The Commonplace
Home Papers Evidence Explore Trends Syntheses Digests About 🎲 Workforce Futures
Direction, evidence grade, and study type are AI-generated labels (gpt-5-mini), not human-verified. Syntheses are LLM-written. "Tensions" are machine-detected candidates, not confirmed contradictions. A research-acceleration tool, not peer review. How this is built →

Evidence (8974 claims)

Search and filter individual claims pulled from the papers. Looking for a specific finding ("what's the effect on wages?"), you're in the right place. Want to compare whole outcome categories against each other instead? Use the Evidence Explorer.

The board below groups claims two ways: by broad theme (nine paper-level topics) and by outcome category (the 34 claim-level outcomes that the Explorer and Syntheses also use).

Browse by theme

Nine broad, paper-level topics. Click one to filter the claims below.

Adoption
10085 claims
Filter claims →
Productivity
8974 claims
Filtered →
Governance
8062 claims
Filter claims →
Human-AI Collaboration
7749 claims
Filter claims →
Org Design
5057 claims
Filter claims →
Innovation
4896 claims
Filter claims →
Labor Markets
4088 claims
Filter claims →
Skills & Training
3372 claims
Filter claims →
Inequality
2377 claims
Filter claims →

Claims by outcome category

Counts by direction of finding. These are the same 34 outcome categories the Explorer compares and the Syntheses are written for. A linked row has a published synthesis.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 882 244 117 1097 2424
Governance & Regulation 1010 469 229 135 1875
Organizational Efficiency 977 235 149 90 1462
Technology Adoption Rate 781 299 143 128 1362
Research Productivity 506 155 74 363 1110
Output Quality 555 219 71 70 915
Decision Quality 395 200 95 54 751
Firm Productivity 523 67 101 27 724
AI Safety & Ethics 262 309 75 36 688
Market Structure 195 201 135 30 566
Task Allocation 248 77 96 38 464
Innovation Output 300 34 55 20 411
Skill Acquisition 207 75 65 21 368
Employment Level 138 67 119 24 350
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 156 80 53 33 329
Task Completion Time 211 38 13 16 280
Firm Revenue 183 52 29 5 270
Consumer Welfare 131 77 48 13 269
Inequality Measures 50 141 54 9 254
Worker Satisfaction 104 85 25 13 227
Error Rate 87 112 11 5 215
Automation Exposure 69 69 37 20 198
Wages & Compensation 102 49 31 11 193
Team Performance 115 30 30 11 187
Regulatory Compliance 88 74 17 7 186
Training Effectiveness 109 22 14 21 168
Developer Productivity 116 21 15 8 161
Job Displacement 12 92 26 1 131
Hiring & Recruitment 57 12 9 5 83
Skill Obsolescence 6 59 10 2 77
Social Protection 43 17 8 2 70
Creative Output 35 21 9 4 70
Labor Share of Income 18 23 17 1 59
Worker Turnover 15 16 4 35
Industry 1 1
Clear
Productivity Remove filter
Empirical evaluation was performed across four coordination environments: a repeated matrix game, two grid navigation tasks, and an Overcooked task.
Methods section describes these four benchmark environments used for all reported comparisons between fixed-order agents and A-ToM agents; evaluation metrics were joint payoffs and task-specific success measures.
high positive Adaptive Theory of Mind for LLM-based Multi-Agent Coordinati... coordination performance (joint payoff, success rate) as used in experiments
Operating as a pre-processor (rather than modifying the generator) enables modular integration with existing LLMs and provides an explicit decision point for clarification.
Novelty/architecture claim in the paper explaining that C.A.P. runs before generation and therefore can be plugged into existing LLM pipelines; described design rationale (no empirical integration study presented).
high positive A Context Alignment Pre-processor for Enhancing the Coherenc... ease of integration / ability to attach to existing generation pipelines
C.A.P. verifies semantic alignment between the current expanded prompt and the weighted history and triggers a structured clarification protocol when similarity is below a threshold.
