitual (segunda ordem) relatada no artigo; respaldada metodologicamente pela combinação QUAN→QUAL, incluindo etnografia orientada ao SCF (detalhes empíricos no corpo do artigo, não no resumo).
medium negative A FRICÇÃO PSICOANTROPOLÓGICA (SCF - Symbolic-Cognitive Frict... progressão de iniciativas de IA de pilotos para capacidade organizacional
A literatura de adoção tecnológica (TAM, UTAUT, Difusão de Inovações) tende a tratar a resistência como variável comportamental genérica ou deficiência de 'treinamento', negligenciando dimensões simbólicas (ritos, identidades e poder), mecanismos cognitivos de ameaça (aversão à perda, sobrecarga e heurísticas) e seus efeitos econômicos.
Revisão bibliográfica e posicionamento teórico declarado no artigo comparando modelos consagrados com a perspectiva proposta; sem indicação de meta-análise ou contagem empírica no resumo.
medium negative A FRICÇÃO PSICOANTROPOLÓGICA (SCF - Symbolic-Cognitive Frict... cobertura das dimensões simbólicas e cognitivas na literatura de adoção tecnológ...
A Fricção Psicoantropológica (SCF) é proposta e detalhada como um coeficiente mensurável do custo cultural e da resistência cognitiva que reduz a capacidade de pequenas e médias empresas (PMEs) de transformar iniciativas de Inteligência Artificial (IA) em geração de valor em escala.
Proposição teórica e operacionalização apresentada no artigo; desenho metodológico descrito como QUAN→QUAL incluindo construção de escala psicométrica e etnografia organizacional. O resumo não especifica tamanho de amostra para validação.
medium negative A FRICÇÃO PSICOANTROPOLÓGICA (SCF - Symbolic-Cognitive Frict... capacidade das PMEs de transformar iniciativas de IA em geração de valor em esca...
Over-reliance on data-driven insights without adequate human oversight can worsen market uncertainty.
Reported in the study's qualitative case studies and interpretive analysis as a potential negative consequence of improper AI/Big Data use (no quantified examples provided in the summary).
medium negative An Empirical Study on the Impact of the Integration of AI an... Increase in market uncertainty associated with reduced human oversight
Algorithmic bias is a potential pitfall of using AI and Big Data that can exacerbate market uncertainty.
Identified as a risk in the paper's qualitative analysis and discussion of pitfalls (no incident counts or empirical quantification provided in the summary).
medium negative An Empirical Study on the Impact of the Integration of AI an... Increase in market uncertainty (or risk) attributable to algorithmic bias
External pressures (e.g., pandemics, extreme weather, geopolitical conflicts) disproportionately affect peripheral suppliers in the construction supply chain network.
Mapping of challenge categories to network positions in the study showed external pressures concentrating at peripheral supplier nodes; based on interview reports and network coding (quantitative support not detailed in abstract).
medium negative Social-Network Analytics of Construction Supply Chain incidence of external-pressure-related challenges at peripheral supplier positio...
Relationship and contract issues accumulate at high-centrality brokers, which exhibit a reported degree centrality of 0.818.
Result reported in the paper linking the thematic category (relationship/contract issues) to network nodes identified as high-centrality brokers; a numeric degree centrality value (0.818) is reported for these brokers. Underlying network constructed from thematic coding of interviews; sample size not provided in abstract.
medium negative Social-Network Analytics of Construction Supply Chain prevalence of relationship/contract issues at nodes; degree centrality (0.818)
Six main challenge categories (comprising 16 open codes) concentrate systematically at specific network positions.
Results reported: thematic grouping produced six challenge categories and 16 open codes, and these were mapped to positions in the network showing systematic concentration; underlying data derive from coded interviews and network mapping (sample size not given in abstract).
medium negative Social-Network Analytics of Construction Supply Chain spatial concentration of challenge categories across network positions
Short-run labor market disruptions raise concerns regarding wage inequality and workforce adaptation.
