The Commonplace
Home Papers Evidence Explore Trends Syntheses Digests References Docs 🎲 Workforce Futures
← Papers
Direction, evidence grade, and study type are AI-generated labels (gpt-5-mini), not human-verified. Syntheses are LLM-written. "Tensions" are machine-detected candidates, not confirmed contradictions. A research-acceleration tool, not peer review. How this is built →

Machine-learning personalization lifted Telkomsel’s data-package take-up by 6.6%, delivering IDR 141.6m in incremental revenue in a three-month trial; a CatBoost model flagged monthly data revenue and usage frequency as the top predictors of purchases.

Analysis of the impact of Customer Value Management (CVM) on increasing Cellular Packet Telkomsel (Study case: PT Telkomsel)
Indra Syahputra, Agung Nugroho · December 12, 2025 · International Journal of Financial Accounting and Management
openalex quasi_experimental medium evidence 7/10 relevance Full text usable extracted full text DOI Source PDF

Structured author observations

Linked only from stored provider relations; the raw author line above is never matched by name.

OpenAlex

Latest observation:

  1. Indra Syahputra provider ID
  2. Agung Nugroho provider ID

Semantic Scholar

Latest observation:

  1. Indra Syahputra provider ID
  2. A. Nugroho provider ID
A CatBoost-based CVM personalization campaign at Telkomsel increased data-package take-up by 6.55% and generated IDR 141.6 million in incremental revenue over three months, with monthly data revenue and usage frequency the strongest predictors of purchase propensity.

Citation observations

Cumulative provider counts captured on specific dates; providers are never combined.

Purpose: This study aims to analyze the impact of the Customer Value Management (CVM) program supported by machine learning on increasing customer purchases of Telkomsel cellular data packages, as well as identifying the key behavioral factors influencing purchasing decision. Methodology/approach: This research employs a quantitative explanatory approach using big data analytics. The dataset consists of customer transaction records over a three-month period (January–March 2023), involving 5.7 million customer data points. A supervised machine learning classification model was developed using the CatBoost Gradient Boosting Decision Tree (GBDT) algorithm to predict customer purchasing propensity, supported by Focus Group Discussions (FGD) with subject-matter experts. Results/findings: The CatBoost model achieved an accuracy of 86% in predicting potential lapsers. The test-and-learn campaign based on CVM personalization resulted in a 6.55% increase in take-up rate and generated a revenue uplift of IDR 141.6 million. The most significant factors influencing purchases were monthly data package revenue, frequency of data usage within specific price ranges, and total monthly data revenue. Conclusion: The findings confirm that CVM implementation supported by machine learning effectively enhances personalized marketing, improves customer targeting, and increases purchasing performance at PT Telkomsel. Limitations: This study is limited to a single company, a three-month observation period, and the use of one machine learning algorithm. Contribution: This study contributes empirical evidence on the effectiveness of integrating CVM and CatBoost-based machine learning in large-scale telecom marketing to optimize customer value and revenue growth.

Summary

Main Finding

A Customer Value Management (CVM) program at PT Telkomsel, supported by a CatBoost Gradient Boosting Decision Tree model trained on 5.7 million customer transaction records (Jan–Mar 2023), improved personalized targeting: the model achieved 86% accuracy (for predicting potential lapsers/purchase propensity), the CVM-driven test-and-learn campaign raised take-up rate by 6.55%, and generated an incremental revenue uplift of IDR 141.6 million. The strongest predictors of purchase were monthly data-package revenue, frequency of data usage within specific price ranges, and total monthly data revenue.

