The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Digests 🎲

Evidence (2215 claims)

Adoption
5126 claims
Productivity
4409 claims
Governance
4049 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
2954 claims
Labor Markets
2432 claims
Org Design
2273 claims
Innovation
2215 claims
Skills & Training
1902 claims
Inequality
1286 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 369 105 58 432 972
Governance & Regulation 365 171 113 54 713
Research Productivity 229 95 33 294 655
Organizational Efficiency 354 82 58 34 531
Technology Adoption Rate 277 115 63 27 486
Firm Productivity 273 33 68 10 389
AI Safety & Ethics 112 177 43 24 358
Output Quality 228 61 23 25 337
Market Structure 105 118 81 14 323
Decision Quality 154 68 33 17 275
Employment Level 68 32 74 8 184
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 74 52 32 21 183
Skill Acquisition 85 31 38 9 163
Firm Revenue 96 30 22 148
Innovation Output 100 11 20 11 143
Consumer Welfare 66 29 35 7 137
Regulatory Compliance 51 61 13 3 128
Inequality Measures 24 66 31 4 125
Task Allocation 64 6 28 6 104
Error Rate 42 47 6 95
Training Effectiveness 55 12 10 16 93
Worker Satisfaction 42 32 11 6 91
Task Completion Time 71 5 3 1 80
Wages & Compensation 38 13 19 4 74
Team Performance 41 8 15 7 72
Hiring & Recruitment 39 4 6 3 52
Automation Exposure 17 15 9 5 46
Job Displacement 5 28 12 45
Social Protection 18 8 6 1 33
Developer Productivity 25 1 2 1 29
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Creative Output 15 5 3 1 24
Skill Obsolescence 3 18 2 23
Labor Share of Income 7 4 9 20
Clear
Innovation Remove filter
For each province–sector–size combination, the dataset reports whether firms adopt AI, whether they apply it internally, whether it is embedded in their offerings, and how many firms have valid website content.
Text explicitly lists the reported indicators at the province–sector–size aggregation level (adoption, internal use, embedded in offerings, count of valid website content).
The dataset offers a detailed portrait of AI adoption across regions (NUTS 3), industries, and firm size categories.
Text claims multi-dimensional reporting by region (NUTS 3), industry, and firm size categories in the dataset.
The pipeline identifies explicit evidence of AI use both in firms' internal processes and embedded in their products or services.
Text states the structured rubric is used to identify explicit evidence of AI use in internal processes and in products/services.
The paper uses a systemic pipeline based on large language models (LLMs) to segment website text, semantically filter it, and evaluate it with a structured rubric.
Text describes methodological pipeline components (LLM-based segmentation, semantic filtering, structured rubric evaluation).
The dataset results in 225,628 firm-year observations.
Text explicitly reports 225,628 firm-year observations derived from the dataset across the two benchmark years.
The paper introduces a nationwide dataset that maps how 112,814 Spanish firms communicate and implement artificial intelligence (AI) on their corporate websites in 2023 and 2025.
Text states dataset coverage and firm count (112,814 firms) and benchmark years (2023 and 2025).
Those extended-model equilibria also show increasing concentration consistent with power-law-like distributions (i.e., winner-take-most / superstar effects).
Theoretical model combining quality heterogeneity and reinforcement dynamics that yields equilibrium distributions with heavy tails; argument and formalization presented in the paper; no empirical testing reported.
high positive The Economics of Builder Saturation in Digital Markets market concentration / distribution of returns (power-law-like)
Even as the number of producers increases and average attention per producer falls, total output expands (production scales elastically).
Same formal theoretical model (analytical result): production scales elastically in the model despite finite attention; no empirical validation provided.
high positive The Economics of Builder Saturation in Digital Markets total market output
Mechanisms identified — network structure evolution and increased relational embeddedness — contribute to a broader understanding of how digital transformation shapes innovation dynamics across geographical boundaries in a globalized knowledge economy.
Synthesis of empirical network evolution results and mediation/structural analyses from the 2011–2021 dataset of digital transformation indicators and patent collaboration networks among cities and firms.
high positive How Does Digital Transformation Affect Cross-Regional Collab... role of network structure evolution and relational embeddedness as mechanisms li...
These results provide empirical evidence from a major emerging economy (China) that can offer insights to inform policies and strategies in other regions undergoing digital transition.
Generalization claim based on empirical findings from the 2011–2021 analysis of A-share listed companies' digital transformation and patent collaboration patterns in China.
high positive How Does Digital Transformation Affect Cross-Regional Collab... policy relevance / generalizability of findings to other regions
When the volume of digital patent applications surpasses a certain threshold, the positive effect of digital transformation on the quality of cross-regional collaborative innovation accelerates (nonlinear threshold effect).
