The Commonplace
Home Dashboard Papers Evidence Digests 🎲
← Papers

Africa’s informality, institutional hybridity and resource constraints reshape supply‑chain theory and open up high‑value opportunities for AI economics research; IJOPM’s AfIn initiative aims to build local capacity and publish theory and empirical work leveraging these contexts.

Continental shift: operations and supply chain management research from an African perspective
Essuman, D., Essien, A., Roehrich, J., Lam, H.K.S., Schleper, M., Blome, C. · Fetched March 10, 2026 · White Rose Research Online (University of Leeds, The University of Sheffield, University of York)
openalex theoretical n/a evidence 7/10 relevance Source PDF
The paper argues that Africa’s unique mix of informality, weak formal institutions, resource endowments, and environmental constraints generates distinct OSCM phenomena that both challenge existing theory and create fertile ground for AI-relevant empirical and methodological research, and it introduces the AfIn initiative to support Africa-based OSCM scholarship.

Purpose – Africa is attracting growing research interest in operations and supply chain management (OSCM). However, the implications of Africa’s contexts are understudied and need to be explored to refine and elaborate existing OSCM theories and concepts or develop new ones. This paper addresses these limitations while introducing IJOPM’s Africa Initiative (AfIn), which seeks to provide a platform and support for Africa-based researchers and the broader OSCM community to advance OSCM research on and from Africa. Design/methodology/approach – This conceptual paper draws on multiple streams of literature to disentangle and better understand African contexts and discuss how the continent’s idiosyncrasies can enrich OSCM research. It then details the AfIn, including its motivation and objectives, the review process, and support mechanisms for researchers. Findings – The paper sheds light on seven contextual factors that may influence OSCM research in Africa: (i) informal economy and organizations; (ii) socio-cultural diversity and complexity; (iii) traditional and survival-oriented cultures; (iv) weak formal institutions with strong informal institutions; (v) population growth potential; (vi) abundant resources with low outcomes; and (vii) high environmental constraints. Additionally, the paper provides insights into how these contextual factors underpin five OSCM themes through which future research can advance and shape OSCM theory and practice. These themes include: (i) serving consumer markets; (ii) managing resources; (iii) managing factor market rivalry; (iv) managing environmental hostility; and (v) managing institutions. Originality/value – The paper provides a comprehensive and in-depth understanding of Africa’s contextual idiosyncrasies and their implications for OSCM theory and practice. In doing so, it reveals intriguing, yet underexplored, OSCM phenomena about the continent while laying out actionable pathways through which research using African data can make novel theoretical contributions.

Summary

Main Finding

The paper argues that Africa’s distinctive contextual features — including a large informal economy, socio-cultural diversity, weak formal institutions, abundant but underutilized resources, and high environmental constraints — create unique operations and supply chain management (OSCM) phenomena. These idiosyncrasies both challenge existing OSCM theory and offer fertile ground for novel theoretical contributions. The authors introduce IJOPM’s Africa Initiative (AfIn) to support Africa-based OSCM research and provide a structured pathway for publishing and advancing theory using African contexts.

Key Points

  • Seven contextual factors shaping OSCM research in Africa:
  • Informal economy and organizations
  • Socio-cultural diversity and complexity
  • Traditional and survival-oriented cultures
  • Weak formal institutions coexisting with strong informal institutions
  • Population growth potential (demographic dynamics)
  • Abundant natural resources but low development/outcomes
  • High environmental constraints (infrastructure, geography, climate shocks)
  • Five OSCM research themes where African contexts can advance theory:
  • Serving consumer markets (distribution, last-mile, demand heterogeneity)
  • Managing resources (resource extraction, allocation, quality gaps)
  • Managing factor market rivalry (labor, land, and capital competition, informality)
  • Managing environmental hostility (resilience, adaptation to shocks, infrastructure limitations)
  • Managing institutions (formal vs informal governance, regulation, trust mechanisms)
  • The AfIn initiative: motivation, objectives, review process, and researcher support mechanisms intended to build capacity and increase high-quality OSCM research on/from Africa.
  • The paper is conceptual and synthesizes multiple literature streams to map how Africa’s contexts can be used to refine or generate OSCM theories.