Key Points

  • Objective: Measure impact of CVM + machine learning on increasing purchases of Telkomsel cellular data packages and identify behavioral drivers of purchase decisions.
  • Data scale: 5.7 million customer transaction records over a 3-month window (Jan–Mar 2023).
  • Modeling approach: Supervised classification using CatBoost (GBDT). Model used to predict lapsing/purchase propensity and drive personalized offers via Telkomsel’s CVM/DMP and MyTelkomsel app.
  • Performance: CatBoost model reported 86% accuracy on the prediction task.
  • Field outcome: Personalization campaign (test-and-learn) based on model output produced a 6.55% higher take-up rate and IDR 141.6 million in additional revenue during the campaign period.
  • Key behavioral drivers: monthly revenue from data packages, frequency of data usage in specific price bands, and total monthly data revenue (behavioral transactional variables dominated).
  • Validation & process: Machine learning predictions were supplemented/triangulated with Focus Group Discussions (FGDs) with subject-matter experts.
  • Limitations: single firm (Telkomsel), short observation window (3 months), and reliance on one ML algorithm (CatBoost) — limits generalizability and long-run inference.

Data & Methods

  • Data
    • Source: Telkomsel customer transaction logs and behavioral records (integrated via DMP / MyTelkomsel).
    • Size & period: ~5.7 million customer data points, January–March 2023.
    • Key features used (reported): monthly data-package revenue, frequency of data use within price ranges, total monthly data revenue; likely additional behavioral/transactional covariates from the DMP.
  • Methods
    • Modeling: Supervised classification with CatBoost (Gradient Boosting Decision Tree).
    • Objective variable: purchasing propensity / identifying potential lapsers (binary classification for targeting).
    • Evaluation: Model accuracy reported at 86%; business evaluation via a test-and-learn campaign measuring take-up rate and revenue uplift.
    • Complementary methods: Focus Group Discussions with experts to interpret drivers and support implementation decisions.
  • Field experiment / deployment
    • Personalized offers were delivered through the MyTelkomsel app as part of the CVM program.
    • Impact assessed by comparing take-up and revenue between personalized (treatment) and control treatment groups (test-and-learn framework).
  • Reporting gaps / methodological notes
    • Paper reports accuracy and business uplift but does not detail other ML metrics (AUC, precision/recall, calibration), feature engineering specifics, treatment assignment protocol, or costs of model development/deployment.
    • Short follow-up period — longer-term retention/LTV effects not observed.

Implications for AI Economics

  • Firm-level productivity and ROI
    • Evidence that ML-driven personalization can materially raise conversion rates (+6.55%) and produce measurable short-term revenue gains (IDR 141.6m in this campaign). For firms with large customer bases, small percentage improvements can scale into substantial revenues.
    • Important to weigh incremental revenue against development, data infrastructure, and campaign delivery costs to assess ROI; the paper reports uplift but not net ROI.
  • Targeting efficiency and resource allocation
    • Behavioral transaction variables (spend and usage frequency) are powerful predictors, implying firms can improve targeting efficiency by prioritizing high-signal behavioral features rather than only demographics.
    • CVM enables finer segmentation and potentially lower marketing waste via more relevant offers.
  • Competition, pricing, and market dynamics
    • Widespread adoption of ML-based CVM can intensify competition on personalized offers and dynamic pricing; firms that deploy it effectively may secure a data-driven competitive advantage.
    • May induce heterogeneous pricing and offer strategies across consumers, with distributional implications (e.g., personalized discounts vs. price discrimination).
  • Consumer welfare and regulatory considerations
    • Personalization improves product fit, but raises issues around transparency, privacy, and fairness. Regulators and firms should consider consent, data governance, and potential segmentation-related exclusionary effects.
  • Research design and causal inference
    • The test-and-learn field assessment is the correct applied-economics approach to identify causal impacts of personalization. Future work should report randomized assignment details, longer horizons (LTV), and heterogeneous treatment effects.
    • Researchers should complement predictive performance (accuracy) with causal estimands (ATE, uplift, retention effects) and cost-benefit analyses.
  • Generalizability and future research directions
    • Single-firm, short-horizon evidence is promising but not definitive. Replication across firms, longer panels, and robustness to algorithm choice (compare GBDT vs. neural nets, uplift models, causal forests) are needed to understand external validity and long-run impacts.
    • Combining predictive models with causal uplift/targeting models could further optimize marketing spend (target those with highest incremental response rather than highest propensity).
  • Policy and labor implications
    • Automation of segmentation and campaign management may change marketing labor needs (more analytics roles, fewer manual segmentation tasks).
    • Anticipate shift toward continuous model monitoring, fairness auditing, and consumer-protection compliance as ML personalization scales in telecoms and other industries.

