The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Digests 🎲

Evidence (1286 claims)

Adoption
5126 claims
Productivity
4409 claims
Governance
4049 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
2954 claims
Labor Markets
2432 claims
Org Design
2273 claims
Innovation
2215 claims
Skills & Training
1902 claims
Inequality
1286 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 369 105 58 432 972
Governance & Regulation 365 171 113 54 713
Research Productivity 229 95 33 294 655
Organizational Efficiency 354 82 58 34 531
Technology Adoption Rate 277 115 63 27 486
Firm Productivity 273 33 68 10 389
AI Safety & Ethics 112 177 43 24 358
Output Quality 228 61 23 25 337
Market Structure 105 118 81 14 323
Decision Quality 154 68 33 17 275
Employment Level 68 32 74 8 184
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 74 52 32 21 183
Skill Acquisition 85 31 38 9 163
Firm Revenue 96 30 22 148
Innovation Output 100 11 20 11 143
Consumer Welfare 66 29 35 7 137
Regulatory Compliance 51 61 13 3 128
Inequality Measures 24 66 31 4 125
Task Allocation 64 6 28 6 104
Error Rate 42 47 6 95
Training Effectiveness 55 12 10 16 93
Worker Satisfaction 42 32 11 6 91
Task Completion Time 71 5 3 1 80
Wages & Compensation 38 13 19 4 74
Team Performance 41 8 15 7 72
Hiring & Recruitment 39 4 6 3 52
Automation Exposure 17 15 9 5 46
Job Displacement 5 28 12 45
Social Protection 18 8 6 1 33
Developer Productivity 25 1 2 1 29
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Creative Output 15 5 3 1 24
Skill Obsolescence 3 18 2 23
Labor Share of Income 7 4 9 20
Clear
Inequality Remove filter
Opacity, bias, and errors in AI systems demand auditing, standards, and governance (algorithmic accountability) to ensure trustworthy assessment.
Synthesis of literature on algorithmic bias and accountability plus policy analysis recommending audits and standards; supported by country cases that discuss governance concerns.
high negative The Future of Assessment: Rethinking Evaluation in an AI-Ass... algorithmic fairness, transparency, and reliability
Student data used by AI vendors raises risks around consent, reuse, commercial exploitation, and other data-privacy concerns.
Policy analysis and literature on data governance, privacy law debates; examples from national policy documents in the comparative cases. No original data on breaches or misuse presented.
high negative The Future of Assessment: Rethinking Evaluation in an AI-Ass... privacy risks and governance of student data
Inequities in climate-AI systems appear across three development phases—Inputs, Process, and Outputs—creating multiple failure points where Global North advantages propagate into final products.
Conceptual framework developed from cross-disciplinary synthesis, literature review, and illustrative examples (Inputs → Process → Outputs mapping).
high negative The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Presence of inequities at each phase of the AI development lifecycle (data avail...
Foundation-model development and high-performance computing (HPC) capacity are overwhelmingly located in the Global North.
Descriptive mapping of global HPC infrastructure and foundation-model authorship described in the paper (infrastructure mapping and authorship analysis). No single quantitative sample size reported; evidence based on spatial mapping and documented locations of compute centers and model-development institutions.
high negative The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Geographic distribution of HPC capacity and foundation-model development (locati...
Hierarchy compresses: fewer organizational layers are needed for a given firm output as coordination costs fall.
Analytical proposition in the theoretical model and simulation results showing reduced number of layers under coordination compression.
high negative AI as Coordination-Compressing Capital: Task Reallocation, O... number of hierarchical layers per firm
A one standard-deviation increase in AI adoption (2019–2025, 38 OECD countries) causally reduces employment in routine cognitive occupations by 2.3%.
Panel of 38 OECD countries, 2019–2025; AI Adoption Index (composite of enterprise AI investment, AI patent filings, workforce/firm AI-use surveys); instrumental-variable (IV) estimation to identify causal effect on occupational employment; country and year fixed effects and macro controls reported.
high negative Artificial Intelligence and Labor Market Transformation: Emp... Employment in routine cognitive occupations (percent change per 1 SD increase in...
Higher measured GDP need not imply higher aggregate welfare: the private costs of the arms race can outweigh the market gains from increased output.