Component-level description: alignment verification via semantic embeddings (cosine similarity) or learned classifiers and threshold-based decision branching to initiate clarification; described protocol templates (no empirical validation provided).
high positive A Context Alignment Pre-processor for Enhancing the Coherenc... alignment detection (similarity score) and number/rate of triggered clarificatio...
C.A.P. retrieves dialogue history using a time-weighted decay so recent context is prioritized (approximating human conversational focus).
Design description of a 'time-weighted context retrieval' component; authors propose temporal decay functions (e.g., exponential decay, half-life parameter) applied to dialogue-turn embeddings or metadata (no empirical results reported).
high positive A Context Alignment Pre-processor for Enhancing the Coherenc... recency-weighted relevance of retrieved context / retrieval precision for recent...
C.A.P. is a pre-generation module that expands user utterances to recover omitted premises and implications.
Architecture and methods description in the paper specifying a 'semantic expansion' component; suggested implementations via knowledge-bases or small LLM prompts to generate premises, paraphrases, and implications (no empirical evaluation reported).
high positive A Context Alignment Pre-processor for Enhancing the Coherenc... recovered implicit premises / coverage of implied goals in expanded prompt
Structured argumentation frameworks make chains of inference inspectable and machine-checkable, improving transparency and verifiability of AI outputs.
Argument from formal properties of AFs and representation; no empirical user studies but relies on known formal semantics.
high positive Argumentative Human-AI Decision-Making: Toward AI Agents Tha... inspectability/traceability of inference chains (auditability)
Computational argumentation offers formal, verifiable reasoning representations (argumentation frameworks, attack/support relations).
Established literature on formal argumentation (e.g., Dung-style AFs) and the paper's conceptual description; no new empirical data reported.
high positive Argumentative Human-AI Decision-Making: Toward AI Agents Tha... existence and machine-checkability of formal inferential chains (inspectability/...
The development artifacts are fully transparent and reproducible: the repository includes an archive of 229 human prompts and a git history with 213 commits.
Paper reports counts of prompts (229) and git commits (213) and states these archives are public; these are concrete repository metrics (n=1 development repository).
high positive Semi-Autonomous Formalization of the Vlasov-Maxwell-Landau E... number of human prompts archived (229); number of git commits (213); public avai...
The Lean kernel provided full machine verification of all formalized statements in the development.
Paper reports 'Full verification by the Lean kernel' for the Lean 4 development; supported by availability of the Lean 4 repository and verified theorem artifacts (n=1 project).
high positive Semi-Autonomous Formalization of the Vlasov-Maxwell-Landau E... machine-checked verification status of formalized statements (verified/unverifie...
A specialized prover (Aristotle) automatically closed 111 lemmas during the development.
Quantitative verification metric reported in the paper: 111 lemmas automatically closed by Aristotle; claim tied to the Lean development and prover logs (single project count).
high positive Semi-Autonomous Formalization of the Vlasov-Maxwell-Landau E... number of lemmas automatically discharged by Aristotle (111)
The AI-assisted pipeline combined an AI reasoning model (Gemini DeepThink) to generate the proof, an agentic coding tool (Claude Code) to translate the proof to Lean, a specialized automated prover (Aristotle) that closed 111 lemmas, and the Lean kernel to fully verify the result.
Project workflow description and verification metrics in the paper; reported counts and named components (Gemini DeepThink, Claude Code, Aristotle, Lean kernel); repository and logs purportedly document toolchain usage (n=1 project; 111 lemmas closed by Aristotle reported).
high positive Semi-Autonomous Formalization of the Vlasov-Maxwell-Landau E... composition of toolchain and number of lemmas automatically discharged (111)
A complete formalization in Lean 4 of the equilibrium characterization for the Vlasov–Maxwell–Landau (VML) system was produced through an AI-assisted pipeline.
Single-project artifact: a Lean 4 development containing formal statements, proof scripts and verified theorems reported by the paper (n=1 project); authors report full machine verification by the Lean kernel and provide the repository as public evidence.
high positive Semi-Autonomous Formalization of the Vlasov-Maxwell-Landau E... completeness of formalization / machine-checked verification of the VML equilibr...
iDaVIE's modular architecture supports extensibility (planned features include subcube loading, advanced render modes, video scripting, and collaborative VR sessions).
