The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Digests 🎲

Evidence (3062 claims)

Adoption
5227 claims
Productivity
4503 claims
Governance
4100 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
3062 claims
Labor Markets
2480 claims
Innovation
2320 claims
Org Design
2305 claims
Skills & Training
1920 claims
Inequality
1311 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 373 105 59 439 984
Governance & Regulation 366 172 115 55 718
Research Productivity 237 95 34 294 664
Organizational Efficiency 364 82 62 34 545
Technology Adoption Rate 293 118 66 30 511
Firm Productivity 274 33 68 10 390
AI Safety & Ethics 117 178 44 24 365
Output Quality 231 61 23 25 340
Market Structure 107 123 85 14 334
Decision Quality 158 68 33 17 279
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 75 52 32 21 187
Employment Level 70 32 74 8 186
Skill Acquisition 88 31 38 9 166
Firm Revenue 96 34 22 152
Innovation Output 105 12 21 11 150
Consumer Welfare 68 29 35 7 139
Regulatory Compliance 52 61 13 3 129
Inequality Measures 24 68 31 4 127
Task Allocation 71 10 29 6 116
Worker Satisfaction 46 38 12 9 105
Error Rate 42 47 6 95
Training Effectiveness 55 12 11 16 94
Task Completion Time 76 5 4 2 87
Wages & Compensation 46 13 19 5 83
Team Performance 44 9 15 7 76
Hiring & Recruitment 39 4 6 3 52
Automation Exposure 18 16 9 5 48
Job Displacement 5 29 12 46
Social Protection 19 8 6 1 34
Developer Productivity 27 2 3 1 33
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Creative Output 15 5 3 1 24
Skill Obsolescence 3 18 2 23
Labor Share of Income 8 4 9 21
Clear
Human Ai Collab Remove filter
Caseworker performance significantly improves as chatbot quality improves.
Aggregated results from the randomized experiment show monotonic improvement in caseworker accuracy as the chatbot suggestion accuracy increases; paper states the improvement is statistically significant (specific p-values/statistical tests not provided in the excerpt).
high positive LLMs in social services: How does chatbot accuracy affect hu... caseworker accuracy as a function of chatbot suggestion quality
The authors curated a set of guidelines called the Incentive-Tuning Framework to aid researchers in designing effective incentive schemes for human–AI decision-making studies.
Authors' contribution described in the paper: development of a framework (framework content and evaluation details not provided in excerpt).
high positive Incentive-Tuning: Understanding and Designing Incentives for... guidance for incentive design (qualitative artifact intended to influence study ...
The intelligent scheduling model incorporates legal, contractual, skill-based, and preference-aware constraints to generate equitable and efficient rosters.
Methodological description of constraints encoded in the optimization model for scheduling; experimental validation of resulting rosters reported (conflict reduction and fairness metrics), but specific constraint formulations and datasets are not detailed in the excerpt.
high positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... compliance with constraints and roster equity/efficiency
The performance evaluation framework combines structured metrics (task completion, attendance, punctuality) with unstructured feedback (patient surveys, peer reviews) analyzed using natural language processing.
Methodological description in the paper of the performance evaluation module and use of NLP for unstructured feedback analysis; implementation details and dataset sizes not specified in the excerpt.
high positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... staff performance measurement (task completion, attendance, punctuality) and sen...
The proposed AI-driven HRM framework integrates forecasting, optimization, and performance evaluation to enhance workforce planning, staff scheduling, and continuous assessment.
Methodological contribution described in the paper: framework design with three core modules (demand forecasting, intelligent scheduling, performance evaluation); validated via experiments on synthetic and real hospital datasets (dataset sizes not specified in the text).
high positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... overall workforce planning, scheduling efficiency, and assessment capability (ar...
The study extends human capital theory by integrating emotional and psychological dimensions into explanations of productivity and employment outcomes.
Theoretical contribution asserted by the authors based on their empirical findings linking emotional intelligence and psychological factors to economic outcomes; this is a conceptual extension rather than a statistical result.
high positive Emotional Intelligence as Human Capital: A Behavioral Econom... theoretical framework (human capital theory integration)
Twelve testable hypotheses are proposed, with implications for agentic AI oversight and human-AI collaboration.
