The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (2066 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Inequality Remove filter
Priority research areas include evaluating long‑run distributional impacts of AI diffusion in agriculture, interactions between digital technologies and labor markets, inclusive financing models for adoption, and macroeconomic effects on food prices and trade.
Stated research agenda and gap analysis in the paper’s conclusions, derived from the review of existing literature and identified gaps.
high null result MODERN APPROACHES TO SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION research coverage (presence/absence of long‑run distributional studies, labor ma...
The current evidence base has gaps: more rigorous impact evaluations, long‑term soil and emissions accounting, and studies on distributional outcomes are needed.
Meta‑assessment within the paper noting limitations of existing literature (many short‑term pilots, limited long‑run soil/emissions data, few studies on who captures value); the claim is based on the review's appraisal of methods used in cited studies.
high null result MODERN APPROACHES TO SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION research evidence sufficiency (availability of long‑term causal estimates, soil/...
Economists and policymakers should fund long‑run evaluations (RCTs, quasi‑experimental designs) to estimate causal effects of AI interventions on productivity, welfare, and environmental outcomes.
Evidence‑gap analysis and policy recommendations in the paper; explicit call for rigorous impact evaluation methods given current paucity of long‑run causal evidence.
high null result MODERN APPROACHES TO SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION existence and number of long‑run RCTs/quasi‑experimental studies measuring produ...
There are limited long‑run randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on AI/IoT impacts for smallholders and scarce cross‑country data on distributional effects.
Literature review and evidence‑gap identification within the study; explicit statement that long‑run RCTs and cross‑country distributional data are scarce.
high null result MODERN APPROACHES TO SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION availability of long‑run RCT evidence, number of cross‑country distributional st...
Heterogeneous contexts mean impacts vary; careful piloting, monitoring, and adaptive policy are necessary to manage uncertainty in outcomes.
Synthesis and explicit discussion of uncertainties; evidence gaps section noting variable results across regions and interventions.
high null result MODERN APPROACHES TO SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL TRANSFORMATION variation in intervention impacts across contexts (heterogeneity measures), need...
This paper is a narrative review synthesizing heterogeneous studies and case reports rather than providing meta-analytic estimates of effect sizes.
Methods statement in the paper describing review type as narrative synthesis and noting limitations (no meta-analysis).
high null result Artificial Intelligence in Drug Discovery and Development: R... presence/absence of pooled/meta-analytic effect size estimates
Measurement and research gaps (data scarcity, informality) complicate robust economic assessment of AI impacts; improved metrics, granular labour and firm‑level data, and mixed‑methods evaluation are required.
Methodological critique based on reviewed literature and identified gaps; no new data collection in the paper.
high null result Towards Responsible Artificial Intelligence Adoption: Emergi... availability and granularity of labour and firm-level datasets, prevalence of mi...
There is a need for causal, longitudinal studies on how AI‑enabled fintech affects women's portfolio outcomes and on algorithmic interventions designed to reduce gender gaps.
Explicit statement in the paper noting limitations of existing literature (heterogeneity, limited longitudinal causal evidence, possible platform sample selection).
high null result Women's Investment Behaviour and Technology: Exploring the I... existence/absence of causal longitudinal evidence on fintech impacts by gender
Child-specific surveillance across human, animal, and environmental domains is sparse, limiting understanding of pediatric One Health risks.
Authors' methodological assessment based on literature search and review; explicit limitation stated that standardized child-focused surveillance data are lacking and heterogeneous across sectors.
high null result Safeguarding future generations: a One Health perspective on... coverage and granularity of child-specific surveillance data in One Health domai...
The legal arguments create some uncertainty about scope and enforcement timelines; economic actors will respond to expected enforcement probabilities and expected sanctions, so clarity from regulators or courts will shape the ultimate economic effects.
Doctrinal acknowledgement of legal uncertainty combined with standard economic modeling of regulatory expectations; no empirical modeling in the Article.
high null result Civil Rights and the EdTech Revolution degree of enforcement uncertainty and its effect on economic actor behavior
The paper is primarily legal/policy scholarship rather than an empirical assessment of the prevalence or magnitude of discrimination in EdTech; it does not provide econometric estimates of harm.
