The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (13870 claims)

Adoption
8467 claims
Productivity
7558 claims
Governance
6805 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6363 claims
Org Design
4132 claims
Innovation
4065 claims
Labor Markets
3526 claims
Skills & Training
2945 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 749 196 98 892 1984
Governance & Regulation 817 394 188 121 1544
Organizational Efficiency 771 189 124 83 1177
Technology Adoption Rate 627 233 123 96 1088
Research Productivity 411 123 56 332 933
Output Quality 467 178 59 47 751
Decision Quality 320 174 75 42 618
Firm Productivity 435 55 88 20 604
AI Safety & Ethics 214 276 65 33 593
Market Structure 178 167 122 24 496
Task Allocation 207 64 71 32 379
Skill Acquisition 165 59 60 17 301
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 52 107 13 279
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 116 63 42 11 232
Firm Revenue 150 48 26 3 227
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Task Completion Time 169 29 8 12 219
Worker Satisfaction 89 63 20 12 184
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 76 68 14 5 163
Training Effectiveness 93 21 13 19 148
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Automation Exposure 51 54 22 12 142
Team Performance 86 17 27 9 140
Developer Productivity 94 17 14 6 132
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 51 7 8 3 69
Creative Output 31 17 7 3 59
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 17 17 51
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Overall, findings highlight that AI serves as a revolutionary (transformative) tool rather than merely a replacement tool for employment—changing the nature of human work rather than simply disengaging it.
Synthesis conclusion in the paper drawing on the literature review and the authors' empirical results indicating task reallocation and changing job content.
high positive Impact Of Artificial Intelligence (AI) On Employment degree of job replacement versus task transformation
The paper argues for equal technology governance as a necessary policy response to AI's labor market effects.
Policy recommendations discussed in the paper that call for equitable governance of AI; based on literature synthesis and empirical findings.
high positive Impact Of Artificial Intelligence (AI) On Employment technology governance / equity in AI deployment
The analysis raises policy implications emphasizing reskilling and education to address AI-driven changes in the labor market.
Policy discussion section summarized in the paper; draws on empirical findings and literature to recommend reskilling/education.
high positive Impact Of Artificial Intelligence (AI) On Employment reskilling / education needs
Moderate AI usage is associated with employment growth.
Part of the U-shaped relationship reported in the paper's empirical results; described qualitatively in the abstract/summary.
Secondary empirical evidence from Colombia's EDIT manufacturing survey (N=6,799 firms) shows that management practice quality amplifies the return to technology investment (interaction coefficient 0.304, p<0.01).
Secondary empirical analysis of EDIT manufacturing survey data; sample size reported as N = 6,799 firms; regression interaction term reported as coefficient 0.304 with p < 0.01.
high positive From Automation to Augmentation: A Framework for Designing H... return to technology investment (firm-level productivity/performance)
We endogenize the augmentation function as phi(D, W), where W is a five-dimensional workplace design vector (AI interface design, decision authority allocation, task orchestration, learning loop architecture, psychosocial work environment), and prove that human-centric design is profit-maximizing when the workforce's augmentable cognitive capital exceeds a critical threshold.
Theoretical model and formal proof presented in the paper (analytical derivation of phi(D,W) and threshold condition).
high positive From Automation to Augmentation: A Framework for Designing H... profit-maximization / firm performance under human-centric design
There is a need for energy-efficient AI development to align technological progress with sustainable energy consumption.
Policy recommendation based on the paper's empirical findings that AI adoption increases firm-level electricity demands in the short run; normative argument rather than a directly tested empirical claim.
high positive The Impact of AI Adoption on Electricity Output Growth Gap: ... policy alignment / sustainable energy consumption (recommendation)
The AI-related widening of the electricity output growth gap is stronger among manufacturing firms, non-state-owned firms, small firms, low-tech firms, and low-energy-consumption and low-pollution firms.
Heterogeneity/subgroup analyses across firm characteristics (ownership type, size, sector, technology intensity, baseline energy use and pollution levels) showing larger estimated effects in the listed subgroups. Specific subgroup sample sizes and coefficients not reported in the summary.
high positive The Impact of AI Adoption on Electricity Output Growth Gap: ... corporate electricity output growth gap (heterogeneous effects across firm types...
