The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Digests 🎲

Evidence (2432 claims)

Adoption
5126 claims
Productivity
4409 claims
Governance
4049 claims
Human-AI Collaboration
2954 claims
Labor Markets
2432 claims
Org Design
2273 claims
Innovation
2215 claims
Skills & Training
1902 claims
Inequality
1286 claims

Evidence Matrix

Claim counts by outcome category and direction of finding.

Outcome Positive Negative Mixed Null Total
Other 369 105 58 432 972
Governance & Regulation 365 171 113 54 713
Research Productivity 229 95 33 294 655
Organizational Efficiency 354 82 58 34 531
Technology Adoption Rate 277 115 63 27 486
Firm Productivity 273 33 68 10 389
AI Safety & Ethics 112 177 43 24 358
Output Quality 228 61 23 25 337
Market Structure 105 118 81 14 323
Decision Quality 154 68 33 17 275
Employment Level 68 32 74 8 184
Fiscal & Macroeconomic 74 52 32 21 183
Skill Acquisition 85 31 38 9 163
Firm Revenue 96 30 22 148
Innovation Output 100 11 20 11 143
Consumer Welfare 66 29 35 7 137
Regulatory Compliance 51 61 13 3 128
Inequality Measures 24 66 31 4 125
Task Allocation 64 6 28 6 104
Error Rate 42 47 6 95
Training Effectiveness 55 12 10 16 93
Worker Satisfaction 42 32 11 6 91
Task Completion Time 71 5 3 1 80
Wages & Compensation 38 13 19 4 74
Team Performance 41 8 15 7 72
Hiring & Recruitment 39 4 6 3 52
Automation Exposure 17 15 9 5 46
Job Displacement 5 28 12 45
Social Protection 18 8 6 1 33
Developer Productivity 25 1 2 1 29
Worker Turnover 10 12 3 25
Creative Output 15 5 3 1 24
Skill Obsolescence 3 18 2 23
Labor Share of Income 7 4 9 20
Clear
Labor Markets Remove filter
The proportion of consumers who adopt AI-induced services influences the pricing of those services and through price adjustments will further impact wages across traditional and non-traditional services.
Theoretical development and analysis in the paper via a demand-switching model and a Finite Change General Equilibrium framework introducing AI as a technological shock modeled through price adjustments.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence, Demand Switching and Sectoral Wage ... wages (across traditional and non-traditional services) and service prices
The paper reframes AI governance as a form of social policy shaped by political and economic institutions.
Conceptual/interpretive claim supported by the authors' comparative analysis and theoretical framing of AI governance alongside social policy dimensions.
high mixed Artificial intelligence governance and social policy diverge... conceptual framing of AI governance as social policy influenced by political-eco...
Although many regions use similar ethical language, substantial differences persist in risk allocation, regulatory enforcement, welfare integration and social protection.
Content analysis of policy documents showing overlap in ethical rhetoric but divergence across coded institutional dimensions related to risk allocation, enforcement, welfare integration and social protection (n=24).
high mixed Artificial intelligence governance and social policy diverge... similarity of ethical language vs. divergence in (a) risk allocation, (b) regula...
Five distinct governance models emerge: rights-based (EU), market-driven (US), state-centric (China), hybrid (Australia–Japan–Singapore) and developmental (India).
Typology derived from coding and index comparison of the 24 policy documents; authors classify regions/countries into five labeled governance models.
high mixed Artificial intelligence governance and social policy diverge... categorical classification of regional AI governance model
The findings show clear and systematic differences in how regions govern AI.
Comparative analysis of coded policy documents (n=24) producing indices that the authors interpret as showing systematic cross-regional differences in governance approaches.
high mixed Artificial intelligence governance and social policy diverge... degree and nature of differences in regional AI governance approaches
The documents are systematically coded across four institutional dimensions and converted into simple indices to compare governance approaches across the regions.
Author-reported method: systematic coding of documents on four institutional dimensions and construction of indices for cross-regional comparison (based on the 24 documents).
high mixed Artificial intelligence governance and social policy diverge... coding across four institutional dimensions and index construction
This study uses a comparative qualitative policy analysis based on 24 key AI policy documents published between 2018 and 2025 across the European Union, United States, China, and Indo-Pacific economies.