Explicit limitation noted in the Article (self‑reported).
high null result Civil Rights and the EdTech Revolution whether the Article provides empirical prevalence/magnitude estimates
The Article's evidence consists of illustrative case law and statutory text rather than empirical datasets; it builds doctrinal chains, hypotheticals, and applications of statutory language to modern procurement and EdTech deployment models.
Explicit description of evidence and limits in the Article (self‑reported).
high null result Civil Rights and the EdTech Revolution type of evidence used (doctrinal/case law vs. empirical data)
Methodologically, the paper uses doctrinal legal analysis and policy argumentation — close reading of federal civil‑rights statutes, administrative guidance, and judicial decisions interpreting 'recipient' and 'federal financial assistance.'
Explicit methodological statement in the Article (self‑reported).
high null result Civil Rights and the EdTech Revolution research method used in the Article
The legal argument is grounded in statutory interpretation and precedent about the scope of 'recipient' and how federal financial assistance flows and influence should be understood.
Doctrinal analysis of statutes, administrative guidance, and judicial decisions cited and discussed in the Article.
high null result Civil Rights and the EdTech Revolution basis of the Article's legal theory (statutory and precedent grounding)
Empirical validation of the book’s proposals would require complementary case studies, model documentation, and outcome measurements.
Author/reviewer recommendation in the blurb about methodological limitations and next steps; not an empirical finding.
high null result Governing The Future need for empirical case studies, documented models, and outcome metrics to valid...
The book is predominantly conceptual and policy-analytic and uses illustrative case vignettes rather than presenting a single empirical study.
Explicit methodological description in the Data & Methods blurb: synthesis of technical ideas, governance requirements, and illustrative vignettes; no empirical sample or experimental protocol described.
high null result Governing The Future presence or absence of empirical methodology in the book
The research program is grounded in 12 years of forensic legal research spanning 2014–2026.
Author-stated research timeline and methodology (2014–2026 forensic legal research).
high null result Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research research duration (years of study: 12)
The protocol is underpinned by a forensic audit of approximately 4,200 specialized texts (legal doctrine, regulation, standards, technical literature).
Stated corpus and audit in the Methods section: ~4,200 texts reviewed as part of the forensic audit.
high null result Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research size of the audited corpus (~4,200 texts)
The protocol systematizes arguments for 16 projected rulings at Mexico’s Supreme Court (SCJN) to anchor the proposed rights and rules in constitutional practice.
Doctrinal projection and constitutional strategy section of the compendium describing 16 projected SCJN rulings (method: legal projection/modeling).
high null result Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research existence of a systematized set of arguments aimed at 16 projected SCJN rulings
The compendium’s findings and recommendations are based on a forensic audit of approximately 4,200 specialized texts covering doctrine, jurisprudence, regulation and technical literature.
Stated methodological claim in the compendium: forensic corpus audit of ~4,200 texts (sample size reported).
high null result Diego Saucedo Portillo Sauceport Research size and composition of the document corpus used for analysis (number of texts)
Limitations of the review include the small sample of studies, uneven geographic coverage, heterogeneity in methods across studies, and limited long‑run evidence (especially on generative AI), which complicate causal aggregation.
Author-reported limitations based on the meta-assessment of the 17 included studies (variation in methods, contexts, and time horizons).
high null result The role of generative artificial intelligence on labor mark... limitations to causal inference and generalizability
Design of this work: a systematic literature review and meta‑synthesis of empirical findings from peer‑reviewed journals (2020–2025), based on 17 publications.
Stated methods and inclusion criteria of the paper: systematic review of peer‑reviewed literature (sample = 17).
high null result The role of generative artificial intelligence on labor mark... study design / review methodology
Long-term evidence on generative AI’s structural labor‑market effects is scarce; few longitudinal studies exist.
Assessment of study horizons and methods among the 17 papers indicates limited long-run and longitudinal analyses specifically on generative AI impacts.
high null result The role of generative artificial intelligence on labor mark... availability of long-term / longitudinal studies on generative AI effects
Empirical coverage is limited for low‑income countries; evidence from such settings is scarce.
Geographic distribution of the 17 reviewed studies shows concentration in advanced economies with few or no studies focused on low-income countries.
high null result The role of generative artificial intelligence on labor mark... geographic representativeness of empirical evidence
The literature shows a surge in research activity on AI and labor markets in 2023–2025 and a concentration of studies in advanced economies.