Claims based on observed short-run labor market adjustments in publicly available data and theoretical implications for inequality and adaptation; specific empirical measures, time horizons, and sample sizes are not reported in the excerpt.
medium negative Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... wage inequality measures (e.g., wage dispersion) and indicators of workforce ada...
AI simultaneously increases adjustment pressures for routine tasks.
Argument and cited observations from publicly available labor market data indicating displacement or adjustment in routine-task-intensive occupations (no specific empirical estimates or samples provided).
medium negative Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... employment, job turnover, or earnings for routine-task workers
The Cautious are held in organizational stasis: without early adopter examples they don't enter the virtuous adoption cycle, never accumulate the usage frequency that drives intent, and never attain high efficacy.
Comparative analysis of archetype subgroups in the survey (N=147) showing the 'Cautious' group has lower reported usage frequency, lower intent to increase usage, and lower self-reported efficacy relative to 'Enthusiasts' and 'Pragmatists'.
medium negative Developers in the Age of AI: Adoption, Policy, and Diffusion... Usage frequency; intent to increase usage; self-reported efficacy
Adoption of AI testing tools lags that of coding tools, creating a 'Testing Gap'.
Within-sample comparison of reported adoption rates for coding-oriented AI tools versus testing-oriented AI tools among 147 developers, showing lower adoption for testing tools.
medium negative Developers in the Age of AI: Adoption, Policy, and Diffusion... Adoption rates of AI testing tools versus AI coding tools
Security concerns remain a moderate and statistically significant barrier to adoption.
Survey-derived security-concern metric (N=147) that shows a statistically significant negative association with future adoption intention (reported as moderate in effect size).
medium negative Developers in the Age of AI: Adoption, Policy, and Diffusion... Future intended adoption (intent to increase AI tool usage)
Traditional human resource management (HRM) approaches in hospitals rely on manual processes that are prone to errors, lack adaptability, and fail to adequately balance staff preferences with patient care requirements.
Background/positioning statement in the paper; asserted based on literature and authors' motivation for proposing an AI-driven framework (no specific dataset or quantitative analysis provided for this claim).
medium negative Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... quality/adaptability/error rate of HRM processes (qualitative)
Simulations project measurable reductions in defect rates under AI-HRM scenarios.
Regression-based simulations of the counterfactual model include defect reduction as an organizational outcome and project decreases in defect rates when HR processes are AI-supported.
medium negative Artificial Intelligence and Human Resource Management: A Cou... defect rate (number/proportion of defective outputs)
Simulations show notable reductions in absenteeism under the AI-HRM scenario.
Predictive estimation and regression-based simulations projecting absenteeism rates under counterfactual AI-supported HR processes using the industrial firm dataset.
AI integration into resort-to-force decision-making organizations raises important concerns.
Conceptual claim discussed by the author; the paper does not present empirical data, incident analyses, or quantified risk assessments supporting this claim within the provided excerpt.
medium negative AI governance for military decision-making: A proposal for m... risks/concerns associated with AI in force-decision processes
Governing the complexity introduced by military AI integration is urgent but currently lacks clear precedents.
Authorative claim grounded in argumentation and review-style reasoning; no systematic review or empirical mapping of precedents is provided in the text.
medium negative AI governance for military decision-making: A proposal for m... existence and adequacy of governance precedents for military AI
We can expect increased organizational complexity in military decision-making institutions as AI proliferates.
Theoretical inference presented by the author; no empirical methods or measurements (e.g., complexity metrics, case studies, or sample sizes) are reported.
medium negative AI governance for military decision-making: A proposal for m... organizational complexity in resort-to-force decision-making institutions
When positives are rare, the prevalence effect induces systematic cognitive biases that inflate misses and can propagate through the AI lifecycle via biased training labels.
Analysis of prior experimental evidence cited and discussed in the paper (literature review / synthesis). Specific prior studies and their methods are analyzed in the paper (sample sizes and individual study details not provided in the supplied excerpt).
medium negative Managing Cognitive Bias in Human Labeling Operations for Rar... miss rate (false negative rate) for rare positives; downstream bias in training ...
Many core university functions can now be achieved through AI-powered alternatives, potentially rendering conventional models obsolete for many learners.
