The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (8570 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Adoption Remove filter
AI adoption intensifies existing sustainability challenges for the newsroom, as journalistic content and labour increasingly support AI systems without corresponding financial return.
Qualitative interview data and organisational analysis from Al-Masry Al-Youm indicating increased use of journalistic outputs for AI purposes and lack of matched revenue; sample size not reported in the excerpt.
high negative Platformisation, Power, and AI Governance in the Newsroom: I... financial sustainability / lack of corresponding financial return from AI-relate...
Reliance on global technology providers embeds forms of platform dependency within newsroom operations at Al-Masry Al-Youm.
Qualitative case study based on in-depth interviews with journalists, editors, and technical staff at Al-Masry Al-Youm (Egypt); analysis of newsroom practices and integration of third-party/global AI tools. Sample size not reported in the excerpt.
high negative Platformisation, Power, and AI Governance in the Newsroom: I... platform dependency within newsroom operations
Research on platform governance remains fragmented and lacks an integrative perspective.
Conclusion drawn from the systematic literature review (644 publications) indicating fragmentation in the scholarly literature.
high negative Mission: Orchestration – Governance Mechanisms And Future Re... degree of fragmentation and lack of integrative perspectives in platform governa...
Participants in platform ecosystems cannot be governed through traditional command-and-control mechanisms.
Conceptual claim supported by the literature synthesized in the systematic literature review (644 publications).
high negative Mission: Orchestration – Governance Mechanisms And Future Re... suitability of traditional command-and-control governance for platform participa...
Government subsidies exert a negative moderating influence on the relationship between fintech development and corporate total factor productivity.
Moderation analysis reported in the paper on Chinese A-share listed manufacturing firms (2015–2023); paper states government subsidies weaken the positive fintech–TFP relationship (no numeric interaction estimates provided in the excerpt).
high negative Research on the Impact of Financial Technology on the Total ... corporate total factor productivity (moderated by government subsidies)
Gözetim kapitalizmi sadece teknolojik bir dönüşüm değildir; hukuk, iktidar ve bilgi ilişkilerinin yeniden örgütlendiği, yeni eşitsizlik biçimleri, asimetrik güç ilişkileri ve dijital dolayımılı yönetim biçimleri üreten özgün bir ekonomi-politik rejimdir.
Genel sonuç/sonuçlandırma çıkarımı; sentezleyici teorik analiz; argument based on mapping between technology, law, and power (no empirical evidence in abstract).
high negative GÖZETİM KAPİTALİZMİNİN HUKUKSAL TEMELLERİ: FOUCAULTCU BİR AN... yeni eşitsizlik biçimleri, asimetrik güç ilişkileri ve dijital yönetim biçimleri...
Foucaultcu perspektiften algoritmik yönetimsellik, bireyi yalnızca denetlenen bir özne haline getirmekle kalmayıp, aynı zamanda davranışsal fazlanın üreticisi olan bir veri-nesnesine dönüştürmektedir.
Foucault teorik çerçevesiyle yapılan kavramsal analiz; literatüre dayalı argüman; no empirical sample provided in abstract.
high negative GÖZETİM KAPİTALİZMİNİN HUKUKSAL TEMELLERİ: FOUCAULTCU BİR AN... bireyin özne-nesne dönüşümü (veri-nesnesine dönüşme ve davranışsal fazla üretimi...
Kişisel verilerin metalaştırılması, Julie E. Cohen’in 'biyopolitik kamusal alan' kavramsallaştırması üzerinden değerlendirildiğinde, kişisel bilgi ekonomik üretim ve davranışsal öngörünün hammaddesi olarak hukuksal dispozitif tarafından yapılandırılmaktadır.
Teorik değerlendirme ve kavramsal çerçeveleme; atıf yapılan literatüre dayanıyor; no empirical testing reported.
high negative GÖZETİM KAPİTALİZMİNİN HUKUKSAL TEMELLERİ: FOUCAULTCU BİR AN... kişisel bilgilerin ekonomik hammaddelere dönüştürülmesi ve hukuksal düzenlemeyle...
