The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (13661 claims)

Adoption
8339 claims
Productivity
7479 claims
Governance
6715 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6267 claims
Org Design
4098 claims
Innovation
3987 claims
Labor Markets
3488 claims
Skills & Training
2888 claims
Inequality
2016 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 740 192 95 871 1945
Governance & Regulation 796 388 185 119 1512
Organizational Efficiency 765 186 123 82 1166
Technology Adoption Rate 610 227 121 95 1061
Research Productivity 409 121 56 331 928
Output Quality 464 174 58 47 743
Decision Quality 318 173 75 42 615
Firm Productivity 432 55 88 20 601
AI Safety & Ethics 214 273 65 33 589
Market Structure 175 165 120 24 489
Task Allocation 206 64 70 31 376
Skill Acquisition 161 57 57 16 291
Innovation Output 201 27 41 18 288
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 130 69 43 26 275
Employment Level 104 50 105 13 274
Consumer Welfare 116 62 42 11 231
Firm Revenue 149 45 26 3 223
Inequality Measures 43 120 49 6 218
Task Completion Time 164 29 8 12 214
Worker Satisfaction 89 60 20 12 181
Error Rate 69 89 9 2 169
Regulatory Compliance 74 67 14 4 159
Training Effectiveness 91 19 13 19 144
Wages & Compensation 77 33 25 6 141
Team Performance 86 17 27 9 140
Automation Exposure 49 50 22 12 136
Developer Productivity 91 17 14 5 128
Job Displacement 12 80 19 1 112
Hiring & Recruitment 51 7 8 3 69
Creative Output 31 16 7 2 57
Skill Obsolescence 5 43 6 1 55
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 17 17 51
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
AEL outperforms five published self-improving methods and all non-LLM baselines while maintaining the lowest variance among all LLM-based approaches on the benchmark.
Comparative empirical evaluation on the same sequential portfolio benchmark, comparing AEL to five published self-improving methods and multiple non-LLM and LLM baselines (reported relative ranking and variance).
high positive AEL: Agent Evolving Learning for Open-Ended Environments relative performance (ranking) and variance across methods
On a sequential portfolio benchmark (10 sector-diverse tickers, 208 episodes, 5 random seeds), AEL achieves a Sharpe ratio of 2.13 ± 0.47.
Empirical experiment on the sequential portfolio benchmark with 10 tickers, 208 episodes, evaluated across 5 random seeds (reported Sharpe ratio and standard deviation).
high positive AEL: Agent Evolving Learning for Open-Ended Environments Sharpe ratio (portfolio performance metric)
We introduce Agent Evolving Learning (AEL), a two-timescale framework in which a Thompson Sampling bandit at the fast timescale learns which memory retrieval policy to apply each episode, while LLM-driven reflection at the slow timescale diagnoses failure patterns and injects causal insights into the agent's decision prompt.
Methodological description and proposed algorithmic design in the paper (no additional experimental sample size—design/algorithmic claim).
high positive AEL: Agent Evolving Learning for Open-Ended Environments framework architecture / learning framework
The sustainability of the algorithmic state rests on a movement from technocratic secrecy to value-based transparency to ensure AI- and human collaboration is founded on institutional accountability and algorithmic justice.
Authorial conclusion from the systematic review synthesis (2018-2026) advocating a policy/practice shift; presented as normative policy recommendation rather than quantified empirical finding.
high positive Artificial Intelligence, Public Policy and Governance - impl... sustainability of algorithmic/state governance (accountability and algorithmic j...
Empirical evidence shows great gains in efficiency in fiscal forecasting.
Empirical studies included in the PRISMA-guided review (2018-2026) reporting improved fiscal forecasting outcomes; no quantitative effect sizes provided in abstract.
high positive Artificial Intelligence, Public Policy and Governance - impl... accuracy/efficiency of fiscal forecasting
Empirical evidence shows great gains in efficiency at routinised administrative tasks.
Empirical studies reported in the systematic review (2018-2026); the abstract claims empirical evidence of efficiency gains but does not report specific study counts, sample sizes, or effect magnitudes.
high positive Artificial Intelligence, Public Policy and Governance - impl... efficiency in routinised administrative tasks
Digital infrastructure is a primary determinant of both the pace of AI diffusion and its resulting economic returns.
Synthesis of descriptive patterns, difference-in-differences causal estimates, and instrumental-variable results using Turkish administrative and survey data (2021-2024).
high positive Digital Infrastructure, AI Adoption, and Firm Performance * pace of AI diffusion and economic returns (productivity, exports, labor composit...
Infrastructure-driven AI adoption shifts labor composition toward ICT-related roles.