The effect of AI adoption on the electricity output growth gap is more pronounced for firms operating in highly competitive industries.
Heterogeneity analysis by industry competition intensity (likely via industry-level measures of competition); interaction regressions showing larger estimated effects in more competitive sectors. Sample/subgroup sizes not specified in the summary.
high positive The Impact of AI Adoption on Electricity Output Growth Gap: ... corporate electricity output growth gap (heterogeneous effect by industry compet...
The effect of AI adoption on widening the electricity output growth gap is more pronounced for firms located in economically advanced regions.
Heterogeneity analysis by regional economic development level using the firm-level electricity consumption dataset; stratified or interaction regressions showing larger estimated effects in more advanced regions. Exact subgroup sizes not provided in the summary.
high positive The Impact of AI Adoption on Electricity Output Growth Gap: ... corporate electricity output growth gap (heterogeneous effect by region)
The main result (initial widening of electricity growth gap) is robust to alternative variable definitions, exclusion of firms relying on outsourced AI services or non-AI adoption samples, and controls for endogeneity.
Robustness checks reported in the paper: alternative variable definitions, sample restrictions (excluding outsourced-AI-reliant firms and non-AI samples), and application of endogeneity control methods (e.g., instrumental variables or panel fixed effects). Exact methods and sample sizes not specified in the summary.
high positive The Impact of AI Adoption on Electricity Output Growth Gap: ... corporate electricity output growth gap (robustness of estimated effect)
AI adoption initially widens the corporate electricity output growth gap at the firm level in China.
Empirical analysis using unique firm-level data on corporate electricity consumption in China; econometric estimation comparing electricity output growth between AI-adopting firms and non-adopting peers (panel/firm-level analysis). Sample size not stated in the summary.
high positive The Impact of AI Adoption on Electricity Output Growth Gap: ... corporate electricity output growth gap
Strong governance and advanced digital infrastructure are critical for realizing AI’s potential as a sustainable technology—governance-driven digital transformation is important for achieving sustainable growth.
Interpretation and policy implication drawn from the empirical findings that GQI and DII mitigate the AI→CO2 relationship in the 104-country panel analysis (2000–2023) employing GMM and 2SLS.
high positive Artificial Intelligence: A Blessing or a Curse for Climate A... sustainable growth / reduced environmental impact of AI
The environmental impact of AI is stronger in energy-inefficient and AI-advanced contexts.
Heterogeneity analysis in which the AI→CO2 effect is reported as larger for energy-inefficient countries and for countries in more advanced stages of AI diffusion (same 104-country panel, 2000–2023).
high positive Artificial Intelligence: A Blessing or a Curse for Climate A... CO2 emissions (heterogeneous AI effect by energy efficiency and AI stage)
Adoption of AI currently contributes to higher CO2 emissions.
Empirical panel analysis of 104 countries over 2000–2023 using two-step system GMM and two-stage least squares (2SLS) estimations; AI adoption variable positively associated with country-level CO2 emissions in the reported regressions.
To optimize agentic AI integration and ensure responsible innovation across financial services, interdisciplinary, longitudinal research and robust governance frameworks are needed.
Authors' conclusions and recommendations based on the identified findings and gaps in the reviewed literature.
high positive A Comparative &amp; Systematic Review of Literature on the I... recommended research and governance actions
Diverse architectural models such as multi-agent systems and cloud-based frameworks enable scalable, adaptive agentic AI deployments in financial services.
Synthesis of architecture-focused studies and framework descriptions within the reviewed literature (architectural benchmarking across papers).
high positive A Comparative &amp; Systematic Review of Literature on the I... scalability and adaptivity of deployments
Findings reveal substantial productivity gains and operational efficiencies predominantly in banking and investment.
Systematic review synthesizing multidisciplinary qualitative, quantitative, and bibliometric studies of agentic AI applications in financial services published up to mid-2024 (review-level synthesis).
high positive A Comparative &amp; Systematic Review of Literature on the I... productivity gains and operational efficiencies
The ManagerWorker two-agent pipeline (expensive text-only manager + cheaper worker with repo access) can substitute expensive execution by using expensive reasoning in the manager and cheaper execution in the worker.
