The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (3231 claims)

Adoption
7395 claims
Productivity
6507 claims
Governance
5921 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
5192 claims
Org Design
3497 claims
Innovation
3492 claims
Labor Markets
3231 claims
Skills & Training
2608 claims
Inequality
1842 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 609 159 77 738 1617
Governance & Regulation 671 334 160 99 1285
Organizational Efficiency 626 147 105 70 955
Technology Adoption Rate 502 176 98 78 861
Research Productivity 349 109 48 322 838
Output Quality 391 121 45 40 597
Firm Productivity 385 46 85 17 539
Decision Quality 277 145 63 34 526
AI Safety & Ethics 189 244 59 30 526
Market Structure 152 154 109 20 440
Task Allocation 158 50 56 26 295
Innovation Output 178 23 38 17 257
Skill Acquisition 137 52 50 13 252
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 120 64 38 23 252
Employment Level 93 46 96 12 249
Firm Revenue 130 43 26 3 202
Consumer Welfare 99 51 40 11 201
Inequality Measures 36 106 40 6 188
Task Completion Time 134 18 6 5 163
Worker Satisfaction 79 54 16 11 160
Error Rate 64 79 8 1 152
Regulatory Compliance 69 66 14 3 152
Training Effectiveness 82 16 13 18 131
Wages & Compensation 70 25 22 6 123
Team Performance 74 16 21 9 121
Automation Exposure 41 48 19 9 120
Job Displacement 11 71 16 1 99
Developer Productivity 71 14 9 3 98
Hiring & Recruitment 49 7 8 3 67
Social Protection 26 14 8 2 50
Creative Output 26 14 6 2 49
Skill Obsolescence 5 37 5 1 48
Labor Share of Income 12 13 12 37
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Labor Markets Remove filter
The paper advances a replicable interdisciplinary synthesis method and provides a simulated dataset and transparent protocols enabling other researchers to adapt the approach.
Methods section detailing systematic literature search protocols (ACM/IEEE/Springer, 2020–2024), inclusion criteria, simulation parameterization for the cross-sectoral dataset (seven industries, 2020–2024), and stated reproducibility materials.
high positive AI-Driven Transformation of Labor Markets: Skill Shifts, Hyb... Availability and description of reproducible methods and a simulated dataset (re...
AI adoption is strongly associated with workforce skill transformation (reported correlation r = 0.71).
Correlational analysis reported in the paper using the simulated cross-sectoral dataset that mirrors employment trends across seven industries (Manufacturing, Healthcare, Finance, Education, Transportation, Retail, IT Services) over 2020–2024. This corresponds to sector-year observations (7 sectors × 5 years = 35 observations) and is triangulated with findings from a systematic literature synthesis (ACM, IEEE, Springer publications 2020–2024).
high positive AI-Driven Transformation of Labor Markets: Skill Shifts, Hyb... Skill shift index (measure of changes in required skills and task composition)
Research priorities include rigorous real-world trials assessing patient outcomes, cost-effectiveness, and labor impacts; comparative studies of integration strategies; measurement of long-run workforce effects; and development of standard metrics and monitoring frameworks.
Explicit recommendations from the narrative review based on identified gaps: scarcity of RCTs, economic analyses, and long-term workforce studies.
high positive Human-AI interaction and collaboration in radiology: from co... number and quality of real-world trials, existence of standardized monitoring fr...
Reward shaping at the assignment layer enables an explicit trade-off between diagnostic accuracy and human labor by incorporating penalties for human involvement.
Methodology section describing reward shaping and experimental comparisons showing different accuracy/human-effort trade-offs (results reported in paper; exact experimental details not provided in the summary).
high positive Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning Based Human-AI Online Di... diagnostic accuracy vs human effort (as controlled by reward shaping)
Masked reinforcement learning techniques constrain or mask action spaces, reducing exploration over huge symptom/action spaces.
Paper describes use of masked RL to limit action options during training and execution; used in both assignment and execution layers (methodological claim supported by algorithmic description and experiments).
high positive Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning Based Human-AI Online Di... action-space reduction / sample efficiency / learning stability (as applied to s...
The upper layer ('master') learns turn-by-turn human–machine assignment using masked reinforcement learning with reward shaping to balance accuracy and human cost.
Methodological description in the paper and empirical results from experiments using masked RL and reward-shaped objectives at the assignment layer (implementation and experimental setup reported; dataset/sample size not specified in summary).
high positive Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning Based Human-AI Online Di... assignment policy performance; human effort allocation; diagnostic accuracy unde...
