The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (13870 claims)

Adoption
8467 claims
Productivity
7558 claims
Governance
6805 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6363 claims
Org Design
4132 claims
Innovation
4065 claims
Labor Markets
3526 claims
Skills & Training
2945 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 749 196 98 892 1984
Governance & Regulation 817 394 188 121 1544
Organizational Efficiency 771 189 124 83 1177
Technology Adoption Rate 627 233 123 96 1088
Research Productivity 411 123 56 332 933
Output Quality 467 178 59 47 751
Decision Quality 320 174 75 42 618
Firm Productivity 435 55 88 20 604
AI Safety & Ethics 214 276 65 33 593
Market Structure 178 167 122 24 496
Task Allocation 207 64 71 32 379
Skill Acquisition 165 59 60 17 301
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 52 107 13 279
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 116 63 42 11 232
Firm Revenue 150 48 26 3 227
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Task Completion Time 169 29 8 12 219
Worker Satisfaction 89 63 20 12 184
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 76 68 14 5 163
Training Effectiveness 93 21 13 19 148
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Automation Exposure 51 54 22 12 142
Team Performance 86 17 27 9 140
Developer Productivity 94 17 14 6 132
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 51 7 8 3 69
Creative Output 31 17 7 3 59
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 17 17 51
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
VitaDAO is a community-driven organization funding and acquiring IP for longevity-related research, emphasizing open science and community governance.
Detailed case-study description drawing on VitaDAO's public documentation, governance records, and whitepaper materials.
high positive Decentralized Autonomous Organizations in the Pharmaceutical... IP acquisitions by VitaDAO, funding rounds executed, degree of open-science publ...
Research agenda priorities include: empirically quantifying the value of digital twins on R&D productivity; studying complementarities between AI tools and tacit sensory knowledge; measuring cultural translation costs; and analyzing market concentration risks from proprietary sensory models.
List of recommended empirical research directions derived from conceptual analysis and gap identification; no primary empirical work conducted within the paper itself.
high positive At the table with Wittgenstein: How language shapes taste an... future empirical metrics: R&D productivity changes, complementarity estimates, m...
The collection highlights resolving methodological challenges such as ecological validity, generalization across environments, and integrating domain knowledge rather than purely optimizing benchmarks.
Methodological-focus summary from the collection indicating emphasis on ecological validity, generalization, and domain-knowledge integration across multiple papers.
high positive Towards ‘digital ecology’: Advances in integrating artificia... methodological robustness (ecological validity, cross-site generalization, domai...
Early applications focused on automating straightforward, repetitive tasks (e.g., filtering blank camera‑trap images); current work aims for deeper integration with ecological questions.
Historical-arc observation drawn from the collection's examples and classifications of papers (descriptive review of prior vs. current papers in the collection).
high positive Towards ‘digital ecology’: Advances in integrating artificia... complexity and integration depth of AI applications in ecology (task automation ...
The AI–ecology interface is maturing from simple, task‑automation proofs of concept into genuinely interdisciplinary work that advances both AI methods and ecological science.
Synthesis of the paper collection (mix of methodological, empirical, and translational papers) and the paper's summary of trends across those contributions (no single-sample experiment; claim based on cross-paper review).
high positive Towards ‘digital ecology’: Advances in integrating artificia... advancement of AI methods and ecological science (depth of interdisciplinary int...
Seed 2.0 Lite achieved 75.7% success rate with-skill, an increase of +18.9 percentage points over baseline.
Model-specific reported result in the paper: Seed 2.0 Lite with-skill success rate (75.7%) and reported improvement (+18.9pp); reported from the benchmark runs.
high positive SKILLS: Structured Knowledge Injection for LLM-Driven Teleco... task success rate (percentage) and absolute percent-point lift
GLM-5 Turbo achieved 78.4% success rate with-skill, an increase of +5.4 percentage points over baseline.
Model-specific reported result in the paper: GLM-5 Turbo with-skill success rate (78.4%) and reported improvement (+5.4pp); based on the benchmark evaluation.
high positive SKILLS: Structured Knowledge Injection for LLM-Driven Teleco... task success rate (percentage) and absolute percent-point lift
Nemotron 120B achieved 78.4% success rate with-skill, an increase of +18.9 percentage points over baseline.