Paper describes modular architecture and lists planned/possible future features; this is a software design claim rather than an empirical result.
high positive iDaVIE v1.0: A virtual reality tool for interactive analysis... software extensibility and planned feature set
Because iDaVIE is open-source and extensible, software licensing costs are low and marginal adoption costs fall over time.
Paper states iDaVIE is open-source and designed for community-driven enhancements; economic claim based on general properties of open-source software rather than empirical cost accounting.
high positive iDaVIE v1.0: A virtual reality tool for interactive analysis... licensing cost implication and marginal adoption costs
iDaVIE includes interaction features such as selection, cropping/subcube tools, catalogue overlays, and export back to existing pipelines.
Feature list in paper describing selection, cropping, overlays, in-VR metrics and export functionality; demonstrated integration to export edited masks/subcubes.
high positive iDaVIE v1.0: A virtual reality tool for interactive analysis... availability and functionality of in-VR interaction and export tools
Streaming and downsampling pipelines implemented as Unity plug-ins make large volumes interactively viewable in VR while preserving needed detail for inspection.
Technical description of custom Unity plug-ins for streaming/downsampling and on-the-fly statistics; tested on HI cubes (telescopes listed) per the paper.
high positive iDaVIE v1.0: A virtual reality tool for interactive analysis... interactive rendering performance and retention of inspection-relevant detail
iDaVIE (v1.0) is a working VR software suite that lets astronomers import, render, inspect, and interactively edit very large 3D data cubes in real time.
Described implementation of iDaVIE v1.0 built on Unity/SteamVR with custom plug-ins for parsing/downsampling and real-time rendering; tested on large 3D spectral (HI) cubes from radio telescopes (MeerKAT, ASKAP, APERTIF) as reported in the paper.
high positive iDaVIE v1.0: A virtual reality tool for interactive analysis... ability to import/render/inspect/edit large 3D data cubes in real time (interact...
Personalized LLM coaching produced a statistically significant increase in alignment with the normative empathic taxonomy relative to both the video-based non-personalized feedback and control arms.
Pre-registered randomized experiment with three arms; pre-registered analysis reported statistically significant differences favoring personalized coaching on the primary alignment outcome.
high positive Practicing with Language Models Cultivates Human Empathic Co... statistical difference in alignment to normative empathic patterns (primary outc...
A brief, personalized coaching intervention delivered by a large language model significantly improves participants' alignment with normative, idiomatic empathic communication patterns.
Pre-registered randomized controlled trial with three arms (personalized LLM coaching, video-based non-personalized feedback, control). Outcome measured as alignment to a data-driven normative taxonomy via coding/automated measures. Overall corpus and sample context: 968 participants, 2,904 conversations, 33,938 messages used in the study.
high positive Practicing with Language Models Cultivates Human Empathic Co... alignment with normative empathic patterns (coding/automated alignment metrics)
HindSight reveals a large, real difference between systems that is missed by LLM-based judging (i.e., HindSight detects the retrieval-augmentation advantage while LLM-judged metrics do not).
Combined empirical results: HindSight shows a 2.5× advantage (p < 0.001) for retrieval augmentation while LLM-as-Judge reports no significant difference (p = 0.584).
high positive HindSight: Evaluating LLM-Generated Research Ideas via Futur... Detection of performance difference between retrieval-augmented and vanilla gene...
Experiments in the paper cover 10 AI/ML research topics and use a 30-month forward evaluation window.
Experimental setup reported in the paper: scope explicitly stated as 10 AI/ML topics and a 30-month forward window after cutoff T.
high positive HindSight: Evaluating LLM-Generated Research Ideas via Futur... Scope parameters (number of topics = 10; forward window length = 30 months)
Generated ideas can be algorithmically compared to future publications and matched items can be assigned scores reflecting downstream impact (citation counts and venue acceptance).
Method section: description of algorithmic matching procedure and scoring rules that use citation counts and venue acceptance as impact proxies.
high positive HindSight: Evaluating LLM-Generated Research Ideas via Futur... Match indicators and downstream-impact scores (citations, venue acceptance) for ...