Welfare comparisons performed in the model showing parameter regions where private equilibrium raises GDP but reduces aggregate welfare once investment costs are included.
high negative Janus-Faced Technological Progress and the Arms Race in the ... aggregate welfare (utility/net social surplus)
Because private incentives push agents toward tail outcomes, aggregate overinvestment occurs relative to the social optimum (the arms race is inefficient).
Welfare calculations and comparison of private vs social optima within the model; the paper shows private equilibrium investment exceeds the socially optimal investment given the externalities of the arms race.
high negative Janus-Faced Technological Progress and the Arms Race in the ... aggregate welfare (social welfare loss due to overinvestment)
Heterogeneity in study designs and contexts within the literature limits direct comparability and generalizability of findings.
Limitation noted in the paper based on the authors' assessment of diversity across the 103 reviewed studies (varying methods, contexts, metrics).
high negative Models, applications, and limitations of the responsible ado... comparability/generalizability of evidence across studies
Institutional inertia, fragmented governance structures, limited technical capacity, and weak data stewardship impede scale‑up of AI systems in the public sector.
Thematic synthesis of barriers reported across empirical studies and institutional reports within the systematic review (103 items).
high negative Models, applications, and limitations of the responsible ado... ability to scale AI systems / scale‑up rate
Low‑ and middle‑income contexts face persistent gaps—infrastructure, data ecosystems, and talent retention—that slow AI adoption in public governance.
Consistent findings across multiple studies in the 103‑item corpus reporting infrastructure deficits, weak data ecosystems, and brain drain/retention issues in LMIC settings.
high negative Models, applications, and limitations of the responsible ado... rate/extent of AI adoption in public governance in low- and middle‑income contex...
Risks include bias and discrimination, opacity in decision-making, privacy and cybersecurity threats, liability gaps, and uneven distribution of benefits that can exacerbate inequality.
Compilation from academic and policy literature, regulatory gap analyses, and examples of problematic AI use cases identified in the report's sectoral review.
high negative AI Governance and Data Privacy: Comparative Analysis of U.S.... bias/discrimination incidents, decision-making opacity, privacy/cybersecurity in...
AI creates significant ethical, legal and distributional risks.
Review of policy documents, academic and policy literature, and documented examples of AI deployment across multiple sectors highlighting harms (bias, privacy breaches, liability gaps, unequal benefits).
high negative AI Governance and Data Privacy: Comparative Analysis of U.S.... ethical risks, legal gaps, and distributional outcomes (inequality)
Reliance on imperfect data and model assumptions can produce biased or misleading forecasts; careful validation, transparency about assumptions, and governance are necessary.
Risks & governance discussion in the paper raising this limitation and recommending practices (qualitative argumentation).
high negative AI-Based Predictive Skill Gap Analysis for Workforce Plannin... risk of biased or misleading forecasts arising from data/model limitations (qual...
Significant financial and implementation barriers (infrastructure, staff, validation) risk worsening access inequities between well-resourced and low-resource providers.
Economic analyses, stakeholder surveys, and deployment trend reports synthesized in the paper showing higher upfront costs and validation burdens for adopters; no randomized trials.
high negative Framework for Government Policy on Agentic and Generative AI... access / equity disparities / adoption gap by resource level
Regulatory fragmentation and lack of harmonized standards increase compliance complexity for healthcare AI deployments.
Policy analyses, regulatory reviews, and industry reports synthesized in the paper describing divergent national/regional regulatory approaches and their operational consequences.
high negative Framework for Government Policy on Agentic and Generative AI... regulatory compliance complexity / administrative burden
Both open-source and proprietary approaches carry risks of algorithmic bias and fairness violations, especially when models are uncontrolled or poorly validated across populations.
Multiple peer-reviewed studies and audit reports summarized in the literature synthesis documenting bias/fairness issues across model types and populations.
high negative Framework for Government Policy on Agentic and Generative AI... bias / fairness metrics / differential performance across populations
Rural digital divides and uneven infrastructure constrain the reach of AI health solutions and risk exacerbating health inequities unless explicitly addressed.