Model-specific reported result in the paper: Nemotron 120B with-skill success rate (78.4%) and reported improvement (+18.9pp); results drawn from the benchmark runs.
high positive SKILLS: Structured Knowledge Injection for LLM-Driven Teleco... task success rate (percentage) and absolute percent-point lift
MiniMax M2.5 achieved 81.1% success rate with-skill, an increase of +13.5 percentage points over baseline.
Model-specific reported result in the paper: MiniMax M2.5 with-skill success rate (81.1%) and reported improvement (+13.5pp); based on subset of the 185 scenario-runs across the evaluated models.
high positive SKILLS: Structured Knowledge Injection for LLM-Driven Teleco... task success rate (percentage) and absolute percent-point lift
Results across 5 open-weight model conditions and 185 scenario-runs show consistent skill lift across all models.
Aggregate experimental results reported in the paper: evaluation over 5 model conditions and 185 scenario-runs, with cross-model improvement when SKILL is provided.
high positive SKILLS: Structured Knowledge Injection for LLM-Driven Teleco... skill lift measured as change in task success rate (percentage point improvement...
Returns to advanced digital skills vary by firm size/type: the wage return in large Chaebol conglomerates is approximately 18.7%, significantly higher than the ~9.5% return in Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs), indicating a 'skills–scale' complementarity effect.
Heterogeneity analysis within the extended Mincerian wage regression framework using KLIPS micro-data, comparing estimated returns across firm types (Chaebol vs SMEs). (Sample size and exact model specification not provided in the excerpt.)
high positive Measuring the Economic Returns of Vocational Digital Skills ... wage/worker compensation (percentage wage premiums by firm type: Chaebol ≈ 18.7%...
Workers with only general digital literacy receive a wage premium of approximately 5.8% (after controlling for education, experience, and demographics).
Same empirical framework: extended Mincerian wage equation on KLIPS micro-data with controls for education, experience, and demographic characteristics. (Sample size not specified in the provided excerpt.)
high positive Measuring the Economic Returns of Vocational Digital Skills ... wage/worker compensation (percentage wage premium ≈ 5.8%)
Workers possessing specialized digital skills (e.g., data analysis, programming, automation control) enjoy a significant wage premium of approximately 14.2% after controlling for years of education, work experience, and demographic characteristics.
Empirical estimation using an extended Mincerian wage equation on micro-data from the Korean Labor and Income Panel Study (KLIPS); models control for years of education, work experience, and demographic covariates. (Sample size not specified in the provided excerpt.)
high positive Measuring the Economic Returns of Vocational Digital Skills ... wage/worker compensation (percentage wage premium ≈ 14.2%)
AI-adopting firms increase R&D expenditures following adoption.
Firm financial data showing higher R&D spending for adopters relative to nonadopters in post-adoption periods using the diff-in-diff framework.
high positive AI and Productivity: The Role of Innovation R&D expenditures (absolute or relative change)
Post-adoption patents by AI adopters receive more citations than those of nonadopters.
Difference-in-differences estimates comparing citation counts per patent before and after AI installation versus nonadopters; patent citation data used as the dependent variable.
high positive AI and Productivity: The Role of Innovation citations per patent (average citation count)
Firms that adopt AI subsequently increase patenting relative to nonadopters.
Firm-level analysis using a novel AI adoption measure based on timing of AI product installations and a stacked difference-in-differences design exploiting staggered adoption; dependent variable = firm patent counts (patenting rate). (Sample size and exact time period not specified in the provided text.)
high positive AI and Productivity: The Role of Innovation firm patent counts / patenting rate
Programming experience significantly improved code security.
Association found in the study between participants' programming experience (general programming experience measured for each participant) and the security of their submitted code; statistical analysis in the sample (n = 159) showed a significant positive effect of experience on code security.
high positive The Impact of AI-Assisted Development on Software Security: ... code security (security quality of participants' solutions) as a function of pro...
Using distributed systems as a principled foundation is a useful approach for creating and evaluating LLM teams.