Meta-analytic summary of the publication years and geographic focus among the 17 selected publications (temporal and geographic count of included studies).
high null result The role of generative artificial intelligence on labor mark... publication counts by year and geographic coverage
Results depend on accurate skill extraction from vacancy texts and valid measures of occupational exposure/complementarity; causal interpretation of diffusion effects may be limited by endogeneity (e.g., technology adoption responding to labor-market conditions).
Authors' stated methodological limitations: reliance on text-analysis identification of skills and on constructed measures of exposure/complementarity; acknowledgement of endogeneity concerns limiting causal claims.
high null result Bridging Skill Gaps for the Future Validity and causal interpretability of estimated diffusion effects (methodologi...
The paper proposes two conceptual models (AI/ML‑Driven Labor Market Transformation Model and Sectoral Impact and Resilience Model) to organize heterogeneous findings and generate testable hypotheses about how AI reshapes labor across sectors and skill levels.
Conceptual synthesis integrating Technological Determinism, Socio‑Technical Systems Theory (STS), and Skill‑Biased Technological Change (SBTC); the models are theoretical outputs of the review used to map mechanisms and heterogeneity rather than empirical findings.
high null result The Impact of AI Machine Learning on Human Labor in the Work... conceptual mapping of mechanisms (task automation vs augmentation, sectoral expo...
There are substantial measurement and identification gaps in the literature: heterogeneity in measuring 'AI adoption', limited long‑run causal evidence, and geographic bias toward advanced economies.
Methodological assessment within the review noting variability across studies in AI measures (patents, investment, task exposure proxies), paucity of long‑run causal designs, and concentration of empirical studies in advanced economies; this is a meta‑evidence limitation statement.
high null result The Impact of AI Machine Learning on Human Labor in the Work... quality and robustness of empirical evidence on AI's labor‑market impacts
Quasi-experimental designs (difference-in-differences, instrumental variables, event studies) and panel regressions are useful methods for identifying causal effects of AI adoption where plausibly exogenous variation exists.
Methodological summary in the paper listing common empirical strategies used in the literature to estimate causal impacts of technology adoption.
high null result Intelligence and Labor Market Transformation: A Critical Ana... valid causal estimates of AI's effects on employment and wages
Current research is limited by measurement challenges in capturing AI capabilities and firm-level adoption, and by a lack of longitudinal worker-firm data and causal identification in many settings.
Explicit limitations noted by the paper: gaps in task measures, scarce longitudinal linked datasets, and methodological challenges in causal inference.
high null result Intelligence and Labor Market Transformation: A Critical Ana... quality and availability of AI exposure measures and longitudinal causal evidenc...
This paper's approach is qualitative and based on secondary literature synthesis; it does not collect primary survey, experimental, or administrative data.
Explicit statement in the Data & Methods section of the paper.
high null result Who Loses to Automation? AI-Driven Labour Displacement and t... type of data used (secondary qualitative synthesis rather than primary empirical...
Key empirical gaps remain: better measurement of K_T (AI/software capital), more granular matched employer‑employee and wealth data, and improved estimates of task-substitution elasticities are required to precisely quantify incidence and policy impacts.
Authors’ stated research agenda and limitations section, including sensitivity analyses showing outcome variation with parameter choices and measurement uncertainty.
high null result The Macroeconomic Transition of Technological Capital in the... quality/precision of measurement of K_T and task-substitution elasticities (rese...
Models are prompted to assess profiles along dimensions of social acceptance, marital stability, and cultural compatibility.
Experimental procedure: prompts asked models to rate profiles on the three named dimensions.
high other Sima AIunty: Caste Audit in LLM-Driven Matchmaking ratings for social acceptance, marital stability, cultural compatibility
We evaluate five LLM families (GPT, Gemini, Llama, Qwen, and BharatGPT).
Methods: models enumerated as the LLM families evaluated in the audit.
We vary caste identity across Brahmin, Kshatriya, Vaishya, Shudra, and Dalit, and income across five buckets.
Experimental design described: caste identity explicitly manipulated across five named caste categories; income varied across five buckets.
high other Sima AIunty: Caste Audit in LLM-Driven Matchmaking manipulation of profile attributes (caste, income)
We conduct a controlled audit of caste bias in LLM-mediated matchmaking evaluations using real-world matrimonial profiles.