Returns to advanced digital skills vary by firm size/type: the wage return in large Chaebol conglomerates is approximately 18.7%, significantly higher than the ~9.5% return in Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs), indicating a 'skills–scale' complementarity effect.
Heterogeneity analysis within the extended Mincerian wage regression framework using KLIPS micro-data, comparing estimated returns across firm types (Chaebol vs SMEs). (Sample size and exact model specification not provided in the excerpt.)
high positive Measuring the Economic Returns of Vocational Digital Skills ... wage/worker compensation (percentage wage premiums by firm type: Chaebol ≈ 18.7%...
Workers with only general digital literacy receive a wage premium of approximately 5.8% (after controlling for education, experience, and demographics).
Same empirical framework: extended Mincerian wage equation on KLIPS micro-data with controls for education, experience, and demographic characteristics. (Sample size not specified in the provided excerpt.)
high positive Measuring the Economic Returns of Vocational Digital Skills ... wage/worker compensation (percentage wage premium ≈ 5.8%)
Workers possessing specialized digital skills (e.g., data analysis, programming, automation control) enjoy a significant wage premium of approximately 14.2% after controlling for years of education, work experience, and demographic characteristics.
Empirical estimation using an extended Mincerian wage equation on micro-data from the Korean Labor and Income Panel Study (KLIPS); models control for years of education, work experience, and demographic covariates. (Sample size not specified in the provided excerpt.)
high positive Measuring the Economic Returns of Vocational Digital Skills ... wage/worker compensation (percentage wage premium ≈ 14.2%)
The model is disciplined using data from the Michigan Survey of Consumers and the Survey of Professional Forecasters, targeting key empirical moments.
Calibration/estimation strategy described in the paper: parameters are chosen to match moments from the Michigan Survey of Consumers and SPF (targeted empirical moments). Specific moments and calibration targets are reported in the paper.
high positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics fit to targeted empirical moments (e.g., expectation dispersion, persistence mea...
I develop a search-and-matching model with sticky wages and endogenous separations.
Theoretical/model contribution: construction and analysis of a calibrated search-and-matching framework that incorporates wage stickiness and endogenous separation decisions.
high positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics wage dynamics and separation rates as generated by the model
Workers and firms face information frictions about the aggregate state of the economy (modeled explicitly).
Assumption and mechanism built into the paper's theoretical framework: a search-and-matching model with information frictions for both sides of the market (model specification).
high positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics information precision / belief heterogeneity about aggregate state (model primit...
Households form dispersed, backward-looking expectations about macroeconomic conditions.
Survey evidence from the Michigan Survey of Consumers showing dispersion in individual expectations and patterns consistent with backward-looking (slow/updating) belief formation about macro variables; exact sample sizes and empirical specifications are provided in the paper (not in the summary).
high positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics dispersion and updating dynamics of households' macroeconomic expectations
DARE posits that responsible AI deployment requires the simultaneous and integrated development of Digital readiness, Administrative governance, Resilience & ethics, and Economic equity.
Descriptive claim about the framework's components as reported in the abstract (conceptual proposition).
high positive The DARE framework: a global model for responsible artificia... responsible AI deployment (dependent on development across four DARE dimensions)
This paper introduces the DARE Framework, a holistic, four-dimensional model for national AI strategy and international cooperation.
Factual description of paper content in abstract — the framework is introduced by the authors (conceptual/model contribution).
high positive The DARE framework: a global model for responsible artificia... existence/introduction of a conceptual framework (DARE) for AI strategy
AI tools—ranging from machine learning algorithms in inventory management to natural language processing in customer engagement—are applied in micro‑enterprise contexts.
Descriptive synthesis from included articles reporting specific AI applications (ML for inventory management; NLP for customer engagement) across the reviewed literature.
high positive Role of AI in Enhancing Work Efficiency and Opportunities fo... types of AI applications deployed in micro‑enterprise settings (e.g., ML, NLP)
Global efforts toward establishing shared norms and multilateral cooperation are underway through initiatives led by the United Nations, OECD, UNESCO, and G7.
Qualitative document review identifying initiatives and normative efforts by multilateral organizations (organizations named; specific initiatives referenced qualitatively but not enumerated as a dataset).
high positive The Geopolitics of Artificial Intelligence: Power, Regulatio... existence and activity of multilateral initiatives for AI norms (UN, OECD, UNESC...
