The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (7395 claims)

Adoption
7395 claims
Productivity
6507 claims
Governance
5877 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
5157 claims
Innovation
3492 claims
Org Design
3470 claims
Labor Markets
3224 claims
Skills & Training
2608 claims
Inequality
1835 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 609 159 77 736 1615
Governance & Regulation 664 329 160 99 1273
Organizational Efficiency 624 143 105 70 949
Technology Adoption Rate 502 176 98 78 861
Research Productivity 348 109 48 322 836
Output Quality 391 120 44 40 595
Firm Productivity 385 46 85 17 539
Decision Quality 275 143 62 34 521
AI Safety & Ethics 183 241 59 30 517
Market Structure 152 154 109 20 440
Task Allocation 158 50 56 26 295
Innovation Output 178 23 38 17 257
Skill Acquisition 137 52 50 13 252
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 120 64 38 23 252
Employment Level 93 46 96 12 249
Firm Revenue 130 43 26 3 202
Consumer Welfare 99 51 40 11 201
Inequality Measures 36 105 40 6 187
Task Completion Time 134 18 6 5 163
Worker Satisfaction 79 54 16 11 160
Error Rate 64 78 8 1 151
Regulatory Compliance 69 64 14 3 150
Training Effectiveness 81 15 13 18 129
Wages & Compensation 70 25 22 6 123
Team Performance 74 16 21 9 121
Automation Exposure 41 48 19 9 120
Job Displacement 11 71 16 1 99
Developer Productivity 71 14 9 3 98
Hiring & Recruitment 49 7 8 3 67
Social Protection 26 14 8 2 50
Creative Output 26 14 6 2 49
Skill Obsolescence 5 37 5 1 48
Labor Share of Income 12 13 12 37
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Adoption Remove filter
The architecture will enable richer distributional analysis of AI impacts (by skill, industry, region, age, race, and gender), informing more equitable policy design.
Claim based on proposed fine-grained OAIES and enhanced gross flows combined with microdata sources (CPS, LEHD, administrative records). No empirical distributional estimates are presented.
low positive Enhancing BLS Methodologies for Projecting AI's Impact on Em... differential employment/wage/transition effects across demographic and geographi...
LLM-derived task–capability mappings (if documented and validated) can establish reproducible, transparent measurement standards that other national statistical agencies and researchers could adopt.
Proposal to use LLM outputs and embeddings combined with expert-curated labels and documentation as a transparent reproducible mapping; no current cross-agency adoption or validation studies are provided.
low positive Enhancing BLS Methodologies for Projecting AI's Impact on Em... reproducibility and transparency of task–capability mappings; adoption by other ...
Integrating OAIES with task-based modeling, real-time signals, causal inference techniques, and enhanced gross flows estimation will produce more accurate, timely, and policy-relevant forecasts of job displacement, skill evolution, and workforce transformation across sectors and regions.
Architectural proposal combining multiple methodological components (task-based microsimulation, streaming job-posting/platform/admin signals, DiD/synthetic controls/IVs, high-frequency flows). The paper proposes backtesting and validation but does not present empirical performance data or sample results.
low positive Enhancing BLS Methodologies for Projecting AI's Impact on Em... forecast accuracy, timeliness of forecasts, estimates of job displacement, skill...
Techniques validated in these biomedical studies (compositional transforms, parsimonious ensemble pipelines, augmentation for small samples) are transferable to other biological domains such as agriculture and environmental monitoring.
Authors' assertion of methodological portability; no cross‑domain empirical tests reported in summary.
low positive Editorial: Integrating machine learning and AI in biological... Method transferability / performance in non‑medical biological applications (spe...
Widespread adoption of validated predictive models and curated multi‑omics datasets will shift R&D costs and productivity in biotech/pharma—reducing marginal costs of experiments, shortening timelines, and increasing returns to high‑quality data and models.
Economic analysis and inferred implications from reported improvements in in silico screening, diagnostics, and prognostics; no empirical R&D cost study provided in summary (conceptual projection).
low positive Editorial: Integrating machine learning and AI in biological... R&D marginal cost, development timelines, ROI (conceptual/economic)
The program can reduce skill mismatches and increase effective labor supply in targeted sectors, altering relative demand for AI-complementary vs. AI-substitutable tasks.
