The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (7631 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Productivity Remove filter
Stakeholder validation confirms the system's operational feasibility with 95% approval.
Stakeholder validation (presumably via survey or consultation) reporting 95% approval for operational feasibility. (The summary does not specify the number of stakeholders, selection criteria, or survey instrument.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... operational feasibility approval rate (percentage)
The study validates theoretical frameworks such as triple-entry accounting (Grigg, 2024) and X-Accounting (Faccia et al., 2020).
Conceptual/theoretical alignment demonstrated by mapping the hybrid ML-blockchain architecture and empirical findings to the premises of the cited frameworks. (Summary does not specify formal validation method or criteria.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... theoretical validation / conceptual alignment
The system maintains 99.8% transaction accuracy.
Reported transaction accuracy measured on the same empirical datasets (public-sector financial records and private-sector supply chains) used to evaluate the hybrid system. (The summary does not provide sample size, timeframe, or definition of 'transaction accuracy'.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... transaction accuracy (percentage)
The hybrid system produces a 60% reduction in reconciliation time.
Empirical measurement of reconciliation time on datasets from public-sector financial records and private-sector supply chains comparing hybrid ML-blockchain workflows to traditional reconciliation processes. (No sample size or absolute times provided in the summary.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... reconciliation time (percent reduction)
A hybrid ML-blockchain system achieves a 9.8% improvement in fraud detection accuracy (F1-score).
Quantitative evaluation using empirical data drawn from public-sector financial records and private-sector supply chains; improvement reported as change in F1-score between the hybrid system and baseline (traditional) oversight approaches. (Paper does not report sample sizes or exact baseline metrics in the summary.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... fraud detection accuracy (F1-score)
Both stable individual differences and moment-to-moment fluctuations in perspective-taking influence AI response quality.
Analyses reported in the paper linking both trait-level (stable) and state-level (moment-to-moment) measures of perspective-taking to variation in AI response quality across the benchmark dataset; assessed via the Bayesian IRT model and supplementary within-subject analyses.
medium positive Quantifying and Optimizing Human-AI Synergy: Evidence-Based ... AI response quality (as rated or measured) as a function of trait and state pers...
Theory of Mind (the capacity to infer and adapt to others' mental states) emerges as a key predictor of synergy.
Statistical association reported between participants' Theory of Mind measures and the estimated synergy (improvement in performance with AI), based on analysis of the benchmark dataset (n = 667) within the Bayesian IRT framework.
medium positive Quantifying and Optimizing Human-AI Synergy: Evidence-Based ... synergy (performance improvement with AI assistance) predicted by Theory of Mind...
These AI formulation models reduced experimental workload by 30–50%.
Reported in the review as estimated reductions in experimental workload when using AI-driven formulation optimization. The excerpt lacks details on how workload was measured, which experiments were replaced or reduced, and sample sizes.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... experimental workload (percent reduction in experiments or resources)
In formulation optimization, artificial neural networks, neuro-fuzzy systems, and hybrid model-based AI models have been able to predict dissolution profiles and critical quality attributes with accuracy rates of over 90%.
Reported model performance in formulation optimization studies summarized by the review. The excerpt does not include which specific studies, datasets, cross-validation protocols, or sample sizes produced >90% accuracy.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... predictive accuracy for dissolution profiles and critical quality attributes (pe...
AI has reduced clinical trial duration by up to 59%.
Reported in the review as an observed maximum reduction in trial duration associated with AI-driven approaches. The excerpt omits details on which trials, therapeutic areas, trial phases, or sample sizes produced this figure.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... clinical trial duration (percentage reduction)
AI has sped up compound screening by 1–2 years.
Presented in the review as a comparative reduction in time-to-screening attributed to AI methods. The excerpt does not provide the underlying studies, screening scope, or sample sizes.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... compound screening duration (time saved; measured in years)
AI-enabled platforms have cut the drug discovery pipeline timelines (compared with the traditional 4–6 years) down to 46 days.
Reported as an outcome of AI-enabled platforms in the review. The excerpt does not list the specific platform(s), individual study design(s), or sample sizes underlying the 46-day figure.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... drug discovery pipeline duration (time to identify/advance candidate; measured i...
Artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming pharmaceutical research and development (R and D), and making measurable improvements in efficiency, precision, and cost-effectiveness in drug research and development.
