The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (13661 claims)

Adoption
8339 claims
Productivity
7479 claims
Governance
6715 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6267 claims
Org Design
4098 claims
Innovation
3987 claims
Labor Markets
3488 claims
Skills & Training
2888 claims
Inequality
2016 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 740 192 95 871 1945
Governance & Regulation 796 388 185 119 1512
Organizational Efficiency 765 186 123 82 1166
Technology Adoption Rate 610 227 121 95 1061
Research Productivity 409 121 56 331 928
Output Quality 464 174 58 47 743
Decision Quality 318 173 75 42 615
Firm Productivity 432 55 88 20 601
AI Safety & Ethics 214 273 65 33 589
Market Structure 175 165 120 24 489
Task Allocation 206 64 70 31 376
Skill Acquisition 161 57 57 16 291
Innovation Output 201 27 41 18 288
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 130 69 43 26 275
Employment Level 104 50 105 13 274
Consumer Welfare 116 62 42 11 231
Firm Revenue 149 45 26 3 223
Inequality Measures 43 120 49 6 218
Task Completion Time 164 29 8 12 214
Worker Satisfaction 89 60 20 12 181
Error Rate 69 89 9 2 169
Regulatory Compliance 74 67 14 4 159
Training Effectiveness 91 19 13 19 144
Wages & Compensation 77 33 25 6 141
Team Performance 86 17 27 9 140
Automation Exposure 49 50 22 12 136
Developer Productivity 91 17 14 5 128
Job Displacement 12 80 19 1 112
Hiring & Recruitment 51 7 8 3 69
Creative Output 31 16 7 2 57
Skill Obsolescence 5 43 6 1 55
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 17 17 51
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
We introduce Synthetic Computers at Scale, a scalable methodology for creating such environments with realistic folder hierarchies and content-rich artifacts (e.g., documents, spreadsheets, and presentations).
Methodological description and implementation presented in the paper (design and procedures for generating synthetic computers and artifact types).
high positive Synthetic Computers at Scale for Long-Horizon Productivity S... creation of synthetic computer environments with realistic folder hierarchies an...
This work offers a principled foundation for autonomous AI agents that govern themselves the way humans do: not because rules are imposed upon them, but because deliberation is embedded in how they think.
Concluding claim summarizing the proposed framework's conceptual contribution (theoretical/architectural claim; not an empirical measurement).
high positive Think Before You Act -- A Neurocognitive Governance Model fo... internalized deliberative governance in autonomous agents
Implemented on a production-grade retail supply chain workflow, the framework produces zero false escalations to human oversight.
Empirical implementation on a production-grade retail supply chain workflow reported in the paper (claim stated without sample size or measurement protocol in the abstract).
high positive Think Before You Act -- A Neurocognitive Governance Model fo... false escalations to human oversight
Implemented on a production-grade retail supply chain workflow, the framework achieves 95% compliance accuracy.
Empirical implementation on a production-grade retail supply chain workflow reported in the paper (no sample size or evaluation details provided in the abstract).
We formalize a Pre-Action Governance Reasoning Loop (PAGRL) in which agents consult a four-layer governance rule set: global, workflow-specific, agent-specific, and situational before every consequential action.
Methodological contribution described in the paper (formalization of a governance loop and four-layer rule hierarchy; no numerical sample given in the abstract).
high positive Think Before You Act -- A Neurocognitive Governance Model fo... use of a four-layer rule consultation prior to consequential actions
We propose a neurocognitive governance framework that formally maps this human self-governance process to LLM-driven agent reasoning, establishing a structural parallel between the human brain and the large language model as the cognitive core of an agent.
Theoretical framework and formal mapping presented in the paper (design/proposal rather than empirical validation).
high positive Think Before You Act -- A Neurocognitive Governance Model fo... alignment of agent reasoning structure with human self-governance (conceptual ma...
Before acting, humans engage deliberate cognitive processes grounded in executive function, inhibitory control, and internalized organizational rules to evaluate whether an intended action is permissible, requires modification, or demands escalation.
The paper's framing draws on cognitive/neurocognitive literature about human self-governance (presented as background/theoretical justification; no new empirical human-subject data reported in the abstract).
high positive Think Before You Act -- A Neurocognitive Governance Model fo... human pre-action deliberative cognitive processes (executive function, inhibitor...
The review ends with policy recommendations to address barriers and to facilitate increased public–private partnership (PPP) aimed at increasing health access in India.
