0 cumulative citations
View corpus contextDigital da‘wah can amplify — not replace — in-person pesantren rehabilitation, offering a five-part hybrid model that could expand markets for culturally tailored AI-enabled mental‑health tools; however, clinical and economic effectiveness remains untested.
Therapeutic Da’wah Based in Pesantren: A Systematic Review of Islamic Psychosocial Communication in the Digital Media Era (Study of the ODGJ Pesantren Ainul Yakin Yogyakarta)
openalex
review_meta
low evidence
7/10 relevance
Summary only
summary available; pdf_status=paywall
DOI
Source
PDF
A qualitative systematic review proposes a five-component hybrid model in which digital da‘wah complements face-to-face pesantren rehabilitation to support emotion regulation, spiritual reflection, and long-term psychosocial recovery, but empirical testing is needed to establish impact.
Citation observations
Cumulative provider counts captured on specific dates; providers are never combined.
Psychosocial disorders among santri with mental illness in Indonesian pesantren create spiritual collapse, social isolation, and long-term functional impairment that require integrated medical, psychosocial, and religious support. Existing studies on Islamic therapeutic communication in pesantren and on digital da‘wah develop in parallel and rarely intersect, so models of da‘wah explicitly designed as psychosocial interventions remain underexplored. This study aims to conceptualize a therapeutic da‘wah model that integrates face-to-face pesantren practices with new media for santri with psychosocial vulnerabilities at Pesantren Ainul Yaqin. Using a qualitative Systematic Literature Review, it analyzes Scopus and Sinta articles (2015–2026) on Islamic therapeutic communication, psychosocial rehabilitation in pesantren, and digital da‘wah, selected through three stages (identification, screening, eligibility) and synthesized via thematic, comparative, and integrative analysis. The discussion shows how Qur’anic concepts of nafs and qaulan, professional therapeutic stages (orientation–working–termination), and spiritual–familial rehabilitation practices in pesantren can be extended into digital spaces that support emotion regulation and spiritual reflection. The findings propose a five-component model of pesantren-based therapeutic da‘wah (actors, stages, hybrid channels, content, outcomes), positioning “therapeutic digital da‘wah” as a layer that prolongs and amplifies face-to-face rehabilitation rather than replacing it, while highlighting the need for mixed-method empirical studies to test its psychosocial impact.
Summary
Main Finding
Pesantren-based “therapeutic da‘wah” can be conceptualized as a five-component hybrid model that integrates face-to-face rehabilitation practices in pesantren with digital da‘wah channels to support emotion regulation, spiritual reflection, and long-term psychosocial recovery for santri with mental-health vulnerabilities. Digital da‘wah is framed as a prolongation and amplifier of in-person therapeutic stages rather than a replacement; empirical testing (preferably mixed-methods) is required to evaluate psychosocial impact.
Key Points
- Problem: Santri with psychosocial disorders in pesantren face spiritual collapse, social isolation, and long-term functional impairment that demand integrated medical, psychosocial, and religious support.
- Gap: Research on Islamic therapeutic communication in pesantren and on digital da‘wah have progressed largely independently; very few models explicitly position da‘wah as a psychosocial intervention.
- Conceptual anchors: Qur’anic concepts (nafs, qaulan), and standard therapeutic stages (orientation → working → termination) can inform intervention design.
- Synthesis result: A five-component model is proposed — actors, stages, hybrid channels, content, outcomes — in which therapeutic digital da‘wah extends face-to-face rehabilitation by supporting ongoing emotion regulation and spiritual reflection.
- Practical orientation: Digital components should complement, not substitute, in-person spiritual–familial rehabilitation practices found in pesantren.
- Research need: Calls for mixed-method empirical studies to measure psychosocial outcomes and validate the model.
- Limitations: The study is a qualitative systematic literature review (conceptual/modeling work); empirical evidence on impact remains limited.
Data & Methods
- Design: Qualitative Systematic Literature Review (SLR).
- Sources: Scopus and Sinta databases.
- Timeframe: 2015–2026.
- Article scope: Studies on Islamic therapeutic communication, psychosocial rehabilitation in pesantren, and digital da‘wah.
- Selection process: Three-stage SLR screening — identification, screening, eligibility.
- Analysis: Thematic, comparative, and integrative synthesis to derive conceptual linkages (Qur’anic concepts, therapeutic stages, pesantren practices) and to build the five-component model.
- Notes: The paper focuses on conceptual integration and model-building for Pesantren Ainul Yaqin; counts of included studies and quantitative effect sizes are not reported in the summary.
Implications for AI Economics
- Market and demand formation: Therapeutic digital da‘wah creates demand for culturally and religiously tailored digital mental-health services in Islamic educational settings, opening new markets for platforms, content producers, and service integrators.
- Complementarity of labor and AI: AI-enabled tools (chatbots, recommendation engines, personalized content delivery, emotion-detection) can amplify human-led pesantren rehabilitation but are unlikely to fully substitute therapists/ustadz—policies and business models should value human–AI complementarities.
- Cost-effectiveness and investment priorities: Economic evaluation (cost-effectiveness, cost–benefit, ROI) is needed to compare hybrid models against purely face-to-face or purely digital alternatives; initial investment areas include digital infrastructure, training for pesantren staff, and content localization.
- Measurement and outcome metrics: AI economics research should develop validated outcome metrics (clinical, functional, spiritual well-being, social reintegration, retention) and incorporate both short-term engagement KPIs and long-term psychosocial outcomes for economic assessment.
- Data governance and ethical costs: Privacy, consent, and sensitive-data handling have economic implications (compliance costs, liability, adoption barriers); culturally appropriate data governance frameworks will affect platform design and market uptake.