Stated as a summary conclusion in the review based on cross-domain literature synthesis. Specific studies or quantitative meta-analytic methods and sample sizes are not provided in the excerpt.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... overall R&D efficiency, precision, and cost-effectiveness in pharmaceutical drug...
Experiments on simulated and real-world data show that humans assisted by the adaptive AI ensemble achieve significantly higher performance than humans assisted by single AI models trained either for independent AI performance or for human-AI team performance.
Empirical experiments reported in the paper on both simulated datasets and real-world data; the abstract states results are statistically significant but does not provide sample sizes, datasets, or statistical details in the excerpt.
medium positive Align When They Want, Complement When They Need! Human-Cente... human decision-making performance / human-AI team performance (improvement when ...
An adaptive AI ensemble that toggles between two specialist models (an aligned model and a complementary model) using a Rational Routing Shortcut mechanism overcomes the complementarity–alignment limitation of single-model approaches.
Methodological contribution described in the paper; includes the design of the ensemble and the Rational Routing Shortcut; theoretical guarantees of near-optimality are claimed in the paper (proofs referenced but not shown in the excerpt).
medium positive Align When They Want, Complement When They Need! Human-Cente... contextual model selection/routing and resulting human-AI team performance
EASP offers a practical tradeoff between reasoning quality and latency by avoiding iterative LLM tool-calls at inference time while still producing grounded plans.
Methodological claim in the paper: Probe-then-Plan uses a lightweight probe to avoid heavy iterative LLM tool calls during serving; supported by design rationale and performance-focused evaluations (offline and online).
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... inference latency vs. reasoning/plan validity tradeoff (system performance outco...
EASP has been successfully deployed in JD.com's AI-Search system.
Statement in the paper that EASP was deployed in JD.com's AI-Search system; presumably validated by internal deployment logs and online A/B testing reported.
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... deployment status in production (operational outcome)
Online A/B testing on JD.com demonstrates that EASP achieves substantial lifts in UCVR (user conversion rate) and GMV (gross merchandise volume).
Reported results from online A/B testing on JD.com referenced in the paper indicating lifts in UCVR and GMV (no numerical magnitudes provided in the abstract).
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... UCVR (user conversion rate) and GMV (gross merchandise volume)
Extensive offline evaluations and online A/B testing on JD.com show that EASP significantly improves relevant recall.
Empirical claims in the paper citing extensive offline evaluations and online A/B testing on JD.com as the basis for observed improvements in relevant recall (specific datasets/sizes not reported in the abstract).
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... relevant recall (retrieval effectiveness metric)
Environment-Aware Search Planning (EASP) resolves the blindness-latency dilemma in LLM-based e-commerce search by grounding planning in the real retrieval environment via a Probe-then-Plan mechanism.
Conceptual design and empirical evaluation described in the paper: introduces a lightweight Retrieval Probe to expose a retrieval snapshot and a Planner that diagnoses execution gaps and generates grounded search plans; supported by offline evaluations and online A/B testing on JD.com (section describing method and experiments).
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... ability to produce environment-grounded search plans that address execution gaps...
The study recommends multi-stakeholder collaborations (policymakers, financial institutions, entrepreneurs) to design inclusive AI solutions, bridge the digital skills gap, and foster an environment for equitable entrepreneurial growth.
Policy and practice recommendations drawn in the paper's conclusion based on empirical findings and interpretation of barriers.
medium positive The role of artificial intelligence in enhancing financial l... recommended actions (policy/practice) to improve inclusive AI adoption and entre...
Firms with high AI adoption reported superior decision-making quality compared to low adopters.
Survey comparisons of decision-making quality measures between AI adoption groups in the questionnaire data (N=400), reported as superior for high adopters.
medium positive The role of artificial intelligence in enhancing financial l... decision-making quality
Firms with high AI adoption reported significantly higher financial literacy scores compared to low adopters.
Comparison of financial literacy scores between high and low AI adoption groups derived from the structured questionnaire responses (sample N=400); described as 'significantly higher' in the paper.
medium positive The role of artificial intelligence in enhancing financial l... financial literacy score
There is a positive correlation between the level of AI adoption and key business outcomes.
Survey-based correlational analysis reported in the paper linking self-reported AI adoption level to business outcome measures across the sample of 400 respondents.
medium positive The role of artificial intelligence in enhancing financial l... aggregate business outcomes (financial literacy scores, decision-making quality,...