Author-stated research design and sample: systematic review/comparative qualitative policy analysis of 24 AI policy documents spanning 2018–2025 covering EU, US, China and Indo-Pacific economies.
high mixed Artificial intelligence governance and social policy diverge... research design and document sample
Firms of different ownership structures and industries exhibit different responses to the income distribution changes brought by AI (heterogeneous effects).
Paper reports performing grouped regressions by ownership type and industry to identify heterogeneous responses.
high mixed THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON ENTERPRISE INCOME D... heterogeneous change in income distribution (e.g., labor share or profit-labor r...
Financing constraints are a key factor that hinder firms' choice of technology level, which alters the corresponding income distribution effect of AI.
Paper posits financing constraint as a moderator and states it is considered in empirical analysis (interaction/moderation tests).
high mixed THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON ENTERPRISE INCOME D... change in income distribution effects (e.g., labor share) conditional on financi...
The development of AI may trigger new changes in the interest pattern between corporate profits and labor compensation.
Framed as the central research question/hypothesis; paper conducts empirical tests on firm panel data to evaluate this.
high mixed THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON ENTERPRISE INCOME D... relationship between corporate profits and labor compensation (interest pattern)
Artificial intelligence is profoundly reshaping the organizational form, operating model and operating mechanism of enterprises, and bringing unprecedented impact to the income distribution structure within enterprises.
Statement asserted in the paper's introduction/abstract; motivates empirical analysis using panel data of Shanghai and Shenzhen A-share non-financial listed firms (2010–2022).
high mixed THE IMPACT OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE ON ENTERPRISE INCOME D... income distribution structure within enterprises (general claim)
These findings contribute to the literature by providing empirical insights from a developing economy, where unique socioeconomic and institutional factors shape the impact of AI.
Scope/claim of contribution based on the study's context (Cambodia) and its dataset (n = 351).
This study employed PLS‐SEM analysis on data from 351 respondents, revealing significant workforce reshaping.
PLS-SEM analysis conducted on survey data (n = 351) as reported in the paper.
The rapid adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) is fundamentally transforming labor markets worldwide, presenting both opportunities and challenges.
Statement made in the paper as background/justification; not based on the study's empirical data.
Implementation of human-replacing technologies leads to significant transformations in skill demand: it reduces reliance on low-skilled labour while increasing demand for qualified engineers, system operators and specialists in digital technologies.
Sector-specific analysis and review of international labour-market studies cited in the article documenting skill-biased effects of automation and digitalization; qualitative assessment for Ukraine's mining and metallurgical sector under workforce shortage conditions.
high mixed Human-replacing technologies as a driver of labour productiv... skill demand composition (shift from low-skilled to high-skilled roles)
The study found a significant transformation of the employment structure under the influence of artificial intelligence.
Empirical analysis using an envelope model ("input" orientation) applied to a sample of European Union countries; the paper reports modeled changes in employment structure attributable to AI diffusion.
high mixed Artificial intelligence as a driver of economic growth: Chal... transformation of employment structure
For AI: a cohesive professional vocabulary formed rapidly in early 2024, but the practitioner population never cohered.
Empirical finding from analysis of the 8.2M resume dataset showing a rapid increase in the vocabulary-cohesion metric around early 2024 while the population-cohesion metric did not show a corresponding rise.
high mixed NLP Occupational Emergence Analysis: How Occupations Form an... vocabulary cohesion (rapid formation) and population cohesion (absence of cohesi...
These productivity gains are most pronounced for lower-skilled workers, producing a pattern the authors call “skill compression.”
Cross-study pattern reported in the literature review: comparative evidence across worker-skill strata in multiple empirical papers showing larger relative gains for lower-skilled/junior workers; specific underlying studies and sample sizes are not enumerated in the brief.
high mixed AI, Productivity, and Labor Markets: A Review of the Empiric... relative productivity/gains by worker skill level (leading to 'skill compression...
Safeguards such as audit trails, explainability, and human oversight impose additional implementation costs that must be weighed against efficiency benefits.
Normative and economic reasoning based on requirements for compliance and system design; no empirical cost estimates provided.
high mixed ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE: A CRI... implementation costs versus efficiency gains (net cost-benefit of deploying safe...