System design description plus empirical results on 200 SWE-bench Lite instances showing parity in success rates between a strong-manager/weak-worker pipeline and a strong single agent while using fewer strong-model tokens.
high positive Can AI Models Direct Each Other? Organizational Structure as... ability to substitute expensive execution with expensive reasoning (operationali...
A minimal review-only manager loop adds only 2 percentage points over the baseline, whereas structured exploration and planning by the manager add 11 percentage points, demonstrating that active direction (not mere reviewing) produces most of the benefit.
Ablation-style comparison of pipeline variants on the 200-instance SWE-bench Lite evaluation: review-only manager loop versus manager with structured exploration and planning; reported improvements in percentage points.
high positive Can AI Models Direct Each Other? Organizational Structure as... improvement in task success rate (percentage-point increase)
A strong manager directing a weak worker achieves a 62% success rate on software-engineering tasks, matching a strong single agent which achieves 60%, while using a fraction of the strong-model token usage.
Empirical evaluation on 200 instances from SWE-bench Lite across five pipeline configurations and model pairings; measured task success rates and token usage for manager-worker pipelines versus single-agent baselines.
high positive Can AI Models Direct Each Other? Organizational Structure as... task success rate (percentage of tasks solved)
Overall, the HCT is a robust, accurate, and transparent alternative to the AI-as-advisor approach, offering a simple mechanism to tap into the wisdom of hybrid crowds.
Overall conclusion drawn from the empirical comparisons across datasets and analyses described in the paper (summary statement in abstract).
high positive Beyond AI advice -- independent aggregation boosts human-AI ... overall decision-making performance / robustness / transparency
Using signal detection theory, the paper finds that the HCT outperforms the AI-as-advisor approach because people cannot discriminate well enough between correct and incorrect AI advice.
Analysis in the paper applying signal detection theory to the empirical results (as stated in abstract).
high positive Beyond AI advice -- independent aggregation boosts human-AI ... discriminability between correct and incorrect AI advice (signal detection metri...
The HCT also performed better in almost all cases in which the AI offered an explanation of its judgment.
Empirical results on the subset of four datasets with AI explanations (abstract reports HCT performed better in 'almost all' of these cases).
high positive Beyond AI advice -- independent aggregation boosts human-AI ... decision accuracy when AI provides explanations
The HCT outperformed the AI-as-advisor approach in all datasets.
Empirical comparisons reported across the 10 datasets (statement in abstract that HCT 'outperformed' in all datasets). Specific performance metrics not provided in abstract.
high positive Beyond AI advice -- independent aggregation boosts human-AI ... decision accuracy / task performance
The study points to the need for longitudinal, experimental, or platform-log-based designs to establish causality and measure heterogeneity across platforms.
Authors' methodological recommendations and proposed empirical agenda built on limitations of their cross-sectional survey (N = 450) and literature gaps.
high positive Echo Chambers, Filter Bubbles, and Selective Exposure: Media... recommended research designs for causal inference and heterogeneity assessment
Policy and practice interventions (media literacy, platform design changes, mandated diversity, etc.) are recommended to increase informational diversity and mitigate polarization.
Policy recommendations derived from study findings and literature discussion; not evaluated experimentally in the paper (authors propose interventions as implications).
high positive Echo Chambers, Filter Bubbles, and Selective Exposure: Media... recommended interventions to reduce polarization / increase informational divers...
Algorithmic recommendation (structural) and user selective consumption (behavioural) jointly reinforce ideological positions in digital spaces.
Interpretation based on observed associations between selective exposure and polarization plus reported heterogeneity in perceived algorithmic influence from the N = 450 survey; authors frame results as indicating interacting structural and behavioural mechanisms.
high positive Echo Chambers, Filter Bubbles, and Selective Exposure: Media... ideological reinforcement (increase in polarization linked to combined algorithm...
Higher levels of selective exposure are positively associated with increased ideological polarization.