Described methodology in the paper: a controlled audit using real-world matrimonial profiles to probe LLMs for caste bias.
high other Sima AIunty: Caste Audit in LLM-Driven Matchmaking presence of caste bias in LLM-mediated matchmaking evaluations
Research should prioritise longitudinal and theory-informed evaluations, including intersectionality-informed analyses, and assess downstream impacts on women’s career trajectories alongside robust governance and accountability practices.
Authors' recommendations based on identified gaps from the scoping review.
high positive Artificial intelligence applications supporting women’s care... recommended research priorities (longitudinal/theory-informed studies, intersect...
Using inductive thematic analysis, we identified three functional domains: (1) bias mitigation and representation, (2) skills development and empowerment and (3) career pathways and retention.
Authors' thematic analysis of the 13 empirical studies included in the scoping review.
high positive Artificial intelligence applications supporting women’s care... categorisation of AI applications into functional domains
Artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly integrated into career guidance and organisational decision systems.
Statement in abstract indicating observed trend; supported by literature search contextualising the review (scoping review using PRISMA-ScR).
high positive Artificial intelligence applications supporting women’s care... integration/adoption of AI into career guidance and organisational decision syst...
To foster more equitable outcomes, platform governance should be gender‑responsive, including algorithmic transparency, inclusive system design, and extension of core labor protections to gig workers.
Practical implications stated in the paper arising from the literature synthesis and feminist political economy framing.
high positive Empowerment or Inequality? A Feminist Political Economy Anal... policy interventions (algorithmic transparency, inclusive design, labor protecti...
AI‑enabled platforms can expand income opportunities and flexibility for women.
Thematic synthesis of findings across the 48 reviewed studies; reported in the paper's Findings as one side of a central paradox.
high positive Empowerment or Inequality? A Feminist Political Economy Anal... income opportunities and work flexibility
Generative AI is being used for automation of tax compliance.
Listed in the abstract as an illustrative example of algorithmic application to international tax (generative AI for automating tax compliance); no empirical measurement reported in the abstract.
high positive How TaxTech rewires global wealth chains automation of tax compliance processes
Blockchains are being used for instant trade verification in international tax contexts.
Presented in the abstract as one of three illustrative examples of how algorithmic technologies are being used for international tax purposes; no empirical details provided in the abstract.
high positive How TaxTech rewires global wealth chains use of blockchain for trade verification relevant to tax
It empowers owners of data and code.
Explicit claim in the abstract asserting a power shift toward those who own data and code; presented as a conceptual conclusion from the authors' reflection and examples.
high positive How TaxTech rewires global wealth chains empowerment / concentration of power among data-and-code owners
Global professional service firms are actively developing TaxTech to capture this market.
Direct statement in the abstract indicating market activity by global professional service firms; presented as an observed trend rather than supported by reported empirical data in the abstract.
high positive How TaxTech rewires global wealth chains development and adoption of TaxTech by professional service firms
Technological leaps in the algorithmic processing of information are providing financial actors with new opportunities for transnational financial and legal management that optimize asset allocation.
Stated as a conceptual observation in the paper's abstract; no empirical sample, presented as a general claim about technological change and its opportunities for financial actors.
high positive How TaxTech rewires global wealth chains optimization of asset allocation / opportunities for transnational financial and...
Improvements in skill adaptability reduce the risk of automation substitution.
Analysis linking measures of skill adaptability to lower estimated risk/impact of occupational automation exposure in the CFPS-based models.
high positive Dynamic Evolution and Configurational Heterogeneity of the S... risk of automation substitution
Vocational education background and participation in on-the-job training can mitigate the negative effects of technological shocks on wages.
Interaction analyses in the CFPS-based regressions showing that vocational education and on-the-job training attenuate the estimated negative impact of automation exposure on wages.
high positive Dynamic Evolution and Configurational Heterogeneity of the S... mitigating effect of vocational education and on-the-job training on wage impact...
Technological shocks significantly widen the skill wage gap.
Empirical analysis using the CFPS panel and the occupational task automation exposure index; paper reports statistically significant estimated effect of automation exposure on the skill wage gap.
The article proposes a Strategic Action Framework to support more inclusive and context-responsive AI ecosystems.
Policy recommendation/framework presented by the authors as a conclusion; not empirically evaluated within the study.
high positive Compressed professionalization in informal economies: a soci... Strategic Action Framework (policy intervention)