There is a fundamental tension between AI-driven efficiency and core administrative-law principles—discretion, due process, and accountability.
Doctrinal legal analysis of administrative-law principles in Vietnam and comparative institutional analysis of AI adoption in other systems.
high mixed ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE: A CRI... trade-off between administrative efficiency and adherence to legal principles (d...
The net educational value of AI-generated feedback depends on alignment with pedagogical goals, quality evaluation, integration with human teaching, and governance to manage equity, privacy, and incentives.
Synthesis statement from the meeting report produced by 50 interdisciplinary scholars; conceptual judgment rather than empirical proof.
high mixed The Future of Feedback: How Can AI Help Transform Feedback t... net educational value (composite of learning outcomes, equity metrics, privacy c...
LLMs excel at extracting and generating arguments from unstructured text but are opaque and hard to evaluate or trust.
Synthesis of recent LLM literature and observed properties (generation capability vs. opacity); no empirical evaluation within this paper.
high mixed Argumentative Human-AI Decision-Making: Toward AI Agents Tha... argument extraction/generation performance and model interpretability/trustworth...
The paper is primarily theoretical and historical; empirical validation is needed to quantify the irreducible component of LLM value, and practical degrees of rule‑extractability may exist even if some capabilities remain tacit.
Stated limitations section acknowledging the theoretical nature of the work and the need for empirical follow‑up.
high mixed Why the Valuable Capabilities of LLMs Are Precisely the Unex... need for empirical validation and degree of rule‑extractability of LLM capabilit...
If an LLM's full capability were reducible to an explicit rule set, that rule set would be an expert system; because expert systems are empirically and historically weaker than LLMs, this leads to a contradiction (supporting non‑rule‑encodability).
Logical proof‑by‑contradiction presented in the paper, supported by conceptual mapping between rule sets and expert systems and qualitative historical comparisons.
high mixed Why the Valuable Capabilities of LLMs Are Precisely the Unex... logical consistency of the reducibility-to-rules claim (validity of the contradi...
There are potential measurement gaps in the data, particularly in capturing informal employment and rapid technology diffusion.
Authors' stated limitations noting data coverage issues: official statistics and surveys may not fully capture informal sector dynamics or fast-moving tech adoption. Specific metrics of missingness not provided.
high mixed The AI Transition: Assessing Vulnerability and Structural Re... data completeness / coverage for informal employment and real-time technology di...
The evidence presented in the study is largely correlational, with limited causal identification of AI causing job changes.
Study design and methods statement: reliance on descriptive analyses, occupation-vulnerability mapping, employer surveys, and case studies without quasi-experimental causal identification strategies.
high mixed The AI Transition: Assessing Vulnerability and Structural Re... strength of causal inference about AI → employment outcomes (design limitation)
The paper's proposed ISB+NDMS approach is tailored to the Russian institutional context (leveraging historical planning experience) and its transferability to other political-economic systems is uncertain.
Comparative/transferability claim based on institutional analysis and normative reasoning in the paper; no cross-country empirical comparisons provided.
high mixed DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION’S SOCIOECON... transferability/applicability of ISB+NDMS across institutional contexts
The research methodology combines systemic analysis, comparative assessment of international practices, and analytical generalization of organizational learning models, enabling capture of both structural trends and concrete institutional responses to technological changes.
Methodological statement from the paper describing its approach; this is a factual claim about methods used rather than an empirical finding.
high mixed EDUCATIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL STRATEGIES FOR PREPARING HUMAN ... ability to capture structural trends and institutional responses (through the ch...
The impact of Generative AI on labor markets is heterogeneous across occupations and tasks.
Synthesis of recent empirical studies drawing on population-level data, online job postings, and systematic reviews as described in the paper.
high mixed The Impact of Generative AI on the Future of Employment: Opp... heterogeneity of impacts across occupations and tasks (employment patterns, dema...
The study investigates the benefits and drawbacks associated with the incorporation of innovative artificial intelligence technologies into industrial policies.