Threshold regression / nonlinear analysis relating counts of digital patent applications to the marginal effect of digital transformation on collaborative innovation quality, using 2011–2021 patent and digitalization data from A-share listed firms.
high positive How Does Digital Transformation Affect Cross-Regional Collab... quality of cross-regional collaborative innovation (and its change above a paten...
Advancement of digital transformation positively contributes to both the quality and the quantity of cross-regional cooperative innovation.
Empirical econometric analysis (panel regressions) linking measures of corporate/urban digital transformation to indicators of cross-regional cooperative innovation quality and counts, using A-share listed companies' digital transformation indicators and patent collaboration data, 2011–2021.
high positive How Does Digital Transformation Affect Cross-Regional Collab... quality and quantity (counts) of cross-regional cooperative innovation
China’s urban collaborative innovation network demonstrates a notable quadrilateral spatial structure and has evolved toward a multicenter pattern over time.
Spatio-temporal network analysis based on the same 2011–2021 dataset of digital transformation indicators and patent/co-patent links among cities inferred from A-share listed companies' patent data.
high positive How Does Digital Transformation Affect Cross-Regional Collab... spatio-temporal structure of urban collaborative innovation network (quadrilater...
The cooperative innovation network exhibits pronounced small-world characteristics.
Network analysis of cross-regional collaborative innovation using digital transformation and patent data from A-share listed companies on the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges (2011–2021).
high positive How Does Digital Transformation Affect Cross-Regional Collab... presence of small-world characteristics in the cooperative innovation network
If you can prove the value and the effort behind API token spending (agent memory), you can resell it.
Normative/operational claim within the paper's proposal; presented as an implication of verifiable provenance and market layering, with no empirical proof or transactional data.
high positive Infrastructure for Valuable, Tradable, and Verifiable Agent ... resellability of artifacts derived from API token spending
Enabling timely memory transfer reduces repeated exploration.
Argument in the paper asserting that shared/tradable memory decreases redundant exploration; no experimental or observational data provided.
high positive Infrastructure for Valuable, Tradable, and Verifiable Agent ... frequency/amount of repeated exploration by agents
Together, clawgang and meowtrade transform one-shot API token spending into reusable and tradable assets.
High-level systems argument in the paper; no empirical measurements of reuse or tradability presented.
high positive Infrastructure for Valuable, Tradable, and Verifiable Agent ... conversion of one-shot API calls into reusable/tradable assets
Meowtrade is a market layer for listing, transferring, and governing certified memory artifacts.
Design proposal described in the paper; no pilot deployment, user adoption metrics, or experimental data provided.
high positive Infrastructure for Valuable, Tradable, and Verifiable Agent ... existence/functionality of a market layer for certified memory artifacts
Clawgang binds memory to verifiable computational provenance.
System/design claim describing the proposed mechanism (clawgang) in the paper; no implementation results or empirical validation reported.
high positive Infrastructure for Valuable, Tradable, and Verifiable Agent ... ability to cryptographically or procedurally link memories to provenance
Agent memory can serve as an economic commodity in the agent economy, if buyers can verify that it is authentic, effort-backed, and produced in a compatible execution context.
Conceptual argument in the paper's proposal; no empirical evaluation, sample size, or experiments reported.
high positive Infrastructure for Valuable, Tradable, and Verifiable Agent ... feasibility of agent memory becoming a tradable commodity
Economic theory can be used to generate structured synthetic data that improves foundation-model predictions when the theory implies observable patterns in the data.
General conclusion drawn from the paper's experimental findings: improvement in model predictions after fine-tuning on theory-derived synthetic data.
high positive GARP-EFM: Improving Foundation Models with Revealed Preferen... improvement in foundation-model prediction accuracy when using theory-generated ...
Fine-tuning on GARP-consistent synthetic data substantially improves prediction relative to zero-shot Chronos-2 at all forecast horizons we study.
Empirical results comparing fine-tuned Chronos-2 to zero-shot Chronos-2 across multiple forecast horizons on the authors' experimental panel (no numeric metrics or sample sizes given in the excerpt).
high positive GARP-EFM: Improving Foundation Models with Revealed Preferen... forecast prediction accuracy across forecast horizons
The fine-tuned model serves as a rationality-constrained forecasting prior: it learns price-quantity relations from GARP-consistent synthetic histories and then uses those relations to predict the choices of real consumers.
Empirical approach described in paper: model fine-tuned on synthetic GARP-consistent histories and then evaluated on real consumer choice data (supports claim that model transfers learned relations to predicting real choices).
high positive GARP-EFM: Improving Foundation Models with Revealed Preferen... model's ability to predict real consumer choices (use of learned price-quantity ...
GARP is a simple condition to check that allows us to generate time series from a large class of utilities efficiently.