Hukuk sistemi veri üretimi, dolaşımı, mülkiyeti ve ticarileştirilmesini kurumsallaştırarak gözetim kapitalizminin kurucu unsurlarından biri haline gelmiştir.
Hukuk teorik analizine dayanan argüman; çalışmada Julie E. Cohen ve Foucault perspektifleriyle hukuksal dispozitif incelenmektedir. No quantitative/legal-empirical dataset cited in abstract.
high negative GÖZETİM KAPİTALİZMİNİN HUKUKSAL TEMELLERİ: FOUCAULTCU BİR AN... hukuk sisteminin veri ile ilgili kurumlaştırıcı rolü (üretim, dolaşım, mülkiyet,...
Bu rejimde davranışsal veriler algoritmik altyapılar aracılığıyla sürekli biçimde çıkarılmakta, işlenmekte ve metalaştırılmaktadır.
Kavramsal/diskurs analizi ve literatüre atıf (Zuboff); no empirical measurement or sample described in abstract.
high negative GÖZETİM KAPİTALİZMİNİN HUKUKSAL TEMELLERİ: FOUCAULTCU BİR AN... davranışsal verilerin sürekli çıkarılması, işlenmesi ve metalaşması
Neither setup speaks to the operationally most relevant case for marketing practice: building detailed individual twins from the pre-existing heterogeneous panel data that firms already accumulate through CRM systems, loyalty programs, and repeat surveys.
Author's argument / positioning (identifying a gap between existing published twins and practical marketing use cases).
high negative Synthetic Personalities: How Well Can LLMs Mimic Individual ... applicability of existing twin construction approaches to pre-existing heterogen...
Traditional review perspectives organized by method, data type, or application domain understate a deeper shift toward human–AI hybrid decision systems.
Critical assessment within the integrative conceptual review contrasting existing review axes with the proposed decision-system perspective (no empirical sample size).
high negative Human–AI hybrid finance: from AI tools to decision systems adequacy of existing review perspectives for capturing systemic change in financ...
The benefits of the digital economy are uneven: urban residents gain more than rural residents, widening the urban–rural income gap.
Heterogeneity analysis (urban vs. rural) in the two-way fixed effects panel on 31 provinces (2011–2021) showing larger estimated income effects for urban areas.
Existing SID generation methods rely heavily on unsupervised quantization, and in realistic scenarios the lack of explicit supervision makes it difficult to dictate which items should share an SID, resulting in limited capability for query-dependent ranking.
Background/related-work claim in paper describing limitations of prior SID generation methods (argumentative/literature-based claim). No experimental quantification in the excerpt.
high negative DSIRM: Learning Query-Bridged Discrete Semantic Identifiers ... capability for query-dependent ranking (limitation)
GPU utilization surged from 57% to 94% following the mining software's public release, displacing legitimate research workloads.
Measurement of GPU utilization levels before (57%) and after (94%) the public release of mining software; authors attribute displacement of research workloads to the utilization surge.
high negative The Usefulness Gap in Proof-of-Useful-Work: An Empirical Stu... GPU utilization (and displacement of research workloads)
Budget GPU rental prices rose 38% following the mining software's public release.
Market measurements of budget GPU rental prices before and after the public release of the mining software, reporting a 38% increase.
high negative The Usefulness Gap in Proof-of-Useful-Work: An Empirical Stu... budget GPU rental price change
The mining computation is commodity integer arithmetic portable to any hardware platform, offering no vendor lock-in.
Analysis of the computation showing it relies on basic integer arithmetic operations and is implementable across diverse hardware architectures.
high negative The Usefulness Gap in Proof-of-Useful-Work: An Empirical Stu... hardware specificity / vendor lock-in of mining computation
Mining is unprofitable at current PRL prices ($0.21) across all GPU tiers (-54% to -72% ROI).