Author-stated research objective reported in the text; evidence claimed to come from literature review (novel studies and existing literature), but no specific studies, sample sizes, or empirical measures are provided in the excerpt.
high mixed A Study on Work-Life Balance of Women Employees in the IT Se... benefits and drawbacks of incorporating AI into industrial policy
The paper constructs three policy-contingent labor market scenarios for 2025–2035: (1) an Augmented Services Economy with inclusive productivity gains, (2) a Dual-Speed Labor Market characterized by polarization and uneven adjustment, and (3) a Disruptive Automation Shock involving significant displacement and social strain.
Prognostic, scenario-based approach integrating the three evidence bases (task-level capability mapping, occupational exposure/complementarity analysis, and firm- and worker-level adoption evidence). The scenarios are developed and described in the paper for the 2025–2035 horizon.
high mixed Labor Futures Under Artificial Intelligence: Scenarios for t... alternative labor market trajectories for 2025–2035 (employment levels by sector...
The review synthesizes findings across five thematic areas: AI‑driven task automation and decision support; digital literacy and capacity building; gender‑sensitive employment patterns; infrastructural and policy challenges; and sustainable development outcomes.
Thematic synthesis of the 55 included articles as described in the paper; themes explicitly listed by the authors.
high mixed Role of AI in Enhancing Work Efficiency and Opportunities fo... thematic categorization of evidence across included studies
Major actors such as the United States, China, and the European Union pursue distinct models of AI development and regulation.
Comparative policy analysis and qualitative document review of national/regional AI strategies and regulatory proposals for the United States, China, and the EU (specific documents and sample size not specified).
high mixed The Geopolitics of Artificial Intelligence: Power, Regulatio... model of AI development and regulation adopted by each actor (US, China, EU)
The study identifies the emergence of three competing governance paradigms: the innovation-driven liberal model, the ethics-oriented regulatory model, and the state-controlled authoritarian model.
Finding from the paper's comparative policy analysis and qualitative review of policy documents across major actors (United States, European Union, China); underlying document sources referenced qualitatively but not enumerated as a quantitative sample.
high mixed The Geopolitics of Artificial Intelligence: Power, Regulatio... types of AI governance paradigms (innovation-driven liberal; ethics-oriented reg...
There is substantial heterogeneity in worker experiences within platform-mediated gig work.
Observed variation in roles (primary vs. supplementary), earnings distribution (median below traditional but top-decile premiums), and access to benefits across the 24-country dataset from surveys, administrative records, and platform transaction data.
high mixed The Gig Economy and Labor Market Restructuring: Platform Wor... heterogeneity in employment role, earnings, and benefits access among gig worker...
About 65% of gig workers engage in platform work as supplementary income alongside traditional employment or education.
Self-reported employment status and activity overlap from labor force surveys and administrative linkages in the 24-country dataset.
high mixed The Gig Economy and Labor Market Restructuring: Platform Wor... proportion of gig workers who treat platform work as supplementary income (%)
Institutional factors (education systems, active labor market policies, mobility, industrial policy, social protection) shape net employment outcomes from AI.
Theoretical and policy-focused synthesis; cross-country comparisons in literature highlight institutional mediation though no single new cross-country empirical estimate is provided.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... variation in employment outcomes and distributional impacts across countries wit...
Net employment effects depend on the balance of substitution and complementarity, sectoral exposure, and institutional responses.
Conceptual labor-economics framework (task-based, skill-biased change) and comparative review of cross-country/sectoral evidence emphasizing institutional mediation.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... net employment change (by sector/country) and distributional outcomes
AI will substantially restructure labor markets.
Task-based theoretical approach and cross-sectoral synthesis of empirical studies showing task substitution and complementarity effects across occupations and sectors.
high mixed Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Employment Dynamics... occupational composition, sectoral employment shares, task mix
Whether AI increases or decreases overall inequality depends on AI’s technology structure (proprietary vs. commodity) and on labor-market institutions (rent‑sharing elasticity ξ and asset concentration).
Comparative statics and regime analysis within the calibrated model that varies the technological-form parameter (η1 vs. η0) and the rent‑sharing elasticity ξ, as well as measures of asset concentration.
high mixed When AI Levels the Playing Field: Skill Homogenization, Asse... aggregate inequality (ΔGini) as a function of technology form and institutional ...
AI can equalize individual task performance while increasing aggregate inequality because rents accrue to owners of complementary assets rather than to workers.
