The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (4175 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Org Design Remove filter
Given extended compute budgets, the agent team topology achieves the deep theoretical alignment necessary for complex architectural refactoring.
Empirical benchmarks run with longer/extended computational budgets showing agent teams perform better on complex architectural refactoring tasks (qualitative claim; no numeric effect sizes or sample counts provided in the abstract).
high positive An Empirical Study of Multi-Agent Collaboration for Automate... ability to perform complex architectural refactoring / depth of theoretical alig...
The subagent mode functions as a highly resilient, high-throughput search engine optimal for broad, shallow optimizations under strict time constraints.
Benchmark comparisons in the execution-based testbed under strictly fixed computational time budgets showing subagent architecture excels in throughput/resilience for broad, shallow optimization tasks (qualitative claim in paper; no numeric effect sizes provided).
high positive An Empirical Study of Multi-Agent Collaboration for Automate... search throughput/resilience and effectiveness on broad, shallow optimization ta...
Task-level analyses show that activities expanded in AI-enabled projects—particularly ideation and experimentation—are increasingly compatible with large language model capabilities, suggesting potential for future productivity gains as these technologies mature.
Task-level classification mapping tasks described in proposals to LLM-relevant capabilities using LLM-based classification; finding that tasks expanded in AI-enabled projects cluster on ideation and experimentation, which align with current LLM strengths.
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Science: Returns, Reallocation, a... frequency/expansion of specific task categories (ideation, experimentation) and ...
AI-enabled projects undertake a broader set of tasks.
Task-level analysis of proposal descriptions (task inventories) classifying tasks via keyword extraction and LLMs, showing AI-enabled proposals list a wider variety of activities than non-AI proposals.
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Science: Returns, Reallocation, a... breadth/variety of tasks undertaken in projects
AI-enabled projects involve larger teams.
Comparison of team structure in proposals (team size) between AI-enabled and non-AI projects using the same comprehensive proposal dataset and LLM-based classification of AI presence.
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Science: Returns, Reallocation, a... team size / team structure
AI-enabled projects reallocate resources toward human capital (i.e., shift budget allocations toward labor / human capital).
Analysis of detailed budget allocations in the proposal dataset, comparing projects identified as AI-enabled versus non-AI projects using keyword extraction and LLM classification to identify AI presence and role.
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Science: Returns, Reallocation, a... budget allocation share toward human capital (labor share)
In the short run, AI adoption is associated with modest improvements in scientific outcomes concentrated in the upper tail.
Observational analysis linking identified AI presence in a comprehensive dataset of research proposals (funded and unfunded) to subsequent publication outcomes; AI presence identified via keyword extraction combined with large language model (LLM) classification; publication outcomes measured after proposal submission.
high positive Artificial Intelligence in Science: Returns, Reallocation, a... subsequent publication outcomes (scientific outcomes)
Education and workforce development should shift focus from rote knowledge accumulation to cultivating skills in human-AI collaboration, creative problem-solving, and the design of novel economic domains.
Normative policy recommendation derived from the paper's framework and analysis of anticipated labor market changes (no empirical evaluation or trial data reported in the abstract).
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work educational focus / skill composition
Human-AI co-evolution will significantly increase individual productivity and open new frontiers of economic activity.
Projected outcome based on combined analysis of AI capabilities, historical patterns, and platform growth; the abstract does not report empirical measurement or sample sizes for this projection.
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work individual productivity and emergence of new economic activities
AI-driven productivity augmentation dramatically lowers the barriers to creating economic value, enabling the decentralized generation of employment.
Argument supported by paper's analysis of contemporary labor market dynamics and the growth of digital platforms; no quantified empirical estimates or sample sizes provided in the abstract.
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work barriers to entry for value creation / individual productivity
The transition to an AI-civilization will fundamentally restructure the mechanisms of employment creation from a centralized model (few organizations creating jobs for the many) to a decentralized ecosystem where individuals are empowered to generate their own employment opportunities.
Central thesis of the paper, motivated by theoretical argumentation and synthesis of contemporary data on labor markets and digital platforms (no empirical test or sample sizes specified in the abstract).
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work structure/mechanism of employment creation (centralized vs decentralized)
Historical precedents from past technological revolutions suggest that innovation tends to expand, rather than shrink, the scope of economic activity and employment in the long run.