Analytical assessment by the authors, without reported empirical testing or quantified methodology; based on review of AI capabilities and extrapolation.
medium negative Are Universities Becoming Obsolete in the Age of Artificial ... extent to which conventional university models remain necessary for learners (ob...
Universities' core value proposition is challenged and potentially displaced by AI technologies as they alter how knowledge is accessed, created, and validated.
Authors' analytical argument drawing on technological, economic, and social drivers; presented as synthesis rather than empirical proof (no sample size or empirical method reported).
medium negative Are Universities Becoming Obsolete in the Age of Artificial ... displacement risk of traditional university functions / core value proposition
Traditional IT service hiring will be displaced by expansion of product-focused roles and Global Capability Centres (GCCs).
Synthesis of industry reports and workforce data indicating shifts in hiring patterns; the abstract does not report sample sizes or exact metrics.
medium negative A Study on Hiring Trends In 2026 In India’s Information Tech... hiring volume/trends in traditional IT services versus product and GCC roles
Psychological barriers — specifically algorithm aversion, AI-induced job insecurity, technostress, and diminished occupational identity — impede effective AI integration across U.S. industries.
Literature synthesis of empirical and theoretical work in AI–HRM and organizational psychology cited in the paper (summary does not report primary-study sample sizes).
medium negative Developing Organizational Psychology Frameworks to Prepare t... effectiveness of AI integration (measured via impediments like algorithm aversio...
Workforce psychological readiness, rather than technological capability alone, constitutes the critical bottleneck in organizational AI adoption.
Synthesis of emerging empirical AI–HRM research and theoretical integration (paper reports 'findings' from this synthesis; no primary-sample-size details provided in the summary).
medium negative Developing Organizational Psychology Frameworks to Prepare t... AI adoption / implementation success (affected by psychological readiness)
The integration of AI into U.S. workplaces represents a profound organizational psychology challenge that extends well beyond mere technology adoption.
Conceptual/theoretical argument based on literature synthesis; draws on established theories (Technology Acceptance Model, Human–AI Symbiosis Theory, Job Demands–Resources Model, Organizational Trust Theory) and cited empirical AI–HRM studies (no specific sample sizes or primary data reported in the summary).
medium negative Developing Organizational Psychology Frameworks to Prepare t... organizational psychological readiness / complexity of organizational change ass...
What remains needed is rigorous advice to policymakers concerned about rapid increases in labor churn, scientific development, labor–capital shifts, or existential risk.
Normative conclusion drawn by the author from gaps identified in the seven-book review (qualitative assessment of unmet policy-relevant analysis); sample = 7 books.
medium negative The Economic Impacts of Artificial Intelligence: A Multidisc... availability of rigorous, actionable policy guidance addressing (a) labor churn,...
The reviewed works offer little guidance regarding the transformative scenarios considered plausible by many AI researchers.
Author's evaluative judgment based on the content and emphases of the seven books (qualitative gap analysis); sample = 7 books.
medium negative The Economic Impacts of Artificial Intelligence: A Multidisc... extent of guidance provided on transformative AI scenarios (e.g., rapid, large-s...
AI heightens job insecurity, particularly in organisations lacking structured reskilling programs.
Stated finding derived from the mixed-method study and Scopus database analysis; framed with a conditional modifier pointing to organisations without structured reskilling programs. (Summary does not provide sample size, effect sizes, or statistical significance.)
medium negative Artificial intelligence and organisational transformation: t... employee job insecurity
The stability and patience that define long-term investors can breed strategic inertia.
Introductory assertion in the paper (conceptual observation). The paper does not present empirical data or sample analysis to substantiate this causal claim in the provided excerpt.
medium negative Resilience Coefficient: Measuring the Strategic Adaptability... presence/degree of strategic inertia among long-term investors
Conventional thinking often frames AI uncritically as just a tool for efficiency, which is a narrow perspective that overlooks AI's transformative role.