Primary methodological proposal of the paper; supported by conceptual argument and (per the paper) mappings between distributed-systems concepts and LLM team design (specific experimental validation not detailed in the excerpt).
high positive Language Model Teams as Distributed Systems suitability of distributed-systems framework for designing/evaluating LLM teams
Large language models (LLMs) are growing increasingly capable.
Statement in the paper's introduction/abstract summarizing the field; based on observed progress in LLM development cited by the authors (no experimental sample size provided in the excerpt).
high positive Language Model Teams as Distributed Systems capability of LLMs (general competence/capacity)
Only seven specialized skills produce meaningful gains (up to +30%).
Empirical results showing that 7 out of 49 skills yielded meaningful positive improvements in acceptance-test pass rates, with gains up to 30%.
high positive SWE-Skills-Bench: Do Agent Skills Actually Help in Real-Worl... number of skills with meaningful positive pass-rate gains and magnitude (up to +...
The average gain from injecting skills is only +1.2% in pass rate.
Aggregated pass-rate differences computed across the benchmark tasks comparing with-skill vs without-skill conditions, reported as an average +1.2% gain.
high positive SWE-Skills-Bench: Do Agent Skills Actually Help in Real-Worl... average change in acceptance-test pass rate (+1.2%)
Analysis of benchmark data (n = 667) reveals substantial synergy effects: Llama-3.1-8B improves human performance by 23 percentage points.
Empirical analysis of the same benchmark dataset (n = 667) using the Bayesian IRT model; reported improvement in human performance with Llama-3.1-8B assistance of +23 percentage points.
high positive Quantifying and Optimizing Human-AI Synergy: Evidence-Based ... human task performance (accuracy, measured in percentage points) when assisted b...
Analysis of benchmark data (n = 667) reveals substantial synergy effects: GPT-4o improves human performance by 29 percentage points.
Empirical analysis of a benchmark dataset of n = 667 using the paper's Bayesian IRT framework; reported improvement in human performance with GPT-4o assistance of +29 percentage points.
high positive Quantifying and Optimizing Human-AI Synergy: Evidence-Based ... human task performance (accuracy, measured in percentage points) when assisted b...
The work offers a blueprint for converting the ideological potential of AI into implementable, regulator-compatible utilities in pharmaceutical science by synthesizing quantitative measures and practical measures.
Claim about the paper's contribution (blueprint). It is an author claim about the synthesis and guidance provided; the excerpt does not include empirical validation that following the blueprint yields successful implementation.
high positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... provision of a blueprint/guidance for implementable, regulator-compatible AI uti...
The paper proposes a systematized framework of integration that emphasizes creating high-impact pilot projects, in-the-wild testing, and ongoing monitoring of models in accordance with FDA, EMA, and EU AI Act guidance.
Described as the paper's proposed framework and recommendations for regulatory-aligned implementation. The excerpt indicates the proposal but does not present validation or empirical testing of the framework.
high positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... existence of a proposed integration framework and recommended implementation ste...
Grounded in the Resource-Based View (RBV), AI is conceptualized as a strategic intangible resource that can confer a competitive advantage when integrated with complementary capabilities.
Theoretical framing presented in the paper (RBV-based conceptualization); not an empirical finding but an explicit conceptual claim.
high positive The role of artificial intelligence in enhancing financial l... competitive advantage / firm performance (theoretical linkage)
Firms with high AI adoption had an average profit growth rate of 9.5%, compared to 5.8% for low adopters.
Reported profit growth rates for high vs. low AI adoption groups from the questionnaire data (N=400); the paper gives the specific averages: 9.5% (high adopters) vs. 5.8% (low adopters).
O artigo discute implicações gerenciais e de políticas públicas para reduzir fricção, acelerar adoção responsável e orientar investimentos em produtividade e inclusão.
Seção de discussão mencionada no resumo abordando encargos gerenciais e políticas públicas; não há avaliação empírica de políticas no resumo.
high positive A FRICÇÃO PSICOANTROPOLÓGICA (SCF - Symbolic-Cognitive Frict... recomendações e orientações para ação gerencial e políticas públicas visando red...
O artigo entrega instrumentos replicáveis — a escala SCF-30, um checklist de governança mínima de IA e uma matriz 30-60-90 dias — para uso prático.