A retrieval-augmented idea generator produces 2.5× higher-scoring ideas than a vanilla generator according to HindSight (p < 0.001).
Empirical comparison reported in the paper across the specified experiments (10 AI/ML topics, time-split at T, 30-month forward window); statistical test reporting a 2.5× difference with p < 0.001.
high positive HindSight: Evaluating LLM-Generated Research Ideas via Futur... HindSight score (downstream-impact-based score for generated ideas)
HindSight is a time-split, retrospective evaluation that (1) restricts idea generation to pre-cutoff literature (time T), (2) compares generated ideas to papers published in the following 30 months, and (3) scores matches by downstream impact (citation counts and venue acceptance).
Method described in paper: time-split protocol with a temporal cutoff T, a 30-month forward window, algorithmic matching of generated ideas to later publications, and scoring based on downstream impact metrics (citations and venue acceptance).
high positive HindSight: Evaluating LLM-Generated Research Ideas via Futur... HindSight match score computed from matches to later publications weighted by ci...
The paper introduces a Multi-Object Decoder (MOD) that extends SAM 3D to jointly reconstruct multiple objects from a single image, targeting physically plausible, non-penetrating object configurations and realistic contacts.
Method section: MOD is described as an extension of the single-object SAM 3D architecture to jointly decode multiple object shapes and poses from a monocular image; the method explicitly aims to reduce inter-object penetration and model contacts.
high positive MessyKitchens: Contact-rich object-level 3D scene reconstruc... methodological capability: joint multi-object monocular 3D reconstruction, objec...
LEAFE achieves up to a 14% absolute improvement on Pass@128 versus the strongest baselines.
Empirical result explicitly reported in the paper: maximum observed improvement 'up to +14% Pass@128' in comparisons to baselines on the experimental tasks.
high positive Internalizing Agency from Reflective Experience Pass@128 (absolute percentage point improvement)
Compared with outcome-driven methods (e.g., GRPO) and experience-based baselines (e.g., Early Experience), LEAFE yields consistent gains in Pass@1 and Pass@k under fixed interaction budgets.
Head-to-head experimental comparisons reported between LEAFE and baselines GRPO and Early Experience on the task suite; fixed interaction-budget experimental regime; Pass@1 and Pass@k used as evaluation metrics.
high positive Internalizing Agency from Reflective Experience Pass@1 and Pass@k (fraction of problems solved among k candidate runs)
LEAFE substantially improves long-horizon agentic performance by internalizing recovery behavior learned from environment feedback.
Reported experiments on a suite of long-horizon interactive tasks (multi-step coding and agentic tasks) comparing LEAFE to baselines; evaluation using Pass@k metrics under fixed interaction budgets; qualitative description that LEAFE internalizes recovery behavior from environment feedback.
high positive Internalizing Agency from Reflective Experience Long-horizon agentic performance measured by Pass@k (Pass@1, Pass@k, Pass@128)
The RL fine-tuned Qwen2.5-Coder-7B improves 33.1% over the same base 7B model without RL fine-tuning.
Head-to-head comparison between the tuned model and its untuned base across the 48 evaluation briefs; reported improvement of +33.1%.
high positive Learning to Present: Inverse Specification Rewards for Agent... Absolute or relative quality improvement (%) of tuned vs. untuned Qwen2.5-Coder-...
Fine-tuning a parameter-efficient 7B model (Qwen2.5-Coder-7B) via reinforcement learning in an OpenEnv-compatible environment yields near-state-of-the-art automated slide-generation: the tuned 7B model reaches 91.2% of Claude Opus 4.6’s quality.
Empirical evaluation on 48 diverse business briefs comparing six models; reported relative quality score of tuned Qwen2.5-Coder-7B = 91.2% of Claude Opus 4.6.
high positive Learning to Present: Inverse Specification Rewards for Agent... Relative slide-generation quality (percent of Claude Opus 4.6 quality) across 48...
Managing captures, traces, and replay sessions from a unified single design database ensures consistency across replay targets and sessions.