Paper statement that it proposes twelve testable hypotheses; verifiable by counting hypotheses in the paper.
high positive AI Knows What's Wrong But Cannot Fix It: Helicoid Dynamics i... number of hypotheses proposed (count = 12)
Persistent environmental state induces history sensitivity (dependence of long-run behavior on past trajectories and initial conditions) unless the overall system is globally contracting.
Formal theorem and proof showing that persistence of environmental variables creates non-autonomous/memory-dependent closed-loop behavior, and that only the special case of global contraction removes this history dependence (mathematical analysis of sensitivity to initial conditions).
high positive How Intelligence Emerges: A Minimal Theory of Dynamic Adapti... history sensitivity of trajectories (dependence on initial conditions/past) vs. ...
Under dissipativity assumptions the induced closed-loop system admits a bounded forward-invariant region, guaranteeing viability of the dynamics without requiring global optimality.
A proven structural result (theorem) in the paper: mathematical proof using dissipativity hypotheses on components of the feedback architecture showing existence of a bounded forward-invariant set for the closed-loop dynamics. (The claim is theoretical; no empirical sample size.)
high positive How Intelligence Emerges: A Minimal Theory of Dynamic Adapti... existence of a bounded forward-invariant region (set invariance/boundedness of t...
We demonstrate three distinct workflows across five environments.
Paper lists and evaluates five target environments and describes three workflows (direct translation, translation verified against existing performance implementations, and new environment creation). Sample size: five environments.
high positive Automatic Generation of High-Performance RL Environments number of workflows and environments demonstrated
These trends (increased demand for complementary skills and decreased demand for substitutable skills) hold across geographies including the United States, United Kingdom, and Australia, demonstrating robustness.
Replication/comparison of results within the dataset’s country-specific subsamples (US, UK, Australia) drawn from nearly 30 million job postings collected between 2018 and 2024.
high positive Complement or Substitute? How AI Increases the Demand for Hu... consistency of skill-demand trends across countries
AI-intensive roles are significantly more likely to require complementary non-technical capabilities such as analytical thinking, resilience, and digital literacy.
Empirical analysis of a dataset of nearly 30 million job postings from the United States, the United Kingdom, and Australia between 2018 and 2024; roles classified as AI-intensive and skill mentions extracted from job postings to compare prevalence of non-technical capabilities.
high positive Complement or Substitute? How AI Increases the Demand for Hu... prevalence (requirement) of complementary non-technical capabilities in AI-inten...
Mainstreaming shared input and embracing climate-resilient management approaches are fundamental action items for building institutional resilience.
Paper conclusion lists these recommended action items based on its analysis of governance and sustainability linkages grounded in SDG and global governance literature; the summary does not indicate empirical testing of these recommendations.
high positive Good Governance and Sustainable Development: Pathways, Princ... institutional resilience and climate-resilient management adoption
AI significantly enhances supplier stability in sports enterprises (SE).
Empirical estimation using a dual machine learning (DML) model on panel data of 45 Chinese listed sports enterprises (2012–2023); authors report a statistically significant positive effect of AI on supplier stability.
high positive Can Artificial Intelligence Enhance the Stability of Supply ... supplier stability (component of supply chain stability)
Extending existing behavioral frameworks (e.g., TAM, JD–R, Organizational Trust) to the AI-augmented workplace constitutes a theoretical contribution of the paper.
Theoretical elaboration and integration presented in the paper; contribution characterized as an extension of pre-existing models to AI contexts (no quantitative validation described in the summary).
high positive Developing Organizational Psychology Frameworks to Prepare t... theoretical scope/coverage of behavioral frameworks applied to AI-augmented work...
The paper proposes a five-phase strategic roadmap for phased organizational implementation that integrates HRM practice redesign, psychological support systems, and evidence-based governance mechanisms.
Prescriptive/strategic proposal based on the paper's theoretical synthesis and applied recommendations (roadmap described in the paper; summary contains no implementation trial data).
high positive Developing Organizational Psychology Frameworks to Prepare t... recommended stages for organizational AI implementation (roadmap adherence/inten...
The paper develops a comprehensive, multi-dimensional organizational psychology framework for preparing the U.S. workforce for AI integration composed of six interdependent dimensions: human–AI symbiosis, trust and transparency, job redesign, AI-enabled recruitment and selection, learning and adaptation, and ethical AI governance.