- Scalability vs. fidelity trade-offs: Economic models must account for scaling benefits of digital channels and the potential loss of therapeutic fidelity; payment/incentive structures for pesantren actors will influence adoption.
- Research agenda: Design and fund mixed-method pilots and randomized evaluations that include economic endpoints (cost per QALY-equivalent, productivity/education outcomes) to guide policy and investment; simulate diffusion and adoption under varying subsidy/regulation scenarios.
- Policy and subsidy implications: Public or philanthropic subsidization may be justified where therapeutic digital da‘wah lowers long-term social costs (reduced chronic impairment, improved social functioning), especially in underserved rural pesantren.
If you want, I can (a) convert the five-component model into an operational framework for an AI-enabled pilot (roles, tech stack, measurement plan, budget sketch), or (b) outline specific economic evaluation designs (trial, outcomes, costing methods) to test the model. Which would be most useful?
Assessment
Paper Typereview_meta
Evidence Strengthlow — The paper is a conceptual synthesis based on a qualitative systematic literature review; it proposes a model but reports no quantitative effect sizes, no primary empirical testing, and provides limited empirical evidence on psychosocial or economic impacts.
Methods Rigormedium — The review uses a documented SLR approach (Scopus and Sinta searches, 2015–2026, three-stage screening) and thematic synthesis to build an integrative model, but the summary omits counts of included studies, inclusion/exclusion criteria details, quality appraisal of sources, and any quantitative synthesis, limiting reproducibility and strength of inference.
SampleQualitative systematic literature review of studies on Islamic therapeutic communication, psychosocial rehabilitation in pesantren, and digital da‘wah identified from Scopus and Sinta databases covering 2015–2026; three-stage screening (identification, screening, eligibility) used; paper focuses conceptually on Pesantren Ainul Yaqin; counts of included studies and effect sizes not reported in the summary.
Themeshuman_ai_collab adoption governance
GeneralizabilityContext-specific to pesantren and Islamic therapeutic practices (likely Indonesian cultural/religious settings), limiting transferability to secular or non-Muslim contexts., Findings are based on qualitative synthesis rather than primary empirical testing, so external validity for clinical or economic outcomes is unproven., Heterogeneity across pesantren (size, resources, curricula, staff expertise) may limit applicability of a single model., Digital access and infrastructure variability (urban vs rural) constrain scalability to underconnected pesantren., Potential publication and selection biases in the underlying literature affect representativeness.
Claims (12)
| Claim | Direction | Outcome | Confidence & Evidence | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pesantren-based therapeutic da'wah can be conceptualized as a five-component hybrid model integrating face-to-face rehabilitation practices with digital da'wah channels. Organizational Efficiency | positive | Conceptual integration of therapeutic da'wah components |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
low
|
not reported
|
| Digital da'wah is intended to extend and amplify in-person therapeutic and spiritual rehabilitation rather than replace face-to-face practices. Organizational Efficiency | positive | Continuity and extension of psychosocial and spiritual support |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
low
|
not reported
|
| The proposed hybrid model is intended to support emotion regulation, spiritual reflection, and long-term psychosocial recovery among santri with mental-health vulnerabilities. Worker Satisfaction | positive | Emotion regulation, spiritual reflection, and psychosocial recovery |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
speculative
|
not reported
|
| Santri with psychosocial disorders in pesantren may experience spiritual collapse, social isolation, and long-term functional impairment, creating a need for integrated medical, psychosocial, and religious support. Other | negative | Social functioning and psychosocial impairment |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
low
|
not reported
|
| Research on Islamic therapeutic communication in pesantren and research on digital da'wah have largely developed independently, with few models explicitly treating da'wah as a psychosocial intervention. Research Productivity | negative | Integration of research domains and availability of intervention models |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
low
|
not reported
|
| Qur'anic concepts such as nafs and qaulan, together with the therapeutic stages of orientation, working, and termination, can inform the design of pesantren therapeutic-da'wah interventions. Training Effectiveness | positive | Intervention design and therapeutic-stage integration |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
low
|
not reported
|
| The study does not establish the psychosocial impact of therapeutic digital da'wah because it is a qualitative systematic literature review and reports no quantitative effect sizes. Other | null_result | Psychosocial impact of therapeutic digital da'wah |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
high
|
not reported
|
| AI-enabled tools such as chatbots, recommendation engines, personalized content delivery, and emotion-detection systems may amplify human-led pesantren rehabilitation but are unlikely, according to the paper's implication, to fully substitute therapists or ustadz. Task Allocation | mixed | Human-AI complementarity in rehabilitation delivery |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
speculative
|
not reported
|
| Therapeutic digital da'wah could create demand for culturally and religiously tailored digital mental-health services in Islamic educational settings. Adoption Rate | positive | Potential demand and market formation for tailored digital mental-health services |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
speculative
|
not reported
|
| Economic evaluation is needed to compare the hybrid model with purely face-to-face and purely digital alternatives. Organizational Efficiency | mixed | Relative cost-effectiveness, cost-benefit, and return on investment of delivery models |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
high
|
not reported
|
| Privacy, consent, and sensitive-data handling may affect compliance costs, liability, adoption barriers, platform design, and market uptake for digital therapeutic-da'wah systems. Governance And Regulation | negative | Data-governance costs and adoption constraints |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
speculative
|
not reported
|
| The paper recommends mixed-method pilot studies and randomized evaluations that include psychosocial and economic endpoints to validate the proposed model. Research Productivity | positive | Psychosocial outcomes, education or productivity outcomes, and economic endpoints |
Reading fidelity
high
Study strength
high
|
not reported
|