The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (3470 claims)

Adoption
7395 claims
Productivity
6507 claims
Governance
5877 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
5157 claims
Innovation
3492 claims
Org Design
3470 claims
Labor Markets
3224 claims
Skills & Training
2608 claims
Inequality
1835 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 609 159 77 736 1615
Governance & Regulation 664 329 160 99 1273
Organizational Efficiency 624 143 105 70 949
Technology Adoption Rate 502 176 98 78 861
Research Productivity 348 109 48 322 836
Output Quality 391 120 44 40 595
Firm Productivity 385 46 85 17 539
Decision Quality 275 143 62 34 521
AI Safety & Ethics 183 241 59 30 517
Market Structure 152 154 109 20 440
Task Allocation 158 50 56 26 295
Innovation Output 178 23 38 17 257
Skill Acquisition 137 52 50 13 252
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 120 64 38 23 252
Employment Level 93 46 96 12 249
Firm Revenue 130 43 26 3 202
Consumer Welfare 99 51 40 11 201
Inequality Measures 36 105 40 6 187
Task Completion Time 134 18 6 5 163
Worker Satisfaction 79 54 16 11 160
Error Rate 64 78 8 1 151
Regulatory Compliance 69 64 14 3 150
Training Effectiveness 81 15 13 18 129
Wages & Compensation 70 25 22 6 123
Team Performance 74 16 21 9 121
Automation Exposure 41 48 19 9 120
Job Displacement 11 71 16 1 99
Developer Productivity 71 14 9 3 98
Hiring & Recruitment 49 7 8 3 67
Social Protection 26 14 8 2 50
Creative Output 26 14 6 2 49
Skill Obsolescence 5 37 5 1 48
Labor Share of Income 12 13 12 37
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Org Design Remove filter
Autonomy is characterised through a four-dimensional information-theoretic profile (epistemic, executive, evaluative, social).
Paper defines autonomy as a 4-dimensional information-theoretic profile (conceptual/mathematical definition within the formal model).
high neutral The Accountability Horizon: An Impossibility Theorem for Gov... measure/characterisation of agent autonomy
A life insurance system integrated into an industry partner mobile app was tested in two experiments.
Paper reports two experiments running the ARQuest-enabled life insurance system inside a partner mobile app; experimental setup is stated though sample sizes are not provided in the excerpt.
high neutral AI in Insurance: Adaptive Questionnaires for Improved Risk P... experimental evaluation of system in partner app
The paper's formalism shows that prompt/system messages shape distributions over possible execution paths (indirect control) but do not evaluate actual partial paths at runtime.
Formal mapping in the paper that treats prompts as shaping prior over paths; conceptual argument and illustrative examples.
high neutral Runtime Governance for AI Agents: Policies on Paths degree of control over execution path (distributional shaping vs. path-specific ...
Through a thematic review of existing research, the authors identified recurring themes about incentive schemes: their components, how researchers manipulate them, and their impact on research outcomes.
Authors' stated method and findings: thematic review (the scope/number of reviewed papers not specified in excerpt).
high neutral Incentive-Tuning: Understanding and Designing Incentives for... themes in incentive design practices and reported impacts on empirical study out...
A critical aspect of conducting human–AI decision-making studies is the role of participants, often recruited through crowdsourcing platforms.
Claim based on the authors' thematic literature review noting participant sourcing practices (specific studies and counts not given in excerpt).
high neutral Incentive-Tuning: Understanding and Designing Incentives for... participant recruitment source (e.g., crowdsourcing) and its influence on study ...
Researchers conduct empirical studies investigating how humans use AI assistance for decision-making and how this collaboration impacts results.
Statement summarizing the research landscape; supported implicitly by the authors' thematic review of existing empirical studies (number of studies not specified in excerpt).
high neutral Incentive-Tuning: Understanding and Designing Incentives for... human behaviour and decision outcomes when assisted by AI (empirical study outco...
Returns to AI are heterogeneous across firms; estimating treatment effects requires attention to selection, complementarities, and dynamic adoption pipelines.
Methodological argument referencing treatment-effect literature and observed firm heterogeneity; supported by conceptual examples rather than a single empirical treatment-effect estimate.
high neutral Modern Management in the Age of Artificial Intelligence: Str... heterogeneity in returns to AI adoption (firm-level productivity or performance ...
Sources were selected purposively through explicit inclusion and exclusion criteria tied to conceptual relevance, scholarly quality, and direct contribution to framework building; higher-order categories were retained only after iterative comparison across the four literature streams.