Synthesis of infrastructure and equity literature, national connectivity data referenced in reviewed documents, and policy analyses included in the review period 2020–2025.
high negative Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare in Indonesia: Are We R... geographic disparities in digital infrastructure (broadband access, device avail...
Regulatory and governance frameworks for health AI in Indonesia are fragmented, with limited requirements for transparency/explainability and weak procurement/governance mechanisms.
Thematic analysis of national policy papers, SATUSEHAT governance reports, and regulatory documents identified in the 42 supplementary documents and literature review (2020–2025).
high negative Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare in Indonesia: Are We R... presence/strength of regulation and governance mechanisms (transparency requirem...
Data security, privacy risks, unequal gains, and regulatory shortfalls can undermine the benefits of AI/robotics adoption.
Policy and risk analyses from secondary literature, case studies, and institutional reports synthesized in the paper; examples cited but no original incident-level dataset or incidence rates provided.
high negative AI and Robotics Redefine Output and Growth: The New Producti... data/privacy risk incidence, inequality measures, regulatory adequacy (qualitati...
Transition frictions and skills mismatches are important barriers to workers moving into newly created AI‑related roles.
Qualitative review of workforce and skills literature, case studies, and sector reports; evidence comes from secondary sources with varied methodologies; the paper does not report pooled quantitative estimates.
high negative AI and Robotics Redefine Output and Growth: The New Producti... transition costs, skills mismatch incidence, retraining needs (labor market fric...
High upfront costs, weak digital/physical infrastructure, limited access to credit, low digital literacy, insecure land tenure, and sociocultural factors (including gendered access) limit uptake of digital and precision technologies among smallholders.
Consistent findings across program evaluations, qualitative stakeholder interviews, participatory assessments, and case studies cited in the synthesis.
high negative MODERN APPROACHES TO SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION technology adoption rates (uptake), barriers to adoption
Limited access to capital, data, digital infrastructure, skills, and insecure land tenure reduce adoption rates for advanced innovations among smallholders.
Multiple empirical studies and program evaluations synthesized in the review documenting adoption barriers; policy review identifying structural constraints across regions.
high negative MODERN APPROACHES TO SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION adoption rates of AI/IoT/precision tools, uptake of new practices
AI-driven impacts will be heterogeneous across education, race, gender, age, firm size, and geography, implying crucial equity concerns and the need for disaggregated reporting and targeted validation.
Policy analysis and literature synthesis in the paper; this claim reflects widely-documented labor economics findings about heterogeneous technological impacts though no new empirical breakdowns provided here.
high negative Enhancing BLS Methodologies for Projecting AI's Impact on Em... distribution of employment/wage/transition impacts across demographic and firm/r...
Key failure modes for AI in drug R&D include overfitting, poor generalizability, dataset bias, insufficient external validation, and misalignment with evolving regulatory expectations.
Synthesis of literature and case reports in the narrative review describing observed failures and risks across projects (qualitative evidence).
high negative Artificial Intelligence in Drug Discovery and Development: R... failure incidence of AI projects (model performance collapse, regulatory rejecti...
Absent rigorous controls (validation, applicability-domain reporting, attention to dataset bias), AI models risk overfitting, producing inequitable outcomes and regulatory friction that can undermine economic benefits.
Theoretical arguments plus case reports and literature cited in the review documenting instances and mechanisms of overfitting, dataset bias, and regulatory challenges; narrative summary rather than systematic quantification.
high negative Artificial Intelligence in Drug Discovery and Development: R... model generalizability (out-of-sample performance), subgroup performance dispari...
High linguistic diversity in Africa makes building and evaluating multilingual language technologies more difficult and is a barrier to inclusive AI.
Synthesis of technical literature on NLP and multilingual model development and policy/NGO reports highlighting missing language resources; no original model evaluation reported.
high negative Towards Responsible Artificial Intelligence Adoption: Emergi... language technology availability, model performance across African languages, nu...
Structural constraints—limited digital infrastructure, scarce and skewed data, and high linguistic diversity—complicate AI development, deployment and evaluation in African contexts.
Desk review of infrastructure and data availability reports and scholarly literature demonstrating gaps and their effects; no new measurement in this paper.
high negative Towards Responsible Artificial Intelligence Adoption: Emergi... internet/digital infrastructure coverage, availability and representativeness of...