Statement in the paper summarizing its policy recommendations; based on authors' synthesis of reviewed literature and conclusions.
high positive A Comprehensive Review of Technology Adoption and Its Impact... policy measures to increase health access via PPP
AI, Blockchain, and 5G have great potential for transforming healthcare in India.
Forward-looking claim in the review summarizing technological potential as reported in the literature; presented as potential rather than demonstrated effect (no empirical effect sizes given).
high positive A Comprehensive Review of Technology Adoption and Its Impact... transformative potential of AI/Blockchain/5G for healthcare
These technologies can optimize workforce output in constrained healthcare contexts.
Review assertion synthesizing qualitative and quantitative literature describing impacts on workforce productivity/output; no specific sample size reported in excerpt.
high positive A Comprehensive Review of Technology Adoption and Its Impact... workforce output / productivity
These technologies can increase clinical effectiveness.
Claimed potential in the review based on prior studies (synthesis of evidence; no single quantified trial/sample provided in excerpt).
These technologies can be used to enhance operational effectiveness in healthcare organisations operating under severe constraints.
Review claims and discussion of use-cases/ways technologies may improve operations; based on synthesis of qualitative and quantitative studies (no single trial/sample reported).
high positive A Comprehensive Review of Technology Adoption and Its Impact... operational effectiveness
Healthcare technology is considered a key organizational-efficiency enhancer, particularly in traditional [healthcare] settings addressing escalating health needs.
Synthesis statement from the review summarizing prior papers that view technology as improving organizational efficiency in traditional settings; method = literature review (qualitative/quantitative studies synthesis).
high positive A Comprehensive Review of Technology Adoption and Its Impact... organizational efficiency in traditional healthcare settings
India has a vast population, meaning a vast market for healthcare technology adoption.
Statement in paper's introduction/abstract asserting India's large population makes it a large market; based on literature review/contextual framing (no primary sample size reported).
high positive A Comprehensive Review of Technology Adoption and Its Impact... market for healthcare technology adoption
The capacity to create, maintain, and control digital agents becomes a new axis of international inequality, potentially devaluing the demographic dividend of developing countries and revising the logic of comparative advantages.
Geoeconomic theoretical analysis in the paper; no cross-country empirical analysis demonstrating changed comparative advantages presented.
high positive DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... international inequality and relative value of demographic dividend
The institutional architecture of modern societies (pension systems, taxation models, etc.) is built on assumptions that are systematically undermined by the rise of an agentic economy, necessitating a revision of fiscal and social models, including discrete taxation of algorithmic employment.
Normative and theoretical analysis linking institutional assumptions to agentic economy dynamics; no empirical policy evaluation or fiscal simulation results reported.
high positive DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... need for revision of fiscal/social policy (e.g., taxation of algorithmic employm...
The agent energy profile (AEP) is introduced as a measure of annual energy consumption per unit of cFTE, allowing energy-based comparisons between algorithmic and human cognitive labour.
Methodological/conceptual proposal in the paper; no empirical measurements or energy accounting dataset provided.
high positive DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... annual energy consumption per cFTE
The paper proposes a quantitative identification of algorithmic agents via the category of cognitive full-time equivalent (cFTE), enabling comparison of algorithmic and human productivity within a unified analytical framework.
Methodological proposal (definition and proposed use of cFTE) presented in the paper; no empirical validation or implementation sample reported.
high positive DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... comparability of algorithmic vs human productivity (via cFTE)
The ontological status of technology is transforming from a productivity-enhancing tool to an autonomous participant in economic processes, forming a hybrid factor of production that combines characteristics of both capital and labour.
Theoretical analysis and conceptual framing in the paper; no empirical factor decomposition or production-function estimation provided.
high positive DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... role of technology as a factor of production (hybrid capital-labour)
Institutionalising digital agent registration could transform 'shadow demographics' into formal 'algorithmic demographics'.
Policy/theoretical proposition in the paper (institutionalisation as a mechanism); no empirical pilot or legal implementation evidence reported.
high positive DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... institutional recognition/registering of digital agents (creation of algorithmic...
The concept of 'shadow demographics' describes a growing algorithmic population that expands in parallel with the stagnation or decline of the human population.
Conceptual definition and theorised dynamics in the paper; no empirical counts or longitudinal measurements of algorithmic population provided.
high positive DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... relative size/trend of algorithmic population vs human population
The expanding role of digital agents in production and market processes creates the preconditions for a gradual decoupling of demographic dynamics from economic growth.