Profitability analysis/calculation across GPU tiers using current token price of $0.21; reported ROI range of -54% to -72%.
high negative The Usefulness Gap in Proof-of-Useful-Work: An Empirical Stu... economic profitability (ROI) of mining across GPU tiers
Statistical distribution checks are trivially defeated by adversarial Gaussian sampling.
Demonstration that adversarial Gaussian-sampled outputs pass the system's statistical distribution checks; experimental or analytic demonstration reported.
high negative The Usefulness Gap in Proof-of-Useful-Work: An Empirical Stu... robustness of statistical checks to adversarial sampling
The verification protocol accepts random matrices by design, confirmed by 44 pool-accepted shares from our open-source miner across NVIDIA, AMD, CPU, and Apple Silicon hardware.
Protocol analysis showing acceptance criteria; empirical confirmation via 44 pool-accepted shares generated by an open-source miner run on multiple hardware architectures (44 accepted shares observed).
high negative The Usefulness Gap in Proof-of-Useful-Work: An Empirical Stu... ability of verification protocol to accept non-useful/random computation
The dominant mining software contains no inference code.
Static/dynamic analysis of the dominant mining software deployed on the network showing absence of AI inference routines.
high negative The Usefulness Gap in Proof-of-Useful-Work: An Empirical Stu... presence/absence of inference code in mining software
Pearl's 24 EH/s network -- representing approximately 320,000 GPU-equivalents consuming an estimated 112 MW -- produces zero useful AI computation.
Empirical measurement of Pearl network hashrate (24 EH/s) and mapping to GPU-equivalents and power consumption; analysis of miner code and verification showing no useful AI inference performed.
high negative The Usefulness Gap in Proof-of-Useful-Work: An Empirical Stu... usefulness of AI computation performed by the network (zero useful AI computatio...
Existing LLM4Rec paradigms neglect the trade-off between LLM semantic rewards and recommendation preference rewards during reinforcement learning (RL) alignment.
Author assertion identifying a second limitation of prior work (paper's problem statement).
high negative Taiji: Pareto Optimal Policy Optimization with Semantics-IDs... consideration of cross-domain reward trade-offs in RL alignment
Existing LLM4Rec paradigms are bottlenecked by the difficulty of measuring and improving chain-of-thought (CoT) quality in open-domain recommendation during supervised fine-tuning (SFT).
Author assertion about limitations of prior LLM4Rec paradigms (literature/diagnosis in the paper).
high negative Taiji: Pareto Optimal Policy Optimization with Semantics-IDs... ability to measure and improve CoT quality during SFT
The path coefficient for R&D expenditure is negative, suggesting a possible short-term adjustment effect (even though the mediation is not significant).
Reported negative path coefficient in mediation analysis (value/statistical significance not provided beyond being nonsignificant); interpretation offered by authors as a potential short-term adjustment effect.
high negative Mechanisms and Effects of Artificial Intelligence on New Qua... R&D expenditure path to new quality productive forces
Even creating a new brain‑privacy right would invite weak protection and insufficient incentives for brain‑data supply.
Argumentative claim in the paper based on normative analysis of legal incentives and data-supply dynamics (no empirical data or quantified modeling provided).
high negative Empowerment or behavioral regulation? governing brain–comput... strength of legal protection and incentives for supplying brain data
Privacy rights under the empowerment model cannot fully protect brain privacy.
Theoretical/legal critique in the paper contrasting empowerment-style privacy rights with the nature of brain data (argumentative, no empirical validation).
high negative Empowerment or behavioral regulation? governing brain–comput... effectiveness of empowerment-model privacy rights in protecting brain privacy
Much of the literature on AI systems has focused on aligning users' goals with the agents that act on their behalf, and this work may overlook the need to establish a new normative baseline.
Characterization of existing literature (literature-review/position claim) presented in the paper; no systematic review or quantification provided in the excerpt.
high negative Who Does Your AI Work For? Designing Conversational Agents a... focus of AI literature (alignment) versus attention to normative baseline
These systems have access to reams of sensitive user data.