The study builds and calibrates an integrated system dynamics model that connects demographics, labor supply, economic output, and public finance.
Method: development and calibration of a system dynamics model using official statistics for demographics, labor, output, and fiscal variables (model structure and calibration described in paper).
high positive Fiscal Dynamics in Japan under Demographic Pressure model structure linking demographic cohorts, labor supply, GDP/productivity, tax...
The paper ends with policy implications and recommends periodic evaluation and the integration of AI-related risks into financial governance.
Policy recommendations section in the paper advocating for periodic evaluation and AI-risk integration into financial governance (method: prescriptive/policy analysis based on review findings).
high positive THE LABOR MARKET IN TERMS OF THE SHADOW DIGITAL ECONOMY recommended policy actions (periodic evaluation; AI-risk integration)
Specialized SDE services that require further study are grouped and highlighted.
Section of the paper grouping and highlighting specialized services for future research (method: expert-driven identification from review; no quantitative prioritization stated).
high positive THE LABOR MARKET IN TERMS OF THE SHADOW DIGITAL ECONOMY identification of specialized services needing further study
We introduce a concise conceptual model of a 'shadow' project for designing SDE products or services, detailing participant roles and project composition.
Presentation of a conceptual model within the paper (method: model construction and descriptive exposition; no empirical testing/sample).
high positive THE LABOR MARKET IN TERMS OF THE SHADOW DIGITAL ECONOMY availability of a conceptual 'shadow project' model
The paper proposes a clear classification of criminally oriented products and services in the SDE.
Taxonomy/classification produced in the paper (method: conceptual taxonomy from literature and analysis; no quantitative validation reported).
high positive THE LABOR MARKET IN TERMS OF THE SHADOW DIGITAL ECONOMY classification completeness/coverage of criminal products and services
We identify a structured set of labor‑market roles within the SDE model.
Analytical identification and description of roles within the paper (method: conceptual modeling and qualitative role-mapping; sample size N/A).
high positive THE LABOR MARKET IN TERMS OF THE SHADOW DIGITAL ECONOMY catalogue/structure of labor-market roles in SDE
We propose an integrated definition of the shadow digital economy that synthesizes technical and economic definitions.
Conceptual analysis and literature synthesis in the paper that combines technical and economic definitions into a single integrated definition (method: review/synthesis; no numeric sample).
high positive THE LABOR MARKET IN TERMS OF THE SHADOW DIGITAL ECONOMY conceptual clarity / definitional synthesis
General US employment for prime age workers (age 25–54) is currently high (~80%).
Paper cites a current employment rate of 80% for prime-age workers; likely based on national labor statistics though the exact data source and year are not specified in the excerpt.
high positive Current Labor Challenges and Opportunities in Nursery Crops ... employment rate for prime-age (25–54) population
The growth effect of AI exhibits industry heterogeneity: high‑tech manufacturing industries benefit more significantly.
Heterogeneity/subgroup regressions on the 2003–2017 Chinese industry panel showing larger estimated AI effects in high‑tech manufacturing sectors.
high positive The Impact of Artificial Intelligence Development on Economi... industry growth rate in high‑tech manufacturing
The positive effect of AI on industry growth increases over time.
Dynamic/DID analysis across the 2003–2017 panel showing that the estimated treatment effect grows larger in later periods.
high positive The Impact of Artificial Intelligence Development on Economi... industry growth rate over time (time-varying treatment effect)
The industry growth rate of the treatment group (industries with intensive AI application or high AI patent concentration) is significantly higher than that of the control group.
DID comparison between treatment and control industry groups in the China 2003–2017 panel, where treatment is defined by intensive AI application or AI patent concentration.
AI technology innovation has a significant positive impact on economic growth.
Industry panel data for Chinese industries from 2003 to 2017 analyzed using a differences-in-differences (DID) approach; main specification estimates effect of AI-related innovation on economic growth.
high positive The Impact of Artificial Intelligence Development on Economi... economic growth (industry-level growth rate)
The weeder was equipped with a Raspberry Pi microcontroller and a camera module to detect crops and weeds in real-time, enabling autonomous operation.
