The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Syntheses Digests 🎲

Evidence (8570 claims)

Adoption
8570 claims
Productivity
7631 claims
Governance
6869 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
6491 claims
Org Design
4175 claims
Innovation
4114 claims
Labor Markets
3566 claims
Skills & Training
2966 claims
Inequality
2066 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 758 199 100 900 2007
Governance & Regulation 826 400 191 122 1563
Organizational Efficiency 777 193 124 84 1189
Technology Adoption Rate 635 233 124 97 1098
Research Productivity 422 128 57 336 954
Output Quality 476 179 59 47 761
Decision Quality 328 177 81 47 640
Firm Productivity 435 57 88 20 606
AI Safety & Ethics 218 277 65 33 599
Market Structure 180 170 123 24 502
Task Allocation 213 64 72 33 387
Skill Acquisition 170 61 61 17 309
Innovation Output 203 27 43 18 292
Employment Level 105 54 107 13 281
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 131 69 43 26 276
Consumer Welfare 117 63 42 11 233
Firm Revenue 153 48 26 3 230
Task Completion Time 173 31 8 12 225
Inequality Measures 44 122 49 6 221
Worker Satisfaction 89 65 22 12 188
Error Rate 69 92 10 2 173
Regulatory Compliance 77 69 14 5 165
Automation Exposure 56 56 26 13 154
Training Effectiveness 94 21 13 19 149
Wages & Compensation 77 36 25 6 144
Team Performance 86 17 27 10 141
Developer Productivity 95 17 14 6 133
Job Displacement 12 80 20 1 113
Hiring & Recruitment 52 7 8 3 70
Creative Output 31 18 8 3 61
Skill Obsolescence 5 46 6 1 58
Social Protection 27 16 8 2 53
Labor Share of Income 17 19 17 53
Worker Turnover 11 12 3 26
Industry 1 1
Clear
Adoption Remove filter
The effects of K_T adoption are heterogeneous across industries, firms, countries, and cohorts — early adopters and capital-rich firms/countries gain most — implying important transition dynamics for political economy.
Cross-country comparisons, industry- and firm-level panel heterogeneity analyses, and case studies demonstrating variation in adoption timing and gains; model simulations emphasizing transition path dependence.
high mixed The Macroeconomic Transition of Technological Capital in the... industry-/firm-/country-level productivity, income, employment, and adoption tim...
Aggregate productivity (output per worker or per unit of inputs) can rise while labor’s share and employment decline due to substitution toward K_T.
Macro growth-accounting exercises decomposing output growth into contributions from labor, traditional capital, and technological capital; model simulations showing productivity gains coexisting with falling labor shares under substitution elasticities.
high mixed The Macroeconomic Transition of Technological Capital in the... productivity (e.g., TFP or output per worker) and labor share
Neither MCP nor A2A defines the shared workspace in which humans and agents perform accountable work together.
Analytical claim by the authors contrasting existing standards with the missing specification of a shared human-agent workspace; no empirical evaluation provided.
high negative Collaborative Human-Agent Protocol (CHAP) presence/absence of specifications for shared workspace in existing standards
In current practice the human judgement is recorded, if at all, in application code, chat threads, ticket comments, and tribal memory.
Descriptive statement about current recording practices; presented without empirical study or counts in the provided text.
high negative Collaborative Human-Agent Protocol (CHAP) location and durability of records of human judgement in workflows
The technical surface for this collaboration remains weakly specified.
Asserted by the authors as an assessment of current technical standards and interfaces; no audit or measurement cited in the provided text.
high negative Collaborative Human-Agent Protocol (CHAP) degree of specification/standardization of collaboration interfaces
Macro-level correlation between Frey-Osborne (2013) and Eloundou-era rankings is Spearman rho = -0.750, p = 0.020 (against the original Oxford Martin appendix), indicating inversion.
Reported Spearman correlation and p-value comparing macro-level rankings between the original Frey-Osborne appendix and the paper's Eloundou-era results.
high negative Stable Geometry, Reversing Poles: The Bipolar Structure of A... Spearman correlation between historical and current macro-level automation-risk ...