Algorithmic bias, unequal digital financial literacy, caregiving time constraints, and limited access to personalized solutions can sustain or reproduce gender investment gaps if not addressed.
Synthesis of literature on barriers to financial inclusion and AI fairness concerns, plus platform report observations (review of empirical and conceptual studies; not a single empirical test).
high negative Women's Investment Behaviour and Technology: Exploring the I... gender investment gap, differential product offerings, access metrics
Women statistically exhibit greater risk aversion in some settings compared with men.
Summary of empirical survey and experimental studies on gender differences in risk attitudes discussed in the review (multiple cross‑sectional and lab/field experiments referenced).
high negative Women's Investment Behaviour and Technology: Exploring the I... measured risk aversion / willingness to take financial risk
The digital divide (lack of reliable electricity and connectivity) constrains adoption of MIS and AI, creating geographic and regional inequities in who benefits from the framework.
Infrastructure constraint argument presented in the paper; no quantified coverage maps or population-level access statistics included.
high negative Establishes a technical and academic bridge between the educ... coverage of system access, differential adoption rates by region, inequality in ...
AI-driven equivalency systems carry risks including algorithmic bias, opaque decisions without explainability, and potential reinforcement of inequities when training data under-represents some regions/institutions.
Risk assessment drawing on established AI ethics literature; no empirical bias audit from the proposed system is provided.
high negative Establishes a technical and academic bridge between the educ... measures of algorithmic bias (disparate impact), explainability scores, unequal ...
The major disadvantage of an MIS is dependency on reliable electricity and internet, creating systemic vulnerability due to the digital divide.
Paper notes infrastructure dependency as a constraint; assertion grounded in common infrastructural realities but no measured connectivity or outage statistics from DRC/SA are provided.
high negative Establishes a technical and academic bridge between the educ... geographic/regional access to equivalency services and system uptime availabilit...
Antibiotic use in humans and animals, along with environmental antibiotic residues, generates converging selection pressures that drive AMR relevant to children.
Well-established ecological and microbiological literature summarized in the review showing cross-sector selection pressures; narrative integration rather than new empirical analysis.
high negative Safeguarding future generations: a One Health perspective on... selection and dissemination of antimicrobial resistance genes/pathogens across h...
Child behaviors (hand-to-mouth activity, play, outdoor exposure) increase contact with environmental and animal reservoirs and therefore exposure risk.
Behavioral and exposure studies synthesized narratively; observational evidence from exposure assessments and pediatric environmental health studies cited in review (no meta-analysis).
high negative Safeguarding future generations: a One Health perspective on... frequency/intensity of contact with environmental/animal reservoirs and resultan...
Developmental windows imply early-life exposures can have long-term consequences for health and human capital.
Developmental and epidemiologic literature integrated in the review; narrative citations of studies linking early exposures to later health and cognitive outcomes (no single longitudinal dataset presented).
high negative Safeguarding future generations: a One Health perspective on... long-term health, cognitive development, and human-capital outcomes following ea...
Physiological and immunological immaturity (including neonatal risks) increases children's susceptibility to infectious disease and related harms.
Established biological and clinical literature synthesized in the review; references to neonatal clinical risks and immunological immaturity across pediatric literature (no pooled effect sizes reported).
high negative Safeguarding future generations: a One Health perspective on... susceptibility to infection and severity of disease in neonates and young childr...
Platforms benefit from data-driven scalability and network effects, creating barriers to entry and affecting consumer surplus, innovation incentives, and pricing.
Economic theory of platforms and empirical cases from platform markets synthesized in the literature review; argument supported by secondary empirical studies cited.
high negative Financial Inclusion in the Age of FinTech Platforms: Opportu... barriers to entry; consumer surplus; prices; innovation indicators
Market concentration and network effects create platform power that may squeeze smaller providers, raise costs, or lock users into ecosystems.
Platform economics literature and case examples reviewed in the paper; conceptual and theoretical support with illustrative empirical instances from secondary sources.
high negative Financial Inclusion in the Age of FinTech Platforms: Opportu... market concentration measures; prices/costs to users; switching costs/lock-in
Infrastructure gaps (connectivity, electricity, identity systems) limit who benefits from digital finance.