Afirmação explícita no resumo de que instrumentos replicáveis são disponibilizados; presunção de inclusão dos instrumentos no corpo do artigo.
high positive A FRICÇÃO PSICOANTROPOLÓGICA (SCF - Symbolic-Cognitive Frict... disponibilidade de instrumentos operacionais (escala, checklist, matriz 30-60-90...
AI significantly enhances firms' total factor productivity (TFP).
Empirical results from the multidimensional fixed-effects panel model applied to the 2007–2023 sample of agricultural A-share firms; statistical significance reported in the paper.
high positive Artificial intelligence and the sustainable development of a... total factor productivity (TFP)
The model is disciplined using data from the Michigan Survey of Consumers and the Survey of Professional Forecasters, targeting key empirical moments.
Calibration/estimation strategy described in the paper: parameters are chosen to match moments from the Michigan Survey of Consumers and SPF (targeted empirical moments). Specific moments and calibration targets are reported in the paper.
high positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics fit to targeted empirical moments (e.g., expectation dispersion, persistence mea...
I develop a search-and-matching model with sticky wages and endogenous separations.
Theoretical/model contribution: construction and analysis of a calibrated search-and-matching framework that incorporates wage stickiness and endogenous separation decisions.
high positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics wage dynamics and separation rates as generated by the model
Workers and firms face information frictions about the aggregate state of the economy (modeled explicitly).
Assumption and mechanism built into the paper's theoretical framework: a search-and-matching model with information frictions for both sides of the market (model specification).
high positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics information precision / belief heterogeneity about aggregate state (model primit...
Households form dispersed, backward-looking expectations about macroeconomic conditions.
Survey evidence from the Michigan Survey of Consumers showing dispersion in individual expectations and patterns consistent with backward-looking (slow/updating) belief formation about macro variables; exact sample sizes and empirical specifications are provided in the paper (not in the summary).
high positive Inaccurate Beliefs and Cyclical Labor Market Dynamics dispersion and updating dynamics of households' macroeconomic expectations
High-quality chatbots (96–100% accurate) improved caseworker accuracy by 27 percentage points.
Experimental result reported in paper: treatment with chatbots at 96–100% aggregate accuracy produced a 27 percentage-point increase in caseworker accuracy compared to control; based on the randomized experiment on the 770-question benchmark.
high positive LLMs in social services: How does chatbot accuracy affect hu... change in caseworker accuracy (percentage-point increase) when assisted by 96–10...
Caseworker performance significantly improves as chatbot quality improves.
Aggregated results from the randomized experiment show monotonic improvement in caseworker accuracy as the chatbot suggestion accuracy increases; paper states the improvement is statistically significant (specific p-values/statistical tests not provided in the excerpt).
high positive LLMs in social services: How does chatbot accuracy affect hu... caseworker accuracy as a function of chatbot suggestion quality
AI-integrated fuel blending systems achieve very high precision, demonstrated by a coefficient of determination (R2) of 0.99 during validation.
Model validation results reported in the paper (fuel blending system validation, R2 = 0.99), indicating very high explanatory/ predictive fit compared to traditional models.
high positive AI-Based Technological Transformation as a Driver for Develo... fuel blending accuracy/precision (measured by R2 on validation dataset) and impl...
DARE posits that responsible AI deployment requires the simultaneous and integrated development of Digital readiness, Administrative governance, Resilience & ethics, and Economic equity.
Descriptive claim about the framework's components as reported in the abstract (conceptual proposition).
high positive The DARE framework: a global model for responsible artificia... responsible AI deployment (dependent on development across four DARE dimensions)
This paper introduces the DARE Framework, a holistic, four-dimensional model for national AI strategy and international cooperation.
Factual description of paper content in abstract — the framework is introduced by the authors (conceptual/model contribution).
high positive The DARE framework: a global model for responsible artificia... existence/introduction of a conceptual framework (DARE) for AI strategy
ERM is an integrated, strategic framework that aligns risk management with corporate governance, objective setting, and performance management.
Conceptual descriptions and definitions of ERM drawn from existing ERM frameworks and literature reviewed in the article.
high positive A Literature Review: Effect of Enterprise Risk Management (E... alignment/integration of risk management with governance and performance systems
The authors curated a set of guidelines called the Incentive-Tuning Framework to aid researchers in designing effective incentive schemes for human–AI decision-making studies.