Tool-Mediated Physical (macro M2) has mean OAI = 0.054.
Reported macro-level mean OAI computed after projecting DWA OAI values into the 7-macro typology.
high negative Stable Geometry, Reversing Poles: The Bipolar Structure of A... mean Occupational Automation Index (OAI) for macro M2
Board power disparity weakens the positive relationship between AI competitive actions and operational efficiency.
Interaction tests in the authors' empirical models using governance measures (power disparity) and NLP-identified AI actions from S&P 500 firms' press releases (2010–2022); reported as a negative conditional effect on operational efficiency.
high negative Competing With Artificial Intelligence: Board Governance And... operational efficiency (conditional on board power disparity)
This regulatory pressure creates a direct conflict between multi-stakeholder transparency and corporate data privacy.
Paper's conceptual argument describing a tension between transparency requirements and proprietary data protection; no empirical study provided.
high negative Trustworthy Smart Fabs via Professional Proxies: Scaling Saf... conflict between stakeholder transparency and corporate data privacy
Regulatory compliance demands have surpassed the capacity of manual corporate reporting.
Assertion in paper (conceptual observation about reporting capacity); no empirical measurement or sample size reported.
high negative Trustworthy Smart Fabs via Professional Proxies: Scaling Saf... capacity of manual corporate reporting to meet regulatory demands
The convergence of the 2026 European Union Safe and Sustainable by Design (SSbD) framework, Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD), and Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) introduce a severe governance bottleneck for advanced semiconductor manufacturing facilities ("Smart Fabs").
Declarative claim in paper based on policy convergence analysis; no empirical dataset or sample size reported (conceptual/analytical argument).
high negative Trustworthy Smart Fabs via Professional Proxies: Scaling Saf... governance bottleneck for Smart Fabs
Learning specialized simulator input languages can cost domain scientists hours to days.
Stated motivating claim in the paper (no experimental sample size or formal measurement reported in abstract).
high negative SIGA: Self-Evolving Coding-Agent Adapters for Scientific Sim... time required to learn simulator input languages
In moderate scenarios, AI increases levelised cost of energy (LCOE) by 35 EUR/MWh in key hubs.
Model results for moderate scenarios indicating regional LCOE impacts; reported LCOE increase value for key hubs.
high negative Powering the Future of AI: Navigating the Trade-offs for Eur... increase in LCOE (EUR/MWh) in key hubs
AI risks cumulative emissions overshoots of 67-181 MtCO2 between 2030 and 2050.
Same spatially explicit optimisation model of Europe across 21 AI growth scenarios; reported cumulative emissions overshoot range for 2030–2050.
high negative Powering the Future of AI: Navigating the Trade-offs for Eur... cumulative CO2 emissions overshoot (MtCO2) between 2030 and 2050
Transformational leadership negatively moderates the relationship between AI application and employees' job insecurity, buffering employees' insecurity responses across varying levels of AI application.
Moderation analysis reported in the study using the same employee survey dataset (411 valid responses), indicating a statistically significant buffering (negative) moderating effect of transformational leadership on the AI–job insecurity relationship.
Self-efficacy negatively moderates the relationship between AI application and employees' job insecurity by strengthening the insecurity-reducing effect of moderate AI application and weakening the insecurity-enhancing effect of excessive application.
Moderation analysis on the same cross-sectional survey data (411 valid employee questionnaires), reporting a statistically significant negative (buffering) interaction of self-efficacy with AI application intensity on job insecurity.
GenAI adoption may intensify informational imbalances in low-governance markets (asymmetric adverse effects).
Asymmetric effects observed in cross-market analyses and subgroup tests indicating worsening information asymmetries or related measures in low governance contexts.
high negative The impact of generative AI on institutional efficiency: Reg... informational imbalances / information asymmetry
In weaker governance environments, the benefits of GenAI adoption for institutional efficiency are limited.