Correlational analyses (reported associations / regression-style tests) using survey measures of selective exposure and measures of opinion/political polarization in the same cross-sectional sample (N = 450).
high positive Echo Chambers, Filter Bubbles, and Selective Exposure: Media... ideological / opinion polarization
A large majority of respondents reported frequent exposure to content aligned with their preexisting views (widespread echo chambers / filter bubbles).
Quantitative cross-sectional survey of N = 450 active social media users; self-reported measures of content consumption and indicators of selective exposure; descriptive statistics showing most respondents frequently encounter ideologically consonant content.
high positive Echo Chambers, Filter Bubbles, and Selective Exposure: Media... self-reported exposure to ideologically consonant content (selective exposure)
An AI agent given revealed-preference data predicts subjects' choices more accurately than an AI agent given stated-preference prompts.
Online experiment in which subjects provided written instructions (prompts) and revealed preferences via choices in a series of binary lottery questions; AI agents were given either the revealed-preference data or the stated-preference prompts and their prediction accuracy on subjects' choices was compared.
high positive Should I State or Should I Show? Aligning AI with Human Pref... prediction accuracy of AI agent for subjects' choices
Under economy-wide deployment, the share of computer-vision-exposed labor compensation that is cost-effectively automatable rises sharply (relative to the firm-level 11% estimate).
Model counterfactuals or calibration scenarios comparing firm-level deployment vs economy-wide deployment; qualitative statement that share increases substantially.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... share of labor compensation automatable under economy-wide deployment
At the firm level, cost-effective automation captures approximately 11% of computer-vision-exposed labor compensation.
Calibration and implementation in computer vision; reported firm-level estimate from the framework.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... share of computer-vision-exposed labor compensation captured by cost-effective a...
Scale of deployment is a key determinant: AI-as-a-Service and AI agents spread fixed costs across users, sharply expanding economically viable tasks.
Modeling and calibration arguments showing fixed-cost spreading effects increase set of tasks for which automation is cost-effective; qualitative and quantitative comparisons in implementation.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... number/coverage of economically viable tasks (adoption potential) as a function ...
Because higher accuracy is disproportionately costly (convex cost), full automation is often not cost-minimizing; partial automation, where firms retain human workers for residual tasks, frequently emerges as the equilibrium.
Theoretical model combined with calibration (scaling laws + task mappings); equilibrium outcomes reported from the framework implementation.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... prevalence of partial automation vs full automation as cost-minimizing choices
We model automation intensity as a continuous choice in which firms minimize costs by selecting an AI accuracy level, from no automation through partial human-AI collaboration to full automation.
The paper develops a theoretical framework / model that treats automation intensity as a continuous decision variable; described as the central modeling approach.
high positive Economics of Human and AI Collaboration: When is Partial Aut... degree of automation (accuracy level chosen by firms)
The findings demonstrate that technological innovation strategies, when effectively implemented, provide measurable competitive advantages for banks and offer evidence-based insights for policymakers and practitioners.
Authors' interpretation/conclusion drawing on the reported statistically significant relationships between innovation (product and technological) and competitiveness.
high positive Technology Innovation Strategy and the Competitiveness of Ke... competitiveness (market share, profitability, customer satisfaction)
Technological innovation is positively and statistically significantly related to bank competitiveness (simple linear regression result reported).
Simple linear regression reported in the paper testing the hypothesis that technological innovation influences competitiveness; data collected from innovation-focused executives across licensed banks (paper states data from 39 licensed banks).
high positive Technology Innovation Strategy and the Competitiveness of Ke... competitiveness (market share, return on equity, customer satisfaction)
Product innovation strategy has a positive and statistically significant effect on competitiveness (F(1,134) = 74.983, p < .001).
Bivariate regression analysis reported in the paper with F(1,134)=74.983, p < .001; based on survey data from innovation-focused executives (regression degrees of freedom indicate n≈136 observations).
high positive Technology Innovation Strategy and the Competitiveness of Ke... competitiveness (measured via market share, return on equity, and customer satis...
The results (conceptual/model results) support corporate GenAI policies, leadership development programs, and HR assessment of leader readiness for GenAI-enabled delegation and communication.