Economic argument in paper (theoretical); no empirical tests or sample reported.
low positive Curriculum engineering: organisation, orientation, and manag... skill mismatch indicators, effective labor supply in targeted sectors, demand fo...
Better-aligned curricula can raise the productivity and employability of graduates, shifting returns to human capital and affecting wage distribution by skill.
Theoretical economic reasoning and program rationale presented in paper; no empirical causal evidence provided.
low positive Curriculum engineering: organisation, orientation, and manag... graduate productivity, employability (placement/wage outcomes), wage distributio...
Advantages of the program include traceability, improved career-alignment and employability, audit readiness, and support for innovation through modelling and data analysis.
Paper lists these as intended advantages (asserted benefits); no empirical outcome data provided.
low positive Curriculum engineering: organisation, orientation, and manag... traceability metrics, career-alignment indicators, employability (placement rate...
Practitioners should combine the manufacturing operation tree with AI methods and real operational data to create validated, policy‑aware simulation tools that support economic decision making.
Practical guidance and proposed integration steps in the paper; presented as recommended practice rather than demonstrated case examples.
low positive A Review of Manufacturing Operations Research Integration in... existence and effectiveness of validated, policy‑aware simulation tools for deci...
The proposed roadmap can produce simulations that are realistic, validated against industry data, and useful for decision makers—supporting agility, resilience, and data‑driven planning.
Conceptual roadmap and recommendations in the paper; no empirical demonstrations or validation studies included.
low positive A Review of Manufacturing Operations Research Integration in... simulation realism, validation status, decision usefulness, organizational agili...
Digital financial ecosystems materially improve prospects for sustainable economic growth in emerging and developing economies.
Conceptual linkage and synthesis of cross-country cases and trends; descriptive indicators suggestive of macro benefits but no detailed macroeconomic causal analysis provided in the paper's summary.
low positive DIGITAL FINANCIAL ECOSYSTEMS AND FINANCIAL INCLUSION: AN INT... sustainable economic growth (broad macro indicators such as GDP growth, investme...
Regulatory tightening around IoT security and data privacy will increase demand for auditable, privacy-preserving ML-IDS and motivate standardization/certification (energy/latency classes, detection guarantees).
Survey's policy implications and forward-looking recommendations based on observed industry needs and regulatory trends.
low positive International Journal on Cybernetics & Informatics regulation-driven adoption and demand for compliant IDS solutions
Digitization advantages include clearer qualification pathways, reduced risk of lost records, and pedagogy better aligned with industrial skills.
Stated advantages in the paper's discussion; derived from logical argument and systems-design reasoning rather than empirical comparisons.
low positive <i>Electrotechnical education, institutional complianc... pathway clarity, frequency of lost/missing records, alignment of pedagogy with i...
Implementing Visual Basic–based logigram systems plus automated compliance checks will produce ratified qualifications, career-progression dashboards, and auditable archives.
Architecture and implementation sketch in the paper (proposed Visual Basic logigrams and automated checks); no prototype performance data or deployment case studies provided.
low positive <i>Electrotechnical education, institutional complianc... number of ratified qualifications, availability and accuracy of dashboards, exis...
Digital modernization of recordkeeping (cloud repositories, automated compliance) can restore continuity in credentialing, enable CPD-driven advancement, and help integrate rural training into industry needs.
Proposed systems-design interventions (Azure/GitHub repositories, automated compliance checks) and argumentation in the paper; no pilot data or empirical evaluation reported.
low positive <i>Electrotechnical education, institutional complianc... credential continuity, CPD-driven advancement rates, integration of rural traini...
Policy implication: develop data governance, interoperability, and safeguards to encourage public–private collaboration while protecting smallholders.
Authors' policy recommendation informed by thematic findings on governance and inclusion challenges in the review.
low positive A systematic review of the economic impact of artificial int... policy and regulatory framework quality
Policy implication: prioritize funding for localized AI solutions (context-specific models, language/extension support) and rural digital infrastructure (connectivity, data platforms, stable electricity).
Authors' recommendations based on synthesis of barriers, enabling factors, and observed impacts in the reviewed literature.
low positive A systematic review of the economic impact of artificial int... investment priorities to improve adoption and impact
Advanced pilot implementations report maintenance cost reductions of 10–25%.