Heterogeneity analysis / interaction models showing smaller or non-significant effects of GenAI on institutional efficiency in markets with low governance capacity.
high negative The impact of generative AI on institutional efficiency: Reg... magnitude of GenAI effect on institutional efficiency in low-governance markets
Employees currently lack clear guidance on appropriate use of GenAI within organizations.
Background claim in paper motivating the study (statement that employees 'lack clear guidance on appropriate use').
high negative The Role Of Embeddedness In Generative Ai Adoption: A Perspe... availability/clarity of organizational guidance for employees
Gains from autonomous AI agents (reduced search costs and improved matching) are not automatic because the behavior of current AI agents introduces frictions that limit competitive outcomes.
Theoretical argument drawing on economic search theory and the paper's analysis of agent behavior as described in the abstract; no empirical details or sample sizes provided in abstract.
high negative Agentic markets degree of competition / competitive outcomes in markets with AI agents
Interviews provide expanded analysis on existing skill gaps and lifelong learning needs among wind-energy professionals.
Qualitative interview data are reported to highlight skill gaps and lifelong learning needs; specific counts of interviewees not provided in the summary.
high negative Advanced digital skills demands and priorities in wind energ... presence of skill gaps and lifelong learning needs
The framework reframes the education–employer gap as a structural failure in the pathway and outlines implications for universities, employers, accreditors, and policymakers.
Conceptual claim and implications drawn by the author(s) in the paper (stated in the abstract).
high negative Apprenticeship after AI: Bridging Gaps in Early-Career Knowl... characterization of the education–employer gap (structural pathway failure) and ...
The architecture of the undergraduate degree is structurally incapable of replacing the informal post-degree apprenticeship system through curricular revision alone.
Argument presented in the paper, supported by the systematic review of eighteen peer-reviewed studies and labor-market analyses cited in the abstract.
high negative Apprenticeship after AI: Bridging Gaps in Early-Career Knowl... capacity of undergraduate curricular revisions to substitute for post-degree app...
The informal post-degree apprenticeship system that historically completed graduate formation no longer reliably exists.
Claim based on the paper's systematic review of eighteen peer-reviewed studies and current labor-market analyses (as described in the abstract).
high negative Apprenticeship after AI: Bridging Gaps in Early-Career Knowl... presence/reliability of informal post-degree apprenticeship pathways for graduat...
Higher education has misdiagnosed the resulting challenge as curriculum misalignment—a content problem assumed to be solvable through revised syllabi, AI electives, and marginal expansions of experiential learning.
Argument presented in the paper, supported by the paper's systematic review of eighteen peer-reviewed studies and labor-market analyses (as described in the abstract).
high negative Apprenticeship after AI: Bridging Gaps in Early-Career Knowl... adequacy of curricular fixes (revised syllabi, AI electives, marginal experienti...
Artificial intelligence and automation are restructuring early-career knowledge-work roles by compressing the entry-level functions through which graduates historically built portfolios, developed professional judgment, and earned professional credibility.
Statement supported in the paper by a systematic review of eighteen peer-reviewed studies and current labor-market analyses (as described in the abstract).
high negative Apprenticeship after AI: Bridging Gaps in Early-Career Knowl... compression of entry-level functions used for portfolio-building, judgment forma...
Private-market valuations are concentrated in a small number of firms.
Paper reports concentration of private-market AI valuations (distributional evidence across firms in private markets); exact counts or percentages not provided in the abstract.
high negative Boom, Bubble, or Buildout? A Multi-Method Evaluation of Whet... concentration of private-market valuations across firms
Capital expenditure has accelerated faster than observed monetization in some layers of the AI stack.
Comparative analysis of capex trends vs monetization metrics presented in the paper (layered AI stack comparison); specific sample counts not provided in the abstract.
high negative Boom, Bubble, or Buildout? A Multi-Method Evaluation of Whet... capital expenditure growth relative to monetization (payback) in AI stack layers
Entropy dissipation corresponds to organizational complexity, coordination frictions, energy constraints, regulatory uncertainty, talent mobility pressures, and opportunities to strengthen industrial absorption.