Argumentative/theoretical exposition in the paper; no empirical panel or cross-country time-series evidence reported in the text provided.
high positive DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... degree of coupling between demographic dynamics and economic growth
AI-based digital agents can be interpreted as functional equivalents of economic actors.
Theoretical and conceptual argument presented in the paper (conceptual interpretation; no empirical sample or quantitative validation reported).
high positive DIGITAL AGENTS AS FUNCTIONAL EQUIVALENTS OF ECONOMIC ACTORS:... status/role of digital agents as economic actors
The authors conclude that these findings have implications for responsible and perceptible genAI use in hiring contexts.
Authors' conclusions/recommendations based on the interview findings and analysis.
high positive Resume-ing Control: (Mis)Perceptions of Agency Around GenAI ... need for responsible/perceptible genAI adoption practices
Participants reported only marginal efficiency gains from genAI despite a seemingly seismic shift in how recruiting happens.
Self-reports from 22 interviewed recruiting professionals indicating small/marginal efficiency improvements.
high positive Resume-ing Control: (Mis)Perceptions of Agency Around GenAI ... efficiency gains / task completion efficiency
Individual recruiters also felt compelled to adopt genAI because of the personal need to boost productivity.
Qualitative interview responses (n=22) reporting individual-level productivity motivations for using genAI.
high positive Resume-ing Control: (Mis)Perceptions of Agency Around GenAI ... self-reported motivation to adopt for productivity gains
Recruiters often felt compelled to adopt genAI to combat applicant use of AI.
Interview data from 22 recruiting professionals reporting adoption motivations tied to applicants' AI use.
high positive Resume-ing Control: (Mis)Perceptions of Agency Around GenAI ... motivation for adoption related to applicant behavior
When generative AI (genAI) systems are used in high-stakes decision-making, its recommended role is to aid, rather than replace, human decision-making.
Normative statement presented in the paper (literature/theoretical recommendation), no empirical data reported to support this recommendation within the study.
high positive Resume-ing Control: (Mis)Perceptions of Agency Around GenAI ... recommended role of genAI in decision-making (augmentation vs. replacement)
These findings have important implications for website visibility, the effectiveness of generative engine optimization techniques, and the information users receive; we call for revenue frameworks to foster a sustainable and mutually beneficial ecosystem for publishers and generative search providers.
Synthesis and recommendations based on the empirical findings above (differences in retrieval, crawler-blocking effects, AIO prevalence and stability) leading to policy/revenue recommendation.
high positive How Generative AI Disrupts Search: An Empirical Study of Goo... policy recommendation for revenue frameworks / publisher sustainability
Generative search engines are significantly more likely to retrieve Google-owned content.
Domain/source analysis across the benchmark showing generative outputs (AIO/Gemini) include a higher share of Google-owned domains/content than traditional search results.
high positive How Generative AI Disrupts Search: An Empirical Study of Goo... proportion of results that are Google-owned content
Traditional Google search is significantly more likely to retrieve information from popular or institutional websites in government or education.
Domain classification of results returned by traditional Google search across the benchmark (11,500 queries) showing higher proportions of gov/edu/institutional domains compared to generative outputs.
high positive How Generative AI Disrupts Search: An Empirical Study of Goo... proportion of results from government/education/institutional websites
For 51.5% of representative, real-user queries, AI Overviews (AIOs) are generated and are displayed above the organic search results.
Empirical crawl/measurement across the 11,500-query benchmark comparing Google's search results and AIO outputs; counted fraction of queries with an AIO shown above organic results.
high positive How Generative AI Disrupts Search: An Empirical Study of Goo... presence and placement of AI Overview (AIO)
AI adoption leads to a statistically significant expansion of white-collar employment (reallocation toward higher-skilled occupations).
Difference-in-differences analysis using employer–employee administrative records linked to survey adoption timing, showing significant increases in white-collar employment shares in adopter firms.
high positive The economic impact of artificial intelligence: evidence fro... white-collar employment (count or share)
Using a difference-in-differences framework, AI adoption increases profitability.
Difference-in-differences (DID) estimation using survey adoption data linked to administrative balance-sheet profitability measures.
Using a difference-in-differences framework, AI adoption increases labour productivity.
Difference-in-differences (DID) estimation linking survey-reported adoption timing to administrative balance-sheet measures of labour productivity.
Adoption is concentrated among larger and more knowledge-intensive firms, as well as among firms with higher labour costs.