Stated as a factual consequence of the described integration (conceptual observation in the paper); no empirical measurement or dataset cited in the excerpt.
high negative Who Does Your AI Work For? Designing Conversational Agents a... access by conversational agents to sensitive user data
In the absence of general design principles, hybrid components are typically introduced through ad hoc decisions tailored to specific domains.
Observational/literature-framing claim in the abstract describing current practice; not presented as a quantified empirical result in this paper.
high negative When Cloud Agents Meet Device Agents: Lessons from Hybrid Mu... design practices for hybrid MAS component selection
The effect concentrates at mid-market and is largest on the most priors-reliant generation route in our audit.
Cross-analysis within audit linking where recommendation-set changes occur (mid-market) and magnitude by generation route (priors-reliant routes show larger effects).
high negative Persona Conditioning of Brand Recommendations in Retrieval-A... concentration of persona effect across brand market segments and generation rout...
Mid-market brands swap up to 75% of the recommendation set as the persona changes.
Empirical observation from audit showing proportion of mid-market recommended brands that change when persona is prefixed; reported maximum swap percentage.
high negative Persona Conditioning of Brand Recommendations in Retrieval-A... proportion of recommendation-set changed for mid-market brands
Prefixing the user message with a persona drops the recommendation-set similarity (Jaccard) by Delta = -0.12 to -0.20 relative to a same-persona baseline.
Empirical comparison of recommendation-set Jaccard similarity between persona-prefixed prompts and same-persona baseline across audit runs; reported effect range and baseline comparison.
high negative Persona Conditioning of Brand Recommendations in Retrieval-A... recommendation-set similarity (Jaccard index)
Pure implementations of the data mesh paradigm frequently underdeliver because teams inherit new responsibilities without the platform maturity, tooling, or coordination mechanisms to exercise them effectively.
Argument/observation presented in the paper as rationale for proposing a new architecture (anecdotal/experience-based reasoning rather than reported empirical trial).
high negative Beyond the Data Mesh Illusion: Designing Modern AI-augmented... effectiveness of data mesh decentralization (ability of teams to exercise respon...
Enterprise data platforms face an enduring tension between domain self-service and holistic governance (a flexibility-versus-control trade-off).
Conceptual statement in the paper describing the problem motivating the work (literature/architectural framing).
high negative Beyond the Data Mesh Illusion: Designing Modern AI-augmented... flexibility-versus-control trade-off between domain self-service and centralized...
Achieving this system-level transformation takes time: it requires trust and accountability infrastructure, machine-legible and interoperable data and interfaces, the design and adoption of these new workflows, and economic incentives that favor reconstruction rather than local optimization.
Argumentative claim listing necessary preconditions and complementary investments; presented conceptually without reported empirical measurement in the provided text.
high negative From Augmentation to Reconstruction: Guiding the AI Disrupti... time and prerequisites required for system-level AI transformation
The main reason [the disruption has not fully arrived] is not model capability, nor even the tools built to harness those models; rather, most organizations are still using AI to accelerate workflows designed for a pre-AI world.
Argued in the paper as an explanatory thesis; supported by conceptual argument and illustrative examples (consumer markets, education, news, coding) rather than reported empirical analysis in the provided text.
high negative From Augmentation to Reconstruction: Guiding the AI Disrupti... degree to which organizations adapt workflows versus using AI to accelerate pre-...
The disruption many expect has not fully arrived.
Stated as an observation in the paper's introduction/abstract; no empirical method, sample size, or data reported in the excerpt.
high negative From Augmentation to Reconstruction: Guiding the AI Disrupti... extent/arrival of AI-driven disruption
Reputation mechanisms presuppose persistent identity, behavioral continuity, sanction sensitivity, and costly non-fungibility; absence of any of these undermines reputation systems.