Instrumental-variable estimates showing changes in occupational composition (increase in ICT-related roles) associated with infrastructure-driven AI adoption; based on administrative employment data and enterprise survey (Turkey, 2021-2024).
high positive Digital Infrastructure, AI Adoption, and Firm Performance * share of ICT-related roles in employment (labor composition)
Infrastructure-driven AI adoption raises export intensity.
Instrumental-variable estimates linking infrastructure-driven adoption to firm export intensity using administrative and survey data (Turkey, 2021-2024).
Infrastructure-driven AI adoption raises labor productivity.
Instrumental-variable estimates where infrastructure-driven adoption is instrumented (IV) and linked to firm-level labor productivity measures; data from administrative records and enterprise survey in Turkey (2021-2024).
Improved connectivity (due to pipeline-driven fiber deployment) significantly increases AI adoption, particularly for software-intensive technologies and among small and medium-sized enterprises.
Causal inference using difference-in-differences estimates exploiting staggered pipeline expansion as variation in connectivity; sample drawn from administrative records and nationally representative enterprise survey (Turkey, 2021-2024).
high positive Digital Infrastructure, AI Adoption, and Firm Performance * AI adoption (change due to improved connectivity)
AI adoption is concentrated among large firms and in regions with high-speed broadband and proximity to data centers, particularly for software-intensive and cloud-based applications.
Descriptive analysis using administrative data and a nationally representative enterprise survey from Turkey (2021-2024).
high positive Digital Infrastructure, AI Adoption, and Firm Performance * AI adoption (concentration by firm size and region)
This survey provides scholars and practitioners with a structured understanding of how agentic AI is reshaping financial markets and identifies critical research directions to ensure these systems enhance both operational efficiency and market resilience.
Statement of contribution in the paper; based on the paper's literature review, taxonomy, and identified research agenda.
high positive Agentic Artificial Intelligence in Finance: A Comprehensive ... clarity for research/practice and identification of research directions to impro...
Agentic AI offers substantial potential for enhanced market efficiency, liquidity provision, and risk management.
Survey synthesis of foundational research, market applications, and technical architectures suggesting potential benefits; no original empirical evaluation reported.
high positive Agentic Artificial Intelligence in Finance: A Comprehensive ... market efficiency, liquidity provision, risk management
The emergence of agentic AI represents a fundamental transformation in financial markets, characterized by autonomous systems capable of reasoning, planning, and adaptive decision-making with minimal human intervention.
Conceptual claim stated in the survey's introduction and synthesis of recent advances; based on literature review and theoretical framing rather than new empirical data.
high positive Agentic Artificial Intelligence in Finance: A Comprehensive ... degree of autonomy and decision-making capability of AI systems in financial mar...
Countries around the world are rushing to encourage greater investment and growth in their domestic AI industries.
Statement/observation presented in the paper's introduction; based on the paper's descriptive overview of global policy activity (literature review / policy survey implied). No sample size reported.
high positive Fighting for Democracy Amid the AI Race: Designing Tech In... government encouragement of AI investment and growth
Results indicate that AI-assisted text-to-model methods can substantially lower the cost of constructing structured procedural representations, making course-wide deployment of structured AI coaching systems practically feasible.
Conclusion drawn from reported results (e.g., time reductions and modeled outputs); the paper claims that these results imply lower costs and practical feasibility for course-wide deployment.
high positive Developing Models of Procedural Skills using an AI-assisted ... cost (effort/time) of constructing structured procedural representations and fea...
AI-assisted authoring reduced expert modeling time by 50–70% while producing structurally valid and highly reproducible models under fixed-input conditions.
Quantitative claim reported in the paper comparing expert modeling time with AI assistance and reporting structural validity and reproducibility under fixed-input conditions; exact experimental setup and sample size not stated in the abstract.
high positive Developing Models of Procedural Skills using an AI-assisted ... expert modeling time (and structural validity / reproducibility of produced mode...
We apply the pipeline to instructional materials from a graduate-level online AI course, constructing 23 procedural skill models.
Empirical application reported in the paper: the pipeline was run on course materials and produced 23 models (number explicitly stated).
high positive Developing Models of Procedural Skills using an AI-assisted ... number of procedural skill models produced
The approach automates structural scaffolding while preserving expert oversight for validating causal transitions and failure conditions.
Claim about system design and human-in-the-loop workflow reported in the paper; implies human validation steps are maintained alongside automated generation.
high positive Developing Models of Procedural Skills using an AI-assisted ... degree of automation of structural scaffolding and retention of expert validatio...
We present a human-in-the-loop text-to-model pipeline that uses large language models to transform instructional materials into schema-complete Task-Method-Knowledge models via ontology-constrained prompting and template-based generation.