Analytical model and calibrated simulations demonstrating that within-task compression (reduced worker dispersion) can coexist with rising aggregate inequality (ΔGini) owing to rent concentration at the firm/asset-owner level.
high mixed When AI Levels the Playing Field: Skill Homogenization, Asse... within-task performance dispersion (decrease) and aggregate inequality (ΔGini, i...
Long-run integration (degree of long-run association) between core AI and AI-enhanced robotics differs systematically across national innovation systems.
Country-level decomposition of patent filing series and time-series econometric tests for long-run relationships / cointegration between core AI and AI-enhanced robotics patent series for each country/region (China, U.S., Europe, Japan, South Korea).
high mixed The "Gold Rush" in AI and Robotics Patenting Activity. Do in... measures of long-run association/cointegration between core AI and AI-enhanced r...
Core AI, traditional robotics, and AI-enhanced robotics follow distinct historical trajectories over 1980–2019 and do not move together uniformly.
Time-series analysis using annual patent filing counts (1980–2019) for each domain; tests for common long-run relationships / co-movement across the three patent series (as reported in the paper). Country-aggregated and domain-specific patent time series were analyzed; exact sample size (total patents) not specified in the summary.
high mixed The "Gold Rush" in AI and Robotics Patenting Activity. Do in... annual patent filing counts/time-series trajectories for each of the three domai...
Kondratieff, Schumpeter, and Mandel each highlight different drivers of capitalist long waves: Kondratieff emphasizes regular technological-driven renewal, Schumpeter emphasizes entrepreneurship and innovation-led creative destruction, and Mandel emphasizes class relations and production structures.
Comparative theoretical analysis and literature synthesis across the three schools; conceptual summary of canonical positions (no original dataset; qualitative interpretation).
high mixed Economic Waves, Crises and Profitability Dynamics of Enterpr... theoretical drivers of capitalist cycles
The study's qualitative and exploratory design limits generalizability; the proposed framework requires quantitative testing and broader samples (practicing architects, firms, cross-cultural contexts).
Explicit limitations stated by authors; study is based on semi-structured interviews with architecture students (N unspecified) and inductive thematic analysis.
high mixed Human–AI Collaboration in Architectural Design Education: To... generalizability / external validity of findings and framework
Human factors (training, trust calibration, workflows) determine whether clinicians accept, override, or ignore GenAI suggestions.
Qualitative and quantitative human-AI interaction studies and pilot deployments discussed in the paper; specific sample sizes and effect sizes are not reported in the paper.
high mixed GenAI and clinical decision making in general practice override/acceptance rates; clinician-reported trust and cognitive load; adherenc...
Safety and net benefit of GenAI CDS hinge on deployment details: user interface, real-time feedback, uncertainty quantification, calibration, and how recommendations are presented (strong vs. suggestive).
Human factors and implementation studies referenced; early A/B tests and human-AI interaction research suggest interface and presentation affect acceptance and error rates; no large-scale standardized implementation trial data cited.
high mixed GenAI and clinical decision making in general practice acceptance/override rates; error rates; calibration metrics; clinician trust
Reimbursement models (fee-for-service vs. capitation) will influence whether cost savings from GenAI are realized or offset by increased service volume.
Economic incentive framework and prior health-economics literature cited; the paper does not provide direct empirical tests but references plausible incentive channels.
high mixed GenAI and clinical decision making in general practice total spending; per-patient cost; service volume under different payment models
Performance of structure prediction models scales with data, model size, and compute; there are tradeoffs between accuracy and inference speed/simplicity.
Paper explicitly states scaling behavior and tradeoffs in 'Compute and training' and 'Representative models' sections; no precise scaling curves or thresholds are provided in the text.
high mixed Protein structure prediction powered by artificial intellige... model predictive performance as a function of training data volume, model size, ...
The United States' decentralized education system produces tensions between local innovation and federal accountability, with active debates over data and privacy laws shaping responses to AI in assessment.
Case study of U.S. policy and secondary literature documenting federal-state-local governance dynamics and ongoing legal/policy debates; descriptive evidence from public documents.
high mixed The Future of Assessment: Rethinking Evaluation in an AI-Ass... policy tension between innovation and accountability; data/privacy regulation ac...