The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (7953 claims)

Adoption
5539 claims
Productivity
4793 claims
Governance
4333 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
3326 claims
Labor Markets
2657 claims
Innovation
2510 claims
Org Design
2469 claims
Skills & Training
2017 claims
Inequality
1378 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 402 112 67 480 1076
Governance & Regulation 402 192 122 62 790
Research Productivity 249 98 34 311 697
Organizational Efficiency 395 95 70 40 603
Technology Adoption Rate 321 126 73 39 564
Firm Productivity 306 39 70 12 432
Output Quality 256 66 25 28 375
AI Safety & Ethics 116 177 44 24 363
Market Structure 107 128 85 14 339
Decision Quality 177 76 38 20 315
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 89 58 33 22 209
Employment Level 77 34 80 9 202
Skill Acquisition 92 33 40 9 174
Innovation Output 120 12 23 12 168
Firm Revenue 98 34 22 154
Consumer Welfare 73 31 37 7 148
Task Allocation 84 16 33 7 140
Inequality Measures 25 77 32 5 139
Regulatory Compliance 54 63 13 3 133
Error Rate 44 51 6 101
Task Completion Time 88 5 4 3 100
Training Effectiveness 58 12 12 16 99
Worker Satisfaction 47 32 11 7 97
Wages & Compensation 53 15 20 5 93
Team Performance 47 12 15 7 82
Automation Exposure 24 22 9 6 62
Job Displacement 6 38 13 57
Hiring & Recruitment 41 4 6 3 54
Developer Productivity 34 4 3 1 42
Social Protection 22 10 6 2 40
Creative Output 16 7 5 1 29
Labor Share of Income 12 5 9 26
Skill Obsolescence 3 20 2 25
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
There is recent and increasing interest in forming teams of LLMs (LLM teams).
Claim made in the paper asserting increased interest and deployment at scale; supported in the paper by literature/contextual citations and reported deployments (specific numbers or studies not provided in the excerpt).
medium positive Language Model Teams as Distributed Systems interest and deployment level of LLM teams
The study contributes a conceptual architecture for next-generation accounting automation that bridges traditional compliance models and modern financial infrastructure (enabling real-time validation, automation, and transparency).
Presentation of a proposed conceptual architecture in the paper, supported by empirical evaluation and stakeholder feedback; claimed as a primary contribution. (The summary does not include architecture diagrams, implementation details, or performance benchmarks beyond the reported metrics.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... existence/effectiveness of a proposed conceptual architecture for accounting aut...
Integrating ML and blockchain represents a transformative shift that addresses limitations of traditional financial governance (static ledgers, manual reconciliation, retrospective audits).
High-level argument supported by the study's empirical improvements (fraud detection, reconciliation time, transaction accuracy) and conceptual analysis mapping system capabilities to shortcomings of traditional models. (This is a synthesis/interpretation rather than a single measured outcome.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... transformative improvement in financial governance (qualitative)
Stakeholder validation confirms the system's operational feasibility with 95% approval.
Stakeholder validation (presumably via survey or consultation) reporting 95% approval for operational feasibility. (The summary does not specify the number of stakeholders, selection criteria, or survey instrument.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... operational feasibility approval rate (percentage)
The study validates theoretical frameworks such as triple-entry accounting (Grigg, 2024) and X-Accounting (Faccia et al., 2020).
Conceptual/theoretical alignment demonstrated by mapping the hybrid ML-blockchain architecture and empirical findings to the premises of the cited frameworks. (Summary does not specify formal validation method or criteria.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... theoretical validation / conceptual alignment
The system maintains 99.8% transaction accuracy.
Reported transaction accuracy measured on the same empirical datasets (public-sector financial records and private-sector supply chains) used to evaluate the hybrid system. (The summary does not provide sample size, timeframe, or definition of 'transaction accuracy'.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... transaction accuracy (percentage)
The hybrid system produces a 60% reduction in reconciliation time.
Empirical measurement of reconciliation time on datasets from public-sector financial records and private-sector supply chains comparing hybrid ML-blockchain workflows to traditional reconciliation processes. (No sample size or absolute times provided in the summary.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... reconciliation time (percent reduction)
A hybrid ML-blockchain system achieves a 9.8% improvement in fraud detection accuracy (F1-score).