Paper draws on analysis of economic history (qualitative historical analysis implied; no specific historical datasets or sample sizes provided in the abstract).
high positive AI Civilization and the Transformation of Work scope of economic activity and long-run employment levels
By formalizing the end-to-end transaction model together with its asset and incentive layers, EpochX reframes agentic AI as an organizational design problem focused on infrastructures where verifiable work leaves persistent, reusable artifacts and value flows support durable human-agent collaboration.
Theoretical framing and normative claim in the paper; no empirical evaluation demonstrating that this reframing yields measurable benefits.
high positive EpochX: Building the Infrastructure for an Emergent Agent Ci... organizational framing and potential for durable human-agent collaboration
Credits lock task bounties, allow budget delegation, settle rewards upon acceptance, and compensate creators when verified assets are reused.
Functional description of the credit mechanics and settlement rules within the proposed EpochX marketplace; presented as part of system design without empirical settlement or user-behavior data.
high positive EpochX: Building the Infrastructure for an Emergent Agent Ci... incentive flows, reward settlement, and compensation for asset reuse
EpochX introduces a native credit mechanism to make participation economically viable under real compute costs.
Proposed economic/incentive mechanism described in the paper; no empirical cost analysis, pricing model validation, or participant economic outcomes reported.
high positive EpochX: Building the Infrastructure for an Emergent Agent Ci... economic viability of participation under compute costs
These assets are stored with explicit dependency structure, enabling retrieval, composition, and cumulative improvement over time.
Design-level assertion about data model/asset graph in the EpochX proposal; no empirical results demonstrating retrieval/composition or measured cumulative improvement.
high positive EpochX: Building the Infrastructure for an Emergent Agent Ci... asset retrieval/composition and cumulative improvement
Each completed transaction can produce reusable ecosystem assets, including skills, workflows, execution traces, and distilled experience.
Architectural claim about artifacts produced per transaction in EpochX; described as a design goal rather than backed by empirical evidence or deployment data.
high positive EpochX: Building the Infrastructure for an Emergent Agent Ci... creation of reusable assets (skills, workflows, traces, distilled experience)
Claimed tasks can be decomposed into subtasks and executed through an explicit delivery workflow with verification and acceptance.
Design description of the workflow and verification/acceptance mechanisms in the proposed EpochX architecture; no empirical testing or metrics reported.
high positive EpochX: Building the Infrastructure for an Emergent Agent Ci... task execution workflow, verification and acceptance outcomes
EpochX treats humans and agents as peer participants who can post tasks or claim them.
Architectural/design specification in the paper describing participant roles and interactions; no empirical validation provided.
high positive EpochX: Building the Infrastructure for an Emergent Agent Ci... task posting and claiming behavior / task allocation model
We introduce EpochX, a credits-native marketplace infrastructure for human-agent production networks.
System/design description in the paper (architectural proposal); no deployment, user study, or evaluation results reported.
high positive EpochX: Building the Infrastructure for an Emergent Agent Ci... marketplace infrastructure availability / adoption potential
The paper concludes by articulating expected outcomes for management practice and proposes a research agenda calling for future mixed-methods validation of the framework.
Stated conclusion and explicit call for mixed-methods validation; no validation results provided in this paper.
high positive Behavioral Factors as Determinants of Successful Scaling of ... guidance for management practice and roadmap for empirical validation
The review derives constructs, hypothesized links among them, and governance implications for managing and institutionalizing workplace AI.
Paper reports that reviewed sources were used to derive constructs and governance implications; this is a conceptual derivation rather than empirical testing.
high positive Behavioral Factors as Determinants of Successful Scaling of ... set of constructs, hypothesized relationships, and governance recommendations
The framework and synthesis can be used to diagnose patterns of disengagement and pilot-to-production failure in corporate AI initiatives.
Proposed analytical structure derived from literature synthesis and conceptual mapping; intended as a diagnostic tool but not empirically validated within this paper.
high positive Behavioral Factors as Determinants of Successful Scaling of ... ability to diagnose disengagement and failure modes
The paper integrates adoption frameworks (TAM and TOE) with evidence on human-AI interaction to produce a scaling-oriented conceptual framework for diagnosing disengagement and pilot-to-production failures.