Conceptual framework derived from theoretical integration (TAM, Human–AI Symbiosis Theory, JD–R Model, Organizational Trust Theory) and review of AI–HRM literature; framework construction is a theoretical contribution of the paper (no empirical validation reported in the summary).
high positive Developing Organizational Psychology Frameworks to Prepare t... framework completeness and coverage of domains relevant to workforce preparation...
General US employment for prime age workers (age 25–54) is currently high (~80%).
Paper cites a current employment rate of 80% for prime-age workers; likely based on national labor statistics though the exact data source and year are not specified in the excerpt.
high positive Current Labor Challenges and Opportunities in Nursery Crops ... employment rate for prime-age (25–54) population
State-owned enterprises and high-tech firms with robust digital infrastructure experience the largest productivity and innovation gains from AI adoption, indicating absorptive capacity matters.
Heterogeneity analysis on the same panel data comparing subgroups (state-owned vs. non-state-owned; high-tech vs. others; firms with stronger digital infrastructure), showing larger estimated AI effects in those subgroups.
high positive AI-driven design management: enhancing organizational produc... TFP and innovation (differential effects across firm subgroups)
Adoption of AI strengthens firms' innovation outcomes.
Same panel dataset (A-share-listed design firms, 2014–2023) with AI indicators derived from annual reports and patent texts; regression analyses linking AI indicator to innovation metrics (patent-related measures and/or firm-level innovation proxies referenced in the study).
high positive AI-driven design management: enhancing organizational produc... Innovation (measured via patent-related measures and firm-level innovation proxi...
Integrating AI technologies significantly enhances Total Factor Productivity (TFP) in design-oriented, project-based firms.
Panel regression analysis using firm-level panel data of A-share-listed design-oriented enterprises in China (2014–2023). AI exposure measured via an enterprise-level AI indicator constructed from NLP-based text analysis of annual reports and patents; TFP estimated at the firm level as the dependent variable. Robustness checks (e.g., Propensity Score Matching) reported.
high positive AI-driven design management: enhancing organizational produc... Total Factor Productivity (firm-level TFP)
The study moves beyond treating AI as a monolith by empirically investigating how distinct AI features jointly influence the consumer decision journey.
Methodological claim supported by the study's modeling of three specific AI feature constructs (recommendation engines, chatbots, comparison tools) and analyzing their joint effects via SEM on decision-related outcomes.
high positive Role of artificial intelligence on consumer buying behavior:... joint influence on consumer decision journey outcomes (trust, decision support, ...
AESP is implemented as an open-source TypeScript SDK with 208 tests and ten modules.
Implementation claim in the paper: TypeScript SDK, 208 tests, ten modules; verifiable by inspecting the repository and test suite.
high positive AESP: A Human-Sovereign Economic Protocol for AI Agents with... SDK test count (208) and module count (10)
AESP is built on an ACE-GF-based cryptographic substrate.
Paper states ACE-GF is used as the cryptographic substrate; implementation referenced in SDK.
high positive AESP: A Human-Sovereign Economic Protocol for AI Agents with... cryptographic primitives/substrate used (ACE-GF)
AESP employs HKDF-based context-isolated privacy with batched consolidation.
Cryptographic design described in the paper; HKDF-based isolation and batched consolidation listed as mechanisms.
high positive AESP: A Human-Sovereign Economic Protocol for AI Agents with... context isolation achieved via HKDF and effects of batched consolidation on priv...
AESP uses EIP-712 dual-signed commitments with escrow to bind agent actions to human consent.
Protocol description cites EIP-712 dual-signed commitments with escrow as a core mechanism; implementation stated in SDK.
high positive AESP: A Human-Sovereign Economic Protocol for AI Agents with... use of EIP-712 dual signatures and escrow status for commitments
AESP provides human-in-the-loop review with automatic, explicit, and biometric tiers.
Design specification in the paper describing three tiers of human review; implementation claimed in the SDK.
high positive AESP: A Human-Sovereign Economic Protocol for AI Agents with... presence and functioning of human-review pathways (automatic/explicit/biometric)...
AESP includes a deterministic eight-check policy engine with tiered escalation.
Protocol specification and implementation details described in the paper; presence asserted in the SDK implementation.
high positive AESP: A Human-Sovereign Economic Protocol for AI Agents with... policy checks applied per transaction (count = eight) and escalation tiering beh...