Maintenance cost outcomes reported in case studies and pilot implementations contained in the review.
low positive Digital Twins Across the Asset Lifecycle: Technical, Organis... maintenance cost reductions (percent)
Advanced pilot implementations report energy reductions in the range 15–30%.
Energy performance figures taken from selected high‑performing pilot cases and deployments in the reviewed literature.
low positive Digital Twins Across the Asset Lifecycle: Technical, Organis... energy consumption reductions (percent)
Advanced pilot implementations report schedule acceleration of around 2 months.
Reported case results from advanced pilots and implementations included in the review (single‑project/case evidence).
low positive Digital Twins Across the Asset Lifecycle: Technical, Organis... project schedule reduction (time, months)
Advanced pilot implementations report cost savings of approximately 5%.
Case‑level results from high‑performing pilot deployments and pilot studies identified in the review.
low positive Digital Twins Across the Asset Lifecycle: Technical, Organis... project or lifecycle cost savings (percent)
Advanced pilot implementations report rework and logistics reductions of up to ~80%.
Quantitative figures drawn from case‑level results and advanced pilot deployments reported in the reviewed studies (not aggregated industry averages).
low positive Digital Twins Across the Asset Lifecycle: Technical, Organis... rework and logistics reductions (percent)
Functional and instrumental value of AI systems can speed organizational adoption via increased trust, implying economic importance of demonstrable productivity gains and clear ROI.
Interpretation/implication drawn from the study's empirical finding that functional/instrumental values increase initial trust and that trust positively affects adoption; this is an inference rather than a directly tested macroeconomic effect in the paper.
low positive Reimagining Stakeholder Engagement Through Generative AI: A ... Organizational adoption speed / diffusion (implied)
Destinations that invest in trustworthy AI ecosystems and credible sustainability narratives can capture greater market share, increasing competitive pressure among destinations and platforms.
Conceptual market-structure argument and literature synthesis; illustrated with Kebumen as an emergent destination example; no empirical testing offered.
low positive Sustainable Marketing Framework for Strengthening Consumer T... market share; competitive position
AI personalization can increase demand by improving match quality between tourists and offerings, raising consumer surplus and potentially willingness-to-pay.
Theoretical economic reasoning in the AI economics section of the paper; no empirical estimates or data provided.
low positive Sustainable Marketing Framework for Strengthening Consumer T... demand (bookings); consumer surplus; willingness-to-pay
These effects operate largely through consumer trust in technology (digital trust) as a mediator, with destination image serving as an additional mediator between trust and behavioral intention.
Theoretical mediation model proposed in the paper based on sustainable marketing theory and prior literature; illustrated via case discussion; no empirical testing reported.
low positive Sustainable Marketing Framework for Strengthening Consumer T... digital trust; destination image; visit intention
Digital experience quality, AI-driven personalization, sustainability communication, and social proof jointly shape destination image and tourists’ visit intention.
Conceptual integrative framework and literature synthesis presented in the paper; illustrated using Kebumen UNESCO Global Geopark as a case example; no primary empirical data collected.
low positive Sustainable Marketing Framework for Strengthening Consumer T... destination image; visit intention
Public funding for open models, shared compute infrastructures, and curated public datasets could counteract concentration and promote broad innovation.
Paper advocates this in 'Policy and public‑goods considerations' as a prescriptive policy option; it is a proposed mitigation rather than an empirically tested intervention in the text.
low positive Protein structure prediction powered by artificial intellige... impact of public funding/shared infrastructure on market concentration and innov...
Demand for security engineers, privacy specialists, human moderators, and behavioral scientists will rise, increasing wages in these specialties and altering labor allocations in AI/VR firms.
Authors' labor‑market inference drawn from increased needs implied by TVR‑Sec implementation and literature on moderation/security demand; no labor‑market data or forecasts provided.
low positive Securing Virtual Reality: Threat Models, Vulnerabilities, an... labor demand and wage pressure in security/privacy/safety roles (projected, not ...
Platforms that credibly offer strong privacy and socio‑behavioral protections may capture user trust and monetization opportunities (e.g., enterprise, healthcare, education), making safety features a potential competitive differentiator.
Authors' market‑structure reasoning based on synthesized literature and economic theory; no empirical adoption or revenue data provided to validate this claim.
low positive Securing Virtual Reality: Threat Models, Vulnerabilities, an... user trust and monetization/revenue gains tied to privacy/safety features (specu...