Quantitative evaluation using empirical data drawn from public-sector financial records and private-sector supply chains; improvement reported as change in F1-score between the hybrid system and baseline (traditional) oversight approaches. (Paper does not report sample sizes or exact baseline metrics in the summary.)
medium positive AI-Driven Accounting Oversight Systems: Integrating Machine ... fraud detection accuracy (F1-score)
Both stable individual differences and moment-to-moment fluctuations in perspective-taking influence AI response quality.
Analyses reported in the paper linking both trait-level (stable) and state-level (moment-to-moment) measures of perspective-taking to variation in AI response quality across the benchmark dataset; assessed via the Bayesian IRT model and supplementary within-subject analyses.
medium positive Quantifying and Optimizing Human-AI Synergy: Evidence-Based ... AI response quality (as rated or measured) as a function of trait and state pers...
Theory of Mind (the capacity to infer and adapt to others' mental states) emerges as a key predictor of synergy.
Statistical association reported between participants' Theory of Mind measures and the estimated synergy (improvement in performance with AI), based on analysis of the benchmark dataset (n = 667) within the Bayesian IRT framework.
medium positive Quantifying and Optimizing Human-AI Synergy: Evidence-Based ... synergy (performance improvement with AI assistance) predicted by Theory of Mind...
These AI formulation models reduced experimental workload by 30–50%.
Reported in the review as estimated reductions in experimental workload when using AI-driven formulation optimization. The excerpt lacks details on how workload was measured, which experiments were replaced or reduced, and sample sizes.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... experimental workload (percent reduction in experiments or resources)
In formulation optimization, artificial neural networks, neuro-fuzzy systems, and hybrid model-based AI models have been able to predict dissolution profiles and critical quality attributes with accuracy rates of over 90%.
Reported model performance in formulation optimization studies summarized by the review. The excerpt does not include which specific studies, datasets, cross-validation protocols, or sample sizes produced >90% accuracy.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... predictive accuracy for dissolution profiles and critical quality attributes (pe...
AI has reduced clinical trial duration by up to 59%.
Reported in the review as an observed maximum reduction in trial duration associated with AI-driven approaches. The excerpt omits details on which trials, therapeutic areas, trial phases, or sample sizes produced this figure.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... clinical trial duration (percentage reduction)
AI has sped up compound screening by 1–2 years.
Presented in the review as a comparative reduction in time-to-screening attributed to AI methods. The excerpt does not provide the underlying studies, screening scope, or sample sizes.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... compound screening duration (time saved; measured in years)
AI-enabled platforms have cut the drug discovery pipeline timelines (compared with the traditional 4–6 years) down to 46 days.
Reported as an outcome of AI-enabled platforms in the review. The excerpt does not list the specific platform(s), individual study design(s), or sample sizes underlying the 46-day figure.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... drug discovery pipeline duration (time to identify/advance candidate; measured i...
Artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming pharmaceutical research and development (R and D), and making measurable improvements in efficiency, precision, and cost-effectiveness in drug research and development.
Stated as a summary conclusion in the review based on cross-domain literature synthesis. Specific studies or quantitative meta-analytic methods and sample sizes are not provided in the excerpt.
medium positive THE AI REVOLUTION IN PHARMACEUTICALS: INNOVATIONS, CHALLENGE... overall R&D efficiency, precision, and cost-effectiveness in pharmaceutical drug...
Experiments on simulated and real-world data show that humans assisted by the adaptive AI ensemble achieve significantly higher performance than humans assisted by single AI models trained either for independent AI performance or for human-AI team performance.
Empirical experiments reported in the paper on both simulated datasets and real-world data; the abstract states results are statistically significant but does not provide sample sizes, datasets, or statistical details in the excerpt.
medium positive Align When They Want, Complement When They Need! Human-Cente... human decision-making performance / human-AI team performance (improvement when ...
An adaptive AI ensemble that toggles between two specialist models (an aligned model and a complementary model) using a Rational Routing Shortcut mechanism overcomes the complementarity–alignment limitation of single-model approaches.