Methodological argument in the paper: authors use GARP as a constructive condition to generate synthetic time series from many utility functions (no numeric efficiency metrics provided in the excerpt).
high positive GARP-EFM: Improving Foundation Models with Revealed Preferen... feasibility/efficiency of generating synthetic time series from utility classes
Teaching them basic economic logic improves how they predict demand using an experimental panel.
Reported experimental results in the paper: fine-tuning models on synthetic, economics-consistent data and evaluating on an experimental panel of consumer demand (no numeric sample size or metrics provided in the excerpt).
high positive GARP-EFM: Improving Foundation Models with Revealed Preferen... prediction accuracy of consumer demand
AI adoption and the associated improved governance lead to higher total factor productivity (TFP).
Empirical analysis showing a positive association between firm-level AI application index and measures of total factor productivity in the 2010–2023 Chinese A-share panel.
high positive The risk-mitigation effects of artificial intelligence adopt... total factor productivity (TFP)
AI adoption and the associated improved governance lead to a lower cost of debt financing for firms.
Empirical tests linking firm-level AI application and governance improvements to measures of debt financing costs (e.g., interest rates on debt, financing spreads) in the Chinese A-share firm sample.
high positive The risk-mitigation effects of artificial intelligence adopt... cost of debt financing (interest rate/spread measures)
The governance risk-mitigation effects of AI operate through enhancing external monitoring.
Mechanism analyses showing that AI adoption is associated with measures of stronger external monitoring (e.g., analyst coverage, media scrutiny, regulator activity) in the firm-year panel, linking that channel to reduced misconduct.
high positive The risk-mitigation effects of artificial intelligence adopt... external monitoring intensity (analyst coverage, media/regulatory scrutiny proxi...
The governance risk-mitigation effects of AI operate through strengthening internal control capacity.
Mechanism analyses showing that higher AI application is associated with improved internal control measures (as reported by firms or regulatory/financial-control indicators) in the dataset of Chinese A-share firms.
high positive The risk-mitigation effects of artificial intelligence adopt... internal control capacity (corporate internal control metrics)
The governance risk-mitigation effects of AI operate through lowering agency costs.
Mechanism analyses reported by authors linking AI adoption to reductions in measures interpreted as agency costs (e.g., agency-cost proxies, corporate governance metrics) in the same firm-year panel.
high positive The risk-mitigation effects of artificial intelligence adopt... agency costs (proxied by governance/financial measures)
AI application significantly reduces the monetary amount of penalties associated with executive misconduct.
Regression analyses on monetary penalty data for Chinese A-share firms (2010–2023) showing a statistically significant negative relationship between firm AI application index and penalty amounts.
high positive The risk-mitigation effects of artificial intelligence adopt... monetary amount of penalties for executive misconduct
AI application significantly reduces the frequency (number) of violations by executives.
Empirical frequency/regression analyses on the firm-year panel of Chinese A-share firms using the AI application index; authors report robust reductions in the number/frequency of violations conditional on AI adoption.
high positive The risk-mitigation effects of artificial intelligence adopt... frequency (count) of executive violations
AI application significantly reduces the incidence of executive misconduct.
Empirical analysis on Chinese A-share listed firms (2010–2023) using the constructed firm-level AI application index; reported significant negative association between AI application and whether a firm experiences executive misconduct (incidence).
high positive The risk-mitigation effects of artificial intelligence adopt... incidence (occurrence) of executive misconduct
Using Chinese A-share firms listed in Shanghai and Shenzhen from 2010 to 2023, we construct a firm-level AI application index and examine whether and how AI adoption mitigates executive misconduct.
Authors report building a firm-level AI application index and applying it to Chinese A-share listed firms (Shanghai and Shenzhen) over 2010–2023 to study links between AI adoption and executive misconduct (method: panel analysis using firm-year observations).
high positive The risk-mitigation effects of artificial intelligence adopt... existence and measurement of firm-level AI application index; sample frame of Ch...
The paper provides recommendations for designing strategic indicators to drive adoption, foster innovation, and objectively assess whether digital tools are delivering top-line impact.
Descriptive claim about the content of the perspective article (the authors state they provide these recommendations); the excerpt itself summarizes this contribution.
high positive Strategic Key Performance Indicators for AI in Lead Optimiza... existence of recommended strategic KPIs intended to affect adoption, innovation,...
The shift from expert-driven computer-aided drug design (CADD) to semiautonomous AI necessitates a new framework of impact-oriented KPIs.
Stated by the EFMC2 community authors as a normative conclusion in the perspective piece; based on the characterisation of a technological shift rather than on presented empirical tests in the excerpt.
high positive Strategic Key Performance Indicators for AI in Lead Optimiza... need for new KPI frameworks to assess impact of semiautonomous AI in drug discov...
Harnessing AI's potential requires moving beyond measuring technical model performance (e.g., predictive accuracy) to measuring strategic impact.