Holistic AI integration across supply chain functions yields greater performance benefits than isolated technological implementations.
Comparative analysis using survey and statistical methods (correlation/regression) on data from supply chain professionals; the summary reports superior outcomes for integrated (ecosystem-level) AI adoption versus isolated implementations, but does not provide the comparative metrics or sample breakdown.
medium positive Smart Supply Chain Ecosystems: Artificial Intelligence Enabl... relative supply chain performance (integrated AI implementation vs. isolated AI ...
AI-enabled performance management plays a mediating role that strengthens the linkage between strategic planning and operational outcomes.
Mediation analysis conducted on survey data from supply chain professionals (manufacturing and service sectors); the summary indicates a mediating effect of performance management but provides no mediation statistics (indirect effect size, confidence intervals) or sample size.
medium positive Smart Supply Chain Ecosystems: Artificial Intelligence Enabl... mediating effect of AI-enabled performance management on the relationship betwee...
AI-enabled execution emerged as the strongest direct predictor of supply chain performance.
Regression analysis from the quantitative survey of supply chain professionals comparing AI-enabled planning, execution, and performance management as predictors of supply chain performance; specific coefficients, significance levels, and sample size are not reported in the excerpt.
medium positive Smart Supply Chain Ecosystems: Artificial Intelligence Enabl... supply chain performance (direct predictive strength of AI-enabled execution)
AI integration significantly improved overall supply chain performance.
Quantitative study using data collected from supply chain professionals and analyzed with reliability testing, correlation, and regression methods; the provided text does not include sample size, p-values, or effect magnitudes.
medium positive Smart Supply Chain Ecosystems: Artificial Intelligence Enabl... overall supply chain performance
AI integration significantly improved responsiveness (supply chain responsiveness).
Survey data from supply chain professionals across manufacturing and service sectors analyzed via correlation and regression analyses; the summary does not state sample size or numerical results.
medium positive Smart Supply Chain Ecosystems: Artificial Intelligence Enabl... supply chain responsiveness
AI integration significantly improved operational efficiency.
Quantitative survey of supply chain professionals (manufacturing and service sectors) with statistical analyses including reliability testing, correlation, and regression; specific sample size and effect sizes not provided in the summary.
AI integration significantly improved forecasting accuracy.
Quantitative survey of supply chain professionals (manufacturing and service sectors) analyzed using reliability testing and correlational/regression statistics; exact sample size and effect size not reported in the provided text.
The expanding use of AI is reshaping agricultural production systems and has emerged as a key driver of high-quality development in the sector.
Synthesis and interpretation of the paper’s empirical findings (significant AI effects on TFP, identified channels, and heterogeneous impacts) based on the listed-firm panel analysis.
medium positive Artificial intelligence and the sustainable development of a... sectoral development quality / high-quality development in agriculture
Productivity gains from AI are more pronounced in regions facing higher natural risks.
Heterogeneity analysis in the paper that compares regions with differing natural-risk levels and finds stronger AI–TFP effects in higher-risk regions using the 2007–2023 panel of listed agricultural firms.
medium positive Artificial intelligence and the sustainable development of a... total factor productivity (TFP) by regional natural-risk level
Productivity gains from AI are more pronounced among firms in their growth stage.
Heterogeneity analysis in the paper that splits the sample by firm life-cycle/stage and reports larger AI-associated TFP effects for firms classified as being in the growth stage.
medium positive Artificial intelligence and the sustainable development of a... total factor productivity (TFP) by firm life stage (growth stage)
AI fosters productivity growth by facilitating inter-firm resource sharing.
Mechanism analysis in the paper indicating a significant association between AI adoption and measures of inter-firm resource sharing, which in turn are associated with higher TFP in the panel sample.
medium positive Artificial intelligence and the sustainable development of a... TFP (via inter-firm resource sharing)
AI fosters productivity growth mainly by optimizing labor structures.
Mechanism analysis reported in the paper linking AI adoption to measures of labor-structure optimization and finding that this channel is a significant contributor to TFP gains in the sample of listed agricultural firms.
medium positive Artificial intelligence and the sustainable development of a... TFP (via labor structure / labor composition)
The adoption of AI improves factor allocation efficiency and constitutes a critical economic foundation for efficiency-driven sustainable growth in agriculture by optimizing resource utilization and strengthening risk-management capacity.