Methodological contribution described in the paper; includes the design of the ensemble and the Rational Routing Shortcut; theoretical guarantees of near-optimality are claimed in the paper (proofs referenced but not shown in the excerpt).
medium positive Align When They Want, Complement When They Need! Human-Cente... contextual model selection/routing and resulting human-AI team performance
EASP offers a practical tradeoff between reasoning quality and latency by avoiding iterative LLM tool-calls at inference time while still producing grounded plans.
Methodological claim in the paper: Probe-then-Plan uses a lightweight probe to avoid heavy iterative LLM tool calls during serving; supported by design rationale and performance-focused evaluations (offline and online).
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... inference latency vs. reasoning/plan validity tradeoff (system performance outco...
EASP has been successfully deployed in JD.com's AI-Search system.
Statement in the paper that EASP was deployed in JD.com's AI-Search system; presumably validated by internal deployment logs and online A/B testing reported.
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... deployment status in production (operational outcome)
Online A/B testing on JD.com demonstrates that EASP achieves substantial lifts in UCVR (user conversion rate) and GMV (gross merchandise volume).
Reported results from online A/B testing on JD.com referenced in the paper indicating lifts in UCVR and GMV (no numerical magnitudes provided in the abstract).
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... UCVR (user conversion rate) and GMV (gross merchandise volume)
Extensive offline evaluations and online A/B testing on JD.com show that EASP significantly improves relevant recall.
Empirical claims in the paper citing extensive offline evaluations and online A/B testing on JD.com as the basis for observed improvements in relevant recall (specific datasets/sizes not reported in the abstract).
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... relevant recall (retrieval effectiveness metric)
Environment-Aware Search Planning (EASP) resolves the blindness-latency dilemma in LLM-based e-commerce search by grounding planning in the real retrieval environment via a Probe-then-Plan mechanism.
Conceptual design and empirical evaluation described in the paper: introduces a lightweight Retrieval Probe to expose a retrieval snapshot and a Planner that diagnoses execution gaps and generates grounded search plans; supported by offline evaluations and online A/B testing on JD.com (section describing method and experiments).
medium positive Probe-then-Plan: Environment-Aware Planning for Industrial E... ability to produce environment-grounded search plans that address execution gaps...
The findings provide valuable insights for entrepreneurs, policymakers, and academic institutions to implement adaptive strategies for sustainable and inclusive entrepreneurial growth in the era of artificial intelligence.
Authors' implications/conclusions based on the study results (n=350; statistical analyses) recommending adaptive strategies targeted at stakeholders.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... policy and practice guidance for sustainable and inclusive entrepreneurial growt...
AI functions as a strategic enabler that reshapes entrepreneurial practices, labour dynamics, and innovation strategies.
Conclusion drawn from the study's quantitative findings (survey of 350, regression/SEM results) that linked AI adoption to changes in opportunity recognition, labour substitution, and innovation processes.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... overall entrepreneurial practices, labour dynamics, and innovation strategy orie...
AI-driven innovation processes accelerated product development, improved operational efficiency, and supported experimentation, thereby strengthening entrepreneurial performance.
Survey data from 350 AI-adopting SMEs analyzed with regression and SEM showing positive associations between AI adoption and measures of product development speed, operational efficiency, experimentation, and overall entrepreneurial performance.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... product development speed, operational efficiency, experimentation capability, e...
AI facilitated labour substitution by automating repetitive tasks, allowing human resources to focus on creative and analytical roles.
Responses from the same sample (n=350) of AI-adopting SME entrepreneurs/managers; descriptive statistics and inferential analyses (regression/SEM) linking AI adoption to increased automation and role reallocation.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... labour substitution / automation of routine tasks and reallocation of human role...
AI adoption significantly enhanced opportunity recognition by enabling entrepreneurs to identify emerging market trends, assess risks, and make informed strategic decisions.
Quantitative survey of 350 entrepreneurs and managers of SMEs who had adopted AI; relationships tested using regression analysis and structural equation modelling (SEM) reported a significant positive effect of AI adoption on opportunity recognition.
medium positive Entrepreneurship in the Era of Artificial Intelligence: Rede... opportunity recognition (ability to identify market trends, assess risks, make s...
Sustainable human capital development requires coordinated interaction between education systems, employers, and public institutions.
