The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (4189 claims)

Adoption
8625 claims
Productivity
7686 claims
Governance
6917 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6574 claims
Org Design
4189 claims
Innovation
4131 claims
Labor Markets
3588 claims
Skills & Training
2985 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 761 200 101 904 2020
Governance & Regulation 829 400 191 122 1566
Organizational Efficiency 784 193 125 84 1197
Technology Adoption Rate 637 236 124 97 1103
Research Productivity 431 131 58 340 972
Output Quality 481 183 59 47 770
Decision Quality 332 177 82 49 647
Firm Productivity 439 57 88 20 610
AI Safety & Ethics 218 279 66 33 602
Market Structure 181 170 123 24 503
Task Allocation 214 64 72 33 388
Skill Acquisition 174 62 62 17 315
Innovation Output 204 27 45 18 295
Employment Level 105 54 108 13 282
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 132 69 43 26 277
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 154 48 26 3 231
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 123 50 6 223
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 71 92 10 2 175
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 58 56 26 13 156
Training Effectiveness 96 21 14 19 152
Wages & Compensation 77 37 25 6 145
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 81 21 1 115
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 32 20 8 3 64
Skill Obsolescence 5 47 6 1 59
Social Protection 28 16 8 2 54
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Org Design Remove filter
Programmatic state abstraction delivers the largest returns per token spent (RPTS), improving mean return by up to 76% over raw observations.
Controlled empirical study in the CybORG CAGE-2 POMDP environment comparing context representations (raw observations vs. deterministic state-tracking layer with compressed history) across five model families, six models, and twelve configurations with token-level cost accounting (3,475 episodes).
high positive Context, Reasoning, and Hierarchy: A Cost-Performance Study ... mean return (and returns per token spent, RPTS)
The study's findings offer actionable insights for managers and policymakers to leverage AI for sustainable organizational growth while safeguarding employee well-being.
Authors' concluding statement based on survey findings and analytical results.
high positive Opportunities and Challenges of Human- AI Collaboration in W... practical relevance of findings for management and policy decisions
Successful human–AI collaboration requires a human-centric approach that balances technological advancement with workforce development, ethical governance, and organizational support.
Study conclusion/recommendation based on survey findings (perceptions of opportunities and challenges) and analytical results (correlation/regression).
high positive Opportunities and Challenges of Human- AI Collaboration in W... effective implementation of human–AI collaboration (organizational success facto...
Human–AI collaboration reduces employees' routine workload.
Respondent perceptions collected via the structured questionnaire and analyzed with descriptive statistics and regression in SPSS.
high positive Opportunities and Challenges of Human- AI Collaboration in W... amount of routine work assigned to employees
AI-based systems support better decision-making by providing data-driven insights, allowing employees to focus on higher-level cognitive and strategic activities.
Survey responses (structured questionnaire) analyzed with SPSS (correlation and regression analyses) reporting perceived support for decision-making.
high positive Opportunities and Challenges of Human- AI Collaboration in W... decision-making quality / decision-support
Human–AI collaboration significantly enhances workplace efficiency and productivity by reducing routine workload and improving accuracy and speed in task execution.
Primary data from employees in AI-enabled organizations collected via a structured questionnaire (5-point Likert); analyzed with SPSS using descriptive statistics and regression analysis.
high positive Opportunities and Challenges of Human- AI Collaboration in W... workplace efficiency and productivity (reduction in routine workload, improved a...
Design principles that promote disagreement and decentralization—contextual grounding, community customization, continual adaptation, and polycentric governance—should be used so oversight is distributed across many legitimate centers rather than centralized in one institutional or moral chokepoint.
Normative design recommendations and governance proposals provided in the paper (argumentative; no empirical governance evaluation reported).
high positive Positive Alignment: Artificial Intelligence for Human Flouri... promotion of disagreement and decentralization in AI oversight/governance
A range of technical directions (e.g., data filtering and upsampling, pre- and post-training, evaluations, collaborative value collection) are relevant for supporting positive alignment across different phases of the LLM and agents lifecycle.