Method description emphasizes a single design database coordinating captures and replays across simulation and emulation for the demonstrator system. (Operational claim demonstrated in the implementation; no metrics on error reduction provided.)
high positive ODIN-Based CPU-GPU Architecture with Replay-Driven Simulatio... consistency of trace/replay data and configuration across targets
The captured traces can be deterministically replayed across different execution targets (software/hardware simulation and hardware emulation), reducing cross-platform setup complexity and discrepancies.
The same captured waveforms/traces were replayed on both simulation and emulation environments for the ODIN demonstrator; cross-target replay was part of the described method. (Demonstrated on the single reported system; no broad cross-toolchain study provided.)
high positive ODIN-Based CPU-GPU Architecture with Replay-Driven Simulatio... consistency of reproduced behavior across simulator and emulator targets
BATQuant significantly outperforms prior post-training quantization (PTQ) methods on MXFP4 microscaling floating-point formats under aggressive quantization.
Comparative experiments against rotation-based PTQ techniques and other existing PTQ baselines on the described multimodal and language tasks; improvements shown in benchmark metrics and recovery percentages in the paper's experimental section.
high positive BATQuant: Outlier-resilient MXFP4 Quantization via Learnable... Task-specific accuracy/quality metrics and percent recovery relative to full-pre...
BATQuant recovers up to 96.43% of full-precision performance under aggressive W4A4KV16 quantization on MLLMs and LLMs.
Empirical evaluation reported in the paper: experiments on multiple multimodal large language models (MLLMs) and standard LLMs using an aggressive W4A4KV16 quantization setup; performance reported as percentage of full-precision performance recovered (specific models, benchmark names, and exact sample sizes not enumerated in the summary).
high positive BATQuant: Outlier-resilient MXFP4 Quantization via Learnable... Percentage of full-precision performance recovered (model quality/accuracy on mu...
The paper provides concrete, regulation-inspired policy examples (e.g., content prohibition, sensitive data exfiltration) showing how they map into the Policy function.
Worked, illustrative examples included in the paper mapping regulatory constraints to the Policy(agent_id, partial_path, proposed_action, org_state) formalism.
high positive Runtime Governance for AI Agents: Policies on Paths representability of regulation-inspired policies in the formalism (yes/no; examp...
Runtime policy evaluation can intercept, score, log, allow/modify/block actions, and update organizational state as part of an agent's execution loop (reference implementation architecture).
Reference implementation design described in the paper (runtime policy evaluator hooks, logging, enforcement actions); architectural reasoning and pseudo-workflows provided; no production deployment data.
high positive Runtime Governance for AI Agents: Policies on Paths feasibility of integrating runtime policy evaluator into agent loops (architectu...
Policies can be formalized as deterministic functions p_violation = Policy(agent_id, partial_path, proposed_action, org_state) that return a probability or score of violation for a proposed next action.
Formal definition and mapping in the paper; worked examples showing how regulatory-style constraints map into this function; no large-scale empirical validation.
high positive Runtime Governance for AI Agents: Policies on Paths expressiveness of policy formalism (ability to represent targeted constraints)
Effective governance for agentic LLM systems requires treating the execution path as the central object and performing runtime evaluation of proposed next actions given the partial path.
Theoretical argument and formal proposal of runtime policy evaluator that takes (agent_id, partial_path, proposed_action, org_state) and returns a violation probability; reference architecture described; illustrative examples.
high positive Runtime Governance for AI Agents: Policies on Paths governance effectiveness for path-dependent policies (qualitative/coverage)
The surrogate-driven inverse-design pipeline transfers to physical hardware — designs produced by the CNN+GA pipeline were realized and validated experimentally.
Two fabricated prototypes implemented the optimized pixelated combiners and GaN HEMT Doherty PAs; measured performance metrics correspond to the designs, demonstrating transfer from surrogate-driven design to hardware.
high positive Deep Learning-Driven Black-Box Doherty Power Amplifier with ... consistency between surrogate-driven design outputs and measured prototype perfo...
Under a 20 MHz 5G-NR-like waveform (9 dB PAPR) with digital predistortion (DPD), each prototype reached average PAE greater than 51% while meeting ACLR ≤ −60.8 dBc.