Author-reported sampling and analytic procedure for the integrative review.
high null result RegTech-enabled governance of sanctions-safe enterprise ecos... review source selection and analytic procedure
Methodologically, the paper uses a structured integrative review combined with interpretive theory synthesis to connect literature on RegTech, sanctions compliance, institutional voids, supply chain governance, and algorithmic accountability.
Explicit methodological description in the paper (authors' stated approach).
high null result RegTech-enabled governance of sanctions-safe enterprise ecos... methodological approach used
Existing studies on regulatory technology mainly present it as a firm-level compliance tool, giving little attention to its role in shaping coordination across wider enterprise ecosystems in post-conflict and sanctions-affected settings.
Review finding based on purposive selection and comparison of literature on RegTech and related fields (method: structured integrative review and interpretive theory synthesis).
high null result RegTech-enabled governance of sanctions-safe enterprise ecos... scope of RegTech literature (firm-level focus vs ecosystem coordination)
AI deployment has limited effects on retrial rates.
Same randomized field experiment; retrial rates (repeat customer contacts) were measured and reported as showing limited/no substantive change under AI deployment.
high null result Agentic AI and Human-in-the-Loop Interventions: Field Experi... retrial rates (repeat contact rate)
Five structural characteristics define the Metis AI zone: consequential irreversibility, relational irreducibility, normative open texture, adversarial co-evolution, and accountability anchoring.
Theoretical specification and definition of five characteristics grounded in social science, philosophy, and humanitarian practice; no empirical prevalence or measurement reported.
high null result Metis AI: The Overlooked Middle Zone Between AI-Native and W... defining properties of Metis tasks
The dominant discourse on AI limitations frames the boundary of AI capability as a divide between digital tasks (where AI excels) and physical tasks (where embodiment is required).
Statement in paper framing prevailing discourse; conceptual observation rather than empirical test (literature critique). No sample size reported.
high null result Metis AI: The Overlooked Middle Zone Between AI-Native and W... framing of AI capability boundary
The study used a qualitative interpretivist research design drawing on semistructured interviews with 28 managers and professionals from 12 organizations across technology, finance and knowledge-intensive service sectors in Europe and Asia, using thematic and interpretive analysis supported by organizational document review.
Methodology statement from the paper (explicit description of sample, sectors, regions and analytic approach).
high null result Reimagining work in the age of intelligent automation: a qua... research design and sample characteristics
AI should be conceptualized as a co-evolving organizational capability rather than a deterministic technology.
Argument developed from interpretive analysis of interview data (n=28), literature engagement and organizational document review.
high null result Reimagining work in the age of intelligent automation: a qua... conceptual framing of AI within organizations
The study develops an emergent framework of AI–human co-adaptation comprising three interrelated dimensions: technological alignment, cognitive calibration and ethical anchoring.
Framework derived from thematic/interpretive analysis of interview data (n=28) and supporting organizational documents.
high null result Reimagining work in the age of intelligent automation: a qua... dimensions of AI–human co-adaptation
The paper introduces the concept of 'augmented work agency' as a multi-level, interpretive form of human agency in algorithmically mediated environments.
Conceptual development within the paper grounded in literature review and qualitative interview data (28 participants) and organizational document review.
high null result Reimagining work in the age of intelligent automation: a qua... agency, control and coordination in algorithmic workplaces
The analysis proceeded through within-case coding and cross-case pattern matching across five dimensions: intelligence source, AI mechanism, decision domain, economic implication, and boundary condition.
Method section describing coding and analytical procedures applied to the archival corpus across the four cases.
high null result Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... analytic method (coding and cross-case pattern matching across specified dimensi...
The empirical corpus comprises annual reports, 10-K filings, earnings releases, and official corporate materials published mainly between 2024 and 2026, complemented by recent peer-reviewed literature.
Paper's data description listing document types and time window for archival evidence; number of documents not enumerated.
high null result Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... composition and timeframe of empirical corpus (document types and years)
The study adopts a qualitative comparative multiple-case design using four theoretically sampled cases: Walmart, Unilever, Sprinklr, and DoubleVerify.
Methodological statement in the paper describing case selection and study design.
high null result Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... study design and sample (case selection)
The dominant paradigm for AI agents is an "on-the-fly" loop in which agents synthesize plans and execute actions within seconds or minutes in response to user prompts.
Statement in paper presenting a characterization of current AI agent design; conceptual/observational claim with no empirical data or sample reported.
We thematically analysed twelve semi-structured interviews with SME owners and managers conducted in early 2025 using Atlas.ti, yielding 19 codes grouped into six categories.
Methods statement in the paper describing qualitative sample and analysis procedures.
high null result Artificial Intelligence, Social Capital, and Sustainable Emp... qualitative_analysis_results (codes/categories)
We examine the interplay between AI adoption, social capital formation, workforce dynamics, and sustainable development in Eastern Macedonia and Thrace (EMT), one of the EU's least developed regions.