Cross-sectional analysis of survey linked to administrative balance sheets and employer–employee records showing higher prevalence of reported AI use for firms with larger size, higher knowledge intensity, and higher labour costs.
high positive The economic impact of artificial intelligence: evidence fro... likelihood / prevalence of AI adoption by firm characteristics (size, knowledge ...
Nearly 30 per cent of firms plan to adopt AI within the next two years.
Same 2024 firm-level survey asking about planned AI adoption within two years, linked to administrative records.
high positive The economic impact of artificial intelligence: evidence fro... planned AI adoption within next two years
AI-mediated expert networks are an emerging phenomenon that existing coordination theories fail to account for.
Mentioned as an example in the abstract to motivate theoretical gap; no empirical data or sample provided.
high positive Beyond markets and hierarchies: How GenAI enables unbounded ... performance or coordination of expert networks mediated by AI
GitHub Copilot exhibits 'recursive value creation' as an example of an emerging organizational phenomenon enabled by GenAI.
Illustrative example named in the abstract; no empirical measurement or sample reported within the abstract.
high positive Beyond markets and hierarchies: How GenAI enables unbounded ... developer productivity and value creation dynamics (implied)
UCF provides a theoretical foundation for understanding organizational coordination when GenAI transforms cognitive constraints from scarce to abundant resources.
Position paper asserts UCF as foundational theory for coordination under transformed cognitive constraints; conceptual argument only.
high positive Beyond markets and hierarchies: How GenAI enables unbounded ... ability to explain coordination under changed cognitive constraint regimes
Three emergent organizational forms illustrate UCF principles: cognitive meshworks (coordinated through competence synthesis), algorithmic ecosystems (achieving emergent optimization), and hybrid intelligence collectives (operating through cognitive complementarity).
Conceptual typology and illustrative examples in the position paper; no reported empirical measurement or sample.
high positive Beyond markets and hierarchies: How GenAI enables unbounded ... emergence of new organizational forms under GenAI
We introduce unbounded cognitive fusion (UCF) as a new theoretical framework explaining coordination through cognitive synthesis rather than price signals or authority structures.
Theoretical proposal and framing within the paper; conceptual development rather than empirical validation.
high positive Beyond markets and hierarchies: How GenAI enables unbounded ... organizational coordination explained via cognitive synthesis
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) fundamentally alters [traditional organizational coordination] assumptions by augmenting human cognitive capabilities across organizational boundaries.
Position paper argumentation and conceptual reasoning presented in the abstract; no empirical data or sample reported.
high positive Beyond markets and hierarchies: How GenAI enables unbounded ... human cognitive capability augmentation
The results offer practical insights for evaluating intelligent transformation strategies in the context of Industry 5.0 and data-driven industrial development.
Authors' stated implications and conclusions drawing on empirical findings and the proposed framework.
high positive A Data-Driven Evaluation Framework for Quantifying the Impac... guidance for evaluating intelligent transformation strategies
Integrating AHP–EWM weighting and FCE aggregation within the Feltham–Ohlson valuation structure provides an interpretable quantitative mechanism linking AI adoption, operational capability development, and enterprise value creation.
Methodological exposition and discussion in the paper; authors describe interpretability and linkages enabled by the integrated methods.
high positive A Data-Driven Evaluation Framework for Quantifying the Impac... interpretability of quantitative linkage between AI adoption and enterprise valu...
Higher PI is accompanied by enhanced production and service performance.
Empirical associations shown between PI and production/service performance indicators in the panel data analysis.
high positive A Data-Driven Evaluation Framework for Quantifying the Impac... production and service performance
Higher PI is associated with improved data governance conditions.
Empirical results in the paper reporting positive relationships between PI and indicators of data governance quality.
high positive A Data-Driven Evaluation Framework for Quantifying the Impac... data governance conditions
Higher PI is accompanied by accumulation of knowledge-based human capital.
Authors report empirical associations between PI and proxies for knowledge-based human capital accumulation in the panel analysis.
high positive A Data-Driven Evaluation Framework for Quantifying the Impac... knowledge-based human capital accumulation
Higher PI is associated with increased digital technology investment intensity.
Empirical findings reported in the paper linking PI to greater intensity of digital technology investment in the sample firms.
high positive A Data-Driven Evaluation Framework for Quantifying the Impac... digital technology investment intensity
The Process Performance Index (PI) is positively associated with firm profitability.
Empirical regression results on the panel data indicating a positive association between PI and measures of firm profitability.