Comparative conceptual analysis and framework building based on reviewed literature; no new empirical validation reported.
high positive Behavioral Factors as Determinants of Successful Scaling of ... diagnostic capacity for identifying causes of disengagement and pilot-to-product...
Integrating technological, human, and organizational capabilities is important to maximize the benefits of AI in smart manufacturing.
Conclusion based on thematic patterns in interviews, observations, and document analysis from purposively sampled supply chain and production professionals; identified as an implementation implication.
high positive Assessing the Effectiveness of AI-Driven Techniques for Dema... realization of AI benefits / implementation success
Firms adopting AI-driven forecasting and inventory strategies can achieve higher operational agility, better strategic resource alignment, and maintain a competitive advantage in dynamic manufacturing contexts.
Synthesis and implications drawn from thematic analysis of interviews, site visits, and documents from purposively sampled industry practitioners; presented as study conclusions rather than quantitatively tested outcomes.
high positive Assessing the Effectiveness of AI-Driven Techniques for Dema... operational agility / strategic alignment / competitive advantage
AI supports sustainability initiatives within manufacturing operations.
Thematic analysis of practitioner interviews and organizational documentation where respondents linked AI-based forecasting/inventory optimization to sustainability outcomes (e.g., waste reduction).
high positive Assessing the Effectiveness of AI-Driven Techniques for Dema... sustainability outcomes (e.g., waste reduction)
AI improves supply chain coordination among partners and internal functions.
Interview and document-based thematic findings from purposively sampled supply chain managers and industry experts reporting enhanced coordination following AI adoption.
high positive Assessing the Effectiveness of AI-Driven Techniques for Dema... supply chain coordination
AI contributes to operational resilience in manufacturing supply chains.
Qualitative evidence from interviews and organizational documents indicating that AI-enabled forecasting and inventory controls improve firms' ability to adapt to disruptions; thematic analysis produced resilience as a reported benefit.
Organizational readiness, skilled personnel, data quality, and robust technological infrastructure are critical factors influencing AI effectiveness.
Recurring themes identified via thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews with supply chain and production professionals, corroborated by observational site visits and organizational documents from purposive sample.
high positive Assessing the Effectiveness of AI-Driven Techniques for Dema... AI effectiveness (implementation success/performance)
AI reduces excess inventory levels in manufacturing firms.
Thematic findings from interviews, site visits, and documents from industry experts and practitioners who reported decreased excess inventory following AI-driven forecasting and inventory optimization.
AI reduces stockouts in manufacturing supply chains.
Practitioner accounts and organizational document evidence from purposive qualitative sampling and thematic analysis indicating fewer stockouts associated with AI-driven forecasting and inventory controls.
AI adoption reduces operational inefficiencies in manufacturing processes.
Thematic analysis of qualitative data (semi-structured interviews, site observations, organizational documents) from purposively sampled industry practitioners reporting reductions in inefficiencies after AI implementation.
high positive Assessing the Effectiveness of AI-Driven Techniques for Dema... operational inefficiencies
AI supports proactive decision-making among supply chain and production stakeholders.
Qualitative reports from interviews and document review with supply chain managers, production planners, and industry experts; thematic analysis identified proactive decision-making as a theme associated with AI use.
high positive Assessing the Effectiveness of AI-Driven Techniques for Dema... proactivity of decision-making
AI enables adaptive inventory management in manufacturing operations.
Findings from thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews with supply chain managers, production planners, and industry experts, plus observational site visits and organizational documents (purposive sampling).
high positive Assessing the Effectiveness of AI-Driven Techniques for Dema... adaptive inventory management capability
AI technologies enhance forecasting accuracy in smart manufacturing.
Qualitative evidence from purposive sample of supply chain managers, production planners, and industry experts gathered via semi-structured interviews, observational site visits, and organizational documents; analyzed using thematic analysis.
Geographical, cultural, and institutional proximities facilitate collaboration in the AI industry.
SAOM inclusion of dyadic proximity covariates in the longitudinal patent-collaboration model (2013–2024) with reported positive effects for geographic, cultural, and institutional proximity on tie formation.
high positive The evolutionary mechanism of artificial intelligence indust... tie formation / collaboration probability
Organizations with higher innovativeness attract more collaborative partners.