Study context and scope as stated in the paper; empirical work conducted in EMT.
high null result Artificial Intelligence, Social Capital, and Sustainable Emp... regional_AI_adoption_and_social_capital_interplay
Research has concentrated on advanced urban economies, leaving the implications of AI for peripheral small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) operating under weak human capital, thin digital infrastructure, and constrained social capital — underexplored.
Statement in the paper contrasting existing research focus (advanced urban economies) with a lack of attention to peripheral SMEs; no empirical sample size for this bibliographic claim reported in the excerpt.
high null result Artificial Intelligence, Social Capital, and Sustainable Emp... research_coverage_of_peripheral_SMEs
Under the Brier score specifically, with type-independent inflation cost, the second-best welfare equals the first-best welfare (welfare equivalence).
Analytical result/proof specialized to the Brier score and the assumption of type-independent inflation costs; comparative welfare analysis in the model.
high null result The Endogeneity of Miscalibration: Impossibility and Escape ... principal welfare (second-best vs. first-best) under Brier scoring and type-inde...
The synthesis covers research and practitioner guidance from the years 2023–2025.
Methods statement specifying the temporal scope of sources used for the synthesis.
This paper synthesizes recent research and practitioner guidance (2023–2025) to develop a practical model for designing human–AI collaboration in the financial reporting function (controllership).
Methods section declaration describing scope and approach (literature/practitioner guidance synthesis covering 2023–2025).
high null result Collaborative Intelligence in Accounting: A Human + AI Compl... organizational_efficiency
We conducted a controlled experiment comparing traditional task-splitting methods with AI-assisted approaches using GitLab Duo.
Methodological statement in the paper reporting a controlled experiment using GitLab Duo; sample size not stated in the provided summary.
high null result Splitting User Stories Into Tasks with AI -- A Foe or an All... method comparison (experimental design)
The study uses a panel dataset of 35,347 firm-year observations from 2010 to 2023.
Reported sample description in the paper: panel dataset covering 2010–2023 with 35,347 firm-year observations.
high null result When AI Amplifies Negative Echoes: CEO–TMT Faultlines, Eco-A... N/A (sample description)
This paper focuses on five research questions about the historical pathways, leverage points, trajectory differences, alternative projects, and socio-technical programmes related to current dominant generative AI tools and possible AGI-adjacent development.
Explicit listing of the five research questions in the paper's introduction/aims; statement of scope and focus.
high null result Pathways to AGI research_focus
Data analysis utilized regression modeling for performance correlations, time-series analysis for predictive maintenance patterns, and thematic analysis for qualitative interviews.
Paper methods: explicit listing of analytic techniques used (regression, time-series, thematic analysis).
high null result Green Supply Chain Optimization: AI and IoT for Ethical Reso... analytical methods applied
Secondary data encompasses sustainability reports, carbon footprint assessments, and operational performance metrics.
Paper methods: explicit listing of secondary data sources (sustainability reports, carbon footprint assessments, operational metrics).
high null result Green Supply Chain Optimization: AI and IoT for Ethical Reso... types of secondary data used
Blockchain transaction records spanning eighteen months across Nigeria were used as primary data.
Paper methods: explicit statement about 18 months of blockchain transaction records across Nigeria.
high null result Green Supply Chain Optimization: AI and IoT for Ethical Reso... blockchain transaction record timespan
The study uses IoT sensor data from forty-five facilities.
Paper methods: explicit statement that IoT sensor data were collected from 45 facilities.
high null result Green Supply Chain Optimization: AI and IoT for Ethical Reso... IoT sensor data coverage (facility count)
Primary data collection includes structured interviews with supply chain managers.
Paper methods section: primary data described as including structured interviews with supply chain managers (number of interviewees not specified).
high null result Green Supply Chain Optimization: AI and IoT for Ethical Reso... qualitative interview data from supply chain managers
The study uses mixed methods involving case studies from twelve multinational companies across the manufacturing, logistics, and retail sectors.
Paper statement of methods: explicit mention of mixed methods and case studies from 12 multinational companies across the three sectors.
high null result Green Supply Chain Optimization: AI and IoT for Ethical Reso... study sample composition (case study count and sectors)
For over a century, the electric grid has relied on a single statistical assumption: load diversity, the principle that the uncorrelated demands of millions of small consumers produce a smooth, predictable aggregate.
Statement and historical framing presented by the paper as background context; no empirical time series or citations provided in the excerpt.
high null result From Barrier to Bridge: The Case for AI Data Center/Power Gr... aggregate load smoothness / predictability
The study constructs a tripartite evolutionary game framework composed of government regulators, leading computing power incumbents, and downstream AI innovators to analyze strategic interactions and derive evolutionarily stable strategies.