Prescriptive technical recommendations and research directions described by the authors (conceptual proposals, not reported empirical tests).
high positive Positive Alignment: Artificial Intelligence for Human Flouri... applicability of listed technical interventions to LLM/agent lifecycle for posit...
Several existing failures of alignment (e.g., engagement hacking, loss of human autonomy, failures in truth-seeking, low epistemic humility, error correction, lack of diverse viewpoints, and being primarily reactive rather than proactive) may be better addressed through positive alignment, including cultivating virtues and maximizing human flourishing.
Theoretical argument and illustrative examples presented in the paper (no experimental or observational results reported).
high positive Positive Alignment: Artificial Intelligence for Human Flouri... mitigation of specific alignment failures (engagement hacking, autonomy loss, tr...
Positive Alignment is a distinct and necessary agenda within AI alignment research.
Normative argumentation in the paper advocating for a separate research agenda (no empirical validation presented).
high positive Positive Alignment: Artificial Intelligence for Human Flouri... need for a distinct research agenda in alignment
Positive Alignment is the development of AI systems that (i) actively support human and ecological flourishing in a pluralistic, polycentric, context-sensitive, and user-authored way while (ii) remaining safe and cooperative.
Paper's definitional proposal / conceptual framing (normative definition rather than empirical evidence).
high positive Positive Alignment: Artificial Intelligence for Human Flouri... definition and intended properties of 'Positive Alignment' systems
Policy frameworks are necessary to govern verifiable machine intelligence in modern socio-technical infrastructures.
Normative recommendation and policy discussion in the paper; no empirical policy evaluation or legislative case studies are presented in the supplied text.
high positive Optimizing Process Based Reward Models through Reinforcement... existence/need for governance and regulation
Process-based supervision has broader implications for algorithmic fairness and can reduce black-box opacity.
High-level discussion in the paper linking process-verifiability to fairness and reduced opacity; no empirical fairness audits or quantitative fairness metrics reported in the provided text.
high positive Optimizing Process Based Reward Models through Reinforcement... algorithmic fairness / model opacity
Integrating reinforcement learning with process-oriented feedback can foster a more transparent AI ecosystem where the path to a conclusion is as scrutinized as the conclusion itself.
Conceptual claim and proposed benefit in the paper; presented as an argument rather than supported by empirical transparency or interpretability studies in the supplied text.
high positive Optimizing Process Based Reward Models through Reinforcement... transparency / interpretability of model reasoning
Process-based supervision significantly improves the reliability of models in high-stakes domains such as law, medicine, and engineering.
Asserted by the authors as an advantage of PRMs for high-stakes applications; presented as argumentation rather than backed by reported empirical trials or case-study sample sizes in the provided text.
high positive Optimizing Process Based Reward Models through Reinforcement... model reliability in high-stakes domains
Optimizing PRMs through reinforcement learning enhances the verifiability and robustness of multi-step reasoning in large-scale model architectures.
Central argumentative claim of the paper (theoretical proposal and conceptual analysis); no experimental results or quantitative evaluation provided in the text supplied.
high positive Optimizing Process Based Reward Models through Reinforcement... verifiability and robustness of multi-step reasoning
Process-Based Reward Models (PRMs) assign value to each distinct stage of a reasoning chain, providing a more granular signal for training than outcome-only approaches.
Methodological description and conceptual argument in the paper; described as a design/approach rather than empirically validated with data.
high positive Optimizing Process Based Reward Models through Reinforcement... training signal granularity / training effectiveness
Overall, the study provides a cross-sectoral empirical foundation for understanding how budget flexibility, governance, and technology interact to support resilient financial systems in uncertain economic environments.
Synthesis statement based on the paper's cross-sectoral comparative analysis combining firm 10-K data (four firms), Open Budget Survey, OECD database, GAO reports, and the Flexibility Index.
high positive Budgeting for Agility: A Cross-Sectoral Analysis of Fiscal F... resilience of financial systems to uncertainty
In the public sector, systems characterized by strong transparency frameworks and Medium-Term Expenditure Frameworks demonstrate higher alignment between planned and actual expenditures.