Methodological contribution described in the paper; pipeline design and implementation reported (no separate quantitative validation in this sentence).
high positive Developing Models of Procedural Skills using an AI-assisted ... ability to transform instructional materials into schema-complete Task-Method-Kn...
When unfairness is driven by uncertainty (rather than incidental noise), accounting for uncertainty is essential to achieving fair and effective decision-making.
Synthesis/argument based on formalization and simulation experiments showing cases where uncertainty causes unfair outcomes and methods that account for uncertainty mitigate those outcomes.
high positive Fairness under uncertainty in sequential decisions fairness and effectiveness of decision-making when uncertainty is accounted for
The proposed framework can help practitioners diagnose, audit, and govern fairness risks in socio-technical decision systems.
Authors propose a diagnostic/audit/governance framework (conceptual contribution) and illustrate its use through examples and simulations; no field deployment evidence provided in the abstract.
high positive Fairness under uncertainty in sequential decisions practitioner ability to diagnose/audit/govern fairness risks
Algorithmic examples in the paper demonstrate it is possible to reduce outcome variance for disadvantaged groups while preserving institutional objectives such as expected utility.
Algorithmic examples and simulation experiments reported in the paper demonstrating reductions in outcome variance for disadvantaged groups together with preserved expected utility (results from synthetic/simulated data and model runs).
high positive Fairness under uncertainty in sequential decisions outcome variance for disadvantaged groups; expected utility (institutional objec...
The authors formalize model and feedback uncertainty using counterfactual logic and reinforcement learning.
Paper describes formalization/mathematical definitions linking counterfactual logic and reinforcement learning to model and feedback uncertainty (theoretical/methodological contribution).
high positive Fairness under uncertainty in sequential decisions formalization of uncertainty types
This paper introduces a taxonomy of uncertainty in sequential decision-making consisting of three types: model uncertainty, feedback uncertainty, and prediction uncertainty.
Paper presents a conceptual taxonomy and names the three uncertainty types in the text/abstract; theoretical exposition in the methods/definitions sections (no external empirical sample required).
high positive Fairness under uncertainty in sequential decisions categories of uncertainty in sequential decision-making
The emergence of 'Industry 4.0 Inc.' is likely to induce further collaboration among participating incumbents.
Authors' inference based on observed interconnections and overlapping investments in the M&A-based mapping (predictive/interpretive claim; no quantified projection provided in the excerpt).
high positive Industry 4.0 Inc.—Mergers and acquisitions and the digital t... collaboration among incumbent firms
One consequence of increased M&A activity and overlapping investments is the emergence of interconnections that have given rise to a new structure the authors term 'Industry 4.0 Inc.'
Network mapping of corporate linkages and overlapping investments derived from the M&A deal analysis spanning more than two decades (method: empirical mapping of inter-corporate ties); exact counts not provided in the excerpt.
high positive Industry 4.0 Inc.—Mergers and acquisitions and the digital t... emergence of inter-firm interconnections / new industry structure ('Industry 4.0...
Mergers and acquisitions are one of the principal tools industrial firms use to overcome this dual challenge.
Authors' argumentation supported by an empirical analysis of more than two decades of M&A deals (method: M&A deal analysis); exact sample size not stated in provided text.
high positive Industry 4.0 Inc.—Mergers and acquisitions and the digital t... use of M&A to acquire digital capabilities and skills
HAF-DS provides a scalable and adaptable solution for modern textile and PPE supply chains.
Author claim in conclusions indicating scalability and adaptability as properties of the proposed framework; supported implicitly by application to multiple datasets.
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... scalability and adaptability of the solution
Coupling predictive forecasting with prescriptive optimization enhances both accuracy and efficiency in textile and PPE supply chains.
Summary conclusion drawn from the reported experimental improvements in forecast errors and operational metrics on textile and PPE datasets.
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... forecast accuracy and operational efficiency
Service level rose from 95.5% to 97.8%.
Reported experimental operational metric (service level) improvement values under HAF-DS versus baseline (95.5% -> 97.8%).
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... service level (fill rate / on-time fulfillment)
Stockouts decreased by 27.5%.
Reported experimental operational metric indicating a 27.5% reduction in stockouts under HAF-DS compared to baseline.
Inventory cost decreased by 5.4%.
Reported experimental operational metric (inventory cost) showing 5.4% reduction under HAF-DS relative to baseline.
On the combined dataset, HAF-DS reduced Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE) from 9.5% to 8.1%.
Reported experimental result on the combined dataset comparing MAPE of HAF-DS vs baseline (values given: 9.5% -> 8.1%).
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE)
On the combined dataset, HAF-DS reduced Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE) from 19.53 to 17.11 (12.4%).