SAOM results linking organizational innovativeness (measured via patenting/innovation indicators) to greater degree (number of collaborative partners) in longitudinal patent data (2013–2024).
high positive The evolutionary mechanism of artificial intelligence indust... number of collaborative partners (degree)
Universities and research institutions play a more central role in driving network evolution than firms.
SAOM analysis of patent-collaboration network trajectories (2013–2024) showing higher centrality/greater influence of universities and research institutions relative to firms in the modeled network evolution.
high positive The evolutionary mechanism of artificial intelligence indust... network centrality / role in network evolution
Endogenous structural effects — specifically transitivity and preferential attachment — actively shape tie formation in China’s AI industry collaboration network.
Empirical SAOM results on longitudinal patent collaboration data (2013–2024) testing endogenous network effects (transitivity, preferential attachment) on tie formation.
high positive The evolutionary mechanism of artificial intelligence indust... tie formation (probability/creation of collaboration links)
Collaboration networks play a crucial role in fostering innovation within the artificial intelligence (AI) industry.
Statement supported by analysis of longitudinal patent collaboration data (2013–2024) using a stochastic actor-oriented model (SAOM) integrating structural effects, organizational attributes, and dyadic proximities.
high positive The evolutionary mechanism of artificial intelligence indust... innovation (as inferred from collaborative patenting activity)
With calibrated oversight that aligns accountability to real-world risks, AI can secure the profession’s future.
Normative/prognostic claim in the Article (argument that appropriate governance will preserve or strengthen the legal profession).
high positive Rewired: Reconceptualizing Legal Services for the AI Age long-term resilience/stability of the legal profession
With calibrated oversight that aligns accountability to real-world risks, AI can improve service quality in legal services.
Normative/prognostic claim in the Article (argument that governance plus AI yields quality improvements). No empirical effect sizes reported in the excerpt.
high positive Rewired: Reconceptualizing Legal Services for the AI Age service quality of legal services
While the risks of AI are real, they must not eclipse the opportunity: with calibrated oversight that aligns accountability to real-world risks, AI can expand access to legal services.
Normative claim and projected benefit argued by the authors (theoretical/argumentative; no empirical evidence in excerpt).
high positive Rewired: Reconceptualizing Legal Services for the AI Age expansion of access to legal services
The ultimate competitive edge lies in an organization's ability to treat AI not as a standalone tool, but as a core component of sustainable, long-term corporate strategy.
Concluding normative claim in the paper; presented as an interpretation/synthesis rather than supported by cited empirical evidence in the abstract.
high positive The AI Advantage: Strategic Innovation and Global Expansion ... competitive advantage derived from integrating AI into corporate strategy
Successful global expansion is no longer predicated solely on physical presence but on the deployment of scalable, localized AI models that navigate diverse regulatory, linguistic, and cultural landscapes.
Argumentative claim in the paper describing a strategic determinant for global expansion; no empirical sample or quantified outcomes presented in the abstract.
high positive The AI Advantage: Strategic Innovation and Global Expansion ... drivers of successful global expansion (physical presence vs. localized AI deplo...
AI hyper-personalizes customer engagement.
Declarative claim in the paper about AI's effect on customer engagement personalization; no experimental or observational data reported in the abstract.
high positive The AI Advantage: Strategic Innovation and Global Expansion ... degree of personalization in customer engagement
AI acts as an internal engine for operational agility by compressing R&D cycles.
Claim made in the paper asserting R&D cycle compression due to AI; no empirical data, sample size or quantitative measures provided in the abstract.
high positive The AI Advantage: Strategic Innovation and Global Expansion ... length/duration of R&D cycles (time-to-iteration)
The strategic focus has transitioned from mere process automation to autonomous orchestration, where multi-agent systems independently manage complex, cross-border operations and real-time decision-making.
Analytic statement from the paper describing an observed/argued shift in strategic focus; no empirical methodology or sample reported.
high positive The AI Advantage: Strategic Innovation and Global Expansion ... shift in strategic focus from automation to autonomous orchestration via multi-a...
Organizations leverage agentic workflows and domain-specific intelligence to catalyse strategic innovation and facilitate global expansion in the digital era.
Conceptual claim in the paper describing how organizations use specific AI capabilities; no empirical design or sample described in the abstract.
high positive The AI Advantage: Strategic Innovation and Global Expansion ... use of agentic workflows and domain-specific models to drive innovation and glob...