Harmonized international norms and transparency measures would reduce transaction costs, limit market fragmentation, and lower the likelihood of destabilizing arms‑race dynamics, thereby improving the environment for cross‑border investment and trade in AI.
Authors' normative/economic argumentation based on comparative findings; proposed as a policy implication rather than an empirically validated result.
low positive <b>Regulating AI in National Security: A Comparative S... transaction costs, market fragmentation, arms‑race likelihood, and cross‑border ...
Aligning domestic rules with international risk‑mitigation norms, increasing transparency in defence procurement/AI operations, and strengthening multilateral confidence measures would reduce escalation and abuse.
Authors' policy argumentation and normative reasoning based on comparative findings (not empirically tested in the paper).
low positive <b>Regulating AI in National Security: A Comparative S... likelihood of escalation, misuse, or abusive applications of military/dual‑use A...
Better consent mechanisms (granular, transferable, delegable) can change the marginal value and liquidity of personal data—enabling new pricing/contracting models (subscriptions, pay-for-privacy, data dividends).
Normative and conceptual claim from the workshop's economics discussion and design provocations; not empirically evaluated within the workshop summary.
low positive Moving Beyond Clicks: Rethinking Consent and User Control in... data market liquidity and pricing structures
We need to move beyond explicit, one-time decisions to broader ways users can influence data use (e.g., delegation, preferences over inference/usage).
Workshop recommendation emerging from co-design exercises, futures scenarios, and position papers; presented as a normative/design agenda rather than an empirically tested intervention.
low positive Moving Beyond Clicks: Rethinking Consent and User Control in... feasibility/effectiveness of alternative consent modalities (delegation, prefere...
Policy instruments such as open-data mandates, compute-sharing incentives, and conditionality in R&D funding can help ensure equitable validation and local engagement in climate-AI development.
Policy recommendations grounded in normative analysis and analogies to existing public-good interventions; no empirical evaluation of these specific instruments provided in the paper.
low positive The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Adoption of policy instruments and subsequent changes in equity of validation pr...
Economists should prioritize research to quantify returns to investments in CDPI versus private compute, estimate economic costs of maladaptation from biased AI outputs, and design incentive-compatible mechanisms for data sharing and co-production.
Research agenda and recommendations presented by the authors; this is a suggested empirical/theoretical program rather than a tested result.
low positive The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Feasibility and quantified returns of policy/research interventions (e.g., CDPI ...
Establishing Climate Digital Public Infrastructure (CDPI)—shared, interoperable data and compute resources, standards, and governance—can democratize access and reduce inequities in climate-AI.
Policy proposal and normative argument drawing analogies to public goods (observational networks, satellites); no empirical evaluation of CDPI implementations presented.
low positive The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Access to compute/data, interoperability, and distributional equity in climate-A...
Shifting from a model-centric to a data-centric approach (improving data quality, representativeness, and governance) will mitigate the harms caused by current infrastructural asymmetries.
Normative recommendation grounded in conceptual arguments and illustrative examples; not supported by empirical interventions or randomized/controlled comparisons in the paper.
low positive The Rise of AI in Weather and Climate Information and its Im... Improvements in data representativeness, model performance, and equity of output...
Policy and governance should preserve worker agency (participatory design, transparency, clear accountability) and support training and institutional mechanisms (collective bargaining, workplace representation) to negotiate value-sharing from AI productivity gains.
Normative policy recommendation by authors derived from qualitative findings (workshops with 15 UX designers) that highlighted agency and distributional concerns.
low positive The Values of Value in AI Adoption: Rethinking Efficiency in... worker agency and value-sharing mechanisms (policy-targeted outcomes; recommende...
Operationally, platform designers should monitor dependency-graph structure as a systemic risk indicator for price volatility and provide integrator abstractions to encapsulate cross-cutting complexity.
Practical implication drawn from simulation findings (not a direct empirical test on production systems): hybrid integrator results and topology-dominance results motivate these recommendations; no real-world deployment data presented.
low positive Real-Time AI Service Economy: A Framework for Agentic Comput... anticipated reduction in price volatility and market management complexity (supp...
Clinic-aware designs and reliable validation can enable clearer evidence of value, facilitating payer reimbursement, value-based care contracts, and new pricing models for AI-enabled medical devices and services.