The recommended IS research emphases include hybrid human–AI ensembles, situated validation, design principles for probabilistic systems, and adaptive governance.
Explicitly listed components of the authors' proposed research agenda in the discussion section of the paper, derived from synthesis of reviewed literature and conceptual analysis.
high positive The Landscape of Generative AI in Information Systems: A Syn... priority research topics for IS scholarship addressing GenAI (hybrid ensembles, ...
To bridge the misalignment, the paper proposes reorienting IS scholarship from analyzing impacts toward actively shaping the co-evolution of technical capabilities with organizational procedures, societal values, and regulatory institutions.
Authors' proposed research agenda and recommendations derived from the synthesis of the 28 reviewed studies and their socio-technical analysis.
high positive The Landscape of Generative AI in Information Systems: A Syn... focus/strategic orientation of IS research (shift from impact analysis to active...
The study contributes to theory by developing a human-grounded decision analytics perspective and to practice by providing practical advice to executives and analytics leaders.
Author-stated contributions based on the conceptual framework and practical recommendations included in the paper. No practitioner evaluation or citation analysis provided.
high positive Designing Human–AI Collaborative Decision Analytics Framewor... theoretical contribution (human-grounded perspective); practical guidance for ex...
The study reframes AI as an augmentation mechanism rather than a substitute for managerial judgment and extends organizational decision theory to account for socio-technical decision systems.
Theoretical contribution asserted by the paper based on its literature synthesis and conceptual development (claim about extension of theory rather than empirical test).
high positive Reframing Organizational Decision-Making in the Age of Artif... theoretical framing of AI's role in organizational decision theory (augmentation...
The paper develops an integrative conceptual framework that explains how human judgment, algorithmic intelligence, and organizational context interact to shape decision quality and organizational outcomes.
Author-constructed conceptual framework based on synthesized literature across decision sciences, management, and information systems (framework described as output of the meta-analysis; no empirical validation reported in abstract).
high positive Reframing Organizational Decision-Making in the Age of Artif... decision quality and organizational outcomes as shaped by interaction among huma...
The model was prompted to suggest jobs to 24 simulated candidate profiles balanced in terms of gender, age, experience and professional field.
Methods reported in the paper: experimental prompting of GPT-5 with N=24 simulated profiles, balanced across specified attributes.
high positive Gender Bias in Generative AI-assisted Recruitment Processes number and composition of simulated candidate profiles used in the experiment
This study evaluates how a state-of-the-art generative model (GPT-5) suggests occupations based on gender and work experience background for under-35-year-old Italian graduates.
Study design described in the paper: targeted population (under-35 Italian graduates), model used (GPT-5) and evaluation focus (occupation suggestions).
high positive Gender Bias in Generative AI-assisted Recruitment Processes occupation suggestions produced by GPT-5 for specified candidate profiles
Curated (human-authored) Skills substantially improve agent task success on average (+16.2 percentage points).
Aggregate result reported over the SkillsBench benchmark: comparison of pass rates between baseline (no Skills) and curated-Skills conditions across the benchmark. SkillsBench comprises 86 tasks across 11 domains; evaluations used 7 agent–model configurations and 7,308 execution trajectories to compute pass rates and deltas.
high positive SkillsBench: Benchmarking How Well Agent Skills Work Across ... task pass rate (percentage of trajectories passing deterministic verifier)
Common AI applications in accounting include transaction automation, invoice processing, reconciliations, fraud detection, anomaly detection, automated financial reporting, and predictive forecasting.
Descriptive listing drawn from academic and industry sources/case studies summarized in the paper.
high positive Role of Artificial Intelligence in the Accounting Sector presence/use of specific AI applications (binary/coverage across firms)
From interview-based evidence the authors constructed a conceptual framework that integrates empirical insights with existing theories to explain how human–AI interaction alters design cognition.
Synthesis of qualitative interview findings with literature on creative cognition and design thinking; framework presented as an output of the study (framework construction described in paper).
high positive Human–AI Collaboration in Architectural Design Education: To... conceptual framework generation / theoretical integration
The paper issues a research agenda for economists: empirically develop instruments linking first‑person temporal reports with behavioral and neural proxies; theoretically incorporate subjective temporality into models of utility, human capital, attention economics, and platform competition; and evaluate policy accounting for temporal‑experience externalities.