Normative recommendation derived from the paper's systemic analysis and comparative review of institutional responses; no empirical policy evaluation or quantified cross-country causal analysis reported.
medium positive EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... sustainability of human capital development (systemic coordination effects)
Alignment of educational strategies with labor market dynamics is necessary to support effective reskilling and upskilling.
Supported by comparative assessment of international practices and systemic analysis linking education strategies to labor market requirements; evidence is analytical rather than experimental or longitudinally quantified in the paper.
medium positive EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... effectiveness of reskilling/upskilling and labor-market responsiveness
Effective reskilling and upskilling depend on the development of continuous learning ecosystems.
Analytical conclusion drawn from organizational learning models and international practice comparison; no controlled trials or quantitative evaluation of specific ecosystems reported.
medium positive EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... effectiveness of reskilling and upskilling programs
As technological change accelerates, the ability of individuals and organizations to adapt becomes a central condition of economic resilience and long-term competitiveness.
Analytical generalization from organizational learning models and systemic analysis of labor-market dynamics; supported by comparative observations but not by a reported empirical causal study.
medium positive EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... economic resilience and long-term competitiveness (as related to adaptive capaci...
AI-based ESG systems are increasingly applied to extract deeper sustainability signals from corporate disclosures, reports and external data sources.
Descriptive claim supported by cited literature and examples of AI applications in ESG analytics within the paper's background (references to recent AI/ESG studies). The summary does not quantify the rate of adoption.
medium positive Green Intelligence in Finance: Artificial Intelligence-Drive... Adoption/application of AI systems for extracting sustainability signals (descri...
Regression analysis revealed that AI-derived ESG scores were more strongly associated with excess returns than traditional ESG metrics.
Regression models estimating the association between ESG scores (AI-derived vs traditional) and excess returns. The summary does not specify the regression specification, control variables, sample size, time horizon, or statistical significance measures.
medium positive Green Intelligence in Finance: Artificial Intelligence-Drive... Excess returns (dependent variable); strength of association with ESG scores
AI-driven high-ESG portfolios demonstrated lower downside-risk exposure and smaller maximum drawdowns during market stress, indicating stronger resilience.
Downside-risk and maximum drawdown metrics computed for AI-driven high-ESG portfolios versus comparator portfolios during periods of market stress (portfolio-level analysis). Specific stress period(s), sample size and statistical tests are not provided in the summary.
medium positive Green Intelligence in Finance: Artificial Intelligence-Drive... Downside-risk exposure; maximum drawdown
AI-enhanced high-ESG portfolios achieved higher mean returns and superior Sharpe ratios than both AI-based low-ESG portfolios and traditionally rated ESG portfolios.
Portfolio-level performance comparison reported in the study (mean returns and Sharpe ratios calculated for portfolios constructed using AI-driven ESG indicators versus portfolios using conventional ESG ratings). The summary does not report sample size, time period, market coverage, rebalancing frequency, or statistical significance levels.
medium positive Green Intelligence in Finance: Artificial Intelligence-Drive... Portfolio mean returns; Sharpe ratio
The study recommends multi-stakeholder collaborations (policymakers, financial institutions, entrepreneurs) to design inclusive AI solutions, bridge the digital skills gap, and foster an environment for equitable entrepreneurial growth.
Policy and practice recommendations drawn in the paper's conclusion based on empirical findings and interpretation of barriers.
medium positive The role of artificial intelligence in enhancing financial l... recommended actions (policy/practice) to improve inclusive AI adoption and entre...
Firms with high AI adoption reported superior decision-making quality compared to low adopters.
Survey comparisons of decision-making quality measures between AI adoption groups in the questionnaire data (N=400), reported as superior for high adopters.
medium positive The role of artificial intelligence in enhancing financial l... decision-making quality
Firms with high AI adoption reported significantly higher financial literacy scores compared to low adopters.
Comparison of financial literacy scores between high and low AI adoption groups derived from the structured questionnaire responses (sample N=400); described as 'significantly higher' in the paper.
medium positive The role of artificial intelligence in enhancing financial l... financial literacy score
There is a positive correlation between the level of AI adoption and key business outcomes.