Practical implications and recommendations section arguing policy and HR applications based on the conceptual model.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... policy and HR adoption/application
The article introduces an EI-driven trust-calibration framework as an explanatory mechanism showing when generative AI improves leadership effectiveness and when it amplifies managerial errors.
Novel theoretical framework developed in the paper synthesizing EI, trust calibration, and psychological safety to explain boundary conditions of AI in leadership.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... leadership effectiveness (and amplification of managerial errors)
The paper provides an operationalization toolkit including measures: GenAI use intensity; delegation quality indices (clarity, boundaries, success criteria); communication quality indices (empathy, tone, transparency); psychological safety markers; and behavioral trust-calibration measures.
Operationalization section in the paper listing suggested indices and markers for empirical measurement.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... measurement constructs for empirical studies (e.g., GenAI use intensity, delegat...
As a follow-up validation path, the paper proposes a two-wave time-lag design and 180° assessment (leader + subordinates) to reduce common-method bias.
Methodological proposal in the paper describing longitudinal and multi-rater validation approaches.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... robustness/validity of empirical findings (reduction of common-method bias)
The paper proposes a 'Package B' rapid empirical design: a randomized online experiment manipulating access to generative AI in core managerial tasks (decision, delegation, team communication), combined with EI measurement and trust-calibration indicators.
Methodology section proposing the rapid randomized online experiment design as the primary empirical test.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... experimental test of human–AI leadership effects
Emotional intelligence strengthens the positive impact of generative AI on managerial outcomes when trust is properly calibrated and psychological safety is maintained.
Conceptual model and integrative argument combining EI, trust-calibration, and psychological safety; supported by proposed empirical test design.
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... managerial outcomes (e.g., decision quality)
The paper conceptualizes human–AI leadership as an integrated managerial competence.
Conceptual modeling presented in the paper integrating EI theory, psychological safety, and trust calibration (theoretical synthesis).
high positive LEADER EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE GENERATIVE AI ERA: “HUM... human–AI leadership competence (integrated managerial competence)
Hukum diharapkan tidak hanya berfungsi sebagai alat perlindungan, tetapi juga sebagai instrumen strategis dalam mengelola transisi menuju masa depan kerja yang lebih inklusif, adil, dan berkelanjutan di era kecerdasan buatan.
Kesimpulan dan rekomendasi normatif penulis berdasarkan analisis perundang-undangan dan literatur yang dikaji.
high positive Reformasi Hukum Ketenagakerjaan di Era Artificial Intelligen... peran hukum sebagai instrumen pengelolaan transisi tenaga kerja
Pengakuan 'hak atas pengembangan keterampilan berkelanjutan' (right to lifelong learning) penting dan perlu dimasukkan sebagai bagian integral dari perlindungan pekerja di era digital.
Klaim normatif dan rekomendasi kebijakan yang muncul dari studi konseptual dan tinjauan literatur komparatif.
high positive Reformasi Hukum Ketenagakerjaan di Era Artificial Intelligen... pengakuan hak atas pembelajaran berkelanjutan untuk pekerja
Diperlukan reformasi hukum yang lebih progresif dan adaptif, termasuk penguatan sistem jaminan sosial dan pembaruan kebijakan fiskal untuk menangani dampak AI.
Rekomendasi kebijakan yang disimpulkan dari analisis normatif dan komparatif serta tinjauan literatur dalam penelitian.
high positive Reformasi Hukum Ketenagakerjaan di Era Artificial Intelligen... kebutuhan reformasi hukum (jaminan sosial dan kebijakan fiskal)
Diperlukan dasar hukum bagi penerapan model kompensasi inovatif seperti Universal Basic Income (UBI), pajak otomasi, dan skema distribusi manfaat produktivitas AI.
Rekomendasi kebijakan hasil analisis normatif dan komparatif yang dikemukakan penulis berdasarkan tinjauan literatur.
high positive Reformasi Hukum Ketenagakerjaan di Era Artificial Intelligen... kebutuhan dasar hukum untuk mekanisme kompensasi inovatif (UBI, pajak otomasi, d...