Explicitly stated research agenda and methodological recommendations in the paper; no empirical follow‑up included.
high positive XChronos and Conscious Transhumanism: A Philosophical Framew... adoption of proposed research tasks by economics researchers (measurement develo...
Economists will need new empirical measures: validated instruments translating phenomenological constructs (e.g., Chronons) into observable proxies or composite indices for welfare and labor studies, facing standardization and comparability challenges.
Methodological recommendation and discussion in the paper; no empirical measure development or validation reported.
high positive XChronos and Conscious Transhumanism: A Philosophical Framew... development and validation of measurement instruments for subjective temporality
The paper proposes candidate mappings from subjective reports to neural/behavioral signatures (e.g., neural markers of attentional episodes, temporal binding windows) and suggests experimental paradigms to operationalize temporal units.
Methodological proposals and suggested experimental agendas in the paper; no implemented experiments or sample sizes reported.
high positive XChronos and Conscious Transhumanism: A Philosophical Framew... proposed mappings between first‑person temporal reports and neural/behavioral si...
The framework situates itself at the intersection of neurophenomenology, computational phenomenology, brain–computer interfaces, and human–AI teaming research.
Cross-disciplinary literature synthesis and conceptual mapping in the paper; descriptive claim with no empirical sampling (N/A).
high positive XChronos and Conscious Transhumanism: A Philosophical Framew... disciplinary integration (overlap of topics addressed by XChronos)
The paper introduces symbolic operators—Chronons, Hexachronons, Metachronos—as theoretical units intended to bridge first-person phenomenology of temporal experience with third‑person neurotechnology descriptions.
Theoretical proposal and definitional introduction within the paper (conceptual development); no experimental validation or sample (N/A).
high positive XChronos and Conscious Transhumanism: A Philosophical Framew... existence and conceptual definition of symbolic operators linking phenomenology ...
XChronos is a philosophical-epistemological framework arguing that transhumanism must place subjective temporality (lived time, presence, attention, meaning) at the center of design and evaluation.
Conceptual/philosophical analysis and literature synthesis presented in the paper; no empirical sample or dataset (N/A).
high positive XChronos and Conscious Transhumanism: A Philosophical Framew... degree to which subjective temporality is treated as a central evaluative/design...
Recommendation: Treat synthetic participants as heuristic tools (supplemental roles) rather than replacements; use hybrid designs, validate against held-out human samples, pre-register synthetic-data usage, and adopt transparency and reproducibility practices (document prompts, model versions, seeds, fine-tuning).
Authors' recommendations drawn from the systematic review of 182 studies and the identified failure modes and risks.
high positive Synthetic Participants Generated by Large Language Models: A... recommended research practices and safeguards (use-case guidelines, validation p...
A systematic review of 27 evaluated AI education/training programs for the healthcare workforce was conducted following PRISMA guidance and a PROSPERO-registered protocol.
Systematic review design reported in the paper: PRISMA-guided review, protocol registered in PROSPERO, searches of five databases (PubMed, Scopus, CINAHL, Embase, ERIC) on 20 Aug 2024; 27 programs met inclusion criteria.
high positive Assessing the effectiveness of artificial intelligence educa... number of evaluated AI education/training programs included in the review
Higher job performance is positively associated with greater employee retention.
PLS-SEM analysis, N = 350. Reported direct path: Performance → Retention, β = 0.348, p < 0.001.
About 78% of the included studies document productivity increases related to digital transformation initiatives.
Quantitative summary across the 145 included studies indicating the proportion reporting productivity gains (~78%).
high positive Digital transformation and its relationship with work produc... productivity gains (as reported by each study: individual, team, or firm-level p...
A systematic review of 145 empirical studies (published 2020–2025) finds a consistent positive association between digital transformation and work productivity.
Systematic review following PRISMA 2020 of 145 included empirical studies identified and screened from searches (see Methods); inclusion period 2020–2025; productivity outcomes extracted from each study.
high positive Digital transformation and its relationship with work produc... work productivity (individual and organizational productivity indicators)
Core supply‑chain management challenges targeted by simulation are production layout, product strategy, and managing volume and variety.
Survey and critique of simulation applications presented in the paper; conceptual taxonomy of application areas.
high positive A Review of Manufacturing Operations Research Integration in... effectiveness of simulation in addressing production layout, product strategy, a...