Survey-based correlational analysis reported in the paper linking self-reported AI adoption level to business outcome measures across the sample of 400 respondents.
medium positive The role of artificial intelligence in enhancing financial l... aggregate business outcomes (financial literacy scores, decision-making quality,...
Upstream foundation model providers offering fine-tuning and inference services to downstream firms creates a co-creation dynamic that enhances model quality when downstream firms fine-tune models with proprietary data.
Conceptual claim and theoretical framing in the paper: description of an AI supply-chain interaction where providers supply compute/inference and downstream firms fine-tune with proprietary data; the paper posits this co-creation improves model quality as part of the motivating narrative.
medium positive The Economics of AI Supply Chain Regulation model quality (improvement via co-creation)
Under pro-price-competitive policies or compute subsidies, the provider and downstream firms can achieve higher profits along with greater consumer surplus (a win-win-win outcome).
Equilibrium profit comparisons in the game-theoretic model showing that, in the parameter regions where these policies raise consumer surplus, both the upstream provider's profit and downstream firms' profits also increase relative to the baseline.
medium positive The Economics of AI Supply Chain Regulation consumer surplus, provider profit, downstream firms' profits
Policies that promote quality competition in downstream markets always improve consumer surplus.
Model outcomes: comparative-static and equilibrium results show that strengthening downstream quality competition monotonically increases consumer surplus across the parameter space considered in the paper.
medium positive The Economics of AI Supply Chain Regulation consumer surplus (across all modeled parameter regimes)
Pro-price-competitive policies and compute subsidies are complementary: each is effective in different cost regimes and together can cover more cases.
Analytical results from the game-theoretic model showing complementary effectiveness across varying compute/preprocessing cost parameters (comparative statics demonstrating non-overlapping regions of effectiveness).
medium positive The Economics of AI Supply Chain Regulation consumer surplus (policy effectiveness across cost regimes)
New employment opportunities are emerging in AI-complementary occupations.
Findings from job-posting analyses and other empirical studies summarized in the paper that identify growth in AI-complementary job listings and roles (specific metrics not provided in excerpt).
medium positive The Impact of Generative AI on the Future of Employment: Opp... demand for AI-complementary occupations / job opportunities
Generative AI (GenAI), particularly tools such as ChatGPT and Gemini, has rapidly transformed the global technological landscape.
Qualitative/observational statement in paper citing the rapid public adoption of GenAI tools since late 2022; no specific empirical sample sizes reported in the text provided.
medium positive The Impact of Generative AI on the Future of Employment: Opp... technological landscape / adoption of GenAI tools
Holistic AI integration across supply chain functions yields greater performance benefits than isolated technological implementations.
Comparative analysis using survey and statistical methods (correlation/regression) on data from supply chain professionals; the summary reports superior outcomes for integrated (ecosystem-level) AI adoption versus isolated implementations, but does not provide the comparative metrics or sample breakdown.
medium positive Smart Supply Chain Ecosystems: Artificial Intelligence Enabl... relative supply chain performance (integrated AI implementation vs. isolated AI ...
AI-enabled performance management plays a mediating role that strengthens the linkage between strategic planning and operational outcomes.
Mediation analysis conducted on survey data from supply chain professionals (manufacturing and service sectors); the summary indicates a mediating effect of performance management but provides no mediation statistics (indirect effect size, confidence intervals) or sample size.
medium positive Smart Supply Chain Ecosystems: Artificial Intelligence Enabl... mediating effect of AI-enabled performance management on the relationship betwee...
AI-enabled execution emerged as the strongest direct predictor of supply chain performance.
Regression analysis from the quantitative survey of supply chain professionals comparing AI-enabled planning, execution, and performance management as predictors of supply chain performance; specific coefficients, significance levels, and sample size are not reported in the excerpt.
medium positive Smart Supply Chain Ecosystems: Artificial Intelligence Enabl... supply chain performance (direct predictive strength of AI-enabled execution)
AI integration significantly improved overall supply chain performance.
Quantitative study using data collected from supply chain professionals and analyzed with reliability testing, correlation, and regression methods; the provided text does not include sample size, p-values, or effect magnitudes.
medium positive Smart Supply Chain Ecosystems: Artificial Intelligence Enabl... overall supply chain performance