Conceptual framing supported by the paper's empirical findings (panel data on agricultural firms listed on Shanghai and Shenzhen A-share markets, 2007–2023) that show AI raises total factor productivity (TFP) and stronger effects in higher natural-risk regions (interpreted as improved risk management).
medium positive Artificial intelligence and the sustainable development of a... factor allocation efficiency / total factor productivity (TFP); risk-management ...
The findings provide practical guidance for entrepreneurs on building adaptive, AI-integrated organizations by redefining hiring, decision processes, and learning practices.
Prescriptive recommendations derived from the interview analysis and observed patterns in the sample of entrepreneurs (qualitative grounding; specific examples or measured impacts not provided in the excerpt).
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... recommended organizational practices (hiring, decision processes, learning pract...
Hybrid decision architectures have emerged: startup-specific configurations where algorithmic reasoning and human judgment recursively interact to shape decisions, roles and routines.
Thematic synthesis of interview data identifying recurring patterns of human–AI recursive interaction in decision-related practices across the studied startups (qualitative evidence; no quantitative counts reported).
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... composition and interaction patterns of decision-making architectures (human vs....
Entrepreneurs who founded startups after ChatGPT's release integrated AI into their post-release ventures.
Direct accounts from the subset of interviewees who founded startups after ChatGPT's release describing AI incorporation in those ventures (qualitative interview evidence; sample details not given).
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... presence/extent of AI integration in newly founded ventures
AI is becoming embedded in the architecture of startups rather than serving only as a task-automation tool.
Interview data and qualitative analysis identifying patterns of AI integration across startup roles, routines and structures (derived from the same semi-structured interview sample; exact N not provided).
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... degree and nature of AI integration into organizational architecture (roles, rou...
Facilitated access to AI following the release of ChatGPT is transforming how startups organize and make decisions.
Qualitative study using semi-structured interviews with entrepreneurs who founded startups both before and after ChatGPT's release and who integrated AI into their post-release ventures; thematic/qualitative analysis of interview data. (Sample size not reported in the provided excerpt.)
medium positive Hybrid decision architectures: exploring how facilitated AI ... organizational structure and decision-making processes in startups
Education, reskilling, and institutional responses are important in shaping the economic outcomes of artificial intelligence.
Policy implication derived from the observed/modeled heterogenous effects of AI on occupations and productivity; presented as a normative recommendation rather than an empirically tested result in the provided text.
medium positive Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... effectiveness of workforce policies as measured by post-intervention employment,...
Productivity gains associated with AI may support long-term economic growth.
Reference to productivity data and growth theory linking productivity improvements to long-run growth; the paper states this as a potential outcome but does not provide quantified long-run estimates or empirical identification in the excerpt.
medium positive Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... aggregate productivity (e.g., output per worker) and long-run GDP growth
AI complements higher-skill labor.
Interpretation of labor market data patterns and theoretical task-complementarity arguments presented in the paper; empirical details (which datasets, estimation strategy, sample size) are not provided in the text excerpt.
medium positive Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... employment levels, wages, or productivity of higher-skill workers
Artificial intelligence is a skill-biased technological innovation.
Framing and argumentation in the paper situating AI within the skill-biased technical change literature; references to analyses of publicly available labor market and productivity data (sources, time periods, and sample sizes not specified in the text).
medium positive Analysis of Economics and the Labor Market: With Implication... relative labor demand / wages by skill level (skilled vs. unskilled)
Firms' technical competencies amplify the positive effect of AI adoption on performance.
Moderation analysis in the PLS-SEM using the same 280-SME survey indicating a significant positive moderating role for technical/technical competency measures.
medium positive Structural Constraints as Moderators in the Ai–performance R... AI adoption → (financial and/or operational) performance (moderated by technical...
Firms' financial capacity amplifies the positive effect of AI adoption on performance.
Moderation analysis within the PLS-SEM on survey data from 280 Tunisian SMEs showing a significant positive moderating effect of financial strength on the AI adoption → performance link.
medium positive Structural Constraints as Moderators in the Ai–performance R... AI adoption → (financial and/or operational) performance (moderated by financial...
AI adoption significantly improves operational performance of Tunisian SMEs.
Same empirical dataset (n=280) and PLS-SEM analysis reporting a significant AI adoption → operational performance relationship.
AI adoption significantly improves financial performance of Tunisian SMEs.
Survey data from 280 Tunisian SMEs analyzed using partial least squares structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM); significance of the AI adoption → financial performance path reported in the model.