Data & Methods

  • Type of study: Conceptual/theoretical synthesis (no primary empirical data collection).
  • Methods: Literature review across OSCM, development studies, institutional economics, and regional studies to identify contextual factors and link them to OSCM themes.
  • Outputs: Framework linking seven contextual factors to five OSCM themes; description of AfIn’s structure (review pathways and support for Africa-based researchers).
  • Implicit methodological recommendations for future empirical work include leveraging diverse data sources (administrative, survey, behavioral, remote sensing) and mixed-methods designs to capture institutional and informal dynamics.

Implications for AI Economics

  • Research opportunities:
    • Informal economy as a laboratory: Africa’s large informal sectors enable study of how AI-driven automation, platform markets, and pricing algorithms affect informal firms and workers — including displacement, complementarities, and informal-contract dynamics.
    • Heterogeneous markets and fairness: Socio-cultural diversity and data sparsity create challenges/opportunities for fairness-aware ML and for evaluating external validity of AI economic models across population subgroups.
    • Institutions and algorithmic governance: Weak formal institutions with strong informal norms allow investigation into how algorithmic interventions (e.g., automated enforcement, marketplaces, credit scoring) interact with informal governance and trust networks.
    • Resource-constrained optimization: High environmental constraints (limited infrastructure, shocks) motivate development and testing of robust, low-data, low-compute AI methods for supply-chain optimization, demand forecasting, and inventory management.
    • Labor markets & demographic dynamics: Rapid population growth and large informal labor pools afford study of long-run labor reallocation under AI adoption, wage dynamics, and training/skill-biased technological change in contexts with low formal schooling.
    • Natural-resource economics & AI: Abundant resources but low outcomes open avenues for AI-assisted monitoring (satellite imagery), predictive models for value-chain improvements, and incentive/contract design under extraction externalities.
  • Data considerations for AI economics studies:
    • Useful data sources: mobile-phone metadata, fintech/platform transaction logs, household/business surveys, administrative records, satellite/remote sensing, crowdsourced field data.
    • Challenges: measurement error, censoring, selection bias (informal actors may be absent from official datasets), privacy and ethical concerns, and limited digital trace coverage in some regions.
    • Recommended methods: combine causal inference (RCTs, natural experiments, instrumental variables) with structural modeling and simulation; employ transfer learning, domain adaptation, and robustness checks to deal with small or nonrepresentative datasets.
  • Policy and model-design implications:
    • Algorithmic design should consider informal-contract enforcement, cash-based transactions, and heterogenous preferences.
    • AI policies must be tailored to weak institutional environments — e.g., algorithmic accountability mechanisms that operate without strong legal enforcement but leverage community norms.
    • Cost-effective, explainable models are preferred where computational resources and technical capacity are limited.
  • Practical research directions:
    • Study platformization impacts on informal labor markets and small suppliers using causal designs.
    • Use satellite imagery + ML to measure resource flows, crop yields, and supply-chain disruptions, linking them to market outcomes.
    • Develop ML methods robust to intermittent data, high noise, and structural breaks due to shocks.
    • Evaluate AI-enabled policies (credit scoring, logistics routing, demand forecasting) through pilots and RCTs to measure welfare and distributional effects.

Overall, Africa’s OSCM contexts present rich, underexploited settings for AI economics: they expose mechanisms hard to observe elsewhere, require methodological innovations for data-sparse and institutionally complex environments, and offer high social value through applications that can raise productivity and resilience in resource-constrained systems.

Assessment

Paper Typetheoretical Evidence Strengthn/a — The paper is a conceptual/theoretical synthesis without primary empirical analysis or causal estimation; it proposes frameworks and research agendas rather than presenting new causal evidence. Methods Rigormedium — The authors synthesize multiple literatures (OSCM, development studies, institutional economics) and derive a clear framework linking seven contextual factors to five OSCM themes, but they do not present a systematic review protocol, meta-analysis, or empirical validation of the framework. SampleNo primary empirical sample; a narrative literature synthesis drawing on OSCM, development studies, institutional economics, and regional studies literature and illustrative examples from African contexts (no new datasets collected). Themesproductivity adoption labor_markets governance GeneralizabilityFindings are context-specific to African countries and may not generalize to high-income, formal-economy settings., Substantial heterogeneity within Africa (country, urban/rural, sectoral differences) limits broad generalizations across the continent., Recommendations dependent on data availability and digital infrastructure which vary widely across regions., Conceptual nature means empirical applicability depends on future study designs and local institutional detail.