Policy and reimbursement implications discussed by clinicians and industry participants during the workshop and summarized in the workshop report (NSF workshop, Sept 26–27, 2024).
low positive Report for NSF Workshop on Algorithm-Hardware Co-design for ... payer reimbursement approvals, value-based contract adoption, and pricing model ...
Scalable validation ecosystems and continuous objective measures reduce information asymmetries between developers, clinicians, and payers, lowering commercialization and regulatory risk, which raises private returns and speeds adoption.
Economic implications and causal argument set out in the workshop summary based on expert judgement and theory discussed at the NSF workshop (Sept 26–27, 2024).
low positive Report for NSF Workshop on Algorithm-Hardware Co-design for ... information asymmetry indicators, commercialization/regulatory risk measures, fi...
Procedural material modeling (Perlin noise) is a promising technique for robust policy learning and can reduce the need for extensive real-world data collection.
Implication stated in the paper's discussion: authors suggest procedural variation via Perlin noise aided robust policy learning and improved sim-to-real transfer; empirical quantification of reduced real data needs is not provided in the summary.
low positive Learning Adaptive Force Control for Contact-Rich Sample Scra... robustness of learned policy / reduction in required real-world training data (c...
Perception providing the material's location inside the vial was used to guide the agent.
Paper summary states perception input (material location) was provided to the agent; sensing modality and accuracy/details of perception are not specified.
low positive Learning Adaptive Force Control for Contact-Rich Sample Scra... availability/usability of material location information to the agent (perception...
Using CFR avoids the computational and development costs of retraining T2I models to improve color fidelity, providing a lower-cost path to better color authenticity.
Paper emphasizes CFR is training-free and applies at inference, claiming improved color authenticity without model retraining; cost implication is inferred from lack of retraining (quantitative compute savings not provided in the summary).
low positive Too Vivid to Be Real? Benchmarking and Calibrating Generativ... compute/development cost required to improve color fidelity (inference-only CFR ...
Once trained, these simulation-trained summary networks are fast to evaluate and can be used as amortized estimators to enable large-scale counterfactuals, sensitivity analyses, and Monte Carlo-based policy evaluation with much lower per-evaluation cost.
Practical implication claim: based on amortization principle (neural network inference is fast at evaluation time) and reported ability to replace repeated runs of iterative algorithms; the summary asserts reduced per-evaluation cost but does not provide quantitative runtime benchmarks or speedup ratios in the provided text.
low positive ForwardFlow: Simulation only statistical inference using dee... per-evaluation runtime / computational cost (claimed reduction; not quantitative...
Organizations should consider LLM-generated feedback as a high-return, lower-cost PRF option for low-resource retrieval tasks to reduce expenses tied to corpus annotation or expensive retrieval pipelines.
Implication drawn from the paper's cost-effectiveness results (LLM-generated feedback performing well per LLM invocation cost across the evaluated BEIR tasks).
low positive A Systematic Study of Pseudo-Relevance Feedback with LLMs Economic metric: return (retrieval gains) per dollar spent on LLM invocations or...
QCSC capabilities could change the economics of certain AI model classes that rely on expensive scientific simulations for training data by producing richer, cheaper training datasets.
Theoretical link between simulation output quality/cost and training-data generation for physics-informed ML and generative chemistry models; no empirical studies or cost estimates presented.
low positive Reference Architecture of a Quantum-Centric Supercomputer cost and quality of training datasets for simulation-dependent AI models, downst...
QCSC-enabled faster, higher-fidelity simulation can compress R&D cycles in chemistry and materials, lowering time-to-discovery and increasing returns to computational investment for firms.
Use-case analysis linking simulation fidelity/turnaround to R&D timelines; relies on assumed speedups and fidelity improvements but provides no measured speedup data.
low positive Reference Architecture of a Quantum-Centric Supercomputer R&D cycle time (time-to-discovery), cost per discovery, returns to computational...
The proposed approach will increase demand for edge/embedded ML expertise, GNN optimization, and HAPS integration, shifting supplier ecosystems and labor requirements.
Workforce and supply-chain implication stated in the paper's discussion of economic impacts; based on projected capabilities required to implement FL+GNN solutions, not on labor-market measurements.
low positive Federated Learning-driven Beam Management in LEO 6G Non-Terr... demand for specialized skills and supplier ecosystem changes (speculative)