Realistic waveform testing described: a 20 MHz 5G‑NR-like signal with 9 dB PAPR was applied to the prototypes, DPD was used, and measurements reported average PAE > 51% and ACLR ≤ −60.8 dBc for each prototype.
high positive Deep Learning-Driven Black-Box Doherty Power Amplifier with ... average power-added efficiency (PAE %) and adjacent channel leakage ratio (ACLR,...
Each prototype demonstrated drain efficiency greater than 52% at 9 dB back-off.
Back-off efficiency measurements reported for the fabricated prototypes showing drain efficiency > 52% at 9 dB back-off.
high positive Deep Learning-Driven Black-Box Doherty Power Amplifier with ... drain efficiency at 9 dB back-off (%)
Each prototype produced output power exceeding 44.1 dBm at 2.75 GHz.
Measured output power reported from RF characterization of the two fabricated prototypes; reported value > 44.1 dBm at the test frequency.
Each fabricated prototype achieved peak drain efficiency greater than 74%.
Measured RF characterization reported for the two prototypes showing peak drain efficiency > 74%; measurements conducted on fabricated hardware at 2.75 GHz.
high positive Deep Learning-Driven Black-Box Doherty Power Amplifier with ... peak drain efficiency (%)
A genetic-algorithm (GA) blackbox optimizer paired with the CNN surrogate can effectively search the discrete multi-port pixel layout space to synthesize output combiners for Doherty amplifiers.
Method description: CNN surrogate embedded in a blackbox Doherty framework and used within a GA to select pixelated combiner layouts; successful designs were produced and taken to fabrication.
high positive Deep Learning-Driven Black-Box Doherty Power Amplifier with ... ability of optimization stack to find feasible combiner layouts that meet system...
The parallel associative scan enables the reductions required by Newton-style updates across time steps, thereby enabling parallelism across sequence length.
Algorithmic construction and implementation details in the thesis showing how associative scan operations aggregate intermediate Jacobian/ update information across time; examples provided in implementation section.
high positive Unifying Optimization and Dynamics to Parallelize Sequential... practical parallelizability / ability to compute required reductions in parallel
The thesis proves linear convergence rates for a family of fixed-point/Newton-like solvers, with rates depending on approximation accuracy and stability properties of the chosen method.
Mathematical proofs and convergence theorems provided in the theoretical analysis section establishing linear rates under stated assumptions (bounds on approximation error, stability metrics).
high positive Unifying Optimization and Dynamics to Parallelize Sequential... convergence rate (linear) as a function of approximation error and stability mea...
Evaluation of dynamical systems can be cast as solving a system of nonlinear equations, enabling parallel solution methods.
Methodological framing and derivation in the thesis showing recurrent updates and Markov transitions can be represented as a global nonlinear root-finding problem; algorithmic constructions follow from this representation.
high positive Unifying Optimization and Dynamics to Parallelize Sequential... feasibility of parallel solution (existence of equivalent nonlinear-system formu...
Explicit enforcement of signal constraints in DeePC provides a safety/operational advantage over many pure learning approaches that do not explicitly enforce hard constraints.
Algorithmic formulation includes constraints in the optimization; paper contrasts this with unconstrained learning-based controllers and demonstrates constrained, feasible actuation in simulation.
high positive Data-driven generalized perimeter control: Zürich case study explicit constraint satisfaction and operational safety of signal timings
DeePC can compute traffic-light actuation sequences that respect hard operational and safety constraints (e.g., phasing, minimum/maximum green times).
Formulation of DeePC as a constrained optimization problem in the paper with explicit constraint terms for signal phasing and safety; implemented in simulation experiments where constraints are enforced in the controller optimization.
high positive Data-driven generalized perimeter control: Zürich case study constraint satisfaction / feasibility of computed actuation sequences
Reframing urban traffic dynamics with behavioral systems theory allows system evolution to be learned and predicted directly from measured input–output data (no explicit model identification).
Theoretical exposition in the paper showing that traffic trajectories can be represented as linear combinations of past measured trajectories via Hankel/data matrices; used as the basis for predictive control (DeePC).
high positive Data-driven generalized perimeter control: Zürich case study predictive capability from measured I/O trajectories (ability to forecast future...