Claims (30)

ClaimDirectionConfidenceOutcomeDetails
Africa’s distinctive contextual features (large informal economy, socio-cultural diversity, weak formal institutions, abundant but underutilized resources, and high environmental constraints) create unique operations and supply chain management (OSCM) phenomena that both challenge existing OSCM theory and offer fertile ground for novel theoretical contributions. Other mixed medium capacity of African contexts to challenge and advance OSCM theory (theoretical contribution)
Africa's contextual features provide unique OSCM phenomena challenging existing theory
0.01
Africa has a large informal economy and many informal organizations that shape supply-chain behavior and market functioning. Market Structure negative high prevalence of informality and its influence on supply-chain behavior
high prevalence of informality shaping supply-chain behavior and market functioning
0.02
Socio-cultural diversity and complexity across African contexts significantly affect OSCM phenomena (e.g., demand heterogeneity, governance norms). Organizational Efficiency mixed medium impact of socio-cultural diversity on demand heterogeneity and governance in OSCM
0.01
Traditional and survival-oriented cultures in parts of Africa influence firm and household decision-making relevant to OSCM. Decision Quality mixed medium behavioral drivers (survival-oriented decisions) affecting operations and supply chains
0.01
Weak formal institutions often coexist with strong informal institutions in African contexts, shaping governance, trust, and enforcement mechanisms in supply chains. Governance And Regulation mixed high relative strength of formal vs informal institutions and their effects on governance/enforcement
0.02
Africa’s population growth potential and demographic dynamics are important contextual factors for OSCM research and long-run labor market outcomes. Employment mixed medium demographic dynamics' influence on labor supply and OSCM demand
0.01
Africa is abundant in natural resources but exhibits relatively low development/outcomes from those resources, creating resource allocation and value-capture problems relevant to OSCM. Firm Revenue negative high resource endowment versus development outcomes (value capture in supply chains)
0.02
High environmental constraints in many African regions (poor infrastructure, challenging geography, frequent climate shocks) materially affect logistics, resilience, and supply-chain performance. Firm Productivity negative high infrastructure and environmental constraints' impact on logistics/resilience
0.02
Five OSCM research themes where African contexts can advance theory are: serving consumer markets, managing resources, managing factor market rivalry, managing environmental hostility, and managing institutions. Research Productivity positive medium potential of African contexts to generate theoretical advances across these five OSCM themes
0.01
Serving consumer markets in Africa (distribution, last-mile delivery, demand heterogeneity) offers opportunities to study distinct distribution models and last-mile challenges. Organizational Efficiency positive medium novel distribution/last-mile models and understanding of demand heterogeneity
0.01
Managing resources in African supply chains (resource extraction, allocation, quality gaps) highlights unique allocation problems and quality-related frictions for OSCM theory. Firm Productivity positive medium theoretical insights into resource allocation and quality management
0.01
Managing factor market rivalry (competition for labor, land, and capital amid informality) is an OSCM-relevant phenomenon that African contexts can illuminate. Labor Share mixed medium effects of factor market rivalry on operations and supply chains
0.01
Managing environmental hostility (resilience, adaptation to shocks, infrastructure limitations) in African contexts can drive OSCM theory on resilience and adaptation strategies. Organizational Efficiency positive medium resilience/adaptation mechanisms for OSCM under environmental hostility
0.01
Managing institutions (interplay of formal and informal governance, regulation, trust mechanisms) in Africa provides fertile ground for advancing institutional theories in OSCM. Governance And Regulation positive medium institutional governance mechanisms affecting supply-chain outcomes
0.01
The paper introduces IJOPM’s Africa Initiative (AfIn) to support Africa-based OSCM research, outlining motivation, objectives, review process, and researcher support mechanisms. Research Productivity positive high institutional support mechanisms for Africa-based OSCM research and publication pathways
0.02
This paper is conceptual/theoretical and does not conduct primary empirical data collection. Other null_result high study type (conceptual vs empirical)
0.02
The authors recommend leveraging diverse data sources (administrative records, surveys, behavioral data, remote sensing) and mixed-methods designs for future empirical work on African OSCM contexts. Research Productivity positive medium research design strategies for improved empirical inference in African OSCM studies