Cross-country and development literature synthesized in the paper highlighting correlations between infrastructure availability and digital finance uptake; no primary empirical analysis in the paper.
high negative Financial Inclusion in the Age of FinTech Platforms: Opportu... uptake/usage of digital financial services conditional on infrastructure availab...
Measurement issues (task-based output measurement, attributing output changes to AI) and selection into early adoption bias estimated productivity gains upward.
Methodological robustness checks reported in the paper: task-based measures, bounding exercises, placebo tests, and analysis of pre-trends; discussions of selection on unobservables and potential upward bias.
high negative S-TCO: A Sustainable Teacher Context Ontology for Educationa... validity/bias of estimated productivity effects
AI automates routine and some mid-skill tasks, reducing employment in those occupations.
Empirical task-based exposure measures mapping AI capabilities to occupational task content, microdata analyses of employment by occupation using household/employer/administrative datasets, and panel regressions/decompositions that document within-occupation declines and between-occupation shifts.
high negative Intelligence and Labor Market Transformation: A Critical Ana... employment levels in routine and mid-skill occupations
Relying on secondary literature limits the paper's ability to make causal inferences and constrains empirical generalizability to all sectors or countries.
Stated limitations in the paper's Data & Methods section acknowledging scope and inferential constraints.
high negative Who Loses to Automation? AI-Driven Labour Displacement and t... causal inference strength and generalizability of conclusions
Increases in K_T reduce employment levels in affected firms and industries even when aggregate productivity rises.
Panel econometric estimates at firm and industry levels relating K_T intensity to employment outcomes, controlling for demand, input prices, and firm characteristics; difference-in-differences specifications and instrumental-variable robustness checks; corroborated by sectoral case studies.
high negative The Macroeconomic Transition of Technological Capital in the... employment (firm- and industry-level employment counts or employment growth)
Rising technological capital (K_T) — proxied by robot/automation density, software and intangible capital accumulation, AI adoption surveys, and AI-related patenting — leads to a decline in labor’s share of output.
Firm- and industry-level panel regressions linking constructed K_T intensity measures to labor shares, supported by macro growth-accounting decompositions; robustness checks include difference-in-differences and instrumenting adoption with plausibly exogenous shocks (e.g., cross-border technology diffusion, trade shocks); validated with cross-country comparisons and case studies.
high negative The Macroeconomic Transition of Technological Capital in the... labor share of income (share of output paid to labor)
AI’s societal integration in India is gradual, and therefore its impact on economic variables (like wages and inequality) is also gradual.
Synthesis in the paper based on empirical adoption figures (e.g., <0.7% adoption for AI ride services) and the observed weak changes in inequality measures in the transportation sector.
high null result Artificial Intelligence, Demand Switching and Sectoral Wage ... pace of AI integration and consequent economic impact
Despite AI’s introduction, wage inequality in the transportation sector (measured by the Gini coefficient) has not significantly worsened.
Empirical investigation reported in the paper analyzing transportation-sector wage disparities over time using the Gini coefficient; the paper reports no significant worsening post-introduction.
high null result Artificial Intelligence, Demand Switching and Sectoral Wage ... Gini coefficient of wages in the transportation sector
These energy reductions are achieved without statistically significant performance loss.
Paper states that performance loss is not statistically significant across the evaluated benchmarks (as reported in the abstract).
high null result EcoThink: A Green Adaptive Inference Framework for Sustainab... model performance / benchmark accuracy (no statistically significant degradation...
The study uses a mixed-methods approach combining qualitative insights from 1,500 semi-structured customer interviews with quantitative analysis of transaction records, loan repayment histories, and account activity.
Paper states methods explicitly in abstract: 1,500 semi-structured interviews plus quantitative analysis of transaction records, loan repayment histories, and account activity (case-study approach across three platforms).
This paper uses panel data of China's Shanghai and Shenzhen A-share non-financial listed companies from 2010 to 2022 to study AI's effects.
Explicit data description in the paper (sample frame and period stated).
high null result THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON ENTERPRISE INCOME D... n/a (methodological/data claim)