Definition/mapping provided in the paper as part of the HCLM framework; conceptual.
high negative AI Sovereignty as National Learning Capacity: A Human-Center... components of entropy dissipation
Apart from earnings adequacy, occupations characterized by dimensions of precarity were associated with lower LLM exposure (i.e., higher precarity on those dimensions corresponded to lower LLM exposure).
Abstract statement summarizing regression results across separate models for each precarity dimension (exact coefficients not provided in abstract).
Occupations most likely to be exposed to LLM are those where precariousness is lowest.
Summary conclusion based on the reported comparisons of mean LLM exposure across precarity categories using the Labour Force Survey and regression analyses described in methods.
Apart from earnings adequacy, LLM exposure was lower among occupations exhibiting each separate dimension of precarity (contractual instability, schedule unpredictability, working-time mismatch).
Separate multivariate linear regression models (one per precarity dimension) estimated associations between occupational LLM exposure and each dimension using Canada's Labour Force Survey; results reported in abstract (no per-dimension effect sizes provided in abstract).
Using the multidimensional precarity index, occupations characterized by low exposure to precarity had a significantly higher mean LLM exposure (mean 0.386, 95% confidence interval 0.356-0.417) compared to occupations with medium (mean 0.258, 95% CI 0.221-0.295), high (mean 0.260, 95% CI 0.194-0.328) or very high precarity (mean 0.205, 95% CI 0.136-0.275).
Analysis of Canada's Labour Force Survey; constructed multidimensional precarity index; multivariate linear regression models with cluster-robust standard errors; model coefficients used to produce mean estimates of occupational LLM exposure. (Sample size not reported in abstract.)
high negative Large language model exposure and precarious occupations: Un... LLM exposure (mean occupational exposure score)
Algeria lags behind peer countries on key indicators of digital infrastructure, human capital, and institutional frameworks as evidenced by World Bank (2022) and Oxford Insights indices.
Specific comparative claim based on the paper's use of World Bank (2022) indicators and Oxford Insights Government AI Readiness Index scores; the summary does not report numeric index values or sample sizes.
high negative Artificial Intelligence and Economic Productivity: A Compara... index scores for digital infrastructure, human capital, institutional readiness
Findings reveal that Algeria exhibits significant lag in digital infrastructure, human capital, and institutional frameworks compared to peers (Morocco, Egypt, Turkey).
Result reported from the paper's comparative analysis using World Bank indicators, the Oxford Insights Government AI Readiness Index, and sector-specific studies comparing Algeria to Morocco, Egypt, and Turkey; specific quantitative comparisons not provided in the summary.
high negative Artificial Intelligence and Economic Productivity: A Compara... digital infrastructure, human capital, institutional readiness for AI
Algorithmic scenario planning is being used for tax avoidance.
Presented in the abstract as an example of algorithmic technologies applied to international tax purposes (scenario planning for tax avoidance); no empirical details provided in the abstract.
high negative How TaxTech rewires global wealth chains use of algorithmic scenario planning to design or enable tax avoidance
Existing research has significant shortcomings in terms of local empirical evidence, micro task mechanisms, and the impact of cutting-edge AI.
Critical appraisal in the paper's discussion of gaps identified through the systematic literature review; no single-study sample size.
high negative Influence of Artificial Intelligence in the Labor Market completeness/coverage of empirical research
Skill mismatch constitutes the core contradiction of labor force transformation.
Interpretive conclusion from the literature review asserting that mismatches between worker skills and job/task requirements are central to the labor-market effects of AI.
high negative Influence of Artificial Intelligence in the Labor Market skill mismatch / skill obsolescence
Current results show that the hardest tier remains far from saturated: across mainstream harness and backbone configurations, the average full pass rate is 2.6%.