Design description in the paper: hardware integration of Raspberry Pi and camera module for real-time detection (method: system design and implementation). No sample size or quantitative test data reported for detection accuracy in the provided summary.
high positive AI-Enabled Wi-Fi Operated Robotic Weeder for Precision Weed ... real-time crop/weed detection and autonomous operation (system capability)
Platform work accounts for 12.8% of labor income for participants in the studied sample.
Earnings and income calculations using platform transaction records combined with labor force survey and administrative income data for the 24-country sample (2015–2025).
high positive The Gig Economy and Labor Market Restructuring: Platform Wor... share of participants' labor income derived from platform work (%)
Platform-mediated gig work has grown to represent 4.2% of total employment across 24 OECD countries (2015–2025).
Aggregate analysis of administrative data, national labor force surveys, and platform transaction records covering 24 OECD countries over the 2015–2025 period.
high positive The Gig Economy and Labor Market Restructuring: Platform Wor... share of total employment represented by platform-mediated gig work (%)
The study reframes AI as an augmentation mechanism rather than a substitute for managerial judgment and extends organizational decision theory to account for socio-technical decision systems.
Theoretical contribution asserted by the paper based on its literature synthesis and conceptual development (claim about extension of theory rather than empirical test).
high positive Reframing Organizational Decision-Making in the Age of Artif... theoretical framing of AI's role in organizational decision theory (augmentation...
The paper develops an integrative conceptual framework that explains how human judgment, algorithmic intelligence, and organizational context interact to shape decision quality and organizational outcomes.
Author-constructed conceptual framework based on synthesized literature across decision sciences, management, and information systems (framework described as output of the meta-analysis; no empirical validation reported in abstract).
high positive Reframing Organizational Decision-Making in the Age of Artif... decision quality and organizational outcomes as shaped by interaction among huma...
The model was prompted to suggest jobs to 24 simulated candidate profiles balanced in terms of gender, age, experience and professional field.
Methods reported in the paper: experimental prompting of GPT-5 with N=24 simulated profiles, balanced across specified attributes.
high positive Gender Bias in Generative AI-assisted Recruitment Processes number and composition of simulated candidate profiles used in the experiment
This study evaluates how a state-of-the-art generative model (GPT-5) suggests occupations based on gender and work experience background for under-35-year-old Italian graduates.
Study design described in the paper: targeted population (under-35 Italian graduates), model used (GPT-5) and evaluation focus (occupation suggestions).
high positive Gender Bias in Generative AI-assisted Recruitment Processes occupation suggestions produced by GPT-5 for specified candidate profiles
Common AI applications in accounting include transaction automation, invoice processing, reconciliations, fraud detection, anomaly detection, automated financial reporting, and predictive forecasting.
Descriptive listing drawn from academic and industry sources/case studies summarized in the paper.
high positive Role of Artificial Intelligence in the Accounting Sector presence/use of specific AI applications (binary/coverage across firms)
Two regimes emerge: an inequality-increasing regime when AI is proprietary (concentrated control), rents concentrate because firms capture most gains (low ξ), and complementary assets are concentrated.
Model regime characterization and calibrated simulations showing rising firm profits and aggregate inequality under proprietary-AI assumptions and low rent-sharing elasticity.
high positive When AI Levels the Playing Field: Skill Homogenization, Asse... firm profits, wage shares, and aggregate inequality (ΔGini)
Generative AI shifts economic value toward concentrated complementary assets (firm-level capital, proprietary data/algorithms), increasing firm profits and rents captured by asset owners.
Model results from a task-based framework with heterogeneous firms and complementary assets; calibration via MSM to six empirical moments; counterfactuals show increased profit shares when AI confers advantages to firms owning complementary assets.
high positive When AI Levels the Playing Field: Skill Homogenization, Asse... firm profits / rent share attributable to complementary assets
Structural breaks in patenting dynamics are concentrated after 2010, consistent with an inflection in AI diffusion and commercialization.
Application of structural-break detection methods to patent filing time series (1980–2019) across domains; reported concentration of detected breakpoints after 2010. (Paper reports timing and clustering of breaks; exact statistical tests not enumerated in the summary.)
high positive The "Gold Rush" in AI and Robotics Patenting Activity. Do in... timing and frequency of detected structural breaks in patent filing time series
Patenting in AI-enhanced robotics experienced a sharp acceleration beginning in the early 2010s.