Cross-sectional analysis using Open Budget Survey 2023, OECD Budget Practices Database, and U.S. GAO oversight reports linking transparency and MTEFs to alignment between planned and actual expenditures.
high positive Budgeting for Agility: A Cross-Sectoral Analysis of Fiscal F... alignment between planned and actual expenditures (forecast/policy alignment)
Firms with decentralized budgeting structures and embedded predictive analytics exhibit lower forecast deviations and faster resource reallocation.
Comparative empirical analysis of four large firms using Form 10-K data (2019–2023) and the Flexibility Index to relate decentralization and AI integration to forecast deviations and reallocation speed.
high positive Budgeting for Agility: A Cross-Sectoral Analysis of Fiscal F... forecast deviation (predictive alignment) and speed of resource reallocation
The framework contributes to improving understanding of enterprise coordination and governance under constrained legal conditions and offers a basis for future analytical and empirical research.
Author-stated contribution of the paper based on the developed theoretical framework; positioned as foundation for future work.
high positive RegTech-enabled governance of sanctions-safe enterprise ecos... conceptual contribution to understanding enterprise coordination and governance
The analysis identifies theoretical conditions under which such governance may support verifiable integrity, adaptive compliance, and access to formal markets.
Theoretical conditions derived from the review and theory synthesis (no empirical testing reported in this paper).
high positive RegTech-enabled governance of sanctions-safe enterprise ecos... verifiable integrity, adaptive compliance, access to formal markets
The study develops a theory-based framework explaining how RegTech-supported governance may, under specified conditions, enable sanctions-safe enterprise ecosystems during post-conflict reconstruction.
Primary contribution of the paper: theory synthesis built from integrative review of five literature streams (RegTech, sanctions compliance, institutional voids, supply-chain governance, algorithmic accountability).
high positive RegTech-enabled governance of sanctions-safe enterprise ecos... potential for RegTech-supported governance to enable sanctions-safe enterprise e...
Post-conflict reconstruction relies heavily on private enterprises to bring back employment, rebuild supply networks, and reconnect damaged economies.
Statement grounded in literature cited in the review (paper positions this as a general premise from post-conflict reconstruction literature); no primary data reported.
high positive RegTech-enabled governance of sanctions-safe enterprise ecos... role of private enterprises in employment recovery, supply-network rebuilding, a...
There is a positive spillover effect on AI-ineligible chats: treated workers adapted their multitasking workflow to devote greater attention to these chats.
Experiment-level observations comparing worker behavior on AI-ineligible chats between treatment and control; treated workers reallocated attention/effort (multitasking workflow changes) leading to improved attention on AI-ineligible chats.
high positive Agentic AI and Human-in-the-Loop Interventions: Field Experi... attention/effort devoted to AI-ineligible chats (spillover effect)
Early intervention is essential for sustaining high post-escalation intervention effort.
Temporal analysis of intervention timing within the randomized experiment showing an association between earlier human intervention after escalation and higher subsequent intervention effort.
high positive Agentic AI and Human-in-the-Loop Interventions: Field Experi... post-escalation intervention effort as a function of intervention timing
Human intervention preserves service quality in algorithm-triggered technical escalations (unresolved customer issues beyond the AI's capability).
Experimental subgroup analysis of escalations categorized as algorithm-triggered technical escalations; post-escalation human interventions were observed to maintain service quality in these cases.
high positive Agentic AI and Human-in-the-Loop Interventions: Field Experi... service quality after technical escalations
By reframing reskilling as a shared, supported, and bounded process, AI-driven change can foster long-term career resilience, professional identity renewal, and sustainable human–AI integration.
Conceptual conclusion/implication drawn by the authors from the proposed model and recommendations; no empirical validation included in the paper.
high positive AI-driven skill volatility and the emergence of re-skilling ... career resilience, professional identity renewal, quality of human–AI integratio...
The paper advances a set of sustainable, collective strategies—such as role-linked learning, protected learning time, skill prioritization, and phased AI adoption—to interrupt the reskilling loop and redistribute adaptive demands across organizations.