Authors argue this as a conceptual requirement for realizing AI's benefits in R&D; presented as a recommendation rather than supported by quantified empirical evidence in the excerpt.
high positive Strategic Key Performance Indicators for AI in Lead Optimiza... usefulness of measurement approaches (technical model metrics versus strategic i...
Preliminary analyses suggest that 'AI-native' companies may be outpacing traditional peers.
Explicitly stated in the paper as based on preliminary analyses; the excerpt provides no details on the analyses, metrics, or sample sizes.
high positive Strategic Key Performance Indicators for AI in Lead Optimiza... relative performance of AI-native companies versus traditional peers (e.g., prod...
The broad introduction of AI into the R&D landscape over the last years holds the promise to lift pharmaceutical R&D out of its productivity problem.
Framed as an expectation/promise in the paper; based on recent broad adoption trends of AI in R&D (no specific empirical evaluation or sample size reported in the excerpt).
high positive Strategic Key Performance Indicators for AI in Lead Optimiza... potential improvement in pharmaceutical R&D productivity due to AI adoption
In this verifiable domain, simple arbitrage strategies generate net profit margins of up to 40%.
Empirical result from the SWE-bench case study comparing arbitrage strategy returns using GPT-5 mini and DeepSeek v3.2 (reported maximum net profit margin = 40%).
high positive Computational Arbitrage in AI Model Markets net profit margin of arbitrage strategies
The paper discusses a regulatory framework for token futures markets, providing a theoretical foundation and practical roadmap for the financialization of compute resources.
Policy/regulatory discussion and recommendations included in the paper; draws on comparisons to existing commodity regulation and futures markets.
high positive AI Token Futures Market: Commoditization of Compute and Deri... existence / design of regulatory framework for token futures
The paper explores the feasibility of GPU compute futures as an alternative or complement to token futures.
Discussion/feasibility analysis in the paper (conceptual and comparative discussion; not presented as empirical field evidence).
high positive AI Token Futures Market: Commoditization of Compute and Deri... feasibility of GPU compute futures
Simulation results show that, under an application-layer demand explosion scenario, token futures can reduce enterprise compute cost volatility by 62%–78%.
Monte Carlo simulation results based on the constructed mean-reverting jump-diffusion stochastic process model; scenario described as 'application-layer demand explosion'. (No numerical sample size reported in the abstract.)
high positive AI Token Futures Market: Commoditization of Compute and Deri... enterprise compute cost volatility
The authors propose a complete design for standardized token futures contracts, including the definition of a Standard Inference Token (SIT), contract specifications, settlement mechanisms, margin systems, and market-maker regimes.
Normative/proposal section of the paper specifying contract design components and market microstructure recommendations.
high positive AI Token Futures Market: Commoditization of Compute and Deri... design completeness of token futures instruments
Tokens consumed by AI inference are evolving into a new type of commodity.
Conceptual/systematic analysis and argumentation presented in the paper (comparisons to established commodities and discussion of commodity attributes).
high positive AI Token Futures Market: Commoditization of Compute and Deri... commodity status / commodification of inference tokens
By enabling developers without initial capital to participate in the digital economy, RSI could unlock the 'latent jobs dividend' in low-income countries and help address local challenges in health, agriculture, and services.
Societal-impact argument in the paper linking the RSI model to potential employment gains and localized solutions; speculative extrapolation, no empirical employment estimates or pilot studies reported.
high positive Revenue-Sharing as Infrastructure: A Distributed Business Mo... job creation / participation in digital economy
The RSI model could stimulate innovation in the ecosystem.
Argument based on lowered financial barriers and incentive structures from the paper's theoretical comparative analysis; no empirical measures of innovation provided.
high positive Revenue-Sharing as Infrastructure: A Distributed Business Mo... innovation in the developer/platform ecosystem
The RSI model aligns stakeholder interests (platforms and developers).
Theoretical argument and incentive-alignment reasoning in the paper's comparative framework; no empirical validation presented.
high positive Revenue-Sharing as Infrastructure: A Distributed Business Mo... alignment of stakeholder incentives
A comparative analysis in the paper shows that the RSI model lowers entry barriers for developers.
Detailed comparative (theoretical) analysis within the paper contrasting existing models and RSI; no empirical trial, sample, or randomized test reported.
high positive Revenue-Sharing as Infrastructure: A Distributed Business Mo... entry barriers for developers
Generative AI platforms (Google AI Studio, OpenAI, Anthropic) provide infrastructures (APIs, models) that are transforming the application development ecosystem.
Statement in paper based on literature review and descriptive framing of current platforms; no empirical sample or quantitative test reported.
high positive Revenue-Sharing as Infrastructure: A Distributed Business Mo... availability of AI infrastructure / transformation of development ecosystem