Reported experimental result on the combined dataset comparing RMSE of HAF-DS vs baseline (values given: 19.53 -> 17.11, with percent reduction 12.4%).
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE)
On the combined dataset, HAF-DS reduced Mean Absolute Error (MAE) from 15.04 to 12.83 (14.7%).
Reported experimental result on the combined dataset comparing MAE of HAF-DS vs baseline (values given: 15.04 -> 12.83, with percent reduction 14.7%).
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... Mean Absolute Error (MAE)
Experiments on textile sales and supply chain datasets show significant performance gains over statistical and deep learning baselines.
Empirical evaluation reported on textile sales and supply chain datasets with comparisons to statistical and deep learning baseline models (datasets described broadly; no sample sizes given).
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... forecasting performance relative to baselines
The framework jointly minimizes forecasting error and operational cost through embedding-based feature representation and recurrent neural architectures.
Paper text describing joint objective (minimize forecasting error and operational cost) and the use of embedding-based features plus recurrent networks to accomplish this.
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... combined forecasting error and operational cost
The optimization layer prescribes cost-efficient replenishment and allocation decisions (MILP).
Method description stating the use of a MILP optimization layer to produce replenishment/allocation decisions aimed at cost efficiency.
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... cost-efficient replenishment and allocation decisions
The LSTM captures temporal and contextual demand dependencies.
Methodological description asserting LSTM's role in modeling temporal and contextual dependencies within the forecasting module.
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... ability to capture temporal and contextual demand dependencies
The paper proposes a Hybrid AI Framework for Demand-Supply Forecasting and Optimization (HAF-DS), which integrates a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM)-based demand forecasting module with a mixed integer linear programming (MILP) optimization layer.
Paper description of the proposed framework (design/architecture). Reports integration of LSTM forecasting module and MILP optimization layer as the core contribution.
high positive Hybrid Deep Learning Approach for Coupled Demand Forecasting... design/architecture integration of forecasting and optimization
Dynamic combinations of AI and organizational structure can help managers overcome traditional trade-offs between scale and scope, opening pathways for scalable, cross-market expansion.
Managerial implication drawn from the paper's longitudinal case study of ByteDance; qualitative inference from observed organizational practices and AI deployment patterns.
high positive Scaling high and wide: How firms leverage AI and organizatio... managerial ability to overcome scale–scope trade-offs and enable cross-market ex...
AI transforms the scale–scope nexus from being a trade-off into a source of strategic advantage.
Synthesis and theoretical claim derived from longitudinal case study of ByteDance showing simultaneous scaling and diversification enabled by AI and organizational design.
high positive Scaling high and wide: How firms leverage AI and organizatio... ability to simultaneously achieve scale and scope (strategic advantage from comb...
AI reverses the conventional logic of the resource-based view: rather than valuable resources enabling diversification, diversification amplifies the value of resources.
Theoretical argument supported by the ByteDance case study; paper presents this as a theorized inversion based on observed patterns in the single-case study.
high positive Scaling high and wide: How firms leverage AI and organizatio... amplification of resource value as a result of diversification
The value of AI learning transfer across domains is contingent on access to structurally related data that allow learning to transfer across domains.
Claim derived from the ByteDance longitudinal case study showing conditions for successful cross-domain AI transfer (qualitative evidence emphasizing data structure/relatedness).
high positive Scaling high and wide: How firms leverage AI and organizatio... effectiveness of transfer learning across domains (dependence on structurally re...
AI evolves and improves through self-learning and cross-fertilization across domains, becoming increasingly valuable as learning accumulates.
Theoretical claim supported by longitudinal observations from the ByteDance case study (qualitative evidence from repeated AI deployments over time).
high positive Scaling high and wide: How firms leverage AI and organizatio... AI capability improvement/value accumulation over time
ByteDance leveraged AI and adaptive organizational design to scale rapidly and diversify across industries and markets without incurring rising costs or coordination complexity.
Longitudinal single-case (qualitative) study of ByteDance described in the paper; method reported as a longitudinal case study of one firm.
high positive Scaling high and wide: How firms leverage AI and organizatio... ability to scale and diversify across industries and markets (growth and diversi...
Humble leadership indirectly alleviates the negative indirect effect of HAI-C task complexity on work engagement by enhancing employees' AI self-efficacy.
Reported moderated mediation/conditional process findings from hierarchical regression and bootstrapping on the three-wave matched sample of 497 employees.
AI self-efficacy mitigates (buffers) the negative indirect impact of HAI-C task complexity on employees' work engagement.
Moderated mediation analysis conducted on longitudinal survey data (n=497) using hierarchical regression and bootstrapping; reported in Results that AI self-efficacy weakens the negative indirect effect.