Critical/theoretical argument presented in the paper (conceptual observation). No empirical data, sample, or statistical analysis reported to support this claim.
medium negative Resilience Coefficient: Measuring the Strategic Adaptability... conceptual framing of AI (efficiency-focused vs. transformative framing)
In abundant-resource conditions, emergent tribe formation slightly increases system overload (i.e., makes the near-zero overload slightly worse).
Empirical observations reported in the paper indicating a modest increase in overload when tribes form under abundant resources.
medium negative Increasing intelligence in AI agents can worsen collective o... system overload (slight increase attributable to tribe formation in abundance)
When resources are scarce, AI model diversity and reinforcement learning increase dangerous system overload.
Empirical results from the paper's AI-agent population experiments (simulations/real-agent trials) combined with mathematical analysis indicating increased overload under scarcity when model diversity and individual RL are present.
medium negative Increasing intelligence in AI agents can worsen collective o... system overload (frequency/severity of dangerous overload events)
Combined analysis using Fuzzy PROMETHEE II and DEMATEL identifies High Initial Investment and Supply Chain Integration as critical barriers and dominant causal drivers that influence other dependent barriers.
Findings come from the integrated PROMETHEE II ranking and DEMATEL causal-mapping analyses based on expert input and literature review; detailed sample size and numerical results not provided in the summary.
medium negative Evaluating Critical Barriers to Industry 4.0 Adoption in the... criticality (priority) and causal influence of barriers on other barriers
There are challenges to adopting AI in HRM within IT firms.
Identified through the literature review and the empirical study involving HR professionals; the summary notes challenges but does not enumerate or quantify them.
medium negative AI-Driven Decision Making and Digital Recruitment: Transform... barriers to AI adoption in HR (e.g., implementation, skills, privacy — not speci...
We lack frameworks for articulating how cultural outputs might be actively beneficial.
Authors' identification of a gap in evaluation theory and practice (conceptual analysis); no systematic literature review details provided in the excerpt.
medium negative AI as Entertainment existence/availability of evaluative frameworks that characterize positive cultu...
Current AI evaluation practices show a critical asymmetry: while AI assessments rigorously measure both benefits and harms of intelligence, they focus almost exclusively on cultural harms.
Authors' review/ critique of existing evaluation frameworks and metrics (qualitative analysis in the paper); the excerpt does not list the reviewed studies or their number.
medium negative AI as Entertainment scope and balance of AI assessment metrics (coverage of benefits vs cultural har...
The field of AI is unprepared to measure or respond to how the proliferation of entertaining AI-generated content will impact society.
Authors' assessment of current evaluation practices and frameworks (qualitative analysis presented in the paper); no empirical metrics or sample sizes provided in the excerpt.
medium negative AI as Entertainment readiness/preparedness of AI research and evaluation frameworks to assess societ...
Current literature has primarily focused on automation-based views of decision support and lacks insight into systematic human–AI coordination aided by analytics.
Literature review and conceptual critique within the paper. No systematic mapping study or bibliometric counts reported.
medium negative Designing Human–AI Collaborative Decision Analytics Framewor... coverage of topics in AI decision-support literature (automation-centric vs. hum...
Most organizations have difficulties converting algorithmic results into sustainable managerial decisions due to low levels of trust, lack of explanation, and poor integration between AI systems and human judgment.
Synthesis of existing literature presented in the conceptual paper (literature review). No empirical study or sample provided to quantify 'most organizations.'
medium negative Designing Human–AI Collaborative Decision Analytics Framewor... conversion of algorithmic outputs into sustainable managerial decisions; trust; ...
AI adoption has augmented complexity, uncertainty in decision-making, and accountability stresses for managers.
Claim supported by conceptual argument and literature integration (qualitative synthesis). No empirical sample size or quantitative testing reported.
medium negative Designing Human–AI Collaborative Decision Analytics Framewor... decision complexity, decision uncertainty, accountability stresses
Traditional methods for assessing and developing employees' skills often fail to provide real-time feedback.
Statement supported by literature review cited by the authors; the abstract does not provide empirical comparisons, metrics, or sample sizes.
medium negative GenAI Role in Redefining Learning and Skilling in Companies timeliness of feedback in employee skill assessment (real-time vs. delayed)