Prescriptive/theoretical recommendations proposed by the authors; no empirical evaluation or trial evidence presented.
high positive AI-driven skill volatility and the emergence of re-skilling ... effectiveness of organizational strategies in reducing reskilling burdens
The appropriate design response to Metis tasks is centaur architectures in which humans lead and AI supports, rather than pursuing further automation.
Prescriptive recommendation based on the conceptual analysis and normative reasoning in the paper; not supported by empirical evaluation or quantified comparisons of architectures.
high positive Metis AI: The Overlooked Middle Zone Between AI-Native and W... recommended human-AI system design
The study offers actionable insights for leaders seeking to balance innovation, capability development and ethical governance in AI-enabled workplaces while sustaining human interpretive authority, accountability and responsibility over time.
Implications and recommendations derived from the study's qualitative findings (28 interviews) and interpretive synthesis.
high positive Reimagining work in the age of intelligent automation: a qua... guidance for leadership on balancing innovation and governance
AI reshapes contemporary work by augmenting, rather than substituting, human roles.
Qualitative semistructured interviews with 28 managers and professionals from 12 organizations across technology, finance and knowledge-intensive services in Europe and Asia; thematic and interpretive analysis supported by organizational document review.
high positive Reimagining work in the age of intelligent automation: a qua... nature of human roles (augmentation vs substitution)
The study demonstrates that recent archival case evidence can be used rigorously to analyze an emerging strategic phenomenon without reducing the study to a purely descriptive literature review.
Methodological claim supported by the paper's demonstration of within-case coding and cross-case pattern matching applied to recent archival documents for the four firms.
high positive Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... validity and rigor of archival case methods for studying emerging strategic phen...
The paper develops a process view of AIECI built on sensing, interpretation, and orchestration as the sequence through which AI inputs are transformed into competitive intelligence capability, intelligence-informed decisions, and economic outcomes.
Theoretical contribution synthesized from cross-case analysis and conceptual development within the paper.
high positive Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... conceptual/process model of how AI inputs are transformed into economic outcomes...
Competitive intelligence (the process of sensing, interpreting, and orchestrating responses) rather than AI as a standalone automation tool is the strategic mechanism through which value is created.
Theoretical argument supported by within-case coding and cross-case synthesis of archival materials from four firms demonstrating how AI functions as part of an intelligence infrastructure rather than as isolated automation.
high positive Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... role of competitive intelligence as the mechanism linking AI inputs to economic ...
Across the four cases, AIECI delivered strategic speed under uncertainty (faster, better-timed decisions in uncertain environments).
Archival case evidence (public disclosures and corporate materials) showing firms using AI-enabled intelligence to accelerate decision cycles and respond more quickly to market signals.
high positive Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... strategic speed under uncertainty (reduced time-to-decision and faster strategic...
Across the four cases, AIECI improved allocation quality (better targeting and resource allocation decisions).
Within- and cross-case coding of corporate materials from the four sampled firms reporting improvements in campaign targeting, budget allocation, and resource deployment linked to AI-driven intelligence.
high positive Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... improved allocation quality (better targeting/allocating marketing and operation...
Across the four cases, AIECI produced efficiency gains and cost relief for firms.
Cross-case evidence from archival corporate disclosures and reports for Walmart, Unilever, Sprinklr, and DoubleVerify showing operational/marketing efficiencies and cost savings linked to AI-enabled competitive intelligence.
high positive Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... efficiency improvements and cost relief (reduced costs or improved resource use ...
Across the four cases, AIECI generated value through revenue acceleration.
Cross-case findings from a qualitative comparative multiple-case design using public archival evidence (annual reports, 10-Ks, earnings releases, corporate materials) for four firms (Walmart, Unilever, Sprinklr, DoubleVerify).
high positive Artificial Intelligence Enabled Competitive Intelligence as ... revenue acceleration (increased sales or faster revenue growth attributed to AIE...
We outline a research program for the runtime systems that foundation-model software agents will require.