0.01
Africa’s large informal sectors function as a laboratory to study how AI-driven automation, platform markets, and pricing algorithms affect informal firms and workers (displacement, complementarities, informal-contract dynamics). Job Displacement positive medium effects of AI adoption (automation, platforms, algorithms) on informal firms and workers
0.01
Socio-cultural diversity and data sparsity in Africa create challenges and opportunities for fairness-aware machine learning and external validity testing of AI economic models across population subgroups. Ai Safety And Ethics mixed medium fairness and external validity of ML models across heterogeneous subpopulations
0.01
Weak formal institutions alongside strong informal norms allow researchers to investigate how algorithmic interventions (automated enforcement, marketplaces, credit scoring) interact with informal governance and trust networks. Governance And Regulation positive medium interaction effects between algorithmic interventions and informal governance on market outcomes
0.01
High environmental constraints (limited infrastructure, frequent shocks) motivate the development and testing of robust, low-data, low-compute AI methods for supply-chain optimization, demand forecasting, and inventory management. Research Productivity positive medium performance of low-data/low-compute AI methods under environmental constraints
0.01
Rapid population growth and large informal labor pools in Africa provide settings to study long-run labor reallocation under AI adoption, wage dynamics, and skill-biased technological change where formal schooling is limited. Employment mixed medium labor reallocation, wage dynamics, and skill-biased technological change outcomes under AI adoption
0.01
Abundant natural resources but low economic outcomes motivate AI-assisted monitoring (satellite imagery), predictive models for value-chain improvements, and incentive/contract design to address extraction externalities. Firm Productivity positive medium improvements in monitoring, value-chain performance, and incentive alignment in resource sectors
0.01
Useful data sources for AI economics research in African OSCM contexts include mobile-phone metadata, fintech/platform transaction logs, household/business surveys, administrative records, satellite/remote sensing, and crowdsourced field data. Research Productivity positive medium availability and suitability of various data types for AI/OSCM research
0.01
Key data challenges in African contexts are measurement error, censoring, selection bias (informal actors absent from official datasets), privacy/ethical concerns, and limited digital trace coverage in some regions. Research Productivity negative medium threats to data quality and representativeness for empirical studies
0.01
Recommended empirical methods for African OSCM and AI economics research include combining causal inference designs (RCTs, natural experiments, IV) with structural modeling, simulation, transfer learning, domain adaptation, and robustness checks to handle small or nonrepresentative datasets. Research Productivity positive medium validity and robustness of empirical inference in data-sparse/institutionally complex settings
0.01
Algorithmic and policy design in African OSCM contexts should account for informal-contract enforcement, cash-based transactions, and heterogeneous preferences rather than assuming strong formal enforcement and homogeneous agents. Governance And Regulation positive medium effectiveness of algorithmic/policy interventions when tailored to informal and heterogeneous contexts
0.01
AI policies and algorithmic accountability mechanisms must be tailored to weak institutional environments, for example by leveraging community norms when formal legal enforcement is limited. Governance And Regulation positive medium feasibility and effectiveness of accountability mechanisms in weak institutional contexts
0.01
Cost-effective, explainable AI models are preferred in African OSCM contexts where computational resources and technical capacity are limited. Adoption Rate positive medium practical applicability and adoption of AI models given resource and capacity constraints
0.01
Practical research directions include: studying platformization impacts on informal labor and small suppliers using causal designs; combining satellite imagery with ML to measure resource flows and supply-chain disruptions linked to market outcomes; developing ML methods robust to intermittent data and structural breaks; and evaluating AI-enabled policies (credit scoring, logistics routing, demand forecasting) through pilots and RCTs to measure welfare and distributional effects. Research Productivity positive medium empirical evidence on platformization impacts, remote-sensing-based measurement validity, ML robustness, and welfare/distributional effects of AI policies
0.01

Notes