Authors' contribution described in the paper: development of a framework (framework content and evaluation details not provided in excerpt).
high positive Incentive-Tuning: Understanding and Designing Incentives for... guidance for incentive design (qualitative artifact intended to influence study ...
The intelligent scheduling model incorporates legal, contractual, skill-based, and preference-aware constraints to generate equitable and efficient rosters.
Methodological description of constraints encoded in the optimization model for scheduling; experimental validation of resulting rosters reported (conflict reduction and fairness metrics), but specific constraint formulations and datasets are not detailed in the excerpt.
high positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... compliance with constraints and roster equity/efficiency
The performance evaluation framework combines structured metrics (task completion, attendance, punctuality) with unstructured feedback (patient surveys, peer reviews) analyzed using natural language processing.
Methodological description in the paper of the performance evaluation module and use of NLP for unstructured feedback analysis; implementation details and dataset sizes not specified in the excerpt.
high positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... staff performance measurement (task completion, attendance, punctuality) and sen...
The proposed AI-driven HRM framework integrates forecasting, optimization, and performance evaluation to enhance workforce planning, staff scheduling, and continuous assessment.
Methodological contribution described in the paper: framework design with three core modules (demand forecasting, intelligent scheduling, performance evaluation); validated via experiments on synthetic and real hospital datasets (dataset sizes not specified in the text).
high positive Enhancing hospital workforce planning, scheduling, and perfo... overall workforce planning, scheduling efficiency, and assessment capability (ar...
The Indian government believes that artificial intelligence (AI) will play an important role in India’s continued economic growth, both through its contribution to productivity in the private sector and through smarter and more data-led government.
Reported position in the paper based on review of government statements and policy documents (policy analysis/legal review). No empirical sample size applies; claim is descriptive of government belief.
high positive Regulation and governance of artificial intelligence in Indi... perceived contribution of AI to economic growth (private-sector productivity and...
The positive impact of generative AI on ESG performance is stronger in manufacturing firms, firms in eastern regions, and technology-intensive firms (relative to non-manufacturing, central/western regions, and non-technology-intensive firms).
Heterogeneity/subsample analysis on the panel of Chinese A-share firms (2012–2024) comparing effects across firm types, geographic regions, and technology intensity, showing larger estimated positive effects for manufacturing, eastern-region, and technology-intensive subsamples.
high positive How Can Generative AI Promote Corporate ESG Performance? Evi... corporate ESG performance (differential/heterogeneous effect by firm type, regio...
Sustainable innovation partially mediates the relationship between generative AI and corporate ESG performance improvement.
Mediation analysis conducted on the panel dataset (Chinese A-share firms, 2012–2024) indicating a partial mediating role for sustainable innovation measures between generative AI use and ESG performance.
high positive How Can Generative AI Promote Corporate ESG Performance? Evi... corporate ESG performance (mediated via sustainable innovation)
The quality of information disclosure partially mediates the relationship between generative AI and corporate ESG performance improvement.
Mediation analysis (intermediary variable tests) performed on the same panel (Chinese A-share firms, 2012–2024) showing that information-disclosure quality accounts for part of the effect of generative AI on ESG outcomes.
high positive How Can Generative AI Promote Corporate ESG Performance? Evi... corporate ESG performance (mediated via information disclosure quality)
Generative AI can effectively drive improvements in corporate ESG performance.
Empirical analysis using panel data of Chinese A-share listed firms covering 2012–2024; the paper reports an econometric panel-data model showing a positive effect of generative AI adoption/use on measured firm ESG performance.
high positive How Can Generative AI Promote Corporate ESG Performance? Evi... corporate ESG performance (ESG score/ESG performance indicator)
The study extends human capital theory by integrating emotional and psychological dimensions into explanations of productivity and employment outcomes.
Theoretical contribution asserted by the authors based on their empirical findings linking emotional intelligence and psychological factors to economic outcomes; this is a conceptual extension rather than a statistical result.
high positive Emotional Intelligence as Human Capital: A Behavioral Econom... theoretical framework (human capital theory integration)