Empirical evaluation results reported by the authors summarizing ALE benchmark performance across mainstream harness and backbone configurations (no further detail on exact configurations or task/sample counts in excerpt).
high negative Agents' Last Exam average full pass rate (task success rate) on the hardest tier
The gap is largely an evaluation problem: widely used benchmarks lack sustained performance measurement on real and economically valuable workflows.
Author argument presented in the paper; motivated by benchmarking limitations rather than an empirical test in the excerpt.
high negative Agents' Last Exam coverage and sustained measurement of benchmarks on real workflows
These gains have not translated into economically meaningful deployment across many professional domains.
Assertion in paper arguing a deployment gap between benchmark performance and real-world economic adoption; no quantitative deployment data provided in the excerpt.
high negative Agents' Last Exam translation of benchmark gains into economic deployment
Manual processing of these documents is time-consuming, inconsistent across reviewers, and unscalable.
Author claim / background motivation; no quantitative time or consistency metrics reported in the statement.
high negative Leveraging LLMs for Unstructured Claims Data Analysis effort, consistency, and scalability of manual document processing
Actuaries rely primarily on structured numerical data for reserving and ratemaking, while valuable predictive information in unstructured text including medical records, adjuster notes, and call transcripts remains largely unused.
Author statement/observation in paper introduction; no empirical data or sample size provided to support prevalence claim.
high negative Leveraging LLMs for Unstructured Claims Data Analysis use of unstructured text in actuarial processes
The paper critically analyzes the implications of LLM-integrated search for brand trust, content authenticity, algorithmic bias, and market concentration.
Stated scope of analysis in the paper; presented as critical analysis rather than empirical claims in the provided text.
high negative SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION: HOW LLM-GENERATED SUMMARIES ARE ... implications for brand trust, content authenticity, algorithmic bias, market con...
This paradigm shift raises critical questions regarding brand visibility, content authority, and digital marketing strategy.
Analytical claim in paper discussing implications; supported by theoretical argumentation rather than empirical measurement in the provided text.
high negative SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION: HOW LLM-GENERATED SUMMARIES ARE ... brand visibility and content authority
The emergence of AI-generated summaries and answer-driven search experiences is shifting consumer discovery from link-based navigation to synthesized, context-aware responses.
Stated observation in the paper; argued via conceptual reasoning about AI-generated summaries and answer-driven interfaces rather than reported empirical metrics or sample-based experiments in the excerpt.
high negative SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION: HOW LLM-GENERATED SUMMARIES ARE ... mode of consumer discovery (link-based navigation vs. synthesized AI responses)
Collaborative filtering and graph-based recommendation models are highly effective because they leverage observed user interactions, but this dependence creates a fundamental cold-start challenge when newly added content has no interaction history.
Statement in paper framing problem; references to general properties of collaborative filtering and graph-based recommenders (conceptual / literature-backed claim, no specific experiment reported in this excerpt).
high negative Bridging the Semantic-Collaborative Gap: An Asymmetric Graph... cold-start challenge for new content (lack of interaction history)
The determining barrier to adoption observed in the two studied public-service units was not technological but training-related.
Qualitative analysis and intervention observations across two auditable case studies (SES/CONT in 2024 and UCI/SEDET in 2025); author-developed intervention and outcome changes used to support inference.
high negative The Main Barrier to AI Adoption in the Public Sector is Lack... primary barrier to adoption (training vs. technology)
The adoption of generative artificial intelligence in the public sector has been treated predominantly as a technological problem, with the expectation that productivity gains would follow from more capable models.
Author statement / literature-positioning in paper (assertion about prevailing treatment); no quantitative data provided in text to support prevalence.
high negative The Main Barrier to AI Adoption in the Public Sector is Lack... framing of AI adoption (technological vs. training-related)
The COVID-19 pandemic reduced tourism’s GDP share by approximately 37%.
Fixed-effects panel estimation including a COVID-19 indicator on 33 countries (2017–2023); reported coefficient β = –0.455, p < 0.001 (interpreted as ~37% reduction in the dependent variable).
high negative Which dimensions of AI development shape tourism’s direct co... tourism’s direct GDP share