Observed marked upturn in the AI-enhanced robotics patent time series from the early 2010s onward (patent filings 1980–2019). Structural break tests applied to the time series identify an acceleration concentrated after 2010.
high positive The "Gold Rush" in AI and Robotics Patenting Activity. Do in... annual patent filings in AI-enhanced robotics (rate of change / acceleration)
A dynamic Occupational AI Exposure Score (OAIES) that uses LLMs plus occupational task data can estimate time-varying, task-level AI exposure for occupations and workers.
Paper describes a concrete construction algorithm (task decomposition from O*NET/task inventories, LLM-based capability mapping, augmentation vs automation weighting, diffusion/adoption dynamics, and calibration to observed employment/wage/gross-flow changes). This is a proposed method rather than an applied/validated implementation.
high positive Enhancing BLS Methodologies for Projecting AI's Impact on Em... time-varying task-level AI exposure scores (OAIES)
From interview-based evidence the authors constructed a conceptual framework that integrates empirical insights with existing theories to explain how human–AI interaction alters design cognition.
Synthesis of qualitative interview findings with literature on creative cognition and design thinking; framework presented as an output of the study (framework construction described in paper).
high positive Human–AI Collaboration in Architectural Design Education: To... conceptual framework generation / theoretical integration
A Random Survival Forest built on curated cancer‑death‑related genes (CDRG‑RSF) achieved the best long‑term prognostic performance among 14 tested ML algorithms for pancreatic cancer, with 3‑ and 5‑year AUCs > 0.7.
Comparison of 14 ML survival algorithms on curated prognostic genes; Random Survival Forest (CDRG‑RSF) reported superior 3‑ and 5‑year AUCs exceeding 0.7 (exact sample sizes/cohort details not provided in summary).
high positive Editorial: Integrating machine learning and AI in biological... 3‑ and 5‑year survival AUC (prognostic accuracy)
Experimental knockdown of PSME3 reduced proliferation and invasion and increased apoptosis in LUAD cells, implicating the PI3K/AKT/Bcl‑2 pathway as a mediator.
Functional assays (gene knockdown experiments) reported in the PIGRS study showing decreased proliferation/invasion and increased apoptosis after PSME3 knockdown, with pathway analyses implicating PI3K/AKT/Bcl‑2.
high positive Editorial: Integrating machine learning and AI in biological... Cell proliferation, invasion, apoptosis; downstream pathway activity (PI3K/AKT/B...
Deep neural networks (DNNs) better captured cross‑study differential expression (DEA) signals when predicting miRNA from mRNA than sparse linear models (LASSO); for HIV the cross‑study log2 fold‑change (log2FC) correlation was approximately R ≈ 0.59 for the DNN approach.
Analysis on seven paired viral infection datasets (including WNV and HIV); compared DNNs vs. LASSO for mRNA→miRNA prediction; reported cross‑study log2FC correlation R ≈ 0.59 for HIV for the DNNs. Methods included differential expression signal recovery across studies.
high positive Editorial: Integrating machine learning and AI in biological... Cross‑study correlation of predicted vs observed log2FC (DEA signal recovery)
An AI‑powered pipeline (EPheClass) produced a parsimonious saliva microbiome classifier for periodontal disease with AUC = 0.973 using 13 features.
EPheClass pipeline using ensemble ML (kNN, RF, SVM, XGBoost, MLP), centred log‑ratio (CLR) transform and Recursive Feature Elimination (RFE); reported performance AUC = 0.973 for periodontal disease model with 13 features (sample size not specified in summary).
high positive Editorial: Integrating machine learning and AI in biological... Classification AUC for periodontal disease (saliva)
Higher job performance is positively associated with greater employee retention.
PLS-SEM analysis, N = 350. Reported direct path: Performance → Retention, β = 0.348, p < 0.001.
The paper identifies gaps and recommends that economists conduct randomized evaluations and quasi-experimental studies to estimate causal effects of interventions (hands-on labs, instructor training, compute subsidies) on competencies and earnings.
Policy and research agenda section of the paper arguing for randomized/quasi-experimental methods; no such causal interventions were implemented in this study.
high positive Exploring Student and Educator Challenges in AI Competency D... suggested future measurement targets: causal effects of specific interventions o...
The study conducted a cross-sectional online survey of more than 600 higher-education students and educators from multiple world regions.
Cross-sectional online survey; sample size reported as >600 participants; recruitment targeted a mix of disciplines and institution types; survey mapped to UNESCO 2024 AI competency frameworks.
high positive Exploring Student and Educator Challenges in AI Competency D... sample size and participant composition (number of respondents; roles: students ...