Assessment

Paper Typequasi_experimental Evidence Strengthmedium — Large-scale, real-world deployment with measurable uplift and revenue figures provides credible empirical evidence of effectiveness, but causal inference is weakened by lack of transparent randomization or control-group specification, short (three-month) window, and single-firm setting. Methods Rigormedium — Uses an appropriate, modern ML method (CatBoost) on a very large dataset and supplements analysis with expert FGDs, but the paper reports limited details on validation procedures, robustness checks, alternative specifications, or how the test-and-learn campaign was experimentally implemented (randomization, balance, spillovers), and evaluates only one algorithm. Sample5.7 million Telkomsel customer transaction records from January–March 2023, with behavioral features such as monthly data-package revenue, frequency of data usage within price ranges, and total monthly data revenue; model training and campaign outcomes reported for this single-firm customer base. Themesadoption productivity innovation IdentificationDeveloped a supervised CatBoost classifier on 5.7 million customer records to predict purchase propensity, then implemented a 'test-and-learn' personalized marketing campaign comparing targeted customers (treatment) to baseline results; causal claims rely on observed differences in take-up and revenue but the design lacks detail on randomization, control selection, or adjustments for selection bias. GeneralizabilitySingle firm (Telkomsel) in a specific telecom market (Indonesia) limits applicability to other industries or countries, Short observation period (three months) may not capture seasonality or long-run effects, Results depend on firm-specific product, pricing, and promotional context, Only one ML algorithm (CatBoost) evaluated, so findings may not generalize across modeling choices, Unclear demographic coverage — may not generalize across customer segments not well represented in the dataset

Claims (7)

ClaimDirectionOutcomeConfidence & EvidenceDetails
The dataset consists of 5.7 million customer data points (transaction records) over a three-month period (January–March 2023). Other null_result size of dataset (number of customer transaction records)
Reading fidelity high
Study strength high
n=5700000
0.8
A CatBoost Gradient Boosting Decision Tree (GBDT) classification model achieved an accuracy of 86% in predicting potential lapsers. Other positive accuracy in predicting potential lapsers
Reading fidelity high
Study strength medium
n=5700000
86% accuracy
0.48
The test-and-learn campaign based on CVM personalization resulted in a 6.55% increase in take-up rate. Adoption Rate positive take-up rate (customer purchase rate of data packages)
Reading fidelity high
Study strength medium
6.55% increase
0.48
The test-and-learn campaign generated a revenue uplift of IDR 141.6 million. Firm Revenue positive revenue uplift attributable to the campaign
Reading fidelity high
Study strength medium
IDR 141.6 million
0.48
The most significant factors influencing purchases were monthly data package revenue, frequency of data usage within specific price ranges, and total monthly data revenue. Adoption Rate positive influence of behavioral/usage variables on purchasing decisions
Reading fidelity high
Study strength medium
n=5700000
0.48
CVM implementation supported by machine learning effectively enhances personalized marketing, improves customer targeting, and increases purchasing performance at PT Telkomsel. Adoption Rate positive effectiveness of CVM + machine learning on personalized marketing and purchasing performance
Reading fidelity high
Study strength low
6.55% increase in take-up rate; IDR 141.6 million revenue uplift (as reported)
0.24
This study is limited to a single company (PT Telkomsel), a three-month observation period, and the use of one machine learning algorithm. Other null_result study scope and limitations
Reading fidelity high
Study strength high
not reported
0.8

Notes