Methodological claim documented in the paper describing the model structure and analytic approach (method: formal model specification and ESS derivation).
high null result Evolutionary Dynamics of Openness, Dependence, and Regulatio... model structure (composition and methodological approach)
The paper evaluates 'Spec Kit' and 'TDAD' as instantiations of the SGM via a four-month pilot study.
Empirical pilot evaluation reported in the paper; duration specified as four months. Sample size or number of teams/participants in pilot not specified in the summary.
high null result The Productivity-Reliability Paradox: Specification-Driven G... evaluation of SGM instantiations (Spec Kit, TDAD) over four months
The paper identifies two amplifying mechanisms for PRP: the code review bottleneck and the context window constraint.
Theoretical argumentation in the paper naming two mechanisms that amplify the PRP phenomenon (qualitative explanation).
high null result The Productivity-Reliability Paradox: Specification-Driven G... mechanisms amplifying productivity-reliability trade-off
The paper formally defines PRP with three moderating variables: task abstraction, codebase maturity, and developer experience.
Theoretical/formal definition presented in the paper identifying three moderators; claim is descriptive of the paper's conceptual model.
high null result The Productivity-Reliability Paradox: Specification-Driven G... presence/definition of moderating variables for PRP
This paper conducted a multivocal literature review of 67 sources spanning 2022–2026.
Statement of method in the paper describing the literature review (count of sources = 67).
high null result The Productivity-Reliability Paradox: Specification-Driven G... study corpus size (number of sources reviewed)
Telemetry across 10,000+ developers shows flat delivery metrics (no improvement in delivery outcomes) despite changes in PR and review behavior.
Observational telemetry across >10,000 developers reported in the paper; described result is no meaningful change in delivery metrics (e.g., delivery throughput, lead time) despite increases in PRs and longer reviews.
high null result The Productivity-Reliability Paradox: Specification-Driven G... delivery metrics (throughput/lead time)
A qualitative design was adopted, drawing on 34 semi-structured interviews with project managers across five UK industries.
Qualitative study methods reported in the paper: 34 semi-structured interviews with project managers sampled across five UK industries; Gioia-informed thematic analysis.
high null result E-leadership and human-AI collaboration: socio-technical ali... study_design_and_sample
The literature review employs the PRISMA model to screen, identify, and synthesize available literature on AI, Machine Learning and Deep Learning in promoting managerial productivity and task efficiency.
Methodological statement in the paper's abstract (explicitly states use of PRISMA for screening and synthesis).
high null result Artificial intelligence, machine learning, and deep learning... literature search and synthesis method (PRISMA use)
The paper traces near-term evolutionary trajectories for digital proto-life through three narratives: Lamarck (self-modifying coding agents), Remora (resource-seeking companion chatbots), and Mycelium (DAO-LLC trading bots).
Methodological statement in the abstract: exploratory scenario method with three specified narrative scenarios; descriptive rather than empirical.
high null result Digital Darwinism: steering the evolution of artificial life... narrative scenarios produced (Lamarck, Remora, Mycelium)
The paper develops a typology of enterprise applications by their sensitivity to AI-induced shifts in make-or-buy economics.
Paper's stated contribution (conceptual typology based on analysis of application categories and AI sensitivity).
high null result The Buy-or-Build Decision, Revisited: How Agentic AI Changes... classification (typology) of enterprise applications by sensitivity to AI
This paper adopts a conceptual research approach, combining transaction cost economics and the resource-based view with an assessment of current AI capabilities, to systematically re-evaluate the factors underlying the make-or-buy decision.
Paper's stated methodology and theoretical framing (methodological claim about the paper itself).
high null result The Buy-or-Build Decision, Revisited: How Agentic AI Changes... methodological approach to studying make-or-buy decisions
At this stage, AI adoption in Israel does not result in widespread layoffs; its primary impact lies in restructuring the labor market through a slowdown in recruitment, changes in job composition, and the emergence of new AI-related roles.
Empirical claim reported in the paper; the excerpt does not specify datasets, time periods, or sample sizes supporting this observation.
high null result Artificial Intelligence in Israel, Trends, Developments, and... employment changes attributable to AI adoption (layoffs, recruitment rates, job ...
The analysis employs rigorous econometric methods including difference-in-differences estimation and propensity score matching to control for confounding variables across industry (NAICS 2-digit), firm size, geographic location, occupation-level characteristics, and macroeconomic conditions.
Methodological description in the paper specifying DiD and propensity score matching and listed covariates/controls.
high null result The Generative AI Revolution: Early Evidence of Structural T... methodological controls / identification strategy