Paper claims to present a forward-looking research agenda or program (stated in abstract); this is a conceptual contribution rather than an empirical finding.
high positive AI Harness Engineering: A Runtime Substrate for Foundation-M... research directions needed for runtime systems for foundation-model software age...
Applied to a controlled validation task, the framework yields episode packages whose evidence structure varies systematically with harness level: lower levels produce only a final patch, while higher levels produce reproduction logs, failure attributions, deterministic requirement checks, and structured verification reports.
Empirical application described in the abstract: framework applied to a controlled validation task showing systematic variation in episode-package evidence structure across harness levels. The abstract does not report sample size or statistical measures.
high positive AI Harness Engineering: A Runtime Substrate for Foundation-M... evidence structure of episode packages produced (types of artifacts: final patch...
We propose a trace-based evaluation protocol that converts each agent run into an auditable episode package.
Methodological proposal described in the abstract proposing a trace-based protocol and an auditable episode package format; no quantitative evaluation details provided in the abstract.
high positive AI Harness Engineering: A Runtime Substrate for Foundation-M... auditability of agent runs (availability of trace-based episode packages)
We operationalize the harness through a four-level ladder (H0–H3) that progressively exposes runtime support to the agent.
Design contribution described in the paper (abstract) introducing a four-level ladder (H0–H3) as an operationalization of the harness concept.
high positive AI Harness Engineering: A Runtime Substrate for Foundation-M... degree of runtime support exposed to an agent across harness levels
Foundation models have transformed automated code generation.
Statement in paper's abstract referring to broad impact of foundation models on automated code generation; likely supported by citations and literature overview within the paper (no sample size or quantitative study reported in the abstract).
high positive AI Harness Engineering: A Runtime Substrate for Foundation-M... ability of foundation models to generate code (automation of coding tasks)
The Agent-First paradigm is orthogonal and complementary to transport-layer standards such as MCP, operating as the semantic application layer above existing tool discovery and invocation protocols.
Conceptual argument and mapping presented in the paper asserting interoperability/orthogonality with transport-layer standards (e.g., MCP).
high positive Agent-First Tool API: A Semantic Interface Paradigm for Ente... compatibility_with_transport_layer_standards
Agent-First APIs improve autonomous error recovery by 5.8x (compared to optimized CRUD baselines).
Reported comparative experiments on 50 real operational tasks measuring autonomous error recovery capability.
high positive Agent-First Tool API: A Semantic Interface Paradigm for Ente... autonomous_error_recovery
Agent-First APIs reduce required human interventions by 72.7% (compared to optimized CRUD baselines).
Same set of comparative experiments on 50 real operational tasks reported in the paper.
high positive Agent-First Tool API: A Semantic Interface Paradigm for Ente... required_human_interventions
Comparative experiments on 50 real operational tasks demonstrate that Agent-First APIs achieve 88% end-to-end task success rate versus 64% for optimized CRUD baselines (+37.5%).
Empirical comparative experiments reported in the paper on 50 real operational tasks, comparing Agent-First APIs to optimized CRUD baselines.
high positive Agent-First Tool API: A Semantic Interface Paradigm for Ente... end-to-end_task_success_rate
The paradigm is implemented and validated in a production multi-tenant SaaS platform serving 85 registered tools across 6 business domains.
Reported production implementation and deployment statistics (platform with 85 registered tools spanning 6 business domains).
high positive Agent-First Tool API: A Semantic Interface Paradigm for Ente... deployment_of_paradigm_on_production_SaaS_platform
We propose the Agent-First Tool API paradigm, comprising three integrated mechanisms: (1) a Six-Verb Semantic Protocol that decomposes tool interactions into search, resolve, preview, execute, verify, and recover phases; (2) a Normalized Tool Contract (NTC) providing structured decision-support metadata including confidence scores, evidence chains, and suggested next actions; and (3) a dual-layer governance pipeline combining static capability policies with dynamic risk escalation.
Design and specification presented in the paper (proposed architecture and components).
high positive Agent-First Tool API: A Semantic Interface Paradigm for Ente... proposed_API_paradigm_and_components