Analytic claim in the paper articulating necessary conditions for reputation mechanisms to function; presented as theoretical grounding rather than empirically tested criteria.
high negative Dissociative Identity: Language Model Agents Lack Grounding ... operational conditions for reputation system effectiveness
The analogy from human identity verification and reputation mechanisms (e.g., 'Know Your Customer', credit scores) to 'Know Your Agent' regimes is fundamentally incomplete.
Comparative conceptual argument in the paper highlighting disanalogies between human actors and modular language model agents; no empirical comparison or data provided.
high negative Dissociative Identity: Language Model Agents Lack Grounding ... validity/completeness of the human-to-agent governance analogy
Identity-based, ex post, regulative, sanction-based governance, such as reputation, is structurally inapplicable to dissociative agents.
Normative/theoretical argument in the paper deduced from properties of dissociative agents and requirements of identity-based governance; no empirical or experimental support reported.
high negative Dissociative Identity: Language Model Agents Lack Grounding ... applicability/effectiveness of identity-based governance mechanisms
Dissociativity leaves agents without grounding for identifiability, predictability, credibility, and rehabilitability — the very properties that reputation mechanisms aim to sustain — thereby collapsing trust.
Conceptual inference in the paper combining the dissociative characterization of agents with the functional requirements of reputation systems; no empirical validation provided.
high negative Dissociative Identity: Language Model Agents Lack Grounding ... identifiability, predictability, credibility, rehabilitability, and resultant tr...
An agent's persona is fluid, vulnerable to adversarial attack, and may not internalize sanctions.
Argumentative claim in the paper citing susceptibility of modular agent components (prompts, tools, memory) to manipulation; no empirical attack experiments or sample sizes reported.
high negative Dissociative Identity: Language Model Agents Lack Grounding ... agent robustness to adversarial manipulation and responsiveness to sanctions
Language model agents are ontologically dissociative: they are essentially an assemblage of mutable modules -- foundational models, system prompts, tool-access policies, external memory, and, in some cases, a multi-agent system as a whole -- any of which may change agent behavior.
Theoretical characterization and system-level description in the paper; lists components that can be changed to alter behavior; no empirical measurement or sample reported.
high negative Dissociative Identity: Language Model Agents Lack Grounding ... ontological stability/identity of agents
The share of diffs receiving timely review has declined, exposing a widening gap between code supply and reviewer bandwidth.
Observational telemetry/operational metrics reported in the paper indicating a decline in timely reviews relative to diff supply. No specific numeric sample size provided in the excerpt.
high negative Automating Low-Risk Code Review at Meta: RADAR, Risk Calibra... share of diffs receiving timely review
Differences in patent and trademark classification systems represent a challenge to linking patent and trademark data.
Stated methodological challenge in paper; no quantified measure of the challenge provided in excerpt.
high negative A concordance between patent and trademark classes to link t... difficulty of linking patent and trademark records due to classification differe...
The economic impact of patented technologies remains unclear unless patent data is linked to other data, which can reveal the mechanisms through which new technology diffuses.
Argumentative claim in paper asserting need for linked data to understand economic impact; no empirical sample or specific method reported in excerpt.
high negative A concordance between patent and trademark classes to link t... clarity of economic impact of patented technologies
These results suggest the problem is not in any specific auditor but in any audit whose evidence comes from the audited party.
Synthesis and conclusion drawn from the authors' analyses and experiments across the studied auditing frameworks.
high negative Token Inflation: How Dishonest Providers Can Overcharge for ... robustness of auditing approaches that rely solely on provider-supplied evidence
We call this a trust paradox: every audit must trust some artifact, but current frameworks trust exactly the ones a provider has the strongest reason to manipulate.
Conceptual framing and critique of existing auditing frameworks (argument/analysis in paper).
high negative Token Inflation: How Dishonest Providers Can Overcharge for ... trust dependencies in auditing frameworks
The audit therefore reduces to a consistency check on the provider's own reports.
Logical implication derived from the provider-controlled hiding of model/tokenizer/execution (argument/analysis in paper).
high negative Token Inflation: How Dishonest Providers Can Overcharge